Toddler Times
The Mommy Wars Peace Treaty
Over on Babble Salon, they are debating the Mommy Wars. Have you heard of the Mommy Wars? Its when lazy stay-at-home moms and selfish working moms duel each other to the death.
Do you know who is supposedly involved in the Mommy Wars?
ALL OF US.
The smart discussion on Babble Salon revolves around whether this is an actual issue or just the media stirring things up for ratings (Anderson Cooper’s recent show about whether stay-at-homes moms are lazy being the main catalyst).
For the record, calling stay-at-home moms lazy is ridiculous. I don’t know one working parent that thinks it would be easier to be at home than at work. Quite the opposite.
In fact, a lot of my working mom guilt comes from the relief I feel when I walk out the door.
According to the Mommy Wars, I should expect an army of stay-at-home moms to come banging on my door, wielding dirty diapers and baskets of laundry, calling me a lousy excuse for a mother, just for making the statement above.
I’m waiting.
Waiting.
Nope, so far it hasn’t happened.
Call this crazy but in the two years I have been a working mom, I have never once encountered an opponent from the other side.
Wait, you’re thinking— you don’t know any stay-at-home moms???
Of course I do!
Some of my best friends and most avid readers are stay-at-home moms.
But we are not opponents in any sort of war.
I wrote a post a few months ago about how I often feel like I am cheating at motherhood by leaving my child with her incredibly capable caregiver while I go off to work.
Do you know who rushed to my defense?
EVERYONE.
Working moms and stay-at-home moms both made incredibly supportive comments underneath the post. There wasn’t one negative remark in all 65 responses.
I found out a lot about my readers that day.
They talked about missing their children while at work vs. feeling isolated at home. They talked about working mom guilt vs. career ending regret. They talked about the fear of a caregiver replacing them vs. losing a sense of self. And some moms, of course, talked about working or staying at home out of circumstances that were not their first choice.
Did one mother criticize another mother’s choices?
Nope. Not a one.
In my experience, we are all battling our own issues. Not each other.
I also believe that most mothers, even if they have moments of guilt or envy, wouldn’t do things differently.
So. I would like to send a message to whomever it is that is perpetuating the “Mommy Wars”. And I would love it if you would do the same.
I, __________, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Please sign by commenting below.
Read more of Ilana’s writing at Mommy Shorts.
And don’t miss a post! Follow Ilana on Twitter and Facebook!
Go Back To Toddler Times
46 Comments
Kim at Let Me Start By Saying commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:22 amI, Kim, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Suniverse commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:23 amHmm . . . but how will I know who to pretend feel superior to now? So many decisions.
I’m going to come up with some crazy-ass Crips v Bloods beef for parenting – slipper socks v actual slippers. WHO IS FAILING THE CHILDREN NOW?
Heather K commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:24 amCount me in! I’m a part-time working Mommy, so I get the benefits of both, but also the GUILT of both. A side effect is that it makes it really hard to make REAL mommy friends, because I’m straddling both worlds.
Julie commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:25 amBrilliant! The whole idea of pitting moms against each other is just silly and a waste of time and energy. Every family (and every mom) is different. We should be more supportive of each other when we are all dealing with these very difficult and personal decisions. Like most things in life, there is not a “right” answer that works for everyone.
I am not a part of the Mommy Wars!
amanda commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:26 amwe are all doing what we can to survive – it’s all personal choices we make, and shame on other’s for judging!
Elizabeth commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:28 amYou know I am in! “We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family.” This is the heart of The Mom Pledge. Amen!
The media does its part to perpetuate the “Mommy Wars,” but so do plenty of women. I’m sorry to say it is real. Some women really are at war with each other. I see it every day online. And it needs to stop.
Thanks for spreading a positive message! Off to share this with our community…
Kate commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:33 amI was a SAHM for 5 years. I’m now a working mother, supporting my husband that went back to school, our two pre-schoolers and am pregnant with our third. Someone needs a reality check. We’re all moms, we’re all over worked, underfunded and always tired but overwhelmed with love and sticky kisses.
I,Kate, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Angela commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:37 amThis. Exactly. (Although I have experienced a little bit of the Mommy Wars IRL, unfortunately. But overall, I find most women I encounter to be incredibly supportive.)
Jen commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:38 amI, Jennifer, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
April commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:40 amI’m taking the pledge, officially.
bwsf commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:40 amI, Beth, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Let’s just end this. For the kids.
Marlana commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:43 amI guess I need to read or get out more, I never knew we were referred to as “lazy stay at home moms”. Lazy is the last thing I get to be around here, neither of my 2 daughters (age 5 months and 4 yrs) have been away from me for more than a couple hours. (and that is only when one of them has a dr appt. my mom will watch the other. Or watch both of them if I have a dr appt and my husband takes me.) I’ve never left them to go out just my husband and I or for any “fun reasons”.
My “job” is full time, at least one of them seems to be awake at all times and I am always cleaning something, feeding them, my husband, finally myself when I get to actually sit down. I don’t have help other than my husband. no nanny’s, no daycare, no babysitters, no cleaning service, no personal chef or laundry service, everything that needs to be done throughout the day falls on me.
I received my bachelors degree 3 weeks before my daughter was born.. NEVER used it. The idea of depending on someone else to pretty much raise my child so I could go to work did not sit well with neither myself or my husband so I’ve been been a full time mom since the day my first daughter came home from the hospital. I understand some women do not have that option or even don’t want that option but for me there was never a second thought about it. I’m the best person to be at home with my kids there is not a nanny or daycare center in the world that I feel would be better equipped to have my kids 8 hours a day than I am. I waited til I was older and my husband and I were secure and established before we had kids for the simple reason I wanted to be the one taking care of them at all times.
I’m not in a war with anyone, I do whats best for my family. In my house that means staying at home. I don’t care what choice anyone else makes I can look at my smart, well behaved daughter and know that its because of me and that is all the reassurance I need to know I made the right choice.
Lisa commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:53 amAMEN!!
I, Lisa, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
ilanawiles commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:55 amMarlana- I don’t know anyone who thinks stay-at-home moms are lazy either. I was just referencing Anderson Cooper’s ridiculous show on the topic. He titled it “Are stay-at-home moms lazy?” based on one working mom’s insane opinion which I think was just his (or the show’s) way of getting people riled up for ratings.
I have all the respect in the world for stay-at-home moms. It is the toughest job there is.
Kristin @kdwald commented on Jan 15 12 at 11:28 amThis post is the first one that got me to actually look at the clip from AC – and I know how the producers choose people for the stage. And the vetting and whatnot. They must have looked deep and wide to find women who were willing to get up there and say that about fellow moms.
And while I know that there is an attitude of SAHMs having it “easy” – if not being “lazy” – in some people, most people who take-off to be at home for more than a short leave of absence come to realize that it’s a lot of work – both physically and emotionally. I’ve often thought about returning to the classroom because it would be “easier” on my ego and mental state. I haven’t because of the hustling I know I’d have to do – and for that reason I feel like working moms/parents have it tougher. I’m thankful that our family and our lifestyle choices enable me to even have that struggle because I know a lot of people don’t have the choice.
We’re all on this trip together, and I sign your statement whole-heartedly.
Katie commented on Jan 15 12 at 11:41 amI’m the worst – Selfish DOCTOR mommy! During my pregnancy, I had comments ranging from, “How can you give up all your training and the patients who depend on you to be a stay at home mom?” (never crossed my mind…) to “I just don’t think women should go for big careers AND family, you need to choose.” Amazingly, most of these comments were from women. Not mommies my own age, they were AMAZINGLY supportive, but women in the 40+ range. It was incredibly hurtful, especially since it feels like they’re saying, “You *personally* are not able to handle both.” But you know what? I am handling both. With a very supportive husband and a great daycare.
I have so much respect for stay at home moms, I was raised by one. I would very selfishly miss my job too much, just like I miss my child when I’m at work. My ideal world would be to take him strapped to my back to see all my patients! I think they’d probably like it…
Julie commented on Jan 15 12 at 11:43 amCount me in. I don’t have these kinds of discussions with my real life friends; we’re all too busy raising our families, running our homes and balancing all of the varied demands on our lives, our time and our resources to get all wound up about what some people on TV have to say about us. I really like Anderson Cooper but he doesn’t know jack about my life and why I make the choices I make. He doesn’t know what makes my family work, and neither does anyone else who isn’t me. I’ve given up looking for thoughtful and reasonable discussion online. I have a core group of real life friends, and a core group of online friends whom I trust to be my friend and give it to me straight without judging my choices by their criteria.
I’m a stay at home mom with a part time job; I wonder if that makes me a working mom or a stay at home mom? I earned my bachelors degree just last year. It took me 14 years to get because I chose my children over finishing my degree. And when I graduated, my sons were in the audience cheering, “That’s my mom!” Winning.
Renee commented on Jan 15 12 at 1:00 pmI, Renee, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Having been a nanny for many years before my child and during the yearly years all i have to say is it is ALL hard yet so rewarding! None of the moms i worked for were bad parents, they were WONDERFUL parents. and now i am a stay at home and i love it. am i lazy? Possibly. but the point is everyone does the best we can and we all support eachother. No matter what our desicions are! We all have to WORK, life is work. wether we get paid in kissed and hugs or moneyfor the bils and food its all rewarding and stressfull when we get hours cut or a pay cut or tantrum after tantrum after crying all day. The one thing we all have in common is the most important. WE ALL LOVE OUR KIDS!!!!
Kristen Hill commented on Jan 15 12 at 1:08 pmI am a mother of 3 and have recently become a stay at home mom, not by choice. Well, I have wanted to stay home since my first was born 5 years ago, but we couldn’t afford it. I was pushed out by a new district manager when I came back from maternity leave this summer. I wasn’t available as much as they wanted now that I have 3 even though I was with the company for 8 years and this lady hasn’t even been there a year yet. Needless to say, I am still pretty bitter about the way it happened. But, it was for the best. God has blessed us with everything we’ve needed since I left and I hope I never have to go back. As a former working mom I can’t ridicule someone for making that choice. I only wish that all moms were able to stay home because I do feel it’s best for the kids. No one can take a mothers place as far as the children are concerned. Not even the father. I wonder if a study has been done to see what % of trouble making kids have working moms. Like I said your choice is your own but I know I’m a better mom now because the only thing I have to concentrate on is my children and my home. No more work interfering with my family. They are what come first now and that is exactly what my family needed.
Ellen commented on Jan 15 12 at 2:18 pmThank you, thank you, thank you. It would take me 1500-2000 words to sum up all the ways that I agree, and I don’t want to jam up your comment section, so I’ll just repeat myself – THANK YOU. Real or make believe, Mommy Wars are just plain ludicrous. It’s hard enough being a mom, without wondering if “the other side” is judging you. So glad I’m not the only one who isn’t buying the BS. Have to run – my 11 month old somehow managed to lodge herself half way under the couch in the 17 seconds it’s taken to type this. (Sigh)…..
Mary Helen Sheriff commented on Jan 15 12 at 2:47 pmThank you. Bless you. Life is hard enough without going to war with each other.
elise commented on Jan 15 12 at 3:08 pmFinally a good article about this. All of this is rediculous because:
1. What we are good at/what we enjoy is different. I like to cook and run. But I would never sew anything, and I hate yoga. Anyone’s preference could be another’s annoyance.
2. What we all consider being a ‘working mother’ differs. Some thing of a job as investment banking, some think of a job as nursing. It’s apples to oranges. If I could return to my 16 year old job of lifeguarding with my best friends and playing volleyball on my breaks, then yeah – being a ‘working mom’ would be pretty freaking awesome.
3. The temperment and quantity of our kids varies. I only have one kid so far, and he’s pretty low key and he’s a good napper. But I’ve been around really high energy toddlers, and wow. I couldn’t do it.
4. Your opinion can vary by the day. I have both sucky and awesome days at work. My son’s usually chill, but sometimes he’s a monster – just like every other 2 year old.
Marlana commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:33 pmOh I know Ilana, I just love all these mommy debates. Happens all the time, I actually had a mother tell me I didnt love my kids because I formula fed. (Never mind finding out why.. I am in remission from cancer which I unknowingly had while pregnant with my first daughter. I guess she thought I should have breastfed her chemo and whatever other drugs they had me on for 2 yrs.) My second daughter was never supposed to be born, and I could have died after kid one. I’m happy to be able to stay at home with them. Especially since after surviving cancer it feels like every day is borrowed time.
ilanawiles commented on Jan 15 12 at 10:40 pmWow- your story is amazing. I had a very rough pregnancy (nothing like yours) but it really put giving birth to a healthy child in perspective. It is an absolute miracle.
And people can really suck sometimes. My mother couldn’t breastfeed either for medical reasons and I seem to have turned out just fine.
The Culture Mom commented on Jan 15 12 at 11:51 pmI, Holly Rosen Fink, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Ilana, I have signed it as I support you and the mom’s movement but unfortunately, there are mommy wars where I live. But maybe I cause them, as a mom who failed miserably at being a stay-at-home mom and has been trying ever since I had kids to regain my footing in the industry I work in. It’s not easy.
Elizabeth Hall Magill commented on Jan 16 12 at 9:03 amI completely agree with you! In fact, I think the fabrication of the Mommy Wars keeps the discussion focused on a non-existent divide instead of on ways to help everyone–stay at home and working moms–find a solution to their internal struggles. I’ve written about this on my blog, Yo Mama (elizabethhallmagill@wordpress.com), in my post Itchin for a Catfight: http://elizabethhallmagill.wordpress.com/2011/05/16/itchin-for-a-catfight/
Brittany commented on Jan 16 12 at 12:35 pmI, Brittany, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Alison@Mama Wants This commented on Jan 17 12 at 12:46 amYes, this! So here goes:
I, Alison, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Gina commented on Jan 17 12 at 1:14 amI wanted to respond to this as soon as I read it, but I coudn’t collect my thoughts until now…as I watch the Bachelor.
I am a stay-at-home mom, and I watched about 5 minutes of the Anderson Cooper show. In that time, I was made to feel like a bad mom by the working moms AND the stay-at-home moms. I feel gulty about almost everything on a daily basis, but this was a new low even for me. I am a semi-reluctant stay-at-home mom. I want to love every second at home with my daughter, but I find myself jealous of every mom friend of mine who gets to return to work. As a result of my husband’s job and the fact that we will be moving overseas in a few months, it really isn’t possible for me to work now or for the next few years. I am thankful every day that we are in a position financially where I don’t have to work. Then I feel guilty that other moms would love to be in that position, and I am not appreciating it as fully as I should. Then I think about how much I loved my work and start to feel guilty for not being an earner anymore. Then, as I was reminded by a particularly confident working mom on the AC show, I feel that I am not setting a good example for my daughter to show her that women can do it all and girl power and all that garbage. Then I feel ridiculous that I let a woman I don’t even know make me feel like less of a mom and less of a woman because I am doing what I need to do for my family. Then, as I watch a group of women lose their minds over a man they’ve known for 2 weeks, I have a moment of clarity. The problem isn’t a mom problem, it’s a woman problem. (I swear, I’ll make my point soon)
If The Bachelor approached any of these women in a bar under normal pretenses, they probably wouldn’t give him a second look, except to make a catty comment about his hair or the fact that he does a lot of vest-wearing. However, you make it a competition, and all of a sudden they are fainting, crying, name-calling, and fighting to get a rose. There is a breed of woman who only feels strong, smart, and secure when she is raining criticism down from her soap box at other women, whether about breastfeeding and baby food or dye jobs and shoes. The more superficial jabs can be easily deflected, but when criticism arises about parenting styles, it cuts to the very core of who we are…especially if the career that used to give us feedback isn’t there anymore. What I love about Mommy Shorts is that there always seems to be an atmosphere of lifting-up and support. This is what we need as women, whether we are mothers or not. The decisions we make for ourselves, our children, and our families are based on circumstances that only we know. A favorite quote of my mother was “It costs nothing to be kind.” I recently came across another one that is particularly applicable: Always be kind, for everyone is fighting a hard battle.
Brianne commented on Jan 17 12 at 8:22 amI, Brianne swear to let any mom complain, rant, rave, and cry on my shoulder with no judging – only adult beverages and great food and good listening will be thrown at you!
My motto is try something new if you need help and do what works for YOU. Nobody’s way is right just like nobody’s is wrong. Unless you’re dangling children off a balcony. That’s clearly wrong! Obviously!
cdnkaro commented on Jan 17 12 at 8:51 amAmen! Though I get to ‘enjoy’ the best of both worlds. I am a full-time stay at home mom to four kids aged 4 and under, but am also a full-time PhD student and run my own small translation business (in my ‘spare’ time). When I’m at meetings or teaching my courses at the university, I feel guilty for not being home with the kids. And when we’re having an awesome time together there’s always a little voice in my head nagging me about all that research piling up, and when am I going to catch up? Both worlds have their drawbacks and their awesomeness. My personal motto is: Embrace the chaos. Whatever that chaos may be, depending on your life choices.
Melissa commented on Jan 17 12 at 10:50 amSo..where do I fit into these wars? I work … from home. Forty hours a week, as if I were in an office, but around getting the 9yo off to school every day, and the 4yo hangs out with me, except when she’s at preschool twice a week for a couple hours. Who is my war with?
I, Melissa, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Sabrina commented on Jan 17 12 at 11:05 amThis is the best thing to happen in mommy blogging!
I, Sabrina, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Evan commented on Jan 17 12 at 11:18 amI, Evan, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
I am a working mother and love the days I get to spend at home with my son but I could not stay home every day with him. I envy people who can stay home and who have the patience and energy to be SAHM’s but I know it’s just not for me. It’s best for my family if I’m a loving mommy who goes to work every day than a cranky mommy who stays home.
Tragic Sandwich commented on Jan 17 12 at 12:15 pmI think the whole “Mommy Wars” thing is a ratings grab. Seriously, aren’t most of us using our scant time and energy in different ways?
http://tragicsandwich.com/2012/01/12/whos-got-time-for-the-mommy-wars/
RoryBore commented on Jan 17 12 at 2:06 pmI’ve lived both sides; although I currently stay home. I’ve had comments, positive and negative, in both scenarios. Which only proves: you can’t please everyone, and some days, no one at all.
Sadly, I do think there is a war…a battle of who is right and who is wrong is most definitely being waged. There simple are too many judgie pants out there who want their 2 cents heard. Well, they can talk all they want. At the end of the day, they don’t matter. They can’t tell what kind of mommy I am, and neither do I care what kind of mother they think I am.
I care about what kind of mother my children think I am.
That’s the side I am on.
As for you, judgie-pants: you are either for me, or against me. And you can pick your side….but you’ll be standing on the battlefield alone. This stay at home mom is just too busy to wage war. Honestly, I’ve got better, and frankly, more important matters at hand.
Greta @gfunkified commented on Jan 17 12 at 2:25 pmI, Greta, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
kathy commented on Jan 17 12 at 3:20 pmI, Kathy, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Yes! (I am stay at home, but honestly, I’m pretty jealous of my husband when he goes to work).
Lisa commented on Jan 17 12 at 4:33 pmI, Lisa , am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Kristin commented on Jan 17 12 at 4:41 pmConsider this my signature. Dumbest.Debate.Ever.
Rszustley commented on Jan 17 12 at 9:59 pmI, Renee, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Sara @ Periwinkle Papillon commented on Jan 18 12 at 12:25 amI, Sara, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Allison commented on Jan 18 12 at 9:05 pmAmen!
Jen E @ mommablogsalot commented on Jan 20 12 at 10:18 amI’m in!
I, Jennifer, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
S.J. commented on Feb 03 12 at 7:51 pmDon’t let anything stop you from doing what you know is right for you and your family.Live and let Love.
Amy commented on Feb 12 12 at 8:27 amI, Amy, am a mother. I am not involved in the “Mommy Wars”. We are all mothers making the best decisions we can for ourselves and our family. Thus, we are all part of the same team.
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Mary L Weimer
Beth Anne Ballance
Ilana Wiles
Natalie Holbrook
Monica Bielanko
Emily McClements
Danielle Elwood
Naomi Odes Aytur
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

46