Toddler Times
To Preschool Or Not To Preschool: That Is The Question

Harvard material. But first stop, preschool!
Ten years ago, I thought my biggest challenge would be picking a college. Picking the place where I would study and give my future career wings. A school where I would be proud to attend and find success in my educational pursuits. Sifting through brochures and campus tours, I knew I faced the hardest choice ahead in picking a university.
I only found it difficult because preschool was not on my radar quite yet.
When I first returned to work, we chose a nanny for his childcare. Our nanny is my little sister and the circumstances were perfect — she needed a day job so she could attend class at night, while I needed someone I trusted to watch my son. It has been an amazing two years of working together to raise Harrison and the relationship they share is so heartwarming. One-on-one throughout the day, I trust that all of Harrison’s needs are met quickly and that he receives her undivided attention. I heard for months that a nanny was a great second choice to me being home, but now I wonder if I’m doing my son a disservice with all the one-on-one action.
Is he falling “behind” socially with only the occasional playdate on the weekends? When he gets to kindergarten, how will he know to sit on the carpet square for story time? Will he be too dependent after years of one-on-one? Would he potty train faster among peers?
And then, once we do decide to enroll into preschool…which one? The pricey, fancy building with little toddler yoga and field trips and fresh-from-the-bakery organic snacks? Or the homespun church class with Goldfish and Bible time that fits more like a Moms Morning Out? Or the Montessori school with small classes and play and nurturing the creative heart?
I know that to make the decision, I will need to visit each little school and take into account what fits Harrison best — where he will grow and flourish — all while weighing in cost and driving distance. See, it really is just like choosing a university.
Did you decide to preschool? What swayed your decision? What type of preschool did you pick? Any tips?
P.S. I ended up attending UNC-Greensboro and being extraordinarily happy. Let’s hope I do as well picking a preschool!
Beth Anne writes words & takes pictures on The Heir to Blair.
You can also find her on the Twitters & Facebook.
Go Back To Toddler Times
30 Comments
Nani commented on Jan 13 12 at 4:44 pmI am in the same area as you and have been looking for the same reasons. It’s more for interaction outside of what I can give her than anything else. Bright Horizons and Chesterbrook Academy are in our top right now but I still have so many to look at before we make a decision.
Kathy commented on Jan 14 12 at 8:15 pmTwo of my kids went to nursery school and 2 of them started right in kindergarten. I really saw no difference in peer interactions. The 2 who went to pre-school felt “big” like their older sibling as they were also going to school. My grandson is in pre-school now and it is the best thing that could have happened.
Taryn in Fla commented on Jan 14 12 at 9:19 pmHi B.A.! Preschool is a great way for tots to learn how to interract with others as well as how to develop their sense of self. I think it’s wonderful that your sister has been a nanny to Harrison – what a great, nurturing environment for him! I’d suggest looking for a school that has a low teacher/student ratio or lower enrollment so he can get a little more one on one time. Our daughter has been in daycare since she was 10 weeks old and I really do credit that type of environment for making her the outgoing, silly ray of sunshine that she is (she’s almost 3 now). The peer environment has also helped her with potty training, manners, sharing (sometimes!), trying new foods, and heck, she stopped using the binky there months before mommy even realized. I’ve been to a ton of centers, and I’d recommend checking out as many as you can and going with your gut. We started out at a pricey-yoga-muffin place first, but wound up three months later at a place we initially dismissed (site unseen). Good Luck!!! (p.s. LOVE your blog!)
Shelby Dougherty commented on Jan 15 12 at 7:38 pmI stayed home with my kids and my oldest i know is behind but he was premature and is only behind on speech and some motor skills. But we have already talked about what preschools they are going to and sincce i tought preschool for ayear in high school we are going to send them there. Our oldest will do two years in the younger class with his brother joining him the second year. We are doing this for him just so he doesnt have to struggle later on in school.
Penny Pinching Parent commented on Jan 15 12 at 9:14 pmI have an only and we tried preschool because I really felt like she needed the interaction with other kids and she needed the exposure to listening to other besides us. For us… it’s didn’t go so well. We went to a small church based preschool and at the last minute we wound-up with a teacher who hadn’t taught preschool before (although she had been a elementary school teacher).
We wanted her to go not to learn, but to have fun and like I said learn some of the things that kids just need to learn in a social setting. For us… it was a terrible experience and hopefully it hasn’t jaded her for Kindergarten… I keep telling her “real school is different.”
All she seemed to pick-up was bad habits and grief from her teacher who seemed to pick on my gal. Her teacher would point out things like her inability to pronounce certain words, when she stumbled on the playground, etc. Things that really made my daughter self conscious for the first time in her life. My daughter felt awful and asked me why her teacher always seemed to point out all “her bad stuff” and asked “why she never ever points out my good.”
If you feel like you need to send your child to preschool… my advice would be to pay for the best school you can afford. We looked at much more expensive schools, but felt like she would be fine in a church based environment. We thought… it’s just preschool. We hoped she would be in a loving and positive environment and that just wasn’t the case. I think it would have been the case at a more expensive school where teachers are equipped and trained to handle preschool aged kiddos. This was a small school with extremely small ratios, but it was a case of their hearts seemed to be in the right places, but they just weren’t trained as some schools teachers are.
Like the person mentioned above…. trust your gut. I went against my gut and sent her to the less expensive option. We should have stretched and sent her to the more expensive school.
So, we are at home and start Kindergarten in the Fall.
I NEVER thought we would be a no preschool family, but my daughter is extremely outgoing, fun, lively, smart, pays attention well and I know she will be just fine. I get loads of compliments from her teachers, etc. that she has interactions with and they all tell me not to worry about the lack of preschool.
We make sure to work with her at home and we make sure she has gymnastics class, Sunday school, story time and lots of opportunities where she has to listen, learn, etc. At all these places my daughter is one of the better behaved…. although that wasn’t always the case… she had to grow to that point and we just focused on that as part of our parenting… making sure she knows how to work out problems or differences with others and try to find a common ground so they can play together, we make sure she knows how to listen and follow instructions, etc.I have often thought the exact same thing about giving my daughter too much one on one time or attention. I have wondered if this will “spoil” her. When we meet other kids, I find it’s just the opposite. Because she gets attention and doesn’t have to fight for it, she makes a really good friend/playmate. She is engaging, loving, compassionate, etc. I can’t say the same for some of her little friends.
I will share a piece of advice someone shared with me when I was struggling with the whole preschool decision and wound-up letting her quit the program….
You will never regret your child having too much affection, attention or love.
Brigid from www.naturallyattached.com commented on Jan 15 12 at 9:35 pmMy son is 15 months right now and I don’t think that I will put him into preschool and possibly not Kindergarten either. I may wait until 1st grade or possibly even homeschool through elementary. I’m undecided. I think we tend to rush our children into schooling. Some kids in kindergarten still need to take naps and instead they’re forced to focus and expected to excel?
It’s definitely comes down to personal preference and depends on the personality of your child. I am a Montessori believer and a Mom who thinks rigid schedules for our little ones (birth-6 especially) is just too forceful. We can provide them with socialization through playdates, parks, playgrounds, experiences in general… but again this is tricky depending on your situation and your child’s preference.
Stephanie commented on Jan 16 12 at 12:31 amWe put ours in a program offered at the community center- I think it’s helped my daughter a lot. Our program is 2 hours 2 days a week- just enough to teach her lots and get to be more independent, but not too much :-)
V commented on Jan 16 12 at 11:21 amI’m not a mommy, but as a preschool teacher I can tell you that finding a program that best suits your child and your family life as a whole is definitely hard work! Lots of parents go into the preschool search looking for things like convenience of location and whether or not the school potty trains on site. They may also read the school’s mission or philosophy statement, though I would warn that many schools that claim to be nurturing and child centered are not ). That’s a great place to start. I would also advise parents to spend a good deal of time at a handful of schools once they’ve narrowed it down and observe how the teachers (and director) approach teaching and interact with the children. This will be the surest way for you to get a real sense of the program’s flow and the kind of people who will be caring for and acting as role models for your child! Lastly, even the most wonderful program may not be the best fit if it doesn’t work with your family’s schedule. Do you have to drive all the way across town to drop off your child or interrupt a long established morning ritual? If you have caring adults available to you (like a sister or grandparents!) preschool becomes less a necessity and more of an option. There are other options for your family such as taking weekly art or music classes (where children can learn in a more formal setting) or mommy and me outings that are available in small groups so your child has a chance to interact with other children. Of course, neither of these is quite like preschool so you’ll have to weigh the pros and cons yourself. Lastly there are many misconceptions about schools that are labeled Montessori or Reggio. While they are big names in early childhood education many parents assume that simply because a school is Montessori that it’s a “good school”. Did you know that Maria Montessori believed that children should be taught to use toys in very specific ways (for example, a set of blocks may be designated to use only for building towers starting with the largest blocks on the bottom–try to make a giraffe and the toy will be taken away because it’s not being used “properly”)–that doesn’t sound like the best way to foster creativity does it? In short, do your research. You’ll be glad you did.
KeAnne commented on Jan 18 12 at 11:45 amI had missed this post! My son is 2.5 and we started preschool in August twice a week for 2.5 hours. I’m not sure it was the right decision. Our situation is similar to yours in that D stays with family while I’m at work and has had very little opportunities to socialize. He’s shy and slow to warm up. You think preschool would be perfect for that, right? We picked a church-run preschool that seemed warm and loving, but we’re having major issues that I think stem from D not being used to other kids and how his teachers are handling it. I’m not sure if it’s that particular school or if maybe he’s not ready and we should have waited a year, but it’s been a rough couple of months.
R's Mom commented on Jan 18 12 at 12:05 pmHere’s a thought, if you aren’t ready to completely give up the nanny route right now. R stays with his grandmother three days each week (i.e. lots of one-on-one time), and he goes to preschool two days a week. He loves both his days with his grandma, and his days with his friends, and I feel like he is getting the best of both worlds. R currently goes to a Chesterbrook in our area, and we love it — and they are SO flexible with him being part-time. We can switch up the days he goes each week if something comes up. We can also send him there more than just two days a week with little to no notice (i.e. Grandma is sick), or when my mom plans a vacation, etc. We really like having that back-up for my mom.
Lindsey commented on Jan 18 12 at 12:51 pmBoth of my kids are in full-time daycare at a local church. Aside from the cost (we pay more each month for daycare than we do for our mortgage) and the constant illinesses (daycare = germs), I don’t think I’d have it any other way! One thing I highly recommend when finding the right school is checking your state’s DSS website. There, they list every childcare facility, along with each violation filed against each facility (at least, they do on SC’s DSS website). It really helped us when chosing the right school! Good luck!
Aleta commented on Jan 18 12 at 1:04 pmMy advice is preschool ASAP!
I’ve had my son in FT daycare since he was an infant. His daycare is now morphing towards full on preschool, (he’s 2.5, at around 3 it’s “officially” considered pre-school, with 6-1 instead of 4-1 ratio).
It’s a montessori based school, and we are just thrilled. He’s freaky smart, social, engaging, etc. Allow me a mommy moment to toot his horn: he can use “photosynthesis” correctly in a sentence LOL.
Of course there are the drawbacks, yes there was the two weeks where he was bit/biting… pick up some bad habits from other kids, etc… good with the bad you know but good far outweighs!And, there are TONS of recent studies out there to emphasize how IMPORTANT early childhood learning is.
All this to say… don’t delay on preschool. Harry will LOVE it, you will be thrilled to watch him learn. I am a huge fan of the Montessori type schools, but pick whatever looks best to you. You won’t regret enrolling him sooner rather than later, I promise! (&, part time is always an option too!)
Aleta commented on Jan 18 12 at 1:17 pmJust wanted to respond to V above,
I’m not claiming to be an expert but I am not too sure about the accuracy of your Montessori comments. A true Montessori based school most certainly does not discourage creative play. But I agree with the advice to BethAnne to definitely do your research when selecting a preschool, and I’ll expand to say research both the philosophy, the way they practice it, and of course meet the teachers in person.
molly commented on Jan 18 12 at 1:22 pmWell, here’s my take on it – NOTE: not judging that this is the best option for all moms.
We have a nice balance of preschool 2x a week and my parents watching them 1x a week. Having a shy child, I feel like it is preparing him and helping him develop social skills.
Also? I’m not a great teacher so I love that he gets a well-thought out curriculum. He started preschool at 3-years-old and because of when he was born he will have two years of preschool and one year in pre-k classes. I am very happy with our decision but you’re right. You must find the right class for him. It took me two tries :)
Jenn S. commented on Jan 18 12 at 1:24 pmI was in your same situation with working and my son in a more one-on-one until he was 3 years old, then we switched him to a daycare center/preschool. The change was almost immediate in him. His vocabulary increased exponentially, he became more outgoing and engaging. He now is 5 and loves school, but is also a wonderful loving little boy. I think that the way that we did it helped him out so, so much. He got the wonderful loving 1-on-1 time that is so necessary in those early years, but then when he was a toddler he got to get out and work on his education and how to interact with other kiddos.
Samantha commented on Jan 18 12 at 1:43 pmWe are right where you are. My son was born a few weeks before Harry and we are looking to start him in preschool in the fall. However we are limited in our area because many schools do not take kids unless they are 3 on September 1st.
I stayed home with him the first year, and for the past year and a half he’s been going to a small in-home daycare with 2 other kids his age (and now one infant). The daycare provider is a trained (Waldorf) preschool teacher, so she has started doing a lot of preschool activities with the kids already.
We’re only doing half days, 2x a week for a lot of reasons. One is that we love where he’s at now with the 1-on-1 attention. Plus she already does a lot of preschool activities with them. He also has sleep apnea and our nights have always been rough and most likely will continue to be rough for awhile. Sometimes he needs a really long nap, sometimes he needs 2. Sometimes he needs none. In the 1-on-1 environment he’s in right now he can get that individualized attention that he can’t get at a preschool. But I do want him to have some of that social interaction and teaching in a larger environment. So 2x a weeks seems good for us.
The one we will probably go to is a parent-cooperative close to us. We liked the Montessori school but it just wouldn’t work for our little guy (he’s very tactile and likes to pretend and use things in different ways to figure things out, and this particular school wouldn’t let the kids do that with a lot of the toys, plus he would have had to go all 5 days a week).
Good luck!
Jen B commented on Jan 18 12 at 1:57 pmI asked our pediatrician if my son should go to preschool and she asked “why?” He was already ahead academically/developmentally from what I had taught him at home; so, she said unless “I” needed the break then there was no real reason for him to go to preschool. She said he’ll get enough schooling later and because he was ahead, he might end up being bored and start disliking school before it really even began. Unless you think he needs extra services then he should be fine with his nanny (if that’s what you would really prefer) – assuming the nanny teaches him things like letters, numbers, and colors. I’m sure he gets plenty of interaction with her and has to learn about sharing and stuff with her too. I would assume she takes him out in public so he probably gets more interaction that you realize – parks, library story time, inside play centers…
Mommy2DandK commented on Jan 18 12 at 2:05 pmI vote for part time preschool.
I’m a full time SAHM to my 2, but they are both in a preschool program. My 2 year old is in a Mother’s Day Out program that basically is teaching her how to interact with other kids her age. My 4 year old is in what I consider the best preschool in our town, but it did have a waiting list that I had to get him on when he was 3 months old. He just started this year. He too, is part time. To me, that is the best of both worlds, they still have their time with mommy, but they also get the interaction with the other kids. Plus, it is helping my 4 year old be ready for kindergarten.
I don’t know where I stand on the thought that if you DON’T put them in a program, they won’t be ready for “real” school. I feel that is a bit too broad of a statement.
I DO agree that it may take a try or 2 to find the perfect fit for him. Good luck! Big decision for sure!
Heather commented on Jan 18 12 at 2:12 pmOur situation is this: A goes to a half-day church-based preschool (basically a Mother’s Morning Out) 5 days a week from 8ish until Noon. 3 days a week my mom keeps her in the afternoons and then I take her and work from home 2 afternoons a week. This has worked out amazingly well for us as she is very social and gets that needed interactions with other kids her age, and has learned how to function in a school-type setting. She also gets the one-on-one time with my mom and myself. Its also much more cost-effective this way, as the half-day program is WAY more inexpensive. I think it really depends on what you are looking for Harrison to get out of the experience and what suits your family’s needs the best. I do think there is some value (particularly for first or only children) to having the interaction with kids their own age. I like that its teaching her to share, to play well with others, and to listen to and respect her teachers. She is a VERY social kid (I always joke that she would have been a great second baby!) and with no siblings at home, I feel like that part of her personality wouldn’t have blossomed as much without the interaction she gets there.
Erin commented on Jan 18 12 at 2:15 pmI have Wesley (2) and Liam (4m) in an in-home daycare. It’s a 5 star program, and having just turned 2 in December, I am happy to say Wesley can say all his ABCs and can count to 10. I won’t be enrolling him in a separate preschool program, as he’s already being exposed to the curriculum my DCP has for the older kids in her care. He’s also very social, so I don’t really see the need in taking him from where he’s comfortable, happy, and obviously learning. It’s entirely YOUR decision, BA. If you enroll Harry, I’m sure he’ll benefit, but there are plenty of children out there who do just fine without it. Socially-speaking, Wesley and I would love to have a play date if you’re interested at some point – we’re in your general area.
Bree commented on Jan 18 12 at 2:26 pmChoosing my 2 year old’s child care center was easy because I work there! I teach in the 12-18 months classroom.
Therese commented on Jan 18 12 at 2:54 pmWe are looking into preschool for my 2.5 yr old. My parents watch our girls when I’m in the office. We’re interested in preschool for the social aspects. Most schools around here are 2 days/week for about 2-2.5 hrs/day for 3 yr olds. I think that will be perfect for my daughter. She loves to be around other kids but she usually just watches them. I’m hoping preschool opens her up a bit around other kids.
I toured 3 different places – all were religious based (1 Catholic elementary school, 1 UCC Church, & 1 Lutheran). We are going with the one that *feels* right.
Good luck to you!
Kate commented on Jan 18 12 at 4:05 pmAs a former kindergarten teacher I advise all parents to send their kids to some preschool, even if it’s only a couple mornings a week for a year. Kindergarten used to be the time when kids learned how to go to school but now it’s what first grade was like when I was in school. We could always tell the kids who had never been in a classroom before and while they did eventually “get it” it was a harder adjustment than it needed to be.
Kate commented on Jan 18 12 at 7:04 pmI disagree with those who say preschool is a necessity… I teach kindergarten and used to teach preschool and while there are certainly kids who are at a disadvantage if they enter kindergarten never having set foot in a classroom, there are others for whom it makes no difference. We are lucky enough to have family who watch my two little ones (1 & 3) while I am at school and thus far we have not felt the need to send them to school. My mom takes them to gymnastics and the library story time every week and I take them to a music class and the big one to a cooking class weekly as well. They see plenty of other kids and while my oldest certainly isn’t overly social, she is just a shy kid and I don’t think being in school will change that at all. That said, we do think that next year we will send her to the local public preschool two mornings a week, but that is mostly because she has some medical history and will likely need speech services that I would like to stagy sooner rather than later so they can be more effective. Bottom line. do what works for you and your family. If you think he’s fine, he probably is and if you are concerned that he’s missing something or needs more peer interaction, there are lots of ways to add that into Harry’s day!
Good luck with the decision!
robin commented on Jan 19 12 at 8:23 amWe’re going to send our DS (3yrs. this fall) to 2-day, 3.5 hr/day, pre-school at our church. He is in a fantastic in-home daycare that he just loves, but our reasoning for doing the preschool is to slowly adjust him the the idea of leaving the comforts of his daycare for “school” and also to get used to the atmosphere of learning/doing new things.
I agree that the preschools that are just a few hours seem like Mommy’s Morning Out, but I really think there is something to be said about children socializing and learning how to “go to school.” I wouldn’t feel comfortable sending him straight to full-day, I think he would be super confused and exhausted by the whole thing.
Krista commented on Jan 19 12 at 12:14 pmI chose a daycare/preschool out of necessity. There is just no one near by that I trust with my child in-home. We chose the one we did because a) Best security B)location C) cleanliness D)appearance of children (when visiting several times the children were all happy, playing, clean etc) E) philosophy..not exactly in that order.
We have been supremely happy with our choice. Our son is very well adjusted, truly enjoys being there with his friends and we don’t have the pressure of playdates on the weekend and just wallow in family time..which is good because we know so few people with kids near his age nearby.
Jennifer commented on Jan 19 12 at 10:45 pmI chose a church preschool that is absolutely wonderful. I wanted my son to have more social interaction than I was able to give him. He is only 2, so he goes 3 mornings a week for 3 hours a day. He loves it. He has speech difficulties that are vastly improving because of a combination of speech therapy and preschool. I think it was a great decision. He has learned so much already and I love the art, music, and other educational aspects of the program that I could not provide. And the pride I feel when he succeeds at something at school or has a “first” is wonderful.
Kelly commented on Jan 19 12 at 11:04 pmMy daughter did not attend pre-school and she is all the better for it. While preschool has many benefits, no one ever discusses the negatives. Not only will your child learn to socialize, wait his turn, and sit on the carpet square; he will also learn words, expressions, and behaviors from other children that you may wish he wasn’t exposed to. Positive preschool-like experiences can also be found on the playground, at the library (story time is great!) and through programs like Gymboree – my daughter took music, art and sign language there as well as ballet from a sweet little studio near our home. While I was blessed to be able to take my daughter to experiences like these, you can certainly arrange for your sister to do the same for you and you can take him on weekends. Today, my nearly 7 year old is a leader in her first grade class socially and academically. In fact, last year one month into kindergarten we discussed the possibility of moving her to first grade. The only reason we didn’t was her late birthday would make her nearly 2 years younger than many in the class ahead of her. She is often selected to represent the school at citywide events because of her stellar behavior. Additionally, she never went through a hitting, yelling or biting stage. She never threw a tantrum. And you know what else? She potty trained in less than a week and is one of only a handful of her friends (all of whom went to preschool) who can tie her own shoes. Many of my friends were outraged at the thought that I wasn’t sending my daughter to preschool but we love the idea that for 5 years we had the opportunity to shape her into the little person we wanted her to be with little outside influence. Looking back I have no regrets and am 100% certain I would make the same decision today.
rosemary commented on Jan 20 12 at 2:08 amTotally agree w/Kelly and Jen B. Sounds like some parents are just itching to put the care of their children in the hands of other people. A two-three year old child shouldn’t be rushed into an institution for a whole day experience that can stressful for a very young child. There is nothing being taught at the preschool that a parent with a basic education can’t teach at home w/a little patience and dedication. The foundation of the child’s life (first five years) should be spent w/their parent for the most part. There are plenty of classes outside of the home that can enrich them,and provide social interaction.
Terri commented on Jan 20 12 at 7:52 amI run a Nanny Share out of my home and it works out great. This allowed me to stay home with my daughter, being a single Mom with no family in the area there would be no way to hold down a good paying job without support for back up for illness ect; But the socializing for the kids is a great factor and it begin a Nanny Share, I reduce my price. Maybe your sister would like to take in another child and earn more money while your son gets some social time?
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Beth Anne Ballance
Ilana Wiles
Crissy Page
Natalie Holbrook
Monica Bielanko
Emily McClements
Danielle Elwood
Naomi Odes Aytur
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

30