Toddler Times

Anyone Nurse A Toddler At Night? We’re Night-Weaning!

Posted by naomi on October 3rd, 2011 at 1:00 am
Fuzznightweaned 300x245 Anyone Nurse A Toddler At Night? Were Night Weaning!

He's practically a toddler.

Fuzz is thirteen months. From the time that he was about, I dunno, seven months, he has co-slept for most of the night. Therefore he’s continued to feed for a few minutes, several times a night. It really didn’t bother me that much. In fact, at one point I was singing the praises of co-sleeping because I really felt it saved my sanity since it helped me to get more sleep.

And then suddenly, sometime around a year, it started to bother me. Fuzz started waking up a lot more. Although my sleep was only interrupted very briefly, it was interrupted often, and that was finally starting to wear on me. The toughest part was that he woke up more often at the end of the night, which is when I tend to get my best sleep. So he’d sleep for four hours in the beginning of the night (when I’d do all of my work), then I’d finally get into bed at midnight and he’d start waking up every hour for the rest of the night, or more often. I did that for a few months. I mostly follow the advice of Dr. Jay Gordon when it comes to nursing.  He is a big supporter of co-sleeping and feeding all night as long as the baby (or toddler, or pre-schooler) wants it.  He says:

Don’t get me wrong. I love the family bed, child-led weaning and cuddling all through the first, second, third year or more if it’s working well and if the family is doing well. Don’t let anyone convince you that this is a harmful choice or that there will be “no way” to get him out of your bed if you don’t do it now. Don’t believe anyone who says that babies who cuddle and nurse all night long “never” learn to self soothe or become independent. This is simply not true but it sells books and the myths stay in our culture.

Well, about two weeks ago, when Fuzz turned thirteen months, that whole part about “…if it’s working well…” came into question. I’d officially had enough with the night feeding. It wasn’t working for me anymore. So, we switched things up a bit. I started sleeping in another room while my husband slept with Fuzz. When Fuzz awoke, T soothed him back to sleep and gave him some water in a bottle. Did he scream?

YES.

A LOT.

LOUDLY.

FOR MANY NIGHTS.

NOT JUST THREE.

But T was there with him so he didn’t have to go through it alone.

Now, I feed him at bedtime, and then again when he wakes up at 6am. It was a bit of an adjustment for everyone, including my breasts, but I feel like we’re over a big hurdle. Even if he gets sick and we feed him at night,  it will be easier to do it again. At least I hope it will be.

How about you? Did you continue feeding through the night when your baby was one? When did you stop or when are you planning on stopping?

 

 Anyone Nurse A Toddler At Night? Were Night Weaning!

Go Back To Toddler Times

6 Comments

When Audrey was 12 months old we decided to night wean. Because I work outside the home, it was important to me to nurse her whenever she wanted because I felt like I missed out on so much nursing time when at work. But at 12 months my husband had had enough and took it upon himself to do the nightweaning.

We moved the crib to his side of the bed and he was in charge of all wake ups. The first few nights were torture. I would roll over and be as still as possible so she wouldn’t realize I was there. He would calm her down and get her back to sleep, much the same way he got her to sleep at bedtime. He’d then put her back in her crib.

After about a week of this, with the wakeups getting further and further apart, she was sleeping in her own bed through the night. She realized she wasn’t getting what she wanted and would just sleep. I still nursed on demand during waking hours and whenever she was sick. She reverted back to co-sleeping a few times over the next 9 months, but mostly when there was a stressful event (the birth of a baby sister) or she was sick

I suspect we’ll do the same thing with this one when she hits 1 year (only 2 months to go).

Christine commented on Oct 03 11 at 12:48 pm

Our night feedings were one of the last to go. I nursed all three of my kids for around two years each because it just made sense for us to do so. The transition to weaning wasn’t terribly difficult because they were older. I made an effort to begin weaning at around two with the first two kids because we were going out of state and leaving them with my mom. The third one gave it up on his own.

Heather commented on Oct 03 11 at 3:52 pm

I’m happy for you. However, I agree that all bets are off when they get sick. You have to start all over again. But, hopefully it will be easier the second time. It’s just hard having small children, period. I write this having been up with Abby 3-4 times at night for the last two nights due to ear infection/pain…and I’m ready for a good night’s sleep!

Danielle commented on Oct 03 11 at 4:16 pm

I have this same problem w/my 13 m old. How on earth do you get a toddler to STOP nursing at night! I am so tired and I can t stand so many wake ups. He gets so mad and yells if I don’t nurse him . My husband tries to sooth him, but he just screams, so i give in a nurse him. He wont Cio-I have tried!! I have thought about drying my milk supply or putting vinegar on me so he doesn’t like the taste-but that will probably make him him scream more! Ahh…what to do?

Cara commented on Nov 01 11 at 10:08 am

Around 13 or 14 months, I found myself in the same position. My LO would sleep well for the beginning of the night (in our bed by himself). Once I went to bed, he’d wake up and nurse. He was just snacking and didn’t seem to be sleeping well and I certainly wasn’t! I did a modified version of Dr. Newman’s advice. I didn’t want to worry about looking at the clock (sooo blind without my contacts!). I decided that I was willing to nurse him if he woke up in the first hour or so after he went to bed (usually happened if he fell asleep quickly and didn’t nurse long before bed and I was up anyway) and then I wouldn’t nurse him again until it was light out. He was VERY, VERY mad at me the first night, less so the second and hardly fussed by the third. We have set backs from time to time (he’s 16mos now). He wasn’t eating solids well while his molars and canine teeth came in, so some nights I’d let him nurse if he really wanted. Sometimes, I nurse him because it just seems like that’s what he needs right then. But, at most, he fusses a little bit and rarely cries at all. We’re both sleeping much better. I don’t see him weaning totally anytime too soon (he still LOVES nursing!), but the nights are much better for everyone! I too thought there was no way I could do it and expected it to be much rougher. It was hard to hold my ground at first, but it was worth it.

Theresa commented on Nov 01 11 at 7:29 pm

Great conversation ya’ll. We co-slept with our son up until the time we decided to night wean him at around 11 months. We made sure the routine at naptime and bedtime were super consistent and then we made sure he was very sleepy before we put him down. That reduced the crying a ton. When it came to night sleeping, we moved him from our bed gradually but continued nursing when he awoke until a crib habit was set. Then we stopped all night nursings (there were about 2) cold turkey. We rotated turns so each a parent got some sleep and often dad had more luck because nursing with him is not an option. There were times my son threw tantrums in our arms because he wasn’t getting the boob but we just held him gently and said “the boobies are on night, night”. Using the same language (night, night) we used for his sleep times really helped. If he got too hard to hold we would lie him in the crib and stand quietly by. He soon realized the comfort of our arms was better and he slowly calmed down. Cara – I don’t think you need the vinegar and drying your milk abruptly will cause you quite a bit of discomfort. Pick a night when you are not so tired and your baby is healthy and then don’t give in when he wakes looking to nurse. It will take a few nights or maybe a week but I guarantee the baby will understand and start sleeping more. Good luck and I hope you find this useful!

Amanda commented on Nov 01 11 at 10:42 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Mary L Weimer
  • Beth Anne Ballance
  • Ilana Wiles
  • Natalie Holbrook
  • Monica Bielanko
  • Emily McClements
  • Danielle Elwood
  • Naomi Odes Aytur
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Toddler Times (50 of 1179 articles)