Toddler Times
Considering Extended Breastfeeding?
I nursed my daughter until she was 16 months-old, and only stopped because I was 5 months pregnant and it was getting a little too uncomfortable for both me and her.
I breastfed my son until he was 22 months-old. My goal was to make it until he was 18 months, but that was right at Christmas time, in the middle of winter, a.k.a. – cold and flu season, and I wanted him to have as much defense against getting sick as he could, so I continued through until the spring.
I’m obviously a big supporter of extended nursing, but I also know that it has some pretty strong opinions and stereotypes surrounding it. If you are considering extended breastfeeding, I want to encourage you to go for it!
I think one of the biggest hang-ups for some mamas to get over when thinking about extended nursing is what other people will think of them. We all know that we shouldn’t care what others think of us, but the reality is, it’s hard not to. I want to share a little bit of my experience (and how I dealt with this issue) with you.
The way I avoided others’ opinions was that I didn’t tell people I was still nursing my son, unless they asked specifically, or we were talking about something that had to do with nursing – like sleeping habits.
Most people, besides my family and a small group of close friends, had no idea that I nursed my son that long. It’s not that I was ashamed, or didn’t want them to know, it’s just that I didn’t really think it was any of their business, and I didn’t need their approval, affirmation, or opinion. So I just didn’t tell them.
Just because you extended nurse your toddler, doesn’t mean you have to be an all-out breastfeeding advocate who doesn’t wear a bra and lets her little one walk up and lift up her shirt and start nursing anytime, and anywhere he pleases.
Your toddler has most likely started solid food, and gets a good amount of their nutrition and calories from the 2-3 “regular” meals that they eat each day, so it’s not like they are nursing every two hours the way they do as an infant. You can nurse your toddler in the privacy of your home, and not have to worry about nursing a bigger baby in public and what others will think.
By the time my son was about 18 months-old, I only nursed him three times a day, first thing in the morning when he woke up, before nap time, and before bed. These became special minutes that I got to sit down and relax with my son, and give him some one-on-one attention, in the midst of the crazy days with two young kiddos.
Extended nursing has great benefits for both mother and child, so if it’s something you’ve thought about doing, don’t let worrying about what others will think of you deter you from doing what is best for you, your family, and your babe!
Do you extended nurse your toddler? How have you dealt with others’ opinions and stereotypes of extended breastfeeding?
Photo credit: Daquella manera/Flickr
Getting Something Off My Chest: Should mothers feel weird about extended nursing?
Go Back To Toddler Times
25 Comments
Ella commented on Jul 06 11 at 4:09 pmI still nurse my 14 month old. Why? Because I can! I’m pretty proud of it, too. I don’t add it to conversations when it isn’t necessary, but it becomes necessary because when she is hungry she likes to put her hand in my bra. That’s her signal and it doesn’t mean “breastfeed me.” It means “feed me.” I only nurse her at night and usually she takes a bottle first and nurses to go to sleep. “No child goes to college nursing,” (don’t know where I heard that) and Joelle won’t either. She’s very independent and smart and she will soon let go of the habit (if I leave her with someone else she doesn’t nurse). I just hope I’m ready when she does.
Susannah commented on Jul 06 11 at 9:51 pmI ended up nursing my son until he weaned himself at nearly 4 years old (!). I totally didn’t plan on nursing him that long, but he loved (LOVED) the comfort of nursing, and I loved the sweetness of the special cuddling time it gave us when he was a busy toddler. I just didn’t see any reason to stop until he was ready. For the last two years, he really only nursed briefly just before bedtime, while winding down for the night. I didn’t broadcast the fact that we were in it for the long haul, especially to my family (who always felt a bit squirmy with the idea of breastfeeding, since my mom and grandma had gone the formula route with their babies). I wasn’t ashamed; I was actually a bit proud to be able to give my once-upon-a-time preemie such a good start. That said, I was always aware that our nursing relationship had lasted longer than most of the other families we know. I was reassured to find out that my experience, with a 3 year old who only very gradually weaned himself off nursing was well within the “natural age for weaning” (interesting related link: http://www.kathydettwyler.org/detwean.html). I’ve got a new baby girl, and I’m planning to take the same approach with her, and let her needs drive the duration of our nursing relationship. As long as both of us are fine with it, I’m planning to let her lead the way.
Kinda Crunchy Kate commented on Jul 07 11 at 1:32 pmI nursed my daughter until she was 18 months old and my son until he was 20 months old. I didn’t even think anything about it. I tried to wean each of them when they were around 16 months old, but neither one was ready for it, so we kept going until I was REALLY ready to stop because they had started being a brat about nursing. (Pulling on my shirt, throwing a fit if I didn’t nurse when they wanted to, etc.) I did have people ask me why on earth I hadn’t stopped yet, but it didn’t really bother me. They still seemed like babies at the time so why wouldn’t I still be nursing them? (It sounds like I was tandem nursing. I wasn’t. I just can’t figure out how to phrase the sentences above so it doesn’t sound like that and have it still make sense!) :) Way to go, Emily (and all extended nursing mamas) for doing the best thing for your child and your family!
Laura commented on Jul 07 11 at 1:43 pmMy son is still nursing and he will be 3 years old in September. My goal, before he was born, was to make it until he was 2. 2 came and went and he still enjoys nursing and it is clear to me that he still gains so much for it even if that so much is more emotional than it is nutritional. We nurse every time he goes to sleep and every time he wakes up. We also nurse sometimes when he is totally overwhelmed and the second he latches on his little eyes roll back and it seems like every problem in the world melts away. I am ready to stop nursing, but am committed to him and will let him decide when he is finished. I am fortunate that my family and friends are supportive, though we rarely nurse outside the home. When I do nurse outside the home I do it discreetly, but without shame. I am doing what is absolutely best for our son and am happy to do so.
suzannah {so much shouting, so much laughter} commented on Jul 07 11 at 3:06 pmi nursed my first babe until 21 months when i was 7 month pregnant with #2, and at 20 months, he and i are still nursing. i love nursing a toddler (especially not being pregnant this time around!) it calms us both down, and they are among the quietest moments of my days.
it’s not weird, it just is. he’s still so little to me. i love the nutritional/immune boost he gets (especially during picky seasons), and breastfeeding is a great way to calm tempers and soothe boo-boos. if a mama wants to keep quiet about nursing he toddler, she certainly can, but it also wouldn’t seem so strange to people if they knew of more moms nursing past one.
i love “full term nursing” instead of “extended nursing”. WHO recommends breastfeeding two years–or as long as is mutually desired. (also, i would consider myself a breastfeeding advocate–and i still wear a bra and no one’s lifting up my shirt to nurse anytime, anywhere.)
Laura commented on Jul 07 11 at 3:15 pmI know someone who is nursing her almost 1 year old, and has no plans to stop even though her son clearly isn’t interested. Every time I’ve seen her nurse recently, he pushes away hard, looks like he’s standing on his head trying to get away, and never seems to try to nurse. So, I’m all for it if the child is in to it, enjoys it, whatever. I nursed my daughter until she was 1, and knew towards the end she wasn’t into it anymore. But going beyond that when it’s clearly for the mom and not of interest to the kid seems a little silly to me. Why force your kid into something when he/she doesn’t need to get nourishment that way and doesn’t seem to want to either?
SNSinNC commented on Jul 07 11 at 4:12 pmI still nurse our 19-month-old – once in the morning and once at bedtime, and whenever he asks on the weekend, which is generally about twice a day more (my husband is at home with during the week, and he stopped requesting breastmilk during the day around 18 months). As I often hear of extended breastfeeding, it’s not like I set out to nurse this long, it just happened. I broke it into six month segments – make it to six months, make it to a year. After that, it was, frankly, easier to keep doing it than to stop. When I finally stopped pumping at work at 18 months, that became even more true. I have had no problems – I don’t bring it up, but if I asked I just act like it’s completely normal and no one has ever said anything. At this point though, I’m beginning to kind of want to wean him…which I sometimes feel terrible about, but we’ll start thinking about number two soonish and I wouldn’t mind having my body back for just a little bit, plus I’m a touch tired of being kicked in the nose (nursing is not a calm activity for our son, most of the time). But then I think how short a time this is, in the scheme of things, and can’t quite bring myself to wean him, so we just keep on keeping on. I really want him to be one of those children who decides on his own he’s done, but I don’t particularly see that happening at this point.
Laura commented on Jul 08 11 at 11:24 amI still nurse my 21 month old, she is allergic to milk and eggs and so I know she is getting everything she needs in my milk. No one would ever know she is still nursing, unless I tell them. She only nurses at night, and never even shows interest in it until she is tired and wants to wind down for bed. The World Health Organization encourages mothers to continue nursing for as long as both mother and child are still willing, and I think it’s great. My daughter is very intelligent, healthy, confident and well-adjusted and I feel that a part of that is most definitely attributed to our continued nursing relationship. It was not my intention to nurse past 6 months originally, but that was before I educated myself on the health benefits of nursing, and extended nursing. I feel there is just a general lack of education, and even a lot of misinformation that is made public on the subject of breastfeeding, and it’s really too bad because it gets discouraged when it should be the opposite.
cocoschmoco commented on Jul 09 11 at 1:21 pmI nursed my older son until almost 2.5 (aimed for 2, made it, and then slowly weaned him, partly because I was pregnant and it was uncomfortable).
Assumptions like Laura’s (7/7 @ 3:51 pm) give extended breastfeeding a bad rap. Just like it’s impossible to nurse a baby who doesn’t want to, the same holds true for toddlers. The idea that extended nursing is somehow this “thing” that only the mother wants is crass and ignorant. It’s just another facet of breastfeeding.
I agree that the fact that one is still nursing their toddler doesn’t need to be shouted from the rooftops at all times, but just like when one nurses in public without a cover, both are examples of normal breastfeeding. And the more our society sees examples of it, the more normal it will become.
Angiemonster commented on Jul 10 11 at 9:56 ammy daughter and I are still going strong at 15 months with no end in sight. I am proud of this and make no effort to hide. I am a firm advocate of nip and that includes nursing a toddler. the more people do it, and the more people who see it, the more normal it gets. i wish to take my nursing relationship to 2 at least, and that includes in demand nursing, but will go for as long as she wants it.
Pocket Protector commented on Jul 10 11 at 10:09 amI nursed my daughter until she was 2. It was no big deal, I’m just glad I was able to do so for so long.
Jasmine commented on Jul 10 11 at 10:12 amI extended fed, tandem fed my boys and only now am I in the process of weaning my 2nd boy who is 2.
Jasmine commented on Jul 10 11 at 10:19 amForgot to add my no.1 naturally weaned at age 3. Well depends on a persons views I miss the nursing days with my no.1. And am still nursing no.2 though it’s only when he asks. And most of those times it’s at home
Elsabie commented on Jul 10 11 at 10:55 amI only recently stopped breastfeeding my 3.5 year old daughter and that was only becuase we are trying to conceive again. She was ready for it and I know this because when I explained that she was a big girl now she accepted it without any arguments. We did have a couple of weeks where she would come up to me and say ‘Mummy I’m a big girl now I don’t need milky anymore’. Even when she was 3 she wasn’t ready to wean (I know becuase I tried). I am all for extended breastfeeding and applaud anyone who does it.
Heather commented on Jul 10 11 at 12:07 pmMy son is 17 months old and still nursing. He will decide when he’s ready to stop. I’ll be both sad and happy when he does. Sad to see our special time come to an end, but happy that he feels independent and secure enough to move onto the next chapter of his childhood.
Amy commented on Jul 10 11 at 12:21 pmI nursed my son until he self weaned at 14 months. By the time he was a year old, since he was obviously on solid food, he was only nursing 2-3 times per day. 1st thing in the morning and before bed and sometimes after I picked him up from daycare. Yes, it was a little sad that we didn’t have our, special time anymore before bed, but we instead cuddled over books and lullabies. I figured I would have to ween him at 12 months, but he didn’t seem ready to stop when he turned one and I didn’t feel like pushing him. It worked well for both of us that he self-weaned. I didn’t have to deny him and deal with tantrums and I didn’t have to suffer the pain and discomfort of waiting for my breast milk to dry up. I don’t know how long we would have gone had not weaned at that time. I would think I would have probably stopped by the time he was 2. Given his size and our busy schedules, nursing too much longer beyond that, probably would have been difficult.
Brooke commented on Jul 10 11 at 3:47 pmfunny, I have never thought of nursing less than two or three as “extended” nursing. I thought it was excepted in our culture to nurse this long. Six months to a year is a minimum, not a max. Guess I am living in a very lovely bubble! :)
BMommy commented on Jul 10 11 at 4:03 pmI nursed my son till he was 4yrs 3mos & only stopped because I was pregnant & it became too painful. It’s sad the most people who practice extended nursing are in the “closet” if it was done more in the open it might become more acceptable. I had no problem nursing my son where ever even as he got older. The only person who ever gave me greif was my 90 yr old grandmother who was not nursed & did not nurse her children & thought I should have weaned by 1yr. It’s one of the best things you can do for your kids. There were times when my son was ill & couldn’t / didn’t want to eat or drink. It was the only thing that could calm him down from a tantrum or if he got hurt.
Anne commented on Jul 10 11 at 8:05 pmI nursed until the baby was no longer interested, which was at about 24 months. At that age it was only about once or twice a day, for cuddling and comfort, not nutrition. Those were special times and I saw no reason to stop or make a big deal about it. Toddlers are still babies, but naturally striving for independence. This causes them to wean themselves, and doing it this way was gentle, peaceful, and stress free. Responding to the child’s efforts and needs for both reassurance AND independence and risktaking are key to good parenting. Denying either creates problems.
zara commented on Jul 10 11 at 11:18 pmi am so happy to read that many moms have breastfed their kids for such a long time. i personally fed my daughter until she was3 years old and literally the milk dried up. she is now 5 years old and still misses the breast, so instead she now cuddles in my breasts during bedtime. we still have that special moment of cuddling before going to bed, i know that she misses it a lot still. i did not care what others said. :)
Jennie commented on Jul 11 11 at 12:33 amI think extended nursing is great! I have a 5.5 month old, and our breastfeeding relationship had a rough start but now we are both in sync and our bond is amazing. I look forward to nursing him as long as I can, but I have a question. Some of these ladies say they nurse their toddler maybe once or twice a day; but I was wondering how can they nurse so little and still maintain milk? What about engorgement? If I go 3 hours without nursing I am in a lot of pain!
Jennie H commented on Jul 11 11 at 12:36 amI think extended nursing is great! I have a 5.5 month old, and our breastfeeding relationship had a rough start but now we are both in sync and our bond is amazing. I look forward to nursing him as long as I can, but I have a question. Some of these ladies say they nurse their toddler maybe once or twice a day; but I was wondering how can they nurse so little and still maintain milk? What about engorgement? If I go 3 hours without nursing I am in a lot of pain! I know the body adjusts, but 1-3 times a day doesn’t seem like a lot in order to not dry up?
Jeannie commented on Jul 11 11 at 11:02 pmI nursed my son until he was 2.5 or so; my daughter is still nursing at 14 months. They both seem(ed) to love it, so I can’t imagine doing it differently. To the previous commenter: after around 6 months I stopped getting engorged as much and my body just produced what the baby / toddler needed. I’m working part time now away from my LO and it’s never a problem!
Krista commented on Jul 13 11 at 11:28 pmI grew up with a mother that believed in nursing! She even wore the La Leche League symbol around her neck most days. She nursed all her children till they were about 2, then my youngest brother until just before he turned 3.
I now have a daughter and I wanted to nurse her until she was 2, but only made it to 21 months. She had been self weaning, and it was starting to become a fight to nurse before bed. (She has been independent since the day she was born, and never very much into snuggling.) She is 25 months now, and I know she still remembers nursing because every once in a while she will touch my boob and say/sign milk, but then she will move on to something else.
My family and a few of my friends knew I was still nursing, but I am a very private person and normally don’t divulge any personal information unless I am asked. For me nursing my toddler was something between the two of us, and we both were going to stop when we were ready. It was always a comfort to me to know that at least 1 or 2 times a day she was getting some good wholesome calories.
To Jennie H, Once nursing has been established (after the first few months), I think your supply becomes more just supply and demand. As your baby starts to eat more solid food they will start nursing with less frequency. Your body will adjust without you even noticing. As my baby was self weaning I never became engorged, but when I decided to stop nursing and I was sore for about a day or two.
Tari commented on Apr 04 12 at 11:10 pmMy youngest son was born in 1974. He had a lot of medical issues the first year! We both hung in there and were able to keep up with nursing. We found out that he had many food allergies and later on many eviremental allergies as well. I nursed him on demand until he was 21 months old. I only wish he had wanted to nurse longer. I joined a Le Leache League and they were a huge help. I nursed him until he was 21 months old and wished he had wanted to nurse longer. I just stopped picking him up to nurse. If he signaled that he wanted to…then we would sit down and have that very special time for him to nurse. Eventually he stopped asking for it. I really wished he had wanted to continue more for me than for him as he was ready to quit! I just loved nursing my children. As far as negative comments from others….ignore them. Do what you feel is best for your child. Our Heavenly Father gave us breast to feed our children. It IS a time of Blessing for you and your child!
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Mary L Weimer
Beth Anne Ballance
Ilana Wiles
Natalie Holbrook
Monica Bielanko
Emily McClements
Danielle Elwood
Naomi Odes Aytur
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

25