babble » blogs » Strollerderby
Strollerderby
Reason No. 463 Why I Left NYC: The Other Moms (But Mostly Their Clothes)
There are endless reasons why I left New York eight years ago after living there my whole life. But I’m not about to write (right now) about the ridiculous cost of living in Manhattan, the sticky stench of the subway during the dog days of summer, or the horse-sized rats that stroll down Broadway like they own it and you’re just visiting.
What I will write about right now, however, are the women of New York City. Or, more specifically, the moms. And to get even more specific — the really rich ones.
I’m not particularly sophisticated, but I’m not necessarily a bumpkin either. And yet the sight of some of the moms in New York City might have been the straw that broke my back. I have no interest in competing with them or their wardrobes (and my bank account wouldn’t hold up to the competition anyway), but it’s hard not to feel intimidated by women who have perfected the art of dressing to impress, as is written about in “Curbside at School, a Red Carpet,” in today’s New York Times.
For a certain breed of moms in New York, dropping off their kids at the tony private schools is a red carpet and a fashion show all in one. Some of them dress up — like, really dress up — just for drop off and pick up and then change when they get home. Think about that for a minute. Who has that kind of time? Who cares that much about what the other moms think?
Fortunately my husband drops our older daughter at preschool in the mornings on his way to work (getting anywhere by the crack of 11 is a challenge for me these days since welcoming a second daughter less than two months ago) so I don’t have to put any thought into anything other than getting my teeth brushed and grabbing a shower in between feedings.
I’m happy to dress my girls to impress, particularly since their wardrobe is almost exclusively made up of hand-me-downs from my two nieces (and my sister has good taste, so my girls look good).
Me, on the other hand? It’s a running joke (at my expense) in my family that clothes are not my thing. My parents have spent years begging me to take some interest in my appearance to no avail. My husband would like me to burn the rotating cast of sweatshirts I wear around the house. But none of it affects me. I wear what I like, even if no one likes to look at what I wear. (And I’m not frumpy in a calculated and stylish kind of way, by the way. My frump is genuine and très unstylish.)
When I pick my daughter up from preschool each afternoon, the only thought I put into my wardrobe is whether I’m wearing something for the third day in a row and if anyone will notice and actually be offended.
While I live in a resort town where lots of people have lots of money, unlike Manhattan, no one here is dressed to the nines — like, ever. Showing up in biking, hiking, yoga or ski gear is the norm — even in nice restaurants. Flips flops, hoodies, and torn jeans that weren’t purchased torn are acceptable. Big money is spent, to be sure (the median price for a single family home in my town is $5 million, for example), but not so much on Christian Louboutin heels to be worn before the first latte of the day. The women who dress like that where I live are almost always tourists who assume that’s how people here dress. They are wrong.
I couldn’t handle what goes on in Manhattan, where women spend thousands of dollars on designer clothes designed to look like they spent nothing (but not really). Stilettos worn just for the occasion of the start of school? No, thanks. Floor-length fur coats? I’ll pass (and, uh, not just because it’s 8:30 on a Monday morning). It’s too much effort for my taste, not to mention too much pretension. It’s not how I want to live, and they are not people around whom I want to live.
My clothes are clean (usually) and hopefully I’m not embarrassing my family. I like nice things, but I don’t need to spend a small fortune on clothes just to make a statement that I have money to spend (or don’t, as is the case) as I retrieve my daughter’s backpack from her cubby each afternoon.
It’s one thing to watch snippets of Fashion Week in New York and Paris a couple of times a year on TV. It’s another thing to live it every morning as you send your kid off to finger paint and build blocks.
It’s nice work if you can get it, I suppose. But even if I could, I would probably call in sick.
Do you feel pressure to have your wardrobe compete against the other parents’ when you drop off your kids at school?
Image: Wikipedia
Go Back To Strollerderby
22 Comments
Anon, the original one commented on Oct 20 11 at 4:34 pmOccupy these bitches! Gag me…
Andrea commented on Oct 20 11 at 4:55 pmSeriously? Who cares? I’m a yoga pants and Henley shirts kid of gal myself, but I can not even imagine getting worked up about what other women wear. Guess I don’t have the jealous bitch gene. I actually kind of like looking at really put together women. They look nice. It’s not for me, but whatever. It doesn’t hurt or even affect me in any way, so why would I care?
moremadder commented on Oct 20 11 at 5:48 pmThe concerning thing to me would be the effect on the kids. The article quotes one little girl as saying, ““Mommy, you’re the only one without red bottoms on your shoes.” I used to be so proud that I was raised in the city (Chicago, though, not NYC — much more down to earth), but the way kids in cities are growing up today, I’m relieved to be raising my own in a small town.
One thing that irritated me (and probably many of the moms featured) about the article, however, is that there is no acknowledgment that some of those moms are surely dressed to the nines for work, not dropoff.
LooLoosMommy commented on Oct 20 11 at 7:31 pmHave to agree with @Moremadder a bit here, who says there not off to work? I drop my daughter off generally sporting my gym clothes, however when I have a client or appointment in the morning that’s a different story. I had a job where I was required to wear a lot of high end clothing, which my job paid for so I was happy to oblige so who knows.
michelle commented on Oct 20 11 at 9:26 pmI’m from NYC and this article is total BS. Agree with the pp who said the article didn’t acknowledge that many of the moms are dressed for work. A Carolina Herrera jacket (referenced in the article) would probably only be for the office. Others are in real estate or whatever else that allows them to work from home, or casual offices. Rag & Bone is routine in a lot of downtown offices. And anyway, what’s wrong with dressing nicely at *any* time? For both women and men? Better than wearing pajamas or sweats, which is disrespectful and sets a poor example for kids. All this seems like just so much pandering — another attempt to make Middle America feel superior to, you know, all those shallow bitches in New York. Nice try. Oh, by the way, no dads are mentioned anywhere, because apparently we only scrutinize and judge women for how they dress. I know for a fact that not all of the dads are in business suits, either, but because they are the more serious gender, it’s OK, amirite ladies?
Meredith Carroll commented on Oct 20 11 at 9:41 pmThe vast majority of the moms whose kids go to these specific private schools in Manhattan do not work.
michelle commented on Oct 20 11 at 9:47 pmNot true.
Linda, t.o.o. commented on Oct 20 11 at 11:57 pm“Better than wearing pajamas or sweats, which is disrespectful and sets a poor example for kids.” Here we go again. @@.
bettywu commented on Oct 21 11 at 12:11 amYes Linda, but the best part was the totally un-ironic follow-up line
“because apparently we only scrutinize and judge women for how they dress. “
CW commented on Oct 21 11 at 3:29 am“The vast majority of the moms whose kids go to these specific private schools in Manhattan do not work.”
We almost wound up in Manhattan before my DH’s employer asked if he would be interested in a position at a branch office instead. When we thought we were headed to NYC, I actually researched those tony private schools. I was told flat-out that the schools expect both parents to work full-time, even if there is a younger sibling who is a toddler. The financial aid office will calculate what the SAHM “should” be making, and reduce the aid given accordingly.
bob commented on Oct 21 11 at 10:30 amI thought you weren’t going to talk about the high cost of living.
michelle commented on Oct 21 11 at 11:15 amPoor Bettywu is a little challenged in the reading comprehension department. Perhaps she could have benefited from an education at one of these private schools. Dressing in pajamas or sweats is disrespectful when done by either men or women, as I wrote rather clearly in my post. But we only seem to scrutinize women for their clothing choices.
Anon, the original one commented on Oct 21 11 at 11:15 amOstentatious displays of wealth are generally distasteful and may be becoming dangerous.
michelle commented on Oct 21 11 at 11:16 amI own the fact that I am judgmental.
Taz commented on Oct 21 11 at 12:01 pmyeah this was really judgmental and as a new yorker i think it’s generally not really factual either. just as many moms are in gym type clothes and baseball caps. i don’t know if this is a jealousy issue or what, but if moving to a place where the general style is different makes it easier for her i guess that’s great. i really think new york wealthy moms dress in a variety of ways, from over-the-top to dressed down. also- the writer could have sent her kid to less ritzy pre-school if she really has a problem looking at all of those designer clothes, but i guess she likes to be around rich people (just rich people that don’t dress like rich people?) i don’t know, i don’t really get it.
Linda, t.o.o. commented on Oct 21 11 at 12:50 pm“I own the fact that I am judgmental.” Then also own the fact that you’re shallow and petty and teaching your children that it’s okay to judge based on appearances rather than the content of someone’s character. I’m sure this is exactly what the author was getting at.
Linda, t.o.o. commented on Oct 21 11 at 12:51 pm“While I live in a resort town where lots of people have lots of money, unlike Manhattan, no one here is dressed to the nines — like, ever. Showing up in biking, hiking, yoga or ski gear is the norm — even in nice restaurants.” This is one of my favorite things about living in Seattle. I can go to the symphony… in jeans and hiking boots. :)
Snarky Mama commented on Oct 21 11 at 3:46 pm“While I live in a resort town where lots of people have lots of money, unlike Manhattan, no one here is dressed to the nines — like, ever. Showing up in biking, hiking, yoga or ski gear is the norm — even in nice restaurants.”
*
And this is one of the things I don’t like about living in Portland–fleece is not a dressy fabric people!
Teresa commented on Oct 24 11 at 1:28 pmMaybe they had their pajamas on under their fur coats. I mean seriously, if you don’t care how you look, then you don’t care, and you wouldn’t be writing an article about it because you wouldn’t have noticed what other people were wearing.
I love getting dressed up, I would never wear yoga pants to do anything-probably even to yoga (um if I did yoga). I’m not rich, but if I was I would be sporting Louboutins too! That doesn’t make me a bad person. It just make me a person who likes to get dressed up and wear high heels. We are all different.
You are more judgemental than probably all of the dressed up moms you are judging. They were probably like, “Damn, I am having fun in my fur coat this random Tuesday morning!” and you are being all salty and judgey and getting grumpy about it. The loser is you.
Teresa commented on Oct 24 11 at 4:47 pmI keep coming back to this. The author is judging based on appearences rather than character. How do people not see that? It’s almost comical.
Meredith Carroll commented on Oct 24 11 at 4:51 pm@Teresa — Yes, I’m judging the character of these particular people based on their clothes and when and where they wear them. There’s no hidden meaning in there — it’s spelled out pretty clearly.
Teresa commented on Oct 25 11 at 8:55 am@ Meredith- It seems some of the people responding don’t understand your message, and are blaming the dressed up mothers for judging. I am pretty sure you know what you are writing about-it was loud and clear to me.
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes







Lori Garcia
Joslyn Gray
Amber Doty
Julianna Miner
Monica Bielanko
Sierra Black
Meredith Carroll
Carolyn Castiglia
Sunny Chanel
Madeline Holler
Rebecca Odes
Danielle Smith
Danielle Sullivan
Katherine Stone
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

22