babble » blogs » Strollerderby
Strollerderby
What Made You Decide To Have Kids?
There are parents. There are the childfree-by-choice who are committed to enjoying life unencumbered by little ones.
Then there are those in between. There’s a not small number of couples in their 30s and 40s who haven’t decided to not to have kids. They just haven’t decided to have them yet. As they age, they realize the decision may be made for them, but they still can’t quite make up their minds.
Sound familiar? According to a new Pew study, a lot of people are putting off the baby decision until well into their 30s or early 40s. One woman in that position recently talked to the NYT about it, and she says they got her wrong.
Tamsen Fadal is 40, happily married, and doesn’t have kids. She was profiled in a NYT piece about women who are forgoing having kids in favor of a “fabulous life”, whatever that means. But she says she’s not committed to a child-free life. She just hasn’t decided yet. She writes:
Bottom line: I have not said no to babies and yes to a fabulous life. Those two things can happen at the same time. I have said yes to allowing myself to take the time to make a decision that is right for me. Matt and I are being realistic about the fact that I don’t have forever to make the decision, and that we may not be able to have children at all. Mostly, I am thankful for the fact we are on the same page, and that with or without kids, it’s going to be OK.
A lot of couples I know are in a similar position: they’re postponing making a decision about whether or not to have kids, waiting for it to feel “right” or to achieve a particular milestone in their professional lives, or to have an attack of “baby lust”.
For people weighing the options between child-free living and parenthood, it can be hard to know when to pull the trigger and try to get pregnant.
For me, the decision was always crystal clear: I wanted kids, as soon as possible. For a lot of my friends it’s been less cut and dried.
So I ask you: what made you decide to have kids? Did you strongly consider a child-free life and then opt for parenthood anyway? What advice would you give couples caught in the decision-making process?
Photo: VirtualErn
Go Back To Strollerderby
19 Comments
Gib commented on Aug 16 11 at 11:04 pmMy fiance wouldn’t become my wife unless I agreed to have kids.
So I decided to have kids :)
Shawna Woodson commented on Aug 16 11 at 11:45 pmI accidentally got pregnant, and, against my normal, non-hormonal inclination, decided to keep her!
Brandi commented on Aug 17 11 at 1:14 amI have several friends who knew they wanted to have a child, but kept saying they weren’t ready “just yet”. Waited until they were in their mid 30′s to start trying, then a few years pass & they can’t have a baby without doing very expensive procedures.
We hear of celebrities having children well into their 40′s, but we forget how that isn’t a normal experience for most women. Yes, there are always exceptions to the rule. However generally speaking, if you think you might want one you need to either save your pennies or get on the bus before it’s too late.
Maggie commented on Aug 17 11 at 3:54 amThis is one of those moments when I wonder about our kids reading the blogosphere. A friend of mine decided to have kids “to save the marriage”. When it didn’t work, but left her single-parenting instead, would you want her to tell her kid that?
Another friend grew up in the era when our parents said “when you grow up and have kids” rather than “if … you have kids” … and she decided to have kids because “that’s what you do when you’ve got married, saved a chunk of both salaries, bought the house, decorated the house, and your friends start having kids.” She quit a job she loved to “do the right thing” and stay home to parent. Hated it. Out of her four kids, today two are in jail. Should she be posting to Babble that she wishes she never had them?
From my own personal experience I will tell you that the joys and challenges of motherhood were the area of the biggest lying in my family. Mothers, grandmothers and aunts pushed the notion that motherhood would be my biggest joy and that they never regretted their choices for a moment. So when I found parenting challenging, I thought I was defective in some vital way. But by the time I was in high school, these same women were willing to ‘let me into the club’, sharing their frustrations and regrets just as if they’d never led me down the garden path.
I could say more about this, but maybe my kids are reading it?
Amber commented on Aug 17 11 at 6:38 amI’ve always wanted children. I was making lists of baby names back in middle school. When I got pregnant in college by my abusive boyfriend,however, I knew that I only wanted children with a man who would be a good father…so I did not continue that pregnancy, or the next.
Now I’ve been with my husband for 9 years and have two beautiful children that are the greatest joy in my life.
lam commented on Aug 17 11 at 8:41 amI always wanted kids, but kinda on the “eventually” side. I accidentally got pregnant, and didn’t know it until I miscarried. It was a wake up call. I realized that I would be devastated if I couldn’t have children, and there would never be a “best time” to do it. Three months later, I had my first son.
Taz commented on Aug 17 11 at 1:34 pmi never wanted to give birth to children. i even made my husband agree that he really truly seriously wouldn’t feel he was missing out if we were childless people who became foster parents later in life. he agreed. a year later i was caring for my ill grandmother (who at the time we thought was dying, but it turns out she’s doing great now!) and it was very much like caring for a baby except incredibly sad. i looked around at my family of old people and suffered through a few depressing holidays and i thought maybe i should add a new member to my family to brighten up life! i’m due in january and my husband and i couldn’t be happier! my grandmother is going to be a great grandmother soon!
Seriously? commented on Aug 17 11 at 2:56 pmNone of you have actually answered the question. WHY DID YOU DECIDE TO HAVE CHILDREN? Bonus points if you have an answer that doesn’t include: “Want” “decide” “Should” “always” or accidentally”. If you actually have a reason that isn’t selfish, it will be a miracle the likes of Baby Jesus himself.
tomer commented on Aug 17 11 at 3:14 pm@Lam how can you have a child 3 months after a miscarriage ? r u a rabbit ?
all of you are murderers. overpopulation kills.
Momma, PhD commented on Aug 17 11 at 3:31 pmI knew that I’d feel unfulfilled if I didn’t have kids. I didn’t want to regret putting it off and risk being unable to be a mom. My husband felt the same way.
The timing was more of an issue that whether or not to have kids. I was almost 30, so we didn’t want to dillydally. We knew that we’d regret waiting if it meant having trouble getting pregnant. We knew that we probably wouldn’t regret it. So we went for it.
Alison commented on Aug 17 11 at 4:10 pmWhy not use “want, decide, should, always or accidently”. Should no one stay childfree because of those words, either? That is ridiculous. I am tired of the idea that you should only have children for the sake of the future kids and not factor your own well-being into it.
I chose to have a child because I wanted to love, teach, and raise a human being that came from my husband and I. Also, because I hope to have family around when I’m older and see life perpetuate itself, and hopefully have a relationship with an adult child (maybe children, we’ll see).
Seriously? commented on Aug 17 11 at 5:16 pmAlison, because those are all SELFISH reasons. YOU WANTED “to love teach, blah blah”. Having a child is SELFISH. I just WANT you all to acknowledge that it really has nothing to do with selfLESSness.
lam commented on Aug 17 11 at 7:08 pm@Tomer – Haha, you’re right! That would be an incredible feat. What I meant to say, is that 3 months later I became pregnant with my first son.
lam commented on Aug 17 11 at 7:12 pm@Seriously? – Who said anything about selflessness? Reproduction is the most self-interested thing in the animal kingdom. So what? That doesn’t make or break parenting.
Gib commented on Aug 17 11 at 9:50 pmThe selflessness comes into having a baby only if you don’t really want one and do it for your spouse, or your parents, or something.
Or, if you adopt a kid that needs a home, then that can be selfless.
Actually really wanting a child for yourself, and then creating one, is selfish. You’re doing it to satisfy your own need. That’s fine, but you can’t claim that it’s for the kid, because the kid doesn’t exist when you make the decision and wouldn’t suffer if it wasn’t born.
lam commented on Aug 18 11 at 8:44 amIt’s unrealistic to claim that reproduction is the result of our free will alone. The urge to reproduce is arguably one of the strongest instincts in nature. To label it selfish is to also label eating, breathing, and defending your life selfish, as well.
Sigg commented on Aug 19 11 at 4:41 pmNo, I have no children and I decided not to have children. My boyfriend, on the other hand, does want to have children, but when I ask him why he can’t give me a straight answer. I believe he doesn’t have any real, honest-to-God reason for it other than “that’s what you do with someone you love” or “just ‘coz”. If you are worried for the future, why would you add more people to a planet that can’t support so much people? But if you want to have children so that you are not alone when you grow old and there’s someone to love you and take care of you… could you be more selfish please?
Children are not here to be a source of joy for you, and no parenting experience is out of shouting contests and teens slamming doors, kids throwing temper tantrums and having fights over going to bed, taking a morning shower, washing hands or brushing teeth, or the eternal fight over food. It’s not all roses, and the salepitch thrown at us about “parenthood being the highest purpose of one’s life” or “only through parenthood you get to the next level in life, otherwise you’ll forever stay inmature, incomplete and ignorant of the best of life”.
Don’t have children because that’s what you “should do” or “it’s time” or “your own children will make you happy”. Have them because you wish to, and feel ready to be responsible for another human being, because you honestly believe you can aid that person to become the best they can be, you are willing to respect it as a human being even before it can walk or speak. Have it because you are ready and willing to see the person, not the “cute little baby”. Remember that the people you conceive and give birth to, grow up to be just like the person next to you, sitting on the adjacent cubicle or living next door. They are not pets designed to adore you and worship you. Children also could grow up distancing themselves from their parents, or they could be the ones putting their parents in an elderly home. Some may argue that it depends on “how you raise them”, but when it is also said that parenthood is learned on the go, and you will make many mistakes, how do you know, at any point, that you have been doing things right? Children are not a computer you can program, check and reprogram, or rewrite as needed. No second chances there.
So think about it, and remember, you can be childfree, but you can still have fun with your nieces and nephews, or volunteer at child centers, spending your time with kids that could appreciate your time and care without having to fight them into brushing their teeth.
Scott commented on Aug 19 11 at 8:24 pmI don’t know where this figure comes from exactly, but as I understand it, about 50% of the pregnancies in the U.S. are unplanned pregnancies. The question for many people is not “Why did you decide to have kids” but rather “Why did you decide to keep the baby?” It’s amazing to me that in this day and age so many women get pregnant without meaning to. I know it’s always going to happen, but a full 50%?
It would be great if most parents became parents because they wanted to be, planned to be, and had arguments in favor of it, instead of thinking “oh crap, now what do I do?”
bob commented on Aug 22 11 at 11:57 amI was sleeping too well, fishing too often and was burdened by my cash reserves.
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes







Lori Garcia
Joslyn Gray
Amber Doty
Julianna Miner
Monica Bielanko
Sierra Black
Meredith Carroll
Carolyn Castiglia
Sunny Chanel
Madeline Holler
Rebecca Odes
Danielle Smith
Danielle Sullivan
Katherine Stone
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

19