babble » blogs » Strollerderby
Strollerderby
They Said WHAT?! Most Appalling Things People Say To New Moms
Some people say the stupidest things to new moms. From horrific labor tales to plenty of other opinions that are better left UNSAID. Readers on Facebook and Twitter offered up the most appalling things people said to them when pregnant or with a new babe… and some of these are outrageous! They said what?!
I’ll go first! When I had my first baby, we had taken plenty of pictures and video the first couple days, so I didn’t buy the hospital newborn photos. The nurse handling the order form explained that another family didn’t buy them either, and when they got home their baby died. “They really wished they had bought those photos.”
Stabby
A woman at a garage sale told me with hand motions and everything to “go ahead & get an epidural, honey because it feels like a hot knife is stabbing you in the vagina over and over.” -Robin Plemmons via Facebook
Where’s the remote to shut you up?
“Don’t you know how those are made?” or “You must not have cable,” since I’m pregnant with my third baby under three years of age- Sara, Facebook
Lactivists…
I was in the hospital having an awful delivery experience and while we are all worrying about me and the baby dying my sister is calling my husband’s cellphone- not for updates- but to belittle me for not breastfeeding the baby who wasn’t there yet, since my Dr. recommended it since most of my organs were failing! -Alison Jeffrey via Facebook
Sugar & spice and everything nice
After I had my 2nd son I was at local grocery store when a lady approached me, said how cute my two boys were, then put her hand behind my back consoling me because I didn’t “get my girl”. Lori via Facebook
Mind your bedside manners
2nd opinion doc “you need a c section, now, not after lunch not tomorrow, now. Your baby might be dead or retarded by now” – @SugarTwittes,
NEVER ASSUME
One woman sweetly placed her hand on my belly, rubbing it and smiling in that knowing way before walking off…I didn’t have the heart to tell her I had delivered our daughter three weeks earlier. – Lisa via Facebook
Thanks, Doc
My first child, first check up, the Dr. found out we were about to circumcise him and went on to tell me that he was going to die of a hemorrhage, that I was like the people in Africa doing female mutilation, and that we should have never been parents- Candra Georgi via Facebook
I don’t even have teeth yet!
I was told to stop night nursing or I would rot her teeth (which she didn’t have yet) out of her head- via Twitter, @tristina_wright
Um, ok?
When we shared our favorite boy name with a member of my husband’s family, she said, “Oh, don’t name him that. I know a child molester with that name.” Sara via Facebook
What shocking things have you heard come out of people’s mouths? Or have you had to put your foot in your mouth about something you’ve said?
Go Back To Strollerderby
48 Comments
[...] a funny read about appalling things people say to new moms. I don’t really look pregnant. Well, I thought that I just recently started looking more like [...]
She said WHAT? | Adventures in Baby commented on Jul 29 11 at 1:19 pmHolly commented on Jul 29 11 at 10:40 amEnough with the slideshows already. I REALLY hinders my enjoyment of the site. That said… My CEO upon seeing me back at work post baby: “Don’t you miss her when you’re at work?” Ummm…do you miss YOUR kids when you are at work? Wait, don’t answer that…
jackie commented on Jul 29 11 at 10:48 amSeriously… no more slideshows, please! Is it because you get more page hits that way?
J commented on Jul 29 11 at 10:49 amI agree. Please stop with the slideshows, they are not necessary and make things a bigger pain to read.
Amy commented on Jul 29 11 at 11:04 amThe day I brought my first son home from the hospital, my mother told me that I had not given birth to him because I had a c-section =/
Sarah commented on Jul 29 11 at 12:18 pmWhen I was pregnant with my first child, the doctor that I was seeing told me that if I didn’t have the test to determine if my baby had down syndrome she would be born retarded (her exact words ) or die. My late husband and I had decided that no matter what we would love our baby. I left the office in tears, still refusing the test, and promptly changed any future appointments to another doctor. She is 12 almost 13 now and was born without of the afflictions the doctor swore she would have if I didn’t have the test. She is smart,beautiful, and very talented musically.
Mistress_Scorpio commented on Jul 29 11 at 12:39 pmWhen I was pregnant with my first, a friend at work told me to “prepare to be to’ up from the flo’ up.” Did you just do a Kiegel? Yeah, me too.
Erin commented on Jul 29 11 at 1:00 pmI heard the “Oh, you didn’t get your girl” so many times after having two boys. I hate that.
Kate commented on Jul 29 11 at 1:21 pmTHANK YOU for removing the slideshow! THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU!
Manjari commented on Jul 29 11 at 1:31 pmIt is so awesome of you to LISTEN to your readers’ comments and change your post!
amy commented on Jul 29 11 at 1:41 pm“What do you mean you are having trouble breast feeding? It is the most natural thing in the world.” From my aunt, who stressed me out even further and kept me in tears for two days.
Denise commented on Jul 29 11 at 1:48 pmWhen I am pregnant I have people say to me that I they couldn’t tell if I was really pregnant (isn’t that the same as calling someone fat?). My biggest baby was 7 lbs even. A family member asked why we choose out oldest daughter’s first name since it was the worst on our name list and not very fair to name our daughter after someone on only my side of the family.
admin commented on Jul 29 11 at 1:51 pmThanks for your feedback, readers. We removed it. Best, Babble Editors
Jan commented on Jul 29 11 at 2:12 pmI want to know who Candra’s doctor was so we can use him! Good for him for trying, although he might want to soften his approach :P
bethany commented on Jul 29 11 at 3:21 pmWhen I was pregnant with my neighbor, whom we have never gotten along with, came up to me and told me that I would need a breast reduction after I had the baby or else I would never being able to keep my husband interested…….yeah, she’s lucky she didn’t get slapped!!
Alison commented on Jul 29 11 at 3:32 pm(From a very elderly lady in a Hoveround in the grocery store while I was carrying my baby in an Ergo)
Her: “Is that a real baby”
Me: “Yes”
Her: “Is it alive?”
Me: “Um.”Thanks for getting rid of the slideshow!!!
meme commented on Jul 29 11 at 3:41 pmI was told that in this day and age I could choose not to have a baby, that I shouldn’t fold under the pressure to have a baby, and that you never know if they will grow up and kill you. Um…..
Libby commented on Jul 29 11 at 5:18 pmI told an aunt the name we chose (Desmond), and her response was: oh–that name is still on the table, huh?” As if I were negotiating peace in the mideast.
Other good name comment: A painfully rednecky coworker saw my son’s name on our registry. Her question was “Is that really the name? I thought you were trying to play a prank on us.”
Really? I thought the same thing about your clothes.
Libby commented on Jul 29 11 at 5:23 pmI made the mistake of mentioning that my husband wasn’t a big sports fan, joking that my son would have to learn about sports from his school friends….a coworker lamented that my son would probably end up gay. When I countered with “maybe he will, maybe he wont, what does it matter…?” yikes. It was panic and pity her eyes for our godless sportsless household.
jaime commented on Jul 29 11 at 6:40 pmI’ve had 3 beautiful baby boys, and everytime someone finds that out they say ” so are you going to try for a girl?” Like my 3 kids aren’t good enough!
I HATE that!
J commented on Jul 29 11 at 6:47 pmThe first words out of my mothers mouth when I told her I was pregnant with my first were, “Are you going to raise the baby to be a Satanist?” “Umm…no mom, I’m not…seeing as I’m not now and never have been a Satanist.” “Oh good, Congratulations then.”
Snarky Mama commented on Jul 29 11 at 7:32 pmWhen I was pregnant with my first, my neighbor (whose children I had been babysitting for free for weeks, btw), told me I must be having a girl because my “nose got huge”. Two months later, I my son was born.
Janelle commented on Jul 29 11 at 7:43 pmI love it Stephanie! Your posts are absolutely awesome and whitty. Way to think up some fun stuff to talk about. I have enjoyed them all….and really, the slide shows have not bothered me :)
Mary @ Parenthood commented on Jul 29 11 at 9:59 pmA friend of the family came up to me after church to say that he had thought I’d been putting on quite a lot of weight and only just realized that it seemed to be “quite localized”. He asked whether congratulations were in order. Needless to say I was rather taken aback! This was mid Jan. My daughter was born less than six weeks later.
Cai commented on Jul 29 11 at 10:24 pmMany, many people think my wife and I are a lesbian couple because I have very effeminate looks. I don’t care about that. What I care about is the number of people who ask (sometimes repeatedly) whose baby it is. When we’re clearly a couple, and the baby clearly reacts to both of us as parental units.
Whose baby is it?
OURS.
K commented on Jul 30 11 at 1:28 am“Oh look, that’s not a doll, it’s a real baby!” (Odd. I don’t know many 20-somethings who breastfeed baby dolls at the fabric store.)
“Oh, what a sweet little boy. He’s so handsome. How old is he? He looks like he’s such a happy little gentleman.” (My daughter was wearing a pink shirt and floral pants when this was said.)
MIchelle commented on Jul 30 11 at 12:54 pmMy baby is 18 lbs at 3 months, and short for his age, so he is ROLLING in baby chub. The Hubs’ greatgrandma keeps asking if my ‘milk is too rich’ for him. I don’t even know what that means!
ali commented on Jul 30 11 at 4:56 pmmy daughter was also close to 20 pds at 3 months and I was told to “get her on a breast feeding schedule because there IS such a thing as infant obesity”
La Rêveuse commented on Jul 31 11 at 10:04 pmMy stepmother, who to this day insists that my daughter didn’t have colic–it was MY fault for being a nervous new mom. Oh, so I’m the one that kept her awake for 17 hours straight at 3 months? And I must poke her with pins all day long to make her scream for 3 hours at a time, yeah that’s it.
Note, my daughter is now 4, and I have a second, who slept through the night IN THE HOSPITAL and is the most Zen baby I’ve ever met. But yeah, the colic was just ME being oversensitive and nervous. :rolls eyes: Whatever.
Sarah @ BecomingSarah.com commented on Aug 02 11 at 12:38 amOn the name front, when my husband and I were expecting, we carefully selected one girl name and one boy name. We didn’t find out what we were having until the delivery room, so we the name reveal was our big thing. The names were set in stone. The boy name we picked was Arthur Daniel. Arthur for a man who kept my husband’s family together after his father ducked out, and Daniel for my father, who is as near to a father to my husband as possible.
When we announced them, everybody nodded in approval and chattered excitedly. All except one person. They pretended to sneeze and said “Oh, sorry, it’s just that I’m allergic to the boy name. It’s really bad.”
REALLY? It’s bad enough that you need to criticize our name selection when you know it’s set in stone, but you also feel the need to criticize it after you’ve been told the reasons and sentiments behind our name picks? Really?
I have other ones, but that one to me is it’s own special kind of jackassery.
Sarah R commented on Aug 02 11 at 2:18 pmThis is such a fun post, Steph! I have two (and probably more the more I think about it!)
1) A 60ish person was peering over my shoulder as I held my 3 week old, who had a slight case of jaundice and looked tan. She asked, “Is his father Mexican?” Not that it would have mattered if my husband was Mexican, but I thought it was a nosy question!
2) My mother-in-law was over at our house “helping” me with our son when he was just a couple days old. I was delirious from lack of sleep and the joy of finally having my baby. My son was sleeping peacefully, and she goes, “Oh, just wait until he starts teething.” Thanks for letting me enjoy the moment!
karina commented on Aug 07 11 at 4:48 amSooo… i get this alot (almost 8 months after my son was born)… his name is Alex… simple 4 letter name. when people ask me what his name is I tell them that his name is Alex… and they automatically say “Alexander” beautiful name… my reply is always… nope. just Alex. not Alexander or Alejandro… just Alex. its getting quite annoying that they asume his name is Alexander…
Lindsey commented on Aug 07 11 at 5:11 amMy mother in law gave my child a knit sweater for her baby shower gift. We live in Hawaii…
The night before her husband had told my mom that it was something she had made for someone else but had decided not to give to them. Seriously. He wasn’t kidding. :S
Veronica commented on Aug 07 11 at 5:45 amWhen I went to my first OB appointment, my blood pressure was slightly elevated. I was nervous–first pregnancy, my family and baby’s father didn’t know, unexpected/unplanned pregnancy. Upon discovering my high blood pressure, the nurse comes back and tells me, “We’re transferring your primary care to another doctor because Dr. Miller doesn’t think you’ll keep your baby very long.” Even if the doctor had said that, she didn’t have to tell me and make me even more scared. Now, I have a beautiful and perfect 7 week old baby boy.
April commented on Aug 07 11 at 6:08 amWhen we found out with our daughter that she was a girl we met my husbands Mother and Grandmother at the same time to announce the news..When I said “It’s a Girl!!”, his Grandmother looked at my husband and said “It’s your fault its a girl”…I was like wtf!! It’s not a fault, its OUR baby!! Then with our current pregnancy I called his mother at home and said again “It’s a girl”..he 1st reply..”Well thats Okay” in an approving way!!! Seriously, are you people against baby girls??!!!
Valerie commented on Aug 07 11 at 6:32 amI was told my son would be a bad man and father because his father skipped out before be was born and his grandfather left when his dad was a baby…. Cool thanks for making my personal agony worse.
Agnes commented on Aug 07 11 at 9:02 amEverytime people see me with my 2,5yo son and 7mo daughter, they say: oh, you’re lucky, all the children at home already. Hate it! So if I had 2 boys I would be permitted to have another baby in hope of a girl? I hope for a few girls and boys, I’m not (hopefully) finished yet with my family!
Marilyn commented on Aug 07 11 at 9:15 amI had my second child, a boy, in a freestanding birth center. My MIL, who works for the hospital that tried to switch my first child, told me that it would kill her grandbaby and that midwives don’t know how to deliver babies.
After he was born safely, she and FIL burst into the room and asked when he would be circumcised, before even looking at their first grandson. I was then told that he would grow up to hate us and end up killing us because he’ll get AIDS. We kept the whole baby.
Gloria commented on Aug 07 11 at 9:26 amI wasn’t getting along with Sister in law and I noticed that she never wanted to look much less go near my daughter and when I asked her about it she said it was because she couldn’t stand to look at her. I haven’t spoken to her much since that.
Gloria commented on Aug 07 11 at 9:29 amI wasn’t getting along with Sister in law and I noticed that she never wanted to look much less go near my daughter and when I asked her about it she said it was because she couldn’t stand to look at her. I haven’t spoken to her much since that.
She is the only one who felt that obviously because I always had people come up to tell me how beautiful my daughter was.
When I was in the hospital having my daughter no one came to visit my hubby was the only who there by my side the whole time and he had to call my family and ask them to visit.
My brother told me I was being selfish because I was having a cesarian instead of natural birth despite the fact that I was having complications.
Gloria commented on Aug 07 11 at 9:30 amI wasn’t getting along with Sister in law and I noticed that she never wanted to look much less go near my daughter and when I asked her about it she said it was because she couldn’t stand to look at her. I haven’t spoken to her much since that.
She is the only one who felt that obviously because I always had people come up to tell me how beautiful my daughter was.
When I was in the hospital having my daughter no one came to visit my hubby was the only who there by my side the whole time and he had to call my family and ask them to visit.
My brother told me I was being selfish because I was having a cesarian instead of natural birth despite the fact that I was having complications.
Also that I was being a bad mom because I was not breast feeding.
JenAHM commented on Aug 07 11 at 9:34 amLuckily, I haven’t had too many awful comments since having our daughter, who is now 3 1/2 months old. However, a friend of mine was called selfish by an aunt because she has chosen to breastfeed, therefore, “not allowing anyone else to have the joy of feeding the baby.”
Jamie commented on Aug 07 11 at 9:57 amWhen my son was (maybe) a few weeks old, we went out to dinner at a small local diner with my mother. There was an elderly man at the table next to us that I could have sworn was giving me dirty looks from the moment we walked in. Well he must have built up his courage after we’d been there for a bit because he leaned over and with a dirty look in a snide tone he said, “I ASSUME his father must be at work then, huh?” Yes, actually he was… but the fact that just because I was out in public without him he would assume I was a single mother and be so disgusted by it pissed me off so bad!!
Gloria commented on Aug 07 11 at 10:05 amMy sister in law and i were not getting along to begin with but while at her daughter’s (my niece) 5th birthday she told me the reason she never asked to hold my weeks old baby girl is because she couldn’t bare to look at her. Mind you she is the only one who must have felt this way because i always had people come up and tell me how cute she was.
I spent a week in the hospital because i was overdue and my daughter just did not want to come out and the possibility of a c-section was looking inevitable, my older brother who was asked by my hubby to visit basically told me i was being selfish and not trying hard enough because i was considering a C-Section instead of a natural birth.
Nikki commented on Aug 07 11 at 11:15 amI hate the gender comments! My daughter was always decked out in pink (because we got a gazillion pink outfits at the shower) and people would always say “He’s so cute! What’s his name?”. I was forced to reply, “Caroline. HIS name is Caroline…” LOL
Gloria commented on Aug 08 11 at 6:10 pmsorry about the repeat posts my iphone kept saying that my post was not successful.
Sophistishe.com commented on Aug 10 11 at 4:27 am“You know things are not going to get any easier with Greg Jr. on the way.”
(that was the last convo I had with this person)
HappyMom commented on Aug 18 11 at 3:37 pmWhen I was in my third trimester and feeling quite large, a pretty 20-something, single, child-free, female co-worker said to me, “Wow, you just keep getting bigger everytime I see you. I mean seriously, you are so big, you look structurally unsound.” Then about three weeks after the baby was born and he was nursing often due to a growth spurt, my MIL said, “You’re just not producing enough milk.” Those are fighting words, let me tell you!
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes







Joslyn Gray
Amber Doty
Julianna Miner
Monica Bielanko
Sierra Black
Meredith Carroll
Carolyn Castiglia
Sunny Chanel
Madeline Holler
Wendy Michaels
Rebecca Odes
Danielle Smith
Danielle Sullivan
Katherine Stone
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

48