Strollerderby

Extreme Gender Preference: Indian Baby Girls Given Sex Change Operations

Posted by meredith carroll on June 29th, 2011 at 10:26 am
Baby kokon11 300x225 Extreme Gender Preference: Indian Baby Girls Given Sex Change Operations

Can you even imagine subjecting a baby to an unnecessary sex change surgery for your own gain?

First came the couple keeping the sex of their baby a secret, and now there’s the preschool that’s banning the use of the words “him” and “her.”

But on the opposite end of the spectrum are people who have few qualms about wanting one gender over the other, like, a lot. Count me in this camp (sort of), particularly since I wrote the other day about why I’m happy to have given birth to one daughter with another on the way. But if I did happen to gave birth to a son, I have no doubt I would love him to bits, too. My preference for girls is not much more than skin deep, as I couldn’t in good conscience have a preference that’s seriously stronger for anything other than a healthy baby.

The same can’t be said for some parents in India. Some young girls — as many as 300 — in the city of Indore have allegedly been surgically changed from girls to boys. The genitoplasty surgery, which runs a little over $3,000, has been performed on girls as young as 1 year old.

The state government in Madhya Pradesh is investigating the claims. The surgery involves doctors creating a male penis from the female sex organs. At the end, the girls are injected with male hormones.

The idea behind the surgery, apparently, is that sons improve a family’s prospects.

India is no stranger to gender bias. Aborting a girl fetus isn’t unusual for cultural reasons, particularly since a daughter’s family is responsible for paying for an elaborate wedding and pricey dowry. But you know something’s seriously off when there are 7 million more boys under the age of six than girls in the country.

While I recognize that culture often dictates things like gender preference, I think it’s beyond reprehensible to subject babies to something this serious because of financial reasons or social status. The poor baby girls undergoing these surgeries face a lifetime of problems as a result — physically, hormonally, psychologically and emotionally. It seems beyond warped to me that anyone choosing to have a child ultimately wouldn’t just love and care for whichever flavor comes their way.

If your preference for a boy over a girl is that strong, perhaps you need to rethink the decision to have children at all.

Is there a more extreme example of gender preference than medically unnecessary sex change surgery for babies?

Image: Wikipedia


 Extreme Gender Preference: Indian Baby Girls Given Sex Change Operations

Go Back To Strollerderby

15 Comments

[...] takes its gender preference seriously: It has 7 million more boys than girls under age 6, says Meredith Carroll at Babble. But really, “it’s beyond reprehensible to subject babies to something this serious because [...]

India’s ‘shocking’ child sex-change epidemic « Women Born Transsexual commented on Jun 30 11 at 7:12 pm

[...] takes its gender preference seriously: It has 7 million more boys than girls under age 6, says Meredith Carroll at Babble. But really, “it’s beyond reprehensible to subject babies to something this serious because [...]

India’s ‘shocking’ child sex-change epidemic (The Week) | NewsPeruse.com Latest and Breaking News commented on Jul 01 11 at 12:08 am

[...] 01:46 AM   #1   document.write(fpads); http://blogs.babble.com/strollerderb…ge-operations/ Apparently baby girls are 'pricey' with the traditional Indian wedding needed. Where as a baby boy [...]

Sex Change Operations for Baby Girls in India - The Lounge Forum commented on Jul 02 11 at 8:46 pm

[...] К примеру, в небольшом городке Индор такие операции в 2010 году были проведены над 300 девочками. [...]

Индия: лицензия на пистолет или лотерейный билет в обмен на стерилизацию | Толкователь commented on Jul 04 11 at 4:12 am

More importantly, were they circumcised?

bob commented on Jun 29 11 at 11:52 am

This strikes me as very weird, because the financial cost of such surgery (and years of subsequent treatment) would only be available to families with the kind of means that would make the ‘cost’ of having a girl less dire. Something is off here.

Korinthia commented on Jun 29 11 at 12:00 pm

I concur with “This strikes me as very weird, because the financial cost of such surgery (and years of subsequent treatment) would only be available to families with the kind of means that would make the ‘cost’ of having a girl less dire. Something is off here.”

Have you researched this at all? Sounds like you may have been punk’d.

Dave Lucas commented on Jun 29 11 at 1:29 pm

Yeah, this strikes me as EXTREMELY implausible. There is no way to change a baby girl into a baby boy with one operation; to do it at all would require years of revision surgeries, hormone treatments, etc., on top of the initial $3,000, which is a huge amount of money in rural India. These ‘boys’ would never be able to father children, which seems as though it would limit their (arranged) marriage prospects pretty severely. Either this an urban legend, or it’s some sort of scam being perpetrated on the families.

Diera commented on Jun 29 11 at 3:38 pm

Just because you think it isn’t plausible doesn’t mean there aren’t families desperate enough to fall for it. I have no doubt this is happening.

Kaycee commented on Jun 30 11 at 8:02 am

It is clear the journalist has never been to india and that the journalist has no comprehension of sex reasignment surgery on adults or children.

This racist fabrication was also covered in Pink News.
http://www.pinknews.co.uk/2011/06/28/indian-parents-using-sex-reassignment-surgery-for-more-sons/

There is no way to get a fully functioning penis with the technology level at present. Most sex reasignment surgeries to male of an intersex child have failed miserably. Also the cross sex hormone treatment required to bring on a puberty would mean that the child would be under permanent medical control. In India the cost of that would be unaffordable for anyone but the top 1% of the society, who could just afford to ultrasound and abort anyway if they so wished.

Giving a child hormones at 5 years of age would not occur even in an intersex child being reasigned.

Also assuming the child was sucessfully sex reasigned, the child would be 100% sterile.

I would not only question the accuracy of this report, but bluntly state it is completely and utterly fabricated.

In India there is a very big problem with parents using ultrasound and sometimes genetic testing to determine if a child is a boy or girl and aborting the girls. An abortion is a lot cheaper, as in 2% to 10% of the cost, depending on clinic.

This blatant misuse of a country which people in the West have little to no knowledge of, is racism in disguise. So many people have sexualised and fetishised there ideas of the Eastern and South Asian countries, they can not see the facts, lack of facts or complete and utter fabrications, at all.

We have seen this before when LGBT activists claimed that Iran was forcing gay men to have sex changes when in fact the clincians were screening them out of the programs, at the first meeting. Iran has a lower rate of regretter after sex reasignment surgery amongst TS people than Charing Cross in london.

The constant use of LGBT by the LGBT organisations when campaigning against Iran has actually caused problems for transsexual people on the ground in Iran. LGBT groups know that full well. Transsexuals in Iran would be very easy to round up. I think everyone knows where that piece of political strategy could lead, which is most likely the aim, so that LGBT groups can complain even more.

We should know better than to fall for this completely fabricated nonsense designed to put people from India, into a bad light for what is clearly a political aim.

How do I know these things. I have asked Iranian and Indian people for the actual facts, as I have asked Chinese, Japanese, Iraqi, Malaysian, Brazilian, Chilean and Thai people about there countries. I would suggest people start doing that. People may find that instead of getting answers from some idiot on the internet, that actually asking people in real life over a coffee gets a lot more accurate set of facts.

I have suggested to both Iranian and India associations locally to report the groups responsible for racist fabrications, but unfortunately they just want a quiet life. I would suggest to anyone reading this to report these articles to any associations connnected with India so they can lodge racism complaints against the authors.

Being part of a minority does not make attacking other completely innocent people acceptable for political gain.

It is long overdue the blatant racism by LGBT groups against entire countries, cultures and geo-graphical areas was stopped.

Nemesis commented on Jul 01 11 at 4:01 am

In my opion wen people start trying to play God they end results will be devastating, I have boys and could not be any happier, if I had girls I would feel the same, God chose because he knows wat I need, no matter where I live or wat my situations in life r, once people learn that GOD DOES NOT MAKE MISTAKES, then I believe this world will be a much better place, I just wonder if in the process of all this do them people ever stop to think that those babys are Gods gift to a family, not some thing to use as a means to better position them selfs in sociaty or wat ever thry r tryin to do..JUST SAYING

sandy wilkerson commented on Jul 02 11 at 6:44 pm

I worked in India for many years as a missionary and married an India. It is certainly no lie that girls are far less desired and that abortion (though illegal) is very common, but this story seems quite unlikely as others have stated. Orphanages are overrun with girls but to go to this extreme, I can’t imagine. Only the very wealthy could afford such a thing.

If this is true, I can only imagine it is a serious scam that some very backwards doctors are doing underground to fool uneducated and vulnerable people. Very possibly uneducated people are falling for this scam and believing it is that simple to change their girls into boys and very possibly they are giving them all their life-savings. I wouldn’t doubt a major scam is the culprit here, which is why it may be a one time fee with no follow up surgeries or hormone replacement therapy and such.

One might be surprised how much money poor people have. These people save up their whole lives for weddings and such and though they live in poverty, often have much wealth handed down in gold and jewellery and such. It is very plausible this is happening–but again, that it is a scam.

Tara commented on Jul 02 11 at 6:44 pm

Well everyone beat me to it but um, yeah, not real. And Babble should remove it and take it off the Facebook feed.

Lisa W commented on Jul 02 11 at 8:17 pm

babble has become its name sake babble, what nonsense im ashamed i even liked the page such hatism and racism and the narrowmindedness there is no proof just hear say . many countrys use abortion for many reasons including america and its legal here in the good ole usa to do selective abortion while it is not in the countrys you mention above it is illegal and the doctors are jailed and ridiculed publicaly . i dont see any reports on vaccines and food products that use aborted fetus tissue to either enhance the lfavor of its products or to protect the few .now thats a real issue how about you report on that instead of made up hatism?. pepsi and many other food products we consume contain fetal cells now aint that canibilism? and isnt it murder to use fetal cells of the many to protect the few? its unethical whether your religouse or not get your head out of your rearends and get a clue on tabloid journalism and factual intellegent non biased journalism please. fyi im american, im caucasian with a mixed ratial background including native american ,irish,polish etc, and was raised cathlic and even i know this is made up propraganza .its just not feasable when you look at the cost of sex change you cant just do it like that takes years and alot of money far more then a dowry and its cheaper to abort..’journalits’ like you bring a reputable publishing news source down to the ground do some research and stop bringing down your company its not hard to do some research and add facts or is it hard to come up with a reputable article because you cant come up with ideas. what babble nonsense. there are alot of good articles on babble but many more that leave a bad taste in my mouth like the one above.

Diana Wright commented on Jul 03 11 at 6:32 pm

who wants to eat some processed foods mmm mmm pass that fetus thigh, and lets inject ourselves with dead carcasses while were at it because its better then not being vaccinated . research just type in google foods that use aborted fetuses, then type in vaccines that contain aborted fetuses. now aint that delicously cannabilistic isnt it against the law to murder yet we are allowed to. im growing my own, makeing my own and if it were possible not that it is medically treating myself. just cant trust corporate monsters, nor can you trust statistically flawed medical science.it may save lives but at what cost a life of another to save your own?

Diana Wright commented on Jul 03 11 at 6:36 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Lori Garcia
  • Joslyn Gray
  • Amber Doty
  • Julianna Miner
  • Monica Bielanko
  • Sierra Black
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Carolyn Castiglia
  • Sunny Chanel
  • Madeline Holler
  • Rebecca Odes
  • Danielle Smith
  • Danielle Sullivan
  • Katherine Stone
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Strollerderby (50 of 11490 articles)