Strollerderby

Tying The Knot: Are Parents Better Off Married?

Posted by sierra on April 11th, 2011 at 1:17 pm

4101144667 64905f2e6b 300x225 Tying The Knot: Are Parents Better Off Married?What compelled you to get married?

For me, it was a simple decision: I was pregnant, and my boyfriend wanted to marry me. I’d been against marriage, but he made a persuasive case based on details like sharing health insurance and being able to make medical decisions for each other. Yes, we could have recreated a lot of the benefits of marriage without tying the knot, but marrying him was a simple, practical solution to a host of problems I had little energy to solve while battling morning sickness and making ready for the huge change a baby would bring to our lives.

In other words, it was very pragmatic. There was little romance to our quiet elopement, no fancy dress or giant cake. I never got the big white wedding little girl’s often dream of, and I minded only a little.

For other women though, apparently, the need to be married can take hold with a fever akin to baby lust. They become irrational with the burning need to Get Married. Baby lust I understand. There’s a biological drive to reproduce. Bridal fever, though, is beyond me.

In the Telegraph, Christina Hopkinson writes about the strong-arm tactics she used to get her boyfriend to marry her. Maybe she was feeling the pressure to wed that strikes unmarried women who live with their boyfriends.

Her beloved is a divorce lawyer, and when they met, both of them were staunchly anti-marriage. Over time, as they settled into a partnership together, Christina warmed to the idea of getting married. Her boyfriend didn’t. So she began a campaign of, as she describes it, whining and cajoling him for a proposal. Finally, he gave in and they were married five months later.

That was 8 years ago. It’s hard to argue she did the wrong thing, especially since they’ve had three kids since then. Clearly, these people are committed to their life together. But did they really need to be married to do it?

Lots of people have healthy, happy families without ever saying “I do” to each other. Yes, I got married because I was pregnant. After the hormones wore off, I was pretty annoyed with myself for giving in. Now that I understand marriage better, I’m happier with my situation. Again, it’s got little to do with romance or commitment. I’m just painfully aware that there are financial and legal benefits married couples have that you can’t get any other way.

I’ve written a few articles about marriage this month, and been surprised how strong the voices saying, “Parents should be married” are. Do people really still believe that marriage is a prerequisite to having children? I think kids thrive in stable homes, but those homes can be headed by an unmarried couple, a married couple, a single parent, grandparents or a wide variety of other arrangements.

What do you think? Is it important to be married when you have kids? Did you drag your man down the aisle? Was getting married a mutual thing? Or have you so far resisted the itch to get hitched?

 Tying The Knot: Are Parents Better Off Married?

Go Back To Strollerderby

11 Comments

I think it’s easy to think it’s not important when it’s so easy to GET married. It’s mighty important when you are not allowed to do so.
IOW, we generally take it for granted.

goddess commented on Apr 11 11 at 1:53 pm

My parents are married, as are the parents of the vast majority of my friends. But among my friends most are not themselves married and have kids and mortgages etc. I never ever once as a child or young woman had even a flash of a dream of “getting married” and all that that entailed. I knew I wanted to have kids and I knew that I wanted to fall in love and have a partner but those things had nothing to do with marriage. But then I met a man I fell in love with straight away and we planned on moving overseas together and then he asked me to marry him and I did, 10 months after meeting. For me it was all about the person, and timing, I guess. And because we did move away the day after the wedding I found the fact we were married a very reassuring thing given all the upheaval and the fact we hadn’t known each other for very long. I strongly believe though that marriage has very little to do with having a stable family – it may come into play in terms of how a couple views themselves, but with my friends and peer group it’s a non-issue. I am not from the USA, but live close to it and get all the American media, and I have always noticed and been uncomfortable with how often marriage is used as some kind of moral standard: as if you are a better parent if you’re married and a worse one if you’re not. Which obviously doesn’t make sense in reality. Also, I think in America marriage is most often seen as a religious thing (which is probably where the moral factor comes in), which is wasn’t at all for us.

Steph commented on Apr 11 11 at 2:10 pm

i’m happily married to a divorce lawyer. if anything, his job makes our marriage stronger. he sees the petty disagreements that people have and knows how to avoid them, and also sees first-hand the consequences of divorce on children. getting married was important for him, and we waited until i was ready, which took over six years after we first started dating. i wanted children, knew that i wanted to spend my life with him, and wanted the public, legal, and religious commitment of marriage. the article about this woman strong-arming her husband into marriage made me really uncomfortable. i don’t think men or women should be pushed into marriage, and blaming this man’s career for what was obviously his individual perspective was annoying. also, i’d point out that committed relationships, marital or otherwise, can always break, but you remain a co-parent forever.

daria commented on Apr 11 11 at 2:24 pm

I def did not want to get married, but I was in the same type of situation. We just had the kid and it was just convenient for each of us. We got married in front of a JP and I really wasn’t sentimental about it at all. My mom on the other hand was devastated as she didn’t get to have the grand wedding for her only daughter. But, in the end, it turned out to be the best decision for our son and for each other.

Care commented on Apr 11 11 at 2:33 pm

For me, getting married before I had kids was very important. I had nightmares where I would be pregnant but not married and I always felt so dissapointed during the dream and a few seconds after I woke up until I realized that it was not true. However, I did not get the fever because of the wedding, when I met my husband I was determined to work on our relationship because I knew I found the person I wanted to spend my life with. I don’t think I would have been married if it wasn’t to him.
The only annoyance that marriage brought for me was having to decide if I was going to change my last name (which I didn’t) and having to consult him to make some decisions. I have always been very independent.

Rosana commented on Apr 11 11 at 2:36 pm

@goddess: thanks for the reminder.

Sierra Black commented on Apr 11 11 at 2:41 pm

@daira: thanks! I agree – I didn’t think the man in the Telegraph article was resistant to marriage because of anything intrinsic to his job. Lots of people don’t want to marry for any number of reasons. I love the way you wrote about why it was important to you to be married.

Sierra Black commented on Apr 11 11 at 2:44 pm

I grew up in a traditional (and surprisingly functional and loving) family so I was brought up valuing marriage as something sacred. One day, when I was in my early twenties and in the midst of an unhappy on-again off-again relationship, my dad sat me down and said, “Don’t waste your time with this guy anymore. You deserve better. You deserve someone that is going to love you, treasure you and be with you no matter what. Where would I be without your Mama when I lost my job? What would have happened to your mother if I wasn’t there when we lost your baby sister? What would have happened to me? I couldn’t have survived the hard times without her.” and that’s when I truly “got” what marriage was about.

When I met my husband, I knew by the first date there would be a second and within a month, I knew this was the man I was supposed to be with. We’ve been together nearly 5 years and married almost 3. We’ve been through hard times but our love for each other has never waned. The fact that we both took our marriage vows to heart has given our home a safe, secure environment for our toddler and our son on the way. I do think that the “til death do us part” stability of our home has so far only helped us be better parents.

Katy E commented on Apr 11 11 at 3:29 pm

Hi,

I just want to put it out there that I believe in marriage, but I don’t really believe a wedding is what makes a marriage. I don’t live in the U.S. so I don’t have any of the legal/healthcare issues that unmarried couples seem to have there; in Canada my common-law relationship is legally recognised as being equal to marriage.

My partner is my husband in every way. We met eighteen years ago when I was travelling in Europe and we’ve had to overcome all the hurdles that long distance relationships bring about (separation from our families and friends, immigration paperwork, etc) but I simply see a wedding as being a symbolic gesture (much like a birthday party is to a birthday) and the marriage as being the commitment and the relationship itself. We now have two children, aged almost-seven and four and love support each other unconditionally. He is the best (and funniest) man I know and is exactly the right match for me.

I feel like a make a vow to him every morning when I wake up and see his face on the pillow next to mine.

For me, and I recognize that this is personal, you’re either committed or you’re not; a wedding is a lovely thing to do if you’re into it, but certainly not necessary to build a marriage.

Voice of Reason commented on Apr 11 11 at 3:52 pm

Definitely important to be married before you have kids, if only to protect yourself. I would never drag a man down the aisle or otherwise coerce, though, you never want to feel like you have to talk someone into marrying you!

GP commented on Apr 11 11 at 6:02 pm

I have been with my man/partner/boyfriend/fiance for almost 10 years. Along the way, we had a child together. She is now 7 years old. After all this time, he’s finally proposed to me and we’ll be getting married in 2 weeks, just us and our daughter. Very intimate. I absolutely don’t agree with people who think that parents should be married. We have created a stable family life over the past decade and in all things function as a normal married couple/family unit. The difference that has occurred is that right now, it feels right to take a moment to focus on us as a couple and re-affirm our love with a ceremony. I personally, don’t need the ring, or the joint checking account. In fact, we still will not have combined accounts once we tie the knot, but the thing that does make a difference to me is the affirmation of our vows…verbally…to each other. We never made a “big deal” about our relationship. It’s nice to celebrate our relationship on it’s own (although still being integral to the family unit). Our daughter will be joining us in our ceremony and at the moment is sort of ambivalent about the whole thing. I am looking forward to having a shared last name for ease of filling out school forms, etc. (hopefully we can convince our daughter to also change her name, which is currently hyphenated…she’s not so sure we shouldn’t all hyphenate.) :) Also, we’ve been discriminated against when renting homes because we weren’t married, so those things will be easier.

Bri commented on Mar 28 12 at 7:47 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Lori Garcia
  • Joslyn Gray
  • Amber Doty
  • Julianna Miner
  • Monica Bielanko
  • Sierra Black
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Carolyn Castiglia
  • Sunny Chanel
  • Madeline Holler
  • Rebecca Odes
  • Danielle Smith
  • Danielle Sullivan
  • Katherine Stone
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Strollerderby (50 of 11490 articles)