Strollerderby

Struggling Between Feeling Good and Looking Good

Posted by john cave osborne on March 16th, 2011 at 9:00 am
942138 42006736 Struggling Between Feeling Good and Looking Good

I've been increasing the miles in hopes of decreasing the pounds.

Most parents have any number of things they want to instill in their children. Caroline and I are no exception. And one thing we hope to instill in our 9-year-old girl is a positive self image. The last thing we want for her to do is to strive for a nonexistent brand of perfection by conforming to an unrealistic notion of beauty espoused by a society which regularly becomes enamored with clowns like “The Situation.” We want her to know that the most beautiful thing she could ever be is herself.

So, to that end, we try hard to keep even the most innocent of superficial comments to a minimum. We’re not naive enough to think that she won’t reach her fair share of superficial conclusions with the help of the outside world. But we try to show by example that we’re not overly concerned by the way things look. We want her to know that what’s far more important to us is the way things feel.

Caroline and I are both pretty big on exercise. Particularly Caroline. At 41, she’s as fit as anyone I know. She eats well, and she also enjoys a healthy diet of activities that keep her in tip top shape. Even at 21 weeks pregnant, Caroline still gets her heart rate up several times a week via regular workouts.

Though I’m big on staying fit, too, I’ll be the first to admit that my commitment has slipped a bit through the years. In my 20s, I worked out constantly, in part by training for marathons and going on frequent hikes, including the time I climbed Mt. Rainier. Though I wasn’t as obsessive in my 30s, I still managed to get plenty of exercise. But as I inched closer to the big 4-0, my commitment began to slide. Between work and the demands of a large family, I found it harder and harder to stay in shape. Besides, I rationalized, I no longer had as much time to dedicate to my physique as I once did.

And in some ways, I was right. But that was still no excuse for me to mail it in.

Fortunately, I have one major physical activity I engage in on an annual basis: backpacking a section of the Appalachian Trail. And there’s no way to carry a 40 pound pack up and down the series of hills that carve their way through the mountains for up to 20 miles in a day without being fit from a cardiovascular standpoint. So every year, I’m forced to bone up for it.

Sadly, however, each year, I fall off the bandwagon shortly after these exhausting tests of endurance — but never more so than last year. And by the end of December, I was heavier than I had ever been.

So this January, I decided to recommitted to exercise. And I’m happy to say that well into March, I’m still on track. It’s been quite sometime (if ever) that I’ve done a better job with my diet. And I’ve also managed to work out at least four times each and every week (barring one, that is, due to illness).

But I had let myself go so far, that even with my newfound (or re-found) commitment to fitness, I’m still a bit off from where I’d like to be. As of this post, I’m clocking in at just under 170, down over 12 pounds from my peak in December. But I still have 8 to 10 more to go before I reach what I would consider to be an ideal weight for someone my height and build.

The other day, my daughter caught me examining myself in the mirror after a run.

“What are you doing?” she asked.

“Oh nothing,” I answered as I reached for my shirt.

“I know what you’re doing,” she answered with a smile. “You’re checking yourself out to see if your belly is getting smaller.”

Neurotically, I was tempted to ask her what she thought. But instead, I took it a different approach.

“You know what? You’re right,” I said. “But I shouldn’t be doing that.” I explained that I had gained a bunch of weight over the holidays and that I’ve been working hard to lose that weight. “But not so that I look better,” I answered, fully aware that I was fudging a bit. “But so that I can be more healthy. And one way I know I’m more healthy is if I continue to lose this,” I concluded as I pointed to my, um, Homer Simpson.

She’d noticed that I had stepped up my commitment to fitness. And after our little chat, I think she better understands why, despite having caught me in a vain moment. It really is driven by a desire to be more healthy. But I’m also a 41-year-old man who, in some ways, is trying to hang on to his last shred of youth — one who wants to ditch the 34s and get back into the 32s that have been hanging undisturbed in my closet for far too long.

The good news is that I’m getting close. The bad news is that sometimes I forget that feeling good is way more important than looking good. And if I keep forgetting that, I’d be doing myself a disservice. But worse, still, I might just be doing my daughter a disservice, too.

Read about the personal struggles 6 other parents try to hide from their kids.

Image: stock.xchng

 Struggling Between Feeling Good and Looking Good

Go Back To Strollerderby

18 Comments

I think it’s OK to want to look good AND feel good. Let’s be honest!

Gretchen Powers commented on Mar 16 11 at 9:52 am

@Gretchen Powers — i do, too. but i also don’t want my daughter to think that my exercise is vanity driven, especially considering that even when i’m in “bad” shape, relatively speaking, i’m doing just fine.

John Cave Osborne commented on Mar 16 11 at 10:01 am

But what definition of “look good”. I think that’s the point of it.

I’d rather feel good, myself. Looking good would be gravy, so to speak (note: I loathe gravy with every fiber of my being so its a funny comparison but still). If I were to meet the current Hollywood standard of looking good, I’d probably be a crabby lady due to starvation and having had a ton of plastic surgery to remove ribs and whatnot.

PlumbLucky commented on Mar 16 11 at 10:05 am

@PlumbLucky — EXACTLY. i want my child to know that it’s cool to exercise. but i don’t want her to think that the order of progression is to #1) exercise, then #2) obsess over how your body looks in front of a mirror. your comment nailed it. thanks you for leaving it.

John Cave Osborne commented on Mar 16 11 at 10:10 am

I think we all know, deep inside ourselves, when we look good and when we don’t. And it doesn’t have to be to “Hollywood” standards, but still, we know. I am in great athletic shape right now (running 27-50 miles per week for marathon training—yes you read that right), but about 7-12 lbs more than I am when I look GREAT. I just love food too much : ) I’m working on it, though…still a few months til summer!

Gretchen Powers commented on Mar 16 11 at 10:18 am

I hear you about the mirror obsession, though…I have to admit, I actually avoid mirrors…and I am pretty comfortable with how I look, just don’t need to see it all the damn time.

Gretchen Powers commented on Mar 16 11 at 10:20 am

@Gretchen Powers — GL w/ your marathon!

John Cave Osborne commented on Mar 16 11 at 10:46 am

thanks…I will need it…I feel like a Clydesdale

Gretchen Powers commented on Mar 16 11 at 11:29 am

@Gretchen Powers which one are you running? i’ve run Portland and San Diego (Rock and Roll). I’ve also run several Hood to Coast relays. are you familiar w/ those? 200 mile road races w/ teams of 12. i bet you’ll do great! have you ever run one before? either way, i’m excited for you!

John Cave Osborne commented on Mar 16 11 at 11:34 am

I love the way I look in front of a mirror! I climbed Ranier, too, and the meadow and lodge at the top are just completely spectacular! Well worth the pain.

I’m a mad runner (training for my first 100 mile race), and I confess I do it almost entirely because of vanity. Sure, it keeps me in shape, but I have never really been out of shape. Even when carrying that extra post-pregnancy 50 pounds, I was still strong, fit and perfectly healthy. I think a lot of people don’t realize that you can be fat, quite fat, and still be in utterly spectacular health.

But I like my belly taut. I like my butt small. I like my thighs sharp with muscles and my calves rounded and glowing from the sun. My face looks better when I’m thin, too. I like looking great. I doubt I would kill myself if I had to give those things up, but in the absence of any really good reason not to look terrific, I choose terrific.

I encourage my kids to celebrate looking good, too. Looking good has a dramatic effect on a person’s life chances – everything from your salary to the people you date to the college you go to is affected by how you look. I think kids know that saying “Looks don’t matter” is a big lie. They can plainly see that looks DO matter.

I guess I’m just vain.

andrea commented on Mar 16 11 at 3:12 pm

Such a great post. It really brought me back to my own commitment to exercise. I’ve had issues with depression in the past and the best way for me to keep my mood healthy is – yep, you guessed it – exercise. It never ceases to amaze me that a good workout can *totally* turn my day around. I definitely look a lot better as a result of being fit, but that benefit pales in comparison to feeling strong and healthy and sane (sounds like a cliche, but it’s true). I’m now 38 weeks pregnant and still getting in 4 to 5 workouts a week, but I do wonder how I’ll keep it up once the baby is here…

Catherine commented on Mar 16 11 at 3:15 pm

LOL. In case their was any lingering doubt that Andrea is someone’s fictional creation, now she’s running a 100 mile race! Take that you puny marathon runners! :P At any rate, I exercise because it makes me feel good, but I don’t necessarily think it’s vain to exercise in order to look good. Whatever it takes to get you moving, I’m all for it. It’s not like you end up less healthy from all that exercise just because you initially started or continue because you like the way it makes you look. I admire people in their 40s who can still run. I work out almost eevry day but when I tried running again last summer, I was only about 6 weeks in before I injured my hip. I want to do a mini triathalon over the summer, but I do fear the running part, even though it’s only a 5k.

Linda, the original one commented on Mar 16 11 at 3:54 pm

I’d rather not say which one…too easy to “find” me : ) I have run them before, this is like my 5th or 6th or something. Unlike Andrea : ), I run for stress relief and because it puts me in touch with a deep sense of being human. I think of pre-agricultural hunting peoples running after elk and stuff (I read “Born to Run”) and I am tapping into something very eternal. I know…that’s weird. If I just wanted to look hot weight training would be much better and other exercises are way more efficient for that than running. All that said, I think it’s OK to be a little bit vain, but you also have to have the vanity in its proper balance and be realistic in terms of your aging, etc. I’m not talking so much about fitness as being OK with some wrinkles, etc. Not expecting to look 22, but look like a healthy, attractive 30- or 40- something.

Gretchen Powers commented on Mar 16 11 at 4:41 pm

Lots of people run 100 mile races. I’m doing Hawaii! I would also like to do Alaska. That will be quite the adventure.

andrea commented on Mar 16 11 at 5:20 pm

@Gretchen Powers — oooh. sorry about that. of course… and i’m on board w/ your sentiments. i don’t think they’re weird at all. i feel i tap into something eternal whenever i’m backpacking.
@Linda, the original one — i think a natural byproduct of exercising is that it does make one look better. but w/ regard to our little girl, i guess i’m overly sensitive w/ regard to body image issues. and, given that i’m not exactly fat, i think that coming in from a run, peeling off a shirt and examining my belly could send the wrong message to her. still, i totally hear you. sorry about the hip but glad to hear that you stay in good shape.
@catherine — it *is* amazing how much better, mentally, working out will make you feel. and way to go on being 38 weeks and still getting your workouts in. and GL w/ the baby, as well as with finding a way to continuing your workouts!
@andrea — i think it’s very cool that you love the way you look. and GL w/ the 100 mile race.

John Cave Osborne commented on Mar 16 11 at 6:47 pm

@John, I love to swim. I swim 4000-5000 yards 4-5 times a week and I walk briskly the other days for about an hour. I plan to add some biking if I decide to do the triathalon. I’m hoping my daughter will want to do it with me (She’ll only do it if it doesn’t conflict with one of her roller derby bouts.)

Linda, the original one commented on Mar 16 11 at 7:20 pm

@Linda, the original one — I used to swim, and I loved it. So much gentler on the body than running! You mentioned that you admire folks in their 40s who can still run. I’m one of them, but I sometimes wonder if I’ll be able to claim “runner” status when I’m 50!

John Cave Osborne commented on Mar 17 11 at 9:47 am

I think it’s ok to be honest with your kids… we want to be healthy and look healthy. I’m due in 7 days so I hope I figure out how to manage that balance. haha

CuriousMama commented on Mar 18 11 at 7:47 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Lori Garcia
  • Joslyn Gray
  • Amber Doty
  • Julianna Miner
  • Monica Bielanko
  • Sierra Black
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Carolyn Castiglia
  • Sunny Chanel
  • Madeline Holler
  • Rebecca Odes
  • Danielle Smith
  • Danielle Sullivan
  • Katherine Stone
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Strollerderby (50 of 11490 articles)