babble » blogs » Strollerderby
Strollerderby
Miscarriages Leave Lasting Grief, Even After Healthy Pregnancies
A miscarriage leaves a lasting grief in a woman’s life, one that is not healed by the birth of other healthy children. This is common sense, but science confirms it.
If you’ve lost a pregnancy, or been close to someone who has, you know that the loss leaves a hole in your life that can’t be filled by anyone else. If you’re blessed to have a healthy baby after a miscarriage, that baby brings its own joy. It doesn’t make the grief magically vanish.
A new study backs this up, finding that women who’ve lost a pregnancy are more prone to depression and anxiety for years after the miscarriage. This remains true even if they go on to have healthy babies.
The British study tracked over 13,000 women pregnant women, 20 % of whom had experienced at least one miscarriage. They found that women who had lost a pregnancy were significantly more likely to be depressed than those who had not. Nearly 13% of women who had lost a pregnancy still had symptoms of depression 33 months later. The effects were compounded if a woman had lost two or more pregnancies.
According to Time, the findings are clinically important. Doctors and caregivers will flag women for possible post-partum mood issues if the woman presents with a history of depression or anxiety. Now, they can add having previously experienced a miscarriage to the list of red flags that might signal increased risk for post-partum depression.
Photo: skampy
Go Back To Strollerderby
8 Comments
Amanda commented on Mar 15 11 at 3:52 pmAs someone who experienced an ectopic pregnancy, a miscarriage, and a healthy pregnancy and birth all within a year and half and ended up suffering from postpartum anxiety after my son was born, I can absolutely relate to this article. Even though I have a beautiful baby boy now, there are still triggers that can make me very sad about the lost pregnancies and probably make me overprotective in some ways when it comes to my son.
goddess commented on Mar 15 11 at 4:30 pmMeh. I guess I’m the odd man out. I miscarried twice and while I grieved- it was for the loss of the dream I had for that pregnancy. And really? With each one, the subsequent pregnancy certainly did finish the healing! Now losing our eldest at 6 years old- that left a hole.
While I can certainly understand how miscarriage affects some- maybe most, woman in the manner described above, it certainly doesn’t apply to all.
goddess commented on Mar 15 11 at 4:30 pmwomen- plural. Sigh
AlbertaMom commented on Mar 15 11 at 8:28 pmThough I believe every pregnancy loss is the loss of a child, I think the level of trauma can vary a great deal. I think a miscarriage after years of infertility can carry a heavier toll. I think miscarriage after previous loss can carry a heavier toll. I think an ectopic pregnancy, with emergency decisions about ending the pregnancy to save the mother, can carry a heavier toll. And I have experienced that loss further along in a pregnancy, whether it is a 2nd trimester miscarriage, a stillborn child, or an early infant death, all can carry a much heavier burden than an earlier miscarriage. Do I grieve the loss of my baby at 6 weeks gestation? Yes, but it does in no way compare to the pain I feel over the babies I lost after carrying them for over 5 months. They were all my children, and they all deserve to be grieved, but the level of trauma and pain is different.
goddess commented on Mar 16 11 at 10:48 amAbsolutely Albertamom.
But I must add that I never felt the miscarriages at 11 and 1 0 wks [that I had} we “babies” or my “children” I’ve been pregnant 6 times, had 4 and 2 miscarriages. I never say I had 6 kids. In fact, one was so grossly malformed with T16- how could i have ever considered that anything but a genetic deformity that nature thankfully did not bring to fruition?
Had I not miscarried my 1st, I’d never have logistically been able to have Nicholas. And had I not miscarried my 4th pregnancy., Alexandra would not be here.
But I totally agree that miscarriages in the face of ongoing infertility carry a hug price in grief, comparatively speaking. Just as I can never know their pain, they will never know how it feels to hold a 6 year old child of yours as they die, either.
Amanda commented on Mar 16 11 at 3:22 pmFor me, the hospital experience with the ectopic made things much worse. I was sent the emergency room at a Catholic hospital to get methotrexate by my doctor. The OB resident in the ER was ready to give it to me when the head ER doctor stopped her, and in fornt of me and my husband, said it would be like an abortion since the ectopic was indicated in my blood levels and my heavy bleeding and not big enough yet to see on an ultrasound. After hours of going back and forth, I was eventually sent away and for my troubles, my insurance co. was billed $1,500 bcause I took up an ER bed. (They fought it and never had to pay, though.) My miscarriage was 6 months later at 5 weeks along. Amazingly enough, I got pregnant with my now 8 month old son only 2 weeks after my miscarriage when my bc failed. When I never got my period and had a positve pregnancy test, I was worried that I would have to have a D&C beacuse I didn’t miscarriage fully. When I found out I was actually pregnant for real, I didn’t tell anyone but my husband for months, because I didn’t want to deal with having to tell anyone (again) if I had lost the pregnancy. Maybe other people would have had not as much of a problem dealing with all of this, but for me, it was a lot to handle in a very short time span.
Shannon commented on Jun 24 11 at 5:17 pmAfter trying for a year to concieve we were thrilled to be expecting and then at 17 weeks our Daughter died, while it strengthened our relationship, it rocked my world, threw me for a loop! I was devastated, but i also wanted to be pregnant again asap, i dont know if i wanted to feel like replacing her, or if it was because i felt i failed my husband by not giving him a much wanted child, we got pregnant again after only 4 months, i was shocked i figured it would take awhile again, and now im term with another daughter and terrified that no matter how happy i am and proud to have my daughter with me, i will grieve all over again for my dead daughter….
Mashala commented on Apr 08 12 at 10:48 pmwe lost our first child at 14 weeks..it was the worst time of my life.. I was extremely depressed. I couldnt look at anyone prego or even children.. Three years later I have a beautiful baby girl whos 8 months old.. Til this day I still cry about it as if it were yesterday.. There is no worst feeling then to lose a child.. I was talking to a friend of my mothers who had lost a child years back at 3 months.. He was a healthy child at birth and he died from SIDS.. she told me she didnt know what was worst, to give birth to a child and to see their face, hear their laugh, hold them.. Or to have a miscarriage and never get to experience those things with your child.. The grief never goes away. We just have to wait patiently until we can see our little ones again.. R.I.P Baby Arevalo.. Mommy Daddy and Lily loves
and mImiss you :,(
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Lori Garcia
Joslyn Gray
Amber Doty
Julianna Miner
Monica Bielanko
Sierra Black
Meredith Carroll
Carolyn Castiglia
Sunny Chanel
Madeline Holler
Rebecca Odes
Danielle Smith
Danielle Sullivan
Katherine Stone
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

8