Strollerderby

Is It Time to Ban School Bans?

Posted by sierra on September 9th, 2010 at 6:21 pm

4787916449 93e75d8218 300x200 Is It Time to Ban School Bans? What do Silly Bandz and Christmas trees have in common? They’ve been blacklisted from schools. Schools have banned everything from yoyos to the word meep. Haven’t they figured out by now that these silly bans don’t work?

Now Jezebel has a radical idea: let’s call for a ban on school bans! While we’re at it, we can outlaw censorship in school libraries, too. We might even consider throwing the politicians and ideologues out of controlling our kids’ curriculums.

But let’s start with their right to wear oddly shaped plastic bracelets in English class if they choose.

Here’s Jezebel’s blogger’s list of stuff her school nixed when she was a kid:

pogs
— yoyos
— “socks pulled up to the knee and worn with cutoff shorts” (I think this was supposed to be a gang thing, but I never saw anyone wear it, and only heard of it in our dress code, which had to be read aloud in full during homeroom every day)
— non-approved forms of handball (the approved form was given to us on a mimeographed sheet, which we immediately and gleefully destroyed)
— “rugby” (this was not the sport commonly practiced in the United Kingdom, but rather a game we used to play when we lost our soccer ball, which mostly involved tackling. I kind of get why this was banned.)
— climbing hills
— cat’s cradle
I’m posting hers because the only thing I remember my school banning was black trenchcoats, after the Columbine shooting. I remember this because I’ll never forget my mother wearing her own black trenchcoat to her meeting with our high school principal to discuss my sister’s recalcitrant goth look.
Did your school have any silly bans? Does your kids’ school now?
 Is It Time to Ban School Bans?

Go Back To Strollerderby

0 Comments

My husband taught at an inner city school, and he claims that many bans related to supposed gang-wear are specious.

AwesomeCloud's mom commented on Sep 09 10 at 7:30 pm

Mostly a control issue, some of the admins in school systems go on power trips.

Ri-chan commented on Sep 09 10 at 8:00 pm

I would argue that most ‘bans’ are justified. Some are in response to the hot topic of the minute (example, black trenchcoats), but I don’t allow numerous things in my classroom. Gum, any food, any drinks (except water, but only in a bottle with a lid), rubber bands, permanent markers…in one class, I had to ban pens that ‘click’. It might seem excessive to someone that isn’t a teacher, but until you try not only just keeping thirty-two sixteen-year-olds in their seat long enough for you to take attendance, but then trying to actually get them to care about what you are teaching, pay attention, participate, etc…you will never understand just how annoying those stupid bracelets are. If parents realized how many minutes were spent every day trying to eliminate distractions instead of teaching their children, they wouldn’t be against things like bans and dress codes.

JBoogie commented on Sep 09 10 at 8:50 pm

I remember my high school put a ban on “public displays of affection” we called it the kissing ban and held a kiss-in.

cao commented on Sep 09 10 at 9:37 pm

My high school banned shorts for males, so all the guys showed up in skirts. They also banned Bart Simpson tshirts.

Mistress_Scorpio commented on Sep 10 10 at 5:12 am

I hate to sound like an old man, but it would be nice to see a return to the days when kids dressed for school differently than for play, and acted differently in class than on the playground. It’s not about “freedom of expression.” It’s about preparing them for the real world, where people who don’t know how to behave in the workplace suffer economically for it. School used to teach that, both by modeling the behavior and by insisting on it almost by osmosis — you didn’t need to tell kids not to bring toys to class, not to eat in class, not to wear obscene t-shirts, not to sit in class yakking with each other. It was understood, and the kid who broke one of those rules was quickly corrected. Some teachers were nicer about it than others, but it was still the way things were and we all understood that.

TJDestry commented on Sep 10 10 at 8:01 am

These things get banned because kids fight over them. Or they get stolen. Or “I gave her my princess tiara rubber band and she gave me a cowboy hat in return, and I’m not her friennnnnnnnndddddddd anyyyyymorrrrrrreeeeeeee!”

Shannon commented on Sep 10 10 at 9:05 am

My middle school had a ban on overalls that were half unclasped. I think we had a ban on backwards clothes too. HA.

I do like how some schools have a “business casual” type look – I do audits at schools now, and one district had a “khakis, navy blue or white shirts w/ collars, or any tshirt that was related to the school (sports, etc.)” dresscode. It was nice.

Sarah commented on Sep 10 10 at 10:06 am

I would personally love the simplicity that a strict dress code would bring to my life, improvements at school would be a bonus.

bob commented on Sep 10 10 at 11:01 am

The dress code at our local school is khaki or navy pants, and red or white collared shirts. Works for everyone, and the kids don’t complain because they say they always know what they are going to wear to school. The parents like it because it means that there is less time spent every morning getting ready and the teachers say it eliminates distractions. The kids are allowed to wear sports clothes for special games and playoffs and on their birthday they are not required to wear their uniforms. It seems to work for everybody.

K. commented on Sep 10 10 at 12:25 pm

@JBoogie– I totally get why, as a teacher, you would ban certain objects from your classroom. It’s situational and makes sense for your teaching environment. I don’t like the blanket ban across the schools, though, especially when they become arbitrary. But classroom, by classroom is understandable!
When I was in high school, it became popular for girls to wear boxers as shorts. They quickly banned that claiming a sanitary infraction from the open fly. We worked our way around that by sewing up the fly!
I also support some clothing bans, especially those that are set up to protect kids. Our suburban middle school won’t allow solid red or blue shirts b/c they are gang colors. I wish they’d ban the pants down kids asses simply b/c I don’t get it. I don’t see it as fashionable or anywhere near sexy. And how uncomfortable does that look?!

But socks?! Climbing hills?! That’s taking it too far. Control freaks, that’s what I say!

LogicalMama commented on Sep 10 10 at 12:40 pm

A friend of mine in college who often wore a cutoff denim vest told me that his school banned jackets with inside pockets, supposedly because kids could conceal weapons in the pockets. (The one exception was that athletes could wear their letter jackets, which of course torqued off everyone else even further.) So he cut the sleeves off his denim jacket, turning it into the aforementioned vest. It of course still had inside pockets, but was no longer a jacket, and so met the dress code.

Chip commented on Sep 10 10 at 3:09 pm

Sierra, tell your mom I think she is so awesome!

Amy k commented on Sep 12 10 at 5:58 pm

I agree, LogicalMama, you can’t ban things like pens that click school-wide (as much as I’d like to!). I just had to do it for a particular class because I had one kid who clicked constantly to annoy the people around him, and then they all started doing it. My school has a pretty strict dress-code (only human colored hair, no facial piercing, pants have to be around your waist, no tank-tops or cut-offs, no pants with holes above the knee, no flip-flops, etc…) because all those things are either a. distractions or b. unsafe. And sometimes it’s no big deal, but they have to ban them all together or the kids walk the line and it’s too hard to say well “that’s okay, but that’s not, and it all depends on the mood I’m in today”. I wish they’d ban v-neck shirts. I know it sounds extreme, but seriously, if you saw as much teenage cleavage as I did every single day, you would agree. I swear, I least once a day I have to tell at least one student that she needs to sit up straight because her boobs are f.a.l.l.i.n.g. out. I’m talking nipples here.

JBoogie commented on Sep 12 10 at 7:29 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Lori Garcia
  • Joslyn Gray
  • Amber Doty
  • Julianna Miner
  • Monica Bielanko
  • Sierra Black
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Carolyn Castiglia
  • Sunny Chanel
  • Madeline Holler
  • Rebecca Odes
  • Danielle Smith
  • Danielle Sullivan
  • Katherine Stone
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Strollerderby (50 of 11490 articles)