babble » blogs » Strollerderby
Strollerderby
Should Leaving a Child in a Car Be a Felony?
We talked last week about whether or not automakers should install forgotten kid alarms in cars as a result of the high number of overheating deaths already this year. While many parents see no harm in adding the safety technology to vehicles, Pennsylvania lawmakers want to go one step further. They plan to introduce a bill that would charge parents who leave their children in unattended vehicles with a third-degree felony.
Sen. Robert Tomlinson, R-Bucks County, and Rep. Gene DiGirolamo, R-Bensalem, are sponsoring the legislation and will present it to their respective chambers, according to the Daily American. Supervising adults caught abandoning children in a car currently face misdemeanor charges; a third-degree felony conviction can result in 3 1/2 to 7 years in prison and a fine of up to $15,000.
But wait! Here’s the really unbelievable part: This proposed change in the law comes in response to a slew of hasty parents who’ve left their children locked in the parking lot of the Parx Casino in Bensalem in order to go gamble. You know, with something other than their children’s lives. “Between June 15 and Aug. 25, six parents left a combined 12 children and a puppy unattended in cars in Parx’s sprawling parking lots,” according to the Philadelphia Daily News. “The children ranged from 15 months to 15 years old, and were left unsupervised from a half-hour to six hours.” (The age of the puppy is unknown, but officals say he responds to the name Chip.*)
Law enforcement officials will be able to use discretion in handing out tickets for the offense, presumably to avoid locking up innocent parents who are just dropping library books in the outdoor depository while their kid waits in the car for 30 seconds. (Now you know what I did this afternoon!) But Cleaver’s underlying hope is that this legislation will allow police to identify families afflicted by alcohol abuse or other addictions and lead them to recovery programs.
State Rep. Carl Walker, R-Allegheny Township, has a more cynical outlook about the plan, however. He says, “You can’t legislate common sense for people who are going to a casino and letting their kids sit in a car.” That’s true. I’m not sure letting kids sit in a car should be a felony, but there seems to be a real need to make families in Bensalem understand that parenting is more important than gambling. The Philadelphia Daily News reports that “the state Gaming Control Board last month told the casino to fix the problem” and “Parx officials said that they have permanently banned the offending parents and increased parking lot patrols.”
Gambling is addictive, and commercial gambling is outlawed in many states. Cleaver is right to assume that drinking and gambling go hand in hand, which is why if he really wants to get troubled people the help they need, he should get out of the parking lot and walk into the casino. How about this? Draft a piece of legislation that says no one under the age of 18 is allowed on casino property, period. That would go a long way toward fixing the abandoned kids problem. I’d bet on that.
*I’m just guessing that the dog responds to Chip. Other appropriate names could be Slots, Banker, Dealer and Snooki.
Photo: YummyBubby
Go Back To Strollerderby
0 Comments
[...] Babble (blog) [...]
casino » Blog Archive » That’s Not Why They Call It “Parx” Casino? – Philadelphia Magazine (blog) commented on Sep 07 10 at 6:05 pmBlackOrchid commented on Sep 06 10 at 9:59 pmIf they ban kids from on-property, these people will just leave them in a nearby mall.
I don’t really think there is a good answer, just better oversight of the parking lot by Parx. I can’t stand all these junky new casinos in PA anyway. They are just depressing.
Sara commented on Sep 06 10 at 11:13 pmThere are child neglect statutes in that state I assume? Those cases obviously fit in the realm of child neglect.
Voice of Reason commented on Sep 07 10 at 8:00 am“Draft a piece of legislation that says no one under the age of 18 is allowed on casino property, period.”
There’s already legislation that says that. Your fault is understanding what is “casino property”. The shared parking lot, where many families come to watch the horsies run, is not considered “casino property”.
bob commented on Sep 07 10 at 10:15 amI’m with Sara, if endangerment or neglect are the issue, then use those statutes and prove that the child was endangered or neglected. These statutes only require proof that the child was left in a car for an unspecified time, something that is not inherently felony-bad.
diera commented on Sep 07 10 at 10:16 amGod, I hate choices like this. On the one hand, parents who leave little kids alone in cars for any real period of time suck and should be prosecuted with *something*. On the other hand, if you read what the newspaper said, “…six parents left a combined 12 children and a puppy unattended in cars in Parx’s sprawling parking lots. The children ranged from 15 months to 15 years old, and were left unsupervised from a half-hour to six hours.” Are we really saying that, say, leaving a 15 year old alone in a car for half an hour is the same offense as leaving a 15 month old alone in a car for six hours? Or even an offense at all, in the 15 year old’s case? 15 year olds are almost old enough to drive for Pete’s sake! Pass a law like this, with the laudable goal of protecting little kids being abandoned in parking lots, and pretty soon you’ve got some sort of zero-tolerance prosecution of a parent who left a twelve year old alone for five minutes while he dropped off library books. Neither the public nor the legal system seems to have any kind of common sense whatsoever and I find it frustrating.
Rebecca commented on Sep 07 10 at 10:44 amHey now, some of my best birthdays growing up were in the kids play area in certain casinos in Biloxi. :p
Then again, the kid area was the only reason we went. It would probably have been different if my parents were gamblers.
Alicia commented on Sep 07 10 at 1:14 pmYes, I think it should be a felony. No kid should be left alone in a car for more than 30 seconds at most.
diera commented on Sep 07 10 at 1:16 pm@Alicia: Why?
Rosana commented on Sep 08 10 at 9:12 amHmmm… I just wonder why does there has to be a law to spark common sense on some parents minds. As parents, all we have to ask ourselves before we make decisions like this is: “is this the right think to do or they easy thing to do?”
Rosana commented on Sep 08 10 at 9:14 amOMG!! Horrified with my writing :)
Should read “Hmmm… I just wonder why does there have to be a law to spark common sense on some parents’ minds?”
Becca commented on Sep 08 10 at 11:38 amI don’t think a law will help the target group and will probably unfairly punish normal parents. I am kind of ticked that they changed the law here that you can’t take minors in with you to the tobacco or liquor stores so now you have to leave them in the car ( and have somebody call the cops, or have a sitter to go pick up some rum.
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Joslyn Gray
Amber Doty
Julianna Miner
Monica Bielanko
Sierra Black
Meredith Carroll
Carolyn Castiglia
Sunny Chanel
Madeline Holler
Wendy Michaels
Rebecca Odes
Danielle Smith
Danielle Sullivan
Katherine Stone
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

0