babble » blogs » Strollerderby
Strollerderby
Do Cars Need Forgotten Kid Alarms?
USA Today reports that at least 41 children have died so far this year in hot cars. The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration is considering petitioning automakers to include safety belt reminder chimes for all seating positions. Kids and Cars President Janette Fennell thinks that “these same chimes that sense if people aren’t buckled in should also warn if children are still buckled in cars after they’re locked.” The Consumer Federation of America and Advocates for Highway and Auto Safety agree.
While a chime might help in the case of distracted parents accidentally forgetting their child is in the back seat, what about parents who innocently leave their children in the car on purpose while they run into a store? It turns out, only 18% of hot car deaths from 1998-2009 were caused by parents who intentionally left their children in the car. 30% were the result of children playing in unattended vehicles (in which case the chime would be ineffective in preventing death) and 51% of the deaths involved children forgotten in cars.
Several of my fellow Strollerderby bloggers made it a point to tell me that even loving parents can feel stressed while running errands, get distracted and leave a child in the car that they aren’t used to having with them if their daily routine has suddenly been changed. CNN reported back in June about a car death that happened for similar reasons, and in the piece, Fennell says, “People assume this is happening to bad parents, people who take drugs or use alcohol, maybe abusive parents. But the exact opposite is true. It’s like 95 percent of the people this happens to are wonderful — let me go so far as to say doting parents.” It’s not that I doubt that, it’s that it makes me sad any of our lives should be so hectic when there are children involved.
The Stir covered a story this summer about a Canadian mom who accidentally locked her keys – and her small child - in the car, and I’ve witnessed the same thing happen in New York. I can see myself doing that; closing the car door too early with the keys and my kid inside. I understand the reality is that sometimes you have to take your children with you when you have lots of things to do, but am I the only person who gets worried about the future of America when I read safety tips telling young mothers to hand their baby their cell phone in the back seat, because they are less likely to forget a phone than an infant? If sleep deprivation is the culprit here, why would a tired mind be more able to remember a phone or a purse than a child?
Consumer groups are frustrated that “once-promising technology to prevent deaths to children locked in hot cars isn’t available,” such as ”sensors to detect heat, heartbeats and/or the weight of children.” Hmmm…. sound familiar? Maybe kids should be forced to wear Exmobaby biosensor onesies every time they get in the car? That way, if you forget them in the back seat, you’ll know where they are and how their vital signs are doing. That is, unless you left them with your cell phone…
Photo: Cafe Mom
Go Back To Strollerderby
0 Comments
[...] Strollerderby today I learned that 41 American children died this summer because their parents forgot them in the [...]
Note to Self: Don't Forget the Baby | DADWAGON commented on Sep 02 10 at 1:35 pm[...] talked last week about whether or not automakers should install forgotten kid alarms in cars as a result of the high number of overheating deaths already this year. While many [...]
Should Leaving a Child in a Car Be a Felony? | Strollerderby commented on Sep 06 10 at 7:54 pmAnn commented on Sep 01 10 at 6:28 pmUgh, could the author not have found a picture of a child correctly harnessed and buckled at least? Yes, it’s bad to forget your kid in the car but pictures like this send the message that doing the harness straps up any old way is just fine and dandy! The car seat is not a magical protection bubble that works solely because your kid is sitting in it – it needs to be used correctly.
goddess commented on Sep 01 10 at 7:35 pmNot as much as parents that need a “forgotten brain” alarm…..
Ri-chan commented on Sep 01 10 at 7:39 pmEh, why not? Couldn’t hurt.
Allie commented on Sep 01 10 at 9:51 pmI read a really great article awhile back about this very topic. I can’t remember the writer or the publication (very helpful, I know), but it contained very in-depth interviews with people who had lost their children by leaving them in the car. The thing that really stood out to me in the article was how almost all of the parents had a change in routine the morning of the accident, whether it was a different parent dropping the child off to daycare or dropping off family members in a different order than usual. Your brain goes into a weird auto-pilot to get through some of your daily tasks, and it seemed like these people were operating on auto-pilot without their brain noticing the new scenario. It really freaked me out how absolutely normal these people seemed; its a lot easier to picture these things happening to god awful parents because then it couldn’t happen to you.
Jennifer commented on Sep 02 10 at 12:38 amI put my purse in the backseat always. Therefore regardless of if I have my son with me, I have to open the door and reach into the back. It has more to do with not having much room in the front seat but my son is usually completely silent in the car and I will take any help I can get.
bob commented on Sep 02 10 at 8:44 amHere is the article I think Allie is recalling:
http://www.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/article/2009/02/27/AR2009022701549.html
Rosana commented on Sep 02 10 at 8:50 am“If sleep deprivation is the culprit here, why would a tired mind be more able to remember a phone or a purse than a child?” That is right, I have been able to forget my purse, cellphone, lunch, sometimes even my daughter’s bottle at home (but in that last case I can always call my husband who can run it to the babysitter real quick) but NEVER, NEVER my kids.
I have been driving down the road and suddenly I adjust my mirror to check on my kids, even though I already dropped them at the sitter’s. My point is, as long as your kids are your priority you will not forget them. On the other hand, I do not understand why will people leave their kids in the car to run errands? I does not matter how overwhelmed you are from work, they are your kids and you should learn to suck it up and deal with the situation. Maybe those parents should take a little extra time to planning and make sure they have snacks and water in the car when they know they will have to go in whith their kids.
Sarah commented on Sep 02 10 at 10:34 amI like the idea of the sensor, but most kids are in carseats and a sensor on the seatbelt buckle is moot. My Prius has a weight sensor on the front seat that blinks when there is weight there but the seat belt is not buckled. Maybe something that works along these lines that chimes when the car is turned off but there is weight in the back seat spots?
Nicky's mom commented on Sep 02 10 at 11:25 amPeople still think it’s a good idea to leave their kids in the car ON PURPOSE? Haven’t we heard enough tragic stories about children dying in hot cars?! Jeez, people. Wake up!
e commented on Sep 02 10 at 11:50 amI read the Washington Post article that bob posted and Allie mentioned above when my toddler was a brand-new baby. It HAUNTS me. I think about those parents on a weekly basis. And if you think you would never forget your kid in the car, I encourage you to read it. This could happen to any of us. I truly believe that. I think the author won the Pulitzer Prize for this.
bob commented on Sep 02 10 at 11:51 amI have to drive past my office parking lot when I drive to the daycare center from my house, but I never drive to the daycare from my house because my workday starts before my wife’s does and so she’s the one who drops the kid off in the morning. One day last year, however, my wife needed me to bring the kid to daycare early. So, in my back seat he went. By the time I was approaching my parking lot, as usual, I was thinking ahead to my workday and the kid had fallen asleep. And according to my usual pattern, I pulled into the parking lot and parked the car. That’s when I noticed the daycare bag on the front seat and remembered that I was supposed to be headed to the daycare.
.
Did that happen because my priorities are wrong? No, it has to with habituation. Habits are often good because they allow us to operate at a higher level, to use the thinking parts of our minds while another part dispatches a routine activity (walking and chewing gum, e.g.). But habits can cause mistakes, too, when we slightly vary an otherwise routine activity — because it’s easy to fall into the regular pattern and forget the variance when the time arrives.
diera commented on Sep 02 10 at 12:35 pmThere’s a reason why aviation safety experts use checklists, warning bells, etc. to help keep planes safe rather than just telling the pilots to have ‘safety as their top priority’. No matter what your top priority is, it is literally impossible to never be distracted, and if you read the Washington Post story, it is clear that a little distraction in the wrong circumstances was fatal to these kids. If a car alarm can warn me when my keys are in the ignition (consequence: some inconvenience) then one should be able to warn me when I’m about to forget a sleeping child (consequence: too horrible to contemplate).
As for the question, “If sleep deprivation is the culprit here, why would a tired mind be more able to remember a phone or a purse than a child?”, it’s because the cell phone or the purse is something you *always* get when you get out of the car, while the baby is not always there for some parents. Most of the parents to whom this has happened are people who don’t drop their baby off 100% of the time. When my son was a baby, I dropped him off every single morning at day care, so no matter how sleep deprived I was, I wouldn’t have forgotten because dropping him off was the default action. I was much more paranoid with my daughter, because her father dropped her off more often so my non-drop-off days were the default. If you put something close to the baby that you routinely, without thinking about it, always get when you get out of the car, even when you’re exhausted and distracted you won’t forget the baby.
Marj commented on Sep 02 10 at 12:43 pmMaybe there should be an App for that.
Allie commented on Sep 02 10 at 9:40 pmBob: Thank you for linking the article, it really was a fantastic read. I didn’t realize I was holding my breath reading through your personal experience until I felt it all rush out with relief that it ended well. I feel this enormous amount of empathy for parents that have to go through this, and I think it’s because I can easily imagine it happening to me. And e: Haunted is absolutely the best description of that article. I remember reading it late at night and just having a slow-burning panicked feeling. The day my son’s carseat turned to face forward was the day that I could drop him off at daycare without feeling skittish and half-crazed.
Chaim O commented on Sep 03 10 at 4:22 pmThe technology DOES in fact exist and people need to know about it. There is a system that was developed called “The Backseat Minder”. The system can be easily integrated by car manufacturers if they wish, without the need for expensive and unreliable sensing technology – or batteries. The system watches rear door activity and accurately determines that a child, pet, or handicapped person remains in the back. It then reminds the driver upon leaving the car and the driver is then forced to re-open the rear door and check. If the rear door is not re-opened and a rear button pressed, the horn will honk an SOS signal. The system has been well thought out and anticipates every conceivable situation to ensure that it is accurate and not a nuissance. It is as simple to use as as your headlight switch.
Dorian commented on Sep 03 10 at 7:56 pmNo, cars don’t need them. Parents need to pay attention. All of life is a change in routine. I had changes in routine when my child was a baby. It galls me to read that being used as an excuse because that’s all it is. If you can’t handle one change in routine without leaving your baby to roast, you’re not capable of parenting. I was so tired sometimes that I cried. Did I ever forget my child? No. I stayed off the cell phone when I was driving and I made it a habit to *always* check the back seat as a precaution; it’s just something I did. Responsibility–it works. No, auto makers shouldn’t be required to include this technology. Like everything else in a car, this technology will eventually malfunction. Do you realize the massive liability automakers would be opening themselves up for? People don’t sue over dead batteries. I love children. If I were the CEO of an auto company, would I include the technology? Absolutely not. It is the PARENTS’ responsibility to remember their child is there, not the automakers’. Parents will stop being vigilant and depend on the tech to remind them to drop off their children. If your routine changes–DEAL WITH IT.
Sadmom commented on Sep 08 10 at 9:47 amI am a stay at home mother of 2 beautiful babies. My son just turned 2 and my daughter is 5 months old. My children are my whole world and I spend 99% of my time with my kids. I usually go to the grocery store by myself at least once a week while my kids stay at home with their dad. Yesterday, my son had to come with me and he fell asleep on the way. The whole way there I was thinking about what I needed to pick up at the store, and when I got out of my car to go into the grocery store, I forgot to take my son in with me. I went in and did my shopping and even bought my son a toy, thinking he was at home with his dad and sister. I got back to my car to put the gorceries in the back seat and there he was still sleeping soundly. I gasped and said ‘OH MY GOD!!!” I thank god that it was not hot outside. I never even locked my car becasue I live in a msall town. Someone could have stoeln my child…anything could have happened to him..Luckily someone saw him and called the police. The police arrived after I finished putting the groceries into the car and I was crying my eyes out trying to explaint o him how I could have possibly forgotten him. I had no explination. I had no excuse. All I could tell him was that I would never purposely leave my child in my car. Becasue I am used to shopping by myself, and he had fallen asleep, I just plain forgot. Everyone that knows me and my children, know that I am a wonderful mother who would enever do anything to hurt my kids. This happens to people like me. If someone else had dont this I would have said “how do you forget your child?” But now I know the answer to that and its very scarey. Now I am being investogated by Child Protective services for 60 days. Which is fine becasue I have nothing to hide and I am confident that i am a perfectly capable mother. But, I have been crying for 2 days and I did not sleep at all last night thinking about how things could have ended up so much worse. I thank god I still have my son and I will be checking and doucle checking my backseat anytime I go ANYWHERE from now on. Putting my purse in the back seat sounds like a great idea. It is hard for me to admit that I made such a careless mistake and I know many others would have a hard time posting their story for tohers to hear, but it h=can happen to anyone. We are all human, we are creatures of habit. An alarm would not be a bad idea at all.
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Joslyn Gray
Amber Doty
Julianna Miner
Monica Bielanko
Sierra Black
Meredith Carroll
Carolyn Castiglia
Sunny Chanel
Madeline Holler
Wendy Michaels
Rebecca Odes
Danielle Smith
Danielle Sullivan
Katherine Stone
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

0