babble » blogs » Strollerderby
Strollerderby
Girls Scouts Body Image Campaign: Helping or Hurting the Cause?
That today’s girls are getting unhealthy messages about beauty and how to attain it goes without saying. From the magazines they read to the Photo-shopped images they see, girls are hearing loud and clear that unless they are thin, they are not beautiful. Common sense says this is ridiculous. Beauty is about much more than what size you wear. But while women of all ages fall victim to this mindset, young girls are particularly vulnerable. They haven’t yet had time to gain the life experience that would show them that beauty truly comes from within.
As parents, we combat this issue in many different ways. I refuse to allow beauty magazines in my house and often talk to my own tween about what’s real, what isn’t and why none of it really matters if she doesn’t feel good about who she is inside. But it’s an uphill battle that parents can’t fight alone. That’s why I am pleased to see a high-profile organization like the Girls Scouts of America (GSA) getting involved and trying to combat the problem at the very source: The media.
GSA is addressing the issue on three fronts. First, they’ve teamed up with the Dove Self-Esteem Fund, which is working help “free the next generation from self-limiting beauty stereotypes.” They are also involved in the Healthy Media for Youth Act which, among other things, would provide for the establishment of a National Task Force on Girls and Women in the Media.
And lastly, GSA is using their considerable resources to speak directly to young girls. In a series of videos called “The Changing Face of Fashion,” GSA and modeling agency Wilhelmina Curve showcases plus-sized models talking about their own bodies, self-esteem and careers. Anticipating another tool to use in my fight to keep my own girl’s self-esteem intact, I eagerly clicked on the first video. And just like Julie Gerstein at Lemondrop, I was disappointed. I watched them all and I remain disappointed.
If you close your eyes and listen to what these young women are saying, the videos are mostly good. Despite the fact that they go on a bit about how they came to be models, they also speak of inner beauty, strength and being comfortable with yourself. But when you open your eyes and take a look at them, it feels like more of the same. These young women are gorgeous and if they are also plus-sized, it is impossible to tell. The videos are shot from the shoulders up and each and every one of them would look right at home on the cover of any mainstream beauty magazine.
I get that they were trying to make the point that even curvy girls can be models, but I am not sure how that helps the average girl. You know, the girl who is curvy and short. Or lacks perfect bone structure and gorgeous hair. If they really wanted the average girl to feel good about herself , why didn’t they film average girls feeling good about themselves? Am I missing something here? Do you see the value in the message GSA is sending with these videos?
Image: Girl Scouts
More from this author:
Parenting Products You Probably Don’t Need
Kidz Bop: Do You Censor Your Kid’s Music
Breaking the Binky Habit: When and Why
Sign Language for Babies More Popular Than Ever
Nap Nanny Recalled After Baby’s Death
Twilight Teeth: Freaky or Fab?
Forever 21 Marketing Maternity Wear to Teens?
Christmas in July: Are You Ready?
Is Ghetto Parenting Offensive?
Go Back To Strollerderby
0 Comments
Stephanie commented on Aug 02 10 at 9:28 amAlthough the PSAs are not perfect, I think they are a step in the right direction. And, given that I have seen numerous blogs talking about this, Girl Scouts has sparked significant converstaion about what healthy media images look like, which is crucial. The Healthy Media for Youth Act would do this as well, if we can get it passed. The bill (HR 4925) would do three main things: create a grant program for media literay programs for youth, facilitate research on the health effects of negative media images on youth, and create a taskforce to develop voluntary standards for more girl-positive media.
Girl Scouts has made it easy to support the Healthy Media for Youth Act! Visit http://www.girlscouts4girls.org to send a letter of support to your Member of Congress, urging her or him to co-sponsor this important bill!
Then we can move even further into girl-positive media images!
a Girl Scout commented on Aug 04 10 at 4:32 pmFYI-GSA is not the correct acronym for the Girl Scouts of the USA, GSA is the acronym for the Gay-Straight Alliance. Girl Scouts correct acronym is GSUSA. Thanks.
Ashley commented on Aug 09 10 at 11:48 amIt’s not just the GSA that’s missed the point. Unilever owns Dove. Unilever owns AXE. Unilever is talking out of both sides of their mouths by Campaigning for “Real Beauty” and then using hypersexualized, misogynistic ads that depict women as objects to be used and abused, and it’s making them millions of dollars. I’m not happy that no one at GSA did their research on that, it’s easy enough to find out.
Frankincensed commented on Oct 04 10 at 8:12 amlighten up, girl scout. you make it sound like the GSA is a terrible thing to mix up the girl scouts with.
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Lori Garcia
Joslyn Gray
Amber Doty
Julianna Miner
Monica Bielanko
Sierra Black
Meredith Carroll
Carolyn Castiglia
Sunny Chanel
Madeline Holler
Rebecca Odes
Danielle Smith
Danielle Sullivan
Katherine Stone
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

0