Strollerderby

At-Home Genetic Tests Yield Bogus Results: Probe

Posted by madeline holler on July 22nd, 2010 at 4:52 pm

at home genetic test kits bogus gao fda 300x225 At Home Genetic Tests Yield Bogus Results: ProbeA recent study shows that a small majority of parents want to pull money out of their wallets and light it on fire. Not literally. But lighting money on fire would at least save a trip to Walgreens.

In a poll of nearly 1,500 parents, 53 percent said they would be interested in at-home genetic tests for their kids. These parents said they’d like to know whether their children are at an increased, average or low-risk for developing certain cancers and other diseases so that they might work on preventing them. But here’s the problem: those at-home tests? Totally bogus results.

A recent federal probe into four of widely available test kits revealed inconsistent results. The General Accounting Office sent in various test swabs to each of the genetic test companies. One man’s swabbed cheek returned a high risk for developing prostate cancer from one company, a low risk from another company and average risk from two others. Another test swab, from a man who wears a pacemaker, came back as having a low risk for developing heart disease. Informative!

The GAO presented these another findings at a Congressional hearing called to look at the genetic testing industry. The hearings were called in anticipation of one of the companies, Pathway Genetics, said it would soon start marking its kits in retail pharmacies (though since then the Food and Drug Administration said all the companies need to get approval).

Of course, nobody wants inaccurate information about their own or their kids’ genetic predispositions. But would knowing your child carries the gene for breast cancer be helpful or cause a childhood of worry for you and the kid? If personalized genetic tests could produce trustworthy results, would you do it for yourself or your children? I think I’d personally rather not know. Then again, I was more than happy to undergo genetic testing when I was pregnant with my third kid.

More Posts

OB Group Now Encouraging VBACs

Is it Sad to Have a Boy When you Want a Girl?

Are the Kids Getting Enough Poetry?

Should You Let Your Daughter Do Beauty Pageants?

New Way to Discriminate Against Women

First Thoughts After the Baby Was Born

Mom Defends Tween YouTube Star After Death Threats

5 Parenting Types

Are We Ready for Male Midwives?

When is it time to wean?

Should this boy get survivor benefits?

Creativity Crisis: US Schools’ Next Challenge?

Why Did You Want Kids?

Photo: cpbn.org

 At Home Genetic Tests Yield Bogus Results: Probe

Go Back To Strollerderby

0 Comments

[...] At-Home Genetic Tests Yield Bogus Results [...]

Why I Won't See 'Ramona and Beezus' | Strollerderby commented on Jul 23 10 at 2:31 pm

Not worth spit.

bob commented on Jul 23 10 at 10:12 am

In the news report I heard (NPR), after telling you you were at risk for xyz genetic diseases, some of these companies would then offer to sell you a pill to “cure you”.

Such a pill is currently science fiction. And doubtless full of snake oil.

Samantha commented on Jul 23 10 at 3:51 pm

“The GAO presented these another findings at a Congressional hearing called to look at the genetic testing industry.” Don’t you mean ‘and other’ not ‘another’ in the above? Every article I read with Ms. Holler’s byline seems to have some seriously distracting typos.

Megan commented on Aug 02 10 at 6:04 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Lori Garcia
  • Joslyn Gray
  • Amber Doty
  • Julianna Miner
  • Monica Bielanko
  • Sierra Black
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Carolyn Castiglia
  • Sunny Chanel
  • Madeline Holler
  • Rebecca Odes
  • Danielle Smith
  • Danielle Sullivan
  • Katherine Stone
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Strollerderby (50 of 11490 articles)