Strollerderby

Are Parents Saving for Retirement Instead of Paying for College?

Posted by helaineo on July 22nd, 2010 at 10:30 am

800px Harvard Yard Harvard University 300x225 Are Parents Saving for Retirement Instead of Paying for College? It appears Americans might finally be listening to Suze Orman, at least when it comes to not paying for their children’s college education. According to a survey recently published by Country Financial this week, more Americans say they believe it should be their first priority to plan for their own retirement, rather than putting money aside for their children’s higher scholing.

This is a radical change, and there are likely a number of factors that can explain the sudden finding, almost all related to the continuing impact of the Great Recession on the bottom line of American families.

First, Country Financial found the number of people saying they believed college was a good investment plunged in the past year, down to two-thirds from eighty percent in previous surveys. Country Financial could not explain the finding, but it’s no secret that well-credentialed 20somethings just entering the workforce from college are having an extremely hard time finding any employment, putting them in the same position of unemployed middle-aged workers (aka, the parents), who are also having a hard time getting a new job if they lose their current position, no matter how pedigreed their resumes.

Second, the stock market has essentially been flat for a decade, limiting investment gains in retirement and other savings accounts. Moreover, the real estate wealth accumulated by Americans in recent years turned out to be a financial mirage. As a result, the dire warnings about our financial prospects in our golden years proliferate. Just last week, the non-partisan Employee Benefit Research Institute in Washington released a study saying that just under half of Baby Boomers and Gen Xers are at serious risk of outliving their  savings.

Despite the negative economic news, however, college costs continue to increase at a pace above the rate of inflation, even as American incomes are being downsized. As a result,  cash-strapped parents simply have no choice but to heed the importunings of financial planners like Suze Orman, who have been preaching for years that that saving for retirement is much more important than paying for college. Children, folks like Orman argue, can always take out loans or go to less expensive schools, but we have only a limited number of years to save for retirement. Moreover,  junior might be grateful for a parent tuition assist now, but will be less than thrilled if that homegrown financial aid throws mom and dad into poverty in retirement, leaving them eating cat food in their old age unless their proud college graduate — who will likely be saving for his children’s university college costs at that point — steps in.

So hallelujah we are finally seeing financial sense? Well, not so fast.

Student loans can be crippling life burdens, and encouraging young adults who are unlikely to truly comprehend the life-altering consequences of debt to sign their John Hancock in lieu of parental payments can seem like one more bit of selfishness by the older generations, yet another bill foisted onto the young ‘uns, especially if mom and dad do have the ability to help out. Just under fifty percent of those surveyed told Country Financial surveyors that their own college debt had impacted their lives to some extent, with forty percent of those 18-29 describing the effect “significant.”

And, finally, parents crying uncle when it comes to showering money on their children might just be the worst economic indicator anyone has seen yet. Never mind falling housing and retail sales. Numerous studies have found that parents have continued to spend on their boys and girls over the past two years, even as they’ve cut back on their own personal expenditures. If that’s finally changing, we don’t need Nouriel Roubini to tell us the economy is probably double-dipping back into recession.

So what about you? Are you prioritizing your retirement over saving for your children’s future college expenses? Let us know.

More Poss:

Bethenny Frankel’s Mom Strikes Back

Coke Ends Facebook Campaign After Promoting Porn to Teens

Are the Real Housewives Violating Child Labor Laws?

Does Kate Gosselin Need Mommy “Me” Time?

Mad Men’s Bad Mom Receives Emmy Nod

Model Adrianne Curry Bashes Breastfeeding on Twitter

Meet The Original Grandparents

How to Talk to Children About Money

Arrested While Autistic

Proposed Airline Peanut Ban Cancelled

Parents Sue after Children Cut from Team

Could it Be Cheaper to Live in the City Than Suburbs

Whatever Happened to Flextime?

Leading British Fertility Specialist Says Women Should Have Children in Their Twenties

Photo: Harvard Yard by Daderot

 Are Parents Saving for Retirement Instead of Paying for College?

Go Back To Strollerderby

0 Comments

[...] are beginning to rebel at paying the ever-soaring tab for higher ed, with a study recently released by Countrywide Financial finding the number of moms and dads who say college is a good investment in their child’s [...]

American Economy So Awful Parents are Buying Franchises to Keep Adult Children Employed | Strollerderby commented on Jul 30 10 at 1:03 pm

We are mainly saving for retirement but also making small monthly contributions into our daughter’s 529. Our plan is to have enough saved up for one year of college for her, and it will be up to her to take care of the rest. There is nothing wrong with taking out student loans, and most people I know are not devastated by it. It will cause my daughter to think long and hard about enrolling in a crazy expensive college, too, because I think that most of them aren’t worth it. There are plenty of local (and national) colleges that are less than $10,000/year, and their degrees will get you the same job as a degree that cost 4 times that much.

Lindsay commented on Jul 22 10 at 10:38 am

Agreed. We’re saving for retirement, expect to both have pensions and also contribute to our daughter’s 529. My parents helped me with free room and board for my first three years and I went to a junior college and state school to get my degree. We will likely offer the same deal to my daughter when she’s ready to enter college. I think throwing all that money at a private 4-year school is crazy… and what’ even crazier is doing so when you can’t afford to save for yourself first.

Stephanie commented on Jul 22 10 at 11:04 am

I would advise families not to write off private schools based on the high sticker price. At many schools, that’s just the price that the wealthiest families pay. Colleges use financial aid, including free-money need-based scholarships, to offset the tuition — in effect charging different amounts to different people depending on their income and assets. And the more attractive your kid is to colleges, the more this works for you because it opens up merit-based aid and it can give you bargaining power so you can pit one school’s aid offer against another’s. If your kid can get into an ivy league school, they could benefit from new policies that allow even pretty wealthy students to graduate with no loan debt.
If you are aiming for state school, don’t change your overall plans, or get hearts set on private school. But apply to a couple private colleges too and see what happens.

bob commented on Jul 22 10 at 11:31 am

Good point bob. I went to a small liberal arts college that was $37K my freshman year, and $40K my senior year. However, the college was able to offer me many scholarships that state schools didn’t have access to. Along with the state sponsored scholarships and my athletic scholarship, I was more than covered–I even got a check for books. The important thing is to be proactive in getting money. Taking out a loan should be the last thing you do. Research, write the essays, fill out the applications–there are so many scholarships out there that don’t get filled because students are too lazy to do the paperwork.

JBoogie commented on Jul 22 10 at 1:47 pm

We fund our retirement savings first, then contribute to the kids college savings. Both my husband and I have parents who we may have to support in their old age due to them having never put away anything for themselves. I think that would be more of a burden on children than footing the bill for their own education.

Mistress_Scorpio commented on Jul 22 10 at 8:15 pm

My husband’s parents didn’t bother putting anything away for his college expenses. They did, on the other hand, pay for a decent amount of his little brother’s tuition. Don’t think they have much in the way of retirement savings. Go figure.

Of course, these are the same people who decided they wanted to spend a large bonus on a flat-screen tv instead of Hubby’s braces when he was a kid. And yes, they will actually tell people that they decided that, it wasn’t a coincidence. Now we are saving up for him get braces, but because he is not a kid, insurance won’t pay for any of it. Thanks MIL and FIL. They then got his little brother braces. Not that I’m bitter or anything, but yeah. If they never get on the ball with retirement savings, they are definitely staying with his little brother. ;P

Rebecca commented on Jul 23 10 at 12:37 am

We’re saving for retirement, first, too. It’s just more important to make sure Mom and Dad have a roof over their heads and medicine in their seventies and eighties than to keep the kids from (possibly) having some loan payments in their twenties and thirties.

jenny tries too hard commented on Jul 23 10 at 11:50 am

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Joslyn Gray
  • Amber Doty
  • Julianna Miner
  • Monica Bielanko
  • Sierra Black
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Carolyn Castiglia
  • Sunny Chanel
  • Madeline Holler
  • Wendy Michaels
  • Rebecca Odes
  • Danielle Smith
  • Danielle Sullivan
  • Katherine Stone
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

    More in Strollerderby (50 of 10516 articles)