babble » blogs » Strollerderby
Strollerderby
First Graders Could Get Contraception Under New Policy
A surprising new school policy in Provincetown garnered only one parent phone call — and that call was just a request for more information.
The controversial new policy allows any student to get free condoms at school, even if that student is only 7 years old. And parents aren’t allowed to opt their kids out of the program. If kids want a condom, they get a condom.
Here’s the twist: Before any student can go home with a free condom, they must first talk to a school counselor and listen to advice on the benefits of abstinence.
The new policy is the brainstorm of the town’s health advisory committee and was approved unanimously by the school board on June 10. School board chairman Peter Grosso explains why there’s no age limit on the program. “The thing is, sexual activity starts younger and younger,” Grosso told the Boston Herald. “We don’t know what age that is. So we just said, ‘We’ll make it available to all of them.’ We didn’t want to pick an age, and I really don’t believe we’re going to get first-graders asking for a condom, as a practical matter.”
The policy is not without critics, of course. Conservative group Massachusetts Family Institute is appalled at the idea. “What’s next? Birth control pills?” asked Kris Mineau, head of the conservative group Massachusetts Family Institute, in the Boston Herald. Mineau said the group will support any parent who wants to take legal action.
I’m a strong advocate of early sex ed for kids, that is, honest and age-appropriate information early on. Fundamentally, I don’t think this program — despite the sensational headlines — will end up being any different than others that hand out condoms to kids at school. But there are two things that concern me: 1) Are they promoting condoms to kids in the lower grades? Or is it just a matter of, say, a sign on the wall in the nurse’s office? And 2) I always get a little nervous when parental input is totally disregarded.
Here’s what I think will happen: Some fourth or fifth grade kid will get brave enough to ask for a condom, listen to the speech, then they’ll take it out on the playground where a group of kids will gather around to see what’s inside.
But mostly, the kids who are going to be asking are probably going to be those who are having or are thinking about having sex, like a 14-year-old girl who doesn’t feel safe talking to her parents. This new policy provides her with someone she can talk to — has to talk to, in fact, if she wants her free condom. And maybe that person will say something that makes her think about what she’s about to do.
And no, I don’t think we’ll see any condoms being handed out to first graders.
I think the most interesting thing about this policy is that the school board refuses to let parents decide whether or not their kids can have condoms. And that’s probably where opponents will focus their fight.
What do you think about Provincetown’s policy?
Go Back To Strollerderby
0 Comments
bob commented on Jun 24 10 at 12:34 pmProbably too large anyway…
BlackOrchid commented on Jun 24 10 at 12:52 pmSo your theoretical 14 year old girl (not a first grader, one would hope), who is too shy to talk to any other adult about having sex, is going to go to the trouble of listening to a spiel for some free condoms from her school? That seems at all probable?
NO! Seriously. This policy is ridiculous. Your hypothetical will still have unprotected sex – likely it’s not even up to her – and all this policy will do is cost money, waste money, and give 2nd graders some laughs.
Oh and also the headlines and blogpost discussions! that must have some value, right?
I have this crazy idea! How about our failing schools start actually TEACHING ACADEMICS?!?!?
Sara commented on Jun 24 10 at 1:04 pmI’m confident that my first grader won’t ask for a condom and if a fifth grader does and they all go look at it in the alley on the way home from school that’s not a bad thing.
It sounds like a good program.
anon commented on Jun 24 10 at 1:57 pmThey can’t even manage to teach these kids to read and write and they are going to teach about sex. Sure. Not my kid. Whatever.
diera commented on Jun 24 10 at 2:18 pmI think most kids would rather have unprotected sex than have to listen to a lecture on the benefits of abstinence from a counselor, so I think this is a stupid program. However, if any first grader is aware enough of the existence of condoms to ask for one, what’s the big deal? It’s not like you unwrap one and next thing you know you’re a porn star.
Rebecca commented on Jun 24 10 at 2:59 pmThis is the stupidest thing I have ever heard of. I am 19 and expecting my son here in september. That being said, there is no way in hell I would ever want my little boy to be exposed to that this early on. What does a 1st grader need availability to condoms for? A first grader cant even engage in sex normally, he hasnt hit puberty and it would be quite painful for little girls. I knew about condoms… and I still got pregnant. Why give kids knowledge of that when they are 6?! It only tempts them more as they get older. And we all know condoms are not fully effective. So theres another spike in pregnancy thanks to peoples stupidity. I would never want my son to have a child as a teenager. My reality is a hard one, I would rather he go on in life enjoying it and having fun with his friends than having sex because he can. Giving these kids the opportunity to freely get condoms is just going to make problems, and some may even feel pressured. Really consider what it is you are doing with a mind that young.
Eric Post commented on Jun 24 10 at 5:26 pmAgreed this is ridiculous. A child too embarassed to ask for a condom isn’t going to brave a lecture from a teacher. This is just a publicity stunt. Geez, I know of clinics in Chicago where ADULTS can get free condoms. They just have to go into the clinic, go to the waiting room and they can take as many condoms as they’d like. And you know what? The adults are TOO EMBARRASSED to go into the free clinic and take them. And they don’t even have to talk to or ask anyone. It’s just a matter of going into a free clinic. If you can’t get adults to do that, children aren’t going to say “Gee I’ll talk to that counselor about sex.”
JZ commented on Jun 25 10 at 9:20 amIn instances where high schools have offered free condoms kids still didnt use them. I dont think it’ll work at all. And I dont see a first grader asking for a condom eaither.
nicola goodall commented on Jul 16 10 at 10:29 amComments
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Lori Garcia
Joslyn Gray
Amber Doty
Julianna Miner
Monica Bielanko
Sierra Black
Meredith Carroll
Carolyn Castiglia
Sunny Chanel
Madeline Holler
Rebecca Odes
Danielle Smith
Danielle Sullivan
Katherine Stone
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

0