babble » blogs » Strollerderby
Strollerderby
Because 24 Helmets Can’t Possibly Be Enough*
I won’t do it. I will not take the “Moms for Mouth Guards” pledge. I will not add one more thing to the vast arsenal of helmets, pads, cups, and guards intended to protect our preschoolers, kindergardener and third grader from every conceivable injury they could suffer while doing just about anything. I also refuse to purchase such glorious innovations as “potty mitts” or “baby knee pads.” And, just to top it all off, I’m going to let my four-year-old ride her scooter in a circle in our garage without a helmet. And I’m not even going to watch.
Not everything in life should require the packing of a bag. Soccer practice for 5-year-olds should involve sneakers and a ball, not a mouthguard and a helmet. Learning to walk requires no protective gear. Riding on the kind of tricycle that has a handle behind it for the parent to push, ditto. When my kid turns to me as I load her into a wagon and asks “where’s my helmet?” I know we’ve gone too far. We’re gearing ourselves out of the game, and sending a message that the only really safe place in the world is snugly ensconced in front of the TV.
To me, every additional piece of gear that any given sport requires is just another reason not to play. Has any really dedicated hockey player ever thrown aside her stick because she doesn’t want to put that stinky mouth guard in her mouth one more time? No, but it’s one more straw for the kid who’s not aiming to play for the Olympic women’s team one day. I’ve seen my kids walk away from their bikes because they can’t find their helmets. I know plenty of families who’ve taken one look at the cost of a lacrosse helmet and taken their kid to soccer instead–and there are arguments being made to price kids out of that sport, too: the helmet pictured here will run you about $40.
Pro players need a helmet to head a speeding ball. There’s probably an argument to be made for using one at college level as well; but these things trickle down, and the end result of musings like “she should get used to it early” and “he wants to look like the big kids” is tiny kids with giant bike helmets wobbling around as their mother wheels them through town on a stroller-trike, and a bag full of gear that’s bigger than the kid for nearly every other sport you can name. Skiing requires skis, and a helmet makes sense–but I propose that my four-year-old daughter could learn to play hockey without a special pair of groin-protecting shorts under the padded shorts she already wears.
Of course all of this is well-intentioned. And somewhere out there is a first-grader who had all of her teeth knocked out by a soccer ball, and right next door to her is a child who caught a terrible infection from a shopping cart handle and a dozen toddlers who went to the emergency room with coffee table inflicted injuries. It happens. But every mother who runs inside for a helmet when her kids start sledding down a slight ridge or swaddles her toilet-training kid up in a set of “potty mitts” or campaigns for the removal of a “dangerous” piece of playground equipment is sending a unintended message: the world’s not safe. Better just to stay home.
*9 bike helmets (at least). 5 hockey. 6 skiing. 1 lacrosse. And 3 from a misguided belief that, now that we live in rural New England, we would somehow begin riding horses.
Go Back To Strollerderby
0 Comments
[...] Strollerderby blogger KJ won’t take the “Moms for Mouth Guards” pledge and she’s sick of helmets, too. But every mom [...]
Helmets and Shin Guards, Now Tattoos -- Oh My! | Strollerderby commented on May 20 10 at 5:16 pm[...] Like my fellow Strollerderby blogger KJ, I think we’ve gone a bit overboard when it comes to protective gear for kids. Kids are kids, after all. They’re bound to get [...]
8 Summer Safety Myths That Put Your Child at Risk | Strollerderby commented on Jun 02 10 at 9:01 amHeather commented on May 20 10 at 12:44 pmAmen.
PlumbLucky commented on May 20 10 at 12:55 pmI’ll agree with most everything…but mouthguards and hockey aren’t exactly new, either. It was standard required equipment when I was five! (I’m thinking that hockey helmets, ski-helmets, bike helmets, lacrosse helmets, and equestrian helmets aren’t overprotective parenting so much as required equipment for relatively dangerous sports. Then again, I also wore my bike helmet for a LONG time while riding horses (til I reached a show level where there was a dress code), and I use my hockey helmet for lacrosse as well).
Jen commented on May 20 10 at 1:38 pmThank you! You’ve helped to relive me of some guilt I was feeling. I just bought a two wheel bike for my 6 yr old. I, being the horrible mom I am, did not buy him a helmet to go with it. I mean come on…I spent $50 on the bike and the helmet was 20 more. I wonder if its just a ploy for us moms to buy more crap we cant afford.
Allison commented on May 20 10 at 1:59 pmI get your point, but I think there is a big difference between “potty mitts” and bike helmets. Your child will eventually learn to use the toilet without putting their hands all over it. But as they grow older and no longer are simply riding a tricycle in the garage, but a bike on the street, they will need a helmet. Its good to be flexible but personally I’d rather get them in the habit now.
JBoogie commented on May 20 10 at 4:24 pmMaybe its just a regional thing, but….I have never seen the kids in my neighborhood with helmets on. And the trampoline down the street doesn’t have a net, and the kids are always doing the craziest jumps off it. One time I saw the two little boys drag a mattress out under a basketball hoop so they could try to “super-dunk”. They run around barefoot, and I can guarantee they don’t have on sunscreen, and most of the time their parents don’t come home from work till around 5:30. I’m sure some moms would call Child Protective Services on the parents in my neighborhood but these kids are having a blast–they are ALWAYS outside, stirring up some kind of trouble/fun. And I think it’s great. My son is only 5 months old, so I’m not too worried about the helmet thing yet…
Manjari commented on May 20 10 at 5:40 pmI don’t think it’s overprotective to make your kids wear bike helmets (for bike riding, not learning to walk).
Ella commented on May 20 10 at 9:49 pmYeah, HUGE difference between potty mitts and bike helmets. We have “if you’re motoring under your own power, wear a helmet” bike/scooter rule, and I’m PLEASED that my 18 mo old knew to put her brother’s helmet on before hopping on his scooter.
We didn’t make them wear one when being pushed in the trike, but once he started pedaling, yes. Establishing the habit early. And really, a $20 helmet is too much? In our city, you can get children’s helmets for FREE at many events throughout the city all year long.Full disclosure, my house bears no “child-proofing” merchandise other than outlet sliders. I’m not a safety freak, and others are astonished at the physical freedom I give my children, but a helmet is a MUST for biking/skating/ scootering.
Jackie Miller commented on May 20 10 at 11:33 pmComments
KJ,I certainly understand your frustrations, especially with such products as potty mitts and other ‘glorious innovations’ as you put it. Where I have a different point of view is on mouth guards and their importance.
Why do I feel this way? I have a unique position and first-hand experience on this topic as I’m not only a mother of 5 children, but I’m also an orthodontist.
This is a real problem in my office. Too often, I see patients suffering from injuries that could have been easily prevented with a simple and inexpensive mouth guard (many of which cost as little as a couple of dollars). The injuries range from cracked or broken teeth to more serious injuries to the jaw, mouth or teeth, some of which cause lifelong dental problems for the patient.
Parents are often surprised by how severe an injury to the face can be in kids’ contact sports, or that mouth guards aren’t just for football or hockey, but any contact sport – baseball, basketball, lacrosse, soccer etc.
As an orthodontist who is committed to helping her patients achieve healthy, beautiful smiles, it’s sad to see injuries that could have been easily prevented. That’s why, when my children take part in playing contact sports, mouthguards are part of their equipment. By the way, concerning trampolines, I had a patient lose three of her permanent front teeth from hitting the side of a trampoline. An inexpensive mouthguard could have prevented thousands of dollars of dental work for this young lady.
I would be more than happy to discuss this further with you – let me know if you’d like me to direct message you
MommyDentist commented on May 21 10 at 8:07 amAgreed, things like “Potty Mitts” and padded helmets for toddlers around the house are ridiculous, but fracturing or losing teeth at such a young age is not something to be taken lightly. As a dentist, I’ve seen my share of kids who’ve sustained permanent injury to their front teeth that was totally preventable had they been wearing mouthguards- injuries that ruined years of orthodontics in a single blow. I think you’d change your mind about mouthguards if you had to watch your child sit through root canals, post and core placments, and crown preparations- or implant placements.
Martin commented on Jun 11 10 at 6:41 pmWho uses helmets for daily life? Sounds weird. Kids need to fall and feel som pain to learn how to walk. Helmets will get important when they start riding a bike or moped: http://www.kidsintraffic.com/2009/helmets-important/
Kate commented on Apr 03 11 at 10:51 pmHelmets for bike riding, life preservers for water sports… I’m with you on this one. It’s not even the cost or the clutter, it’s just that there’s always “one more thing” you can do to make a child safer, even if the risk or added protection is minuscule. If you wouldn’t wear it yourself when performing the same activity….
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Lori Garcia
Joslyn Gray
Amber Doty
Julianna Miner
Monica Bielanko
Sierra Black
Meredith Carroll
Carolyn Castiglia
Sunny Chanel
Madeline Holler
Rebecca Odes
Danielle Smith
Danielle Sullivan
Katherine Stone
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

0