babble » blogs » Strollerderby
Strollerderby
Vaccine Court Rules No Link To Autism
In yet another blow to the vaccines-cause-autism theory, the vaccine court ruled today in three cases that there was not sufficient evidence to show that vaccines caused autism in three cases.
Parents of the three boys brought the cases alleging that thimerosal, a mercury derivative once commonly used as a vaccine preservative, caused their autism. The Special Masters of the Court of Federal Claims, who heard the cases, concluded that they failed to meet the burden of proof.
The cases were three of thousands filed by parents through the Department of Health and Human Services’ Vaccine Injury Compensation Program. Last year, the court ruled there was no evidence that early childhood vaccines caused autism in three other cases. However, in 2007 the court ruled that vaccines aggravated an underlying illness in the case of Hannah Poling, triggering her autism symptoms.
The Coalition for Vaccine Safety hit back, issuing a statement accusing the court of dening justice to vaccine-injured children.
“The deck is stacked against families in Vaccine Court. Government attorneys defend a government program, using government-funded science, before government judges. Where’s the justice in that?” asked Rebecca Estepp, a CVS steering committee member and mother of a petitioner in the Omnibus Autism Proceeding.
Read Babble’s full timeline of the vaccine-autism debate, from 1998 to now.
Photo: a.drian via flickr
Related Posts :
Go Back To Strollerderby
8 Comments
[...] http://blogs.babble.com/strollerderby/2010/03/12/vaccine-court-rules-no-link-to-autism/#more-21764 [...]
An important opinion on the “Autism by Immunization” controversy by someone who lives on BOTH sides of the fence « A visit from the Get-Well-Fairy commented on Mar 14 10 at 11:12 am[...] According to the study, 25% of those who didn’t vaccinate were concerned about autism — about possible side effects such as autism — although there has been no proven scientific link. [...]
More Parents Postpone or Skip Vaccinations | Strollerderby commented on May 04 10 at 5:49 pmKikiriki commented on Mar 12 10 at 5:53 pmOkay, so first it was big bad pharma out to get our kids, now it’s the government? It wouldn’t matter WHO decided the vaccines did not cause autism, these people will remain convinced no matter what. The ‘justice’ was that it was heard by a court, Rebecca Estepp. What other kind of justice do you want? Methinks you want the deck actually stacked, and stacked in your favor.
I just don’t get it. This hysteria was caused by ONE doctor, with an insufficient data set, with fabricated results, whose study was allegedly funded by a lawyer to try to prove that MMR vaccines caused autism, AND who also allegedly had a patent for his own separate ‘safer’ measles vaccine (talk about pharma!). This was a study that all other researchers were unable to replicate, a study that has subsequently been found full of falsehoods and lies, and repudiated by the medical journal that published it. And people continue to believe him, in the face of actual science. Incredible.
Laure68 commented on Mar 12 10 at 7:01 pmWhat Kikiriki said.
Also, re the Hannah Poling case – the vaccine court is set up to heavily favor the plaintiff. All they had to show is that a fever could have aggravated her condition, and that vaccines can cause fevers (which is true). They did not have to prove that the vaccines did actually aggravate her condition. Basically, a fever caused by anything could have aggravated her condition, but the way this court is set up that is enough to make a payment.
Citizen Mom commented on Mar 12 10 at 7:15 pmCan we please now focus attention and energy on therapies for helping children and adults on the spectrum? It makes my head ache thinking about how much farther along we could be in actually helping people cope with this disorder if we (the media, scientists, educators, therapists, doctors, parents) had given equal focus.
I am not against researching causes, and I understand why so many parents fought for this cause, but I can only wonder at what expense?
creepycat commented on Mar 14 10 at 2:00 ami’ve got extensive knowledge from both sides. i’m an RN with 20+ years of experience (a few years here and there were doing pediatrics and immunization clinics. i also have a teen who is a high functioning autistic. she’s gifted in writing and illustrating, manga/anime creation, anything art is hers. she has been winning young author awards since 1st grade and is a 2008 Scholastic, inc Gold Key winner for excellence in art (7th & 8th) grade category which is a huge achievement that could’ve been repeated for 2009 had the bank not stollen my house and caused us horrible trauma. Andy Warhol is in the books for this prize as well as Robert Redford and Joyce Carol Oates in the writing category. She will only get on one ride at Disneyland and starts panicking/flapping in crowds or unfamiliar places or at unexpected situations but can chat like a radio host on the internet teen art chat sites.
The first 11 or so years were HELL for me. I had to do ALL of her hygiene and fight with her amazonian frame to brush hair or teeth. Through LOTS of “lead by example” years I am proud to say that she can be very charming and witty and will look most people in the eye for a minute if the conversation is of her liking.
As for the “cause” of this blessing/curse I’m sure it had a lot to do with the trauma I sustained in an abusive relationship. Or it could be the area we live in, reportedly one of the highest rates of Autism and Autism Spectrum Disorders in the U.S., that has THREE military bases within 70 miles or so of each other That’s the first thing that I thought of. Way before the vaccine vigilantes got the Guillotine greased up.
I’ve had some tough times raising my child but I don’t think i’d give her back if they promised to make her “normal”. She is brilliant. Brilliance takes a bit more elbow grease to achieve but it is SO WORTH IT when you see what all those years of hard polishing and shaping can produce.
I’ve seen horrible things in the hospital. Things most people never imagined could exist. A panic and mass hysteria driven boycott on immunizations will bring those ugly things outside of the hospitals cocoon and into your nice cozy homes. Black Death anyone? “Ring around the rosie, pocket full of posies, ashes, ashes………”
Remember my words and remind everyone you speak to. The only reason we have “eradicated” small pox, polio, German measles, etc. is because everyone is forced to get the vaccines that keep outbreaks of these in the general population of the U.S. to a minimum. Yes, some of the vaccines may be developed and produced in too much of a rush and could use a bit more testing and/or research. But in medicine, I’ve learned, the best prognosis is the lesser of two evils. I suppose that the Swine Flu woke a few people up and reminded them that bacteria and virus’s are the smartest and most gung-ho for life creatures on the planet. They can alter DNA for their own survival faster than the drug companies can print up a label for the antibiotic or antiretroviral antidote. Don’t think for a minute that we simple humans can outsmart those microscopic maniacs just because we have the intelligence to know when we’re at risk for being “socialized” or “victimized” by our governments.
Boycotting vaccines is essentially inviting the ravaging and miserably painful illnesses to come back from history and burn through modern society city by city and county by county. So, if we fold this paragraph like the old Madd Magazine back covers we could end up with this statement…….’Boycotting vaccines is essentially a willful cause of harm and/or death to hundreds of people at a time.’ And I don’t see that as a LESSER evil. Do you?
Rosana commented on Mar 15 10 at 10:57 amCitizen Mom, that is exactly what I was thinking. There should be more organizations shifting there attention to raise money to fund therapies that could help this kids live a regular live once their parents are gone.
creepycat commented on Mar 16 10 at 3:43 amwould the moderator of this blog please email me with reason/s for deleting my comment. i’m not angry. i just want to know your guidelines for future comments so they can get approved.
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Joslyn Gray
Amber Doty
Julianna Miner
Monica Bielanko
Sierra Black
Meredith Carroll
Carolyn Castiglia
Sunny Chanel
Madeline Holler
Wendy Michaels
Rebecca Odes
Danielle Smith
Danielle Sullivan
Katherine Stone
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

8