Strollerderby

School Paper Shut Down for Being Too Honest

Posted by jeannesager on November 21st, 2009 at 5:48 pm

newspaper 300x199 School Paper Shut Down for Being Too HonestKids were writing stories about teen pregnancy, shoplifting and honor students who drink and do drugs. So did the school call an intervention? No, they shut down the student newspaper.

The Stevenson High School paper has long been regarded as one of the most hard hitting in terms of high school journalism. Earlier this year, an issue on “hooking up” disappeared. All three thousand four hundred copies.

The school then called for the communication arts program director to review all articles before they were printed, setting off a barrage of complaints against the district for violating kids’ right to free speech.

Now there will be no speech at all.

According to the Chicago Tribune, members of the paper’s staff were told by administrators that they would have to reveal their sources in a piece on students in the National Honor Society and freshmen mentors program who admitted to drinking and smoking. The district wanted the names in order to punish the kids. The reporters refused, opting to run a blank front page instead, explaining to readers why the story wasn’t there.

Rather than applaud the students’ journalistic integrity, the district “spiked” an issue, citing problems with the blank page plus a story on a set of teens in the district who are expecting a child which they deemed “unbalanced” and another story on kids who shoplift.

Frank LoMante, executive director of the Virginia-based Student Press Law Center, told the Tribune he’s read the stories – and they have positive messages for kids such as “don’t shoplift” and “get counseling if you’re pregnant.”

The point of any newspaper is to reflect the stories of its coverage area. For a school, that means addressing the stories of teenage life. Santizing a school paper does not make the problems disappear. If anything, it amplifies why kids are experimenting with danger – because no one is listening to them.

Image: Alex Barth via flickr

More by this author:

 School Paper Shut Down for Being Too Honest

Go Back To Strollerderby

14 Comments

I don’t understand why people still believe there is freedom of speech on school property. Even on college campuses its increasingly restricted. Those kids should have known better then to write about things interesting to them. They are probably all 16+ they should know to kiss ass 24/7 by that age. Welcome to the real world.

Nathan commented on Nov 22 09 at 2:03 am

Hear no evil see no evil

poon commented on Nov 22 09 at 3:18 pm

thats great nathan, just keep spreading that defeatist attitude. these kids were awesome; and even if their school won’t applaud them, i will.

that guy commented on Nov 22 09 at 4:06 pm

Actually Nathan, in Tinker v. De Moines, the Supreme Court ruled that schools cannot restrict a student’s freedom of speech unless it can proved that the student’s statement causes a material and substantial distraction.

Many school districts push their luck on this matter, and I am one hundred percent certain that a legal challenge in this instance would not go in the district’s favor.

Chris commented on Nov 22 09 at 4:07 pm

However Chris, remember that just a few years back the Supreme Court ruled against one Joseph Frederick, citing that his 14-foot-long banner proclaiming “Bong Hits 4 Jesus” promoted drug use and even though he was off school grounds because it had let out early for the day, the court ruled to uphold the school district’s decision to suspend him. = /

Derek commented on Nov 23 09 at 2:04 am

My senior year in HS, I was a journalism student and the HS newspaper cartoonist. I did an honest critique of our school’s response to bomb threats. I got kicked off the staff and lost a journalism scholarship. This was in 1972.
I have long been an advocate of free speech and continue to do so.
Speak your mind! Speak the truth!

Chuck commented on Nov 23 09 at 11:28 am

Derek, in bong hits 4 Jesus, the boy was off school property but was still being counted as “in class” because the students were on a chaperoned trip to a parade. School had not let out early for the day, and the boy was subject to school rules.

jenny tries too hard commented on Nov 23 09 at 11:33 am

School administrators can only restrict student activity if the school board allows it. School boards can only allow restricting student activity if the voters allow it. Voters are the students parents. Where are the parents voices in this situation?

Bluster commented on Nov 23 09 at 12:07 pm

“members of the paper’s staff were told by administrators that they would have to reveal their sources in a piece on students in the National Honor Society and freshmen mentors program who admitted to drinking and smoking.” Journalistic integrity?? Sounds more like Sensationalist Shit! Stories like these will get these kids jobs with Rupert Murdoch one day, the evil prick…

Matt commented on Nov 24 09 at 2:01 am

Well, I see this is a different light then most people. Basically, it’s called Censorship of the truth. Our Nation as a whole had never had these many problems in the past, research whatever time line there is and you will find that our society never had so many problems as it did back in those days. With schools having so many young children of different Ethic backgrounds in there system and the problems of kids bringing weapons to school and committing acts of murder, something had to be done. In this situation, I think the school system is CYA ! Instead of pissing in everyone’s Wheaties for some remarks that may lead to a kid of a certain Ethic group and start a riot, they decide to implement Mass Punishment ! In the military during Boot Camp, if 1 member of a 30 man platoon messes up, everyone gets punished! If you want to take this further then you have to look at the situation regarding the Ft. Hood murders. The individual who committed this act of Middle eastern background and the way the case is going, He’s going to become very popular in the eyes of his people. The US Army is going about this in the wrong way, watch what happens to this case and You will see what I mean.

Phoenix56317 commented on Nov 24 09 at 6:45 pm

I’m 30 years old now but I began to see this kind of thing happening in public school systems when I was still in school. The school administrators don’t look at those kids as citizens with rights granted by law but instead as cattle that have to be kept under control at all costs. That’s what the system demands of the administration and they’ll trample all over the kids’ liberties to achieve it. That might sound a bit extreme but it really is happening and it will get worse unless we reform the way our public schools do business. Children may need to be kept in order in school but that certainly doesn’t have to mean pissing all over their constitutional rights and those of the parents to bring about that order. Unfortunately, people are becoming increasingly desensitized to this kind of thing and the parents usually don’t want to make more waves by fighting it legally and the kids usually think there’s not much they can do. So… nothing gets done at all and things like this continue to happen on a large scale and to a higher degree.

It’s a perfect example of the current political climate in our country. Freedom of speech and freedom of press should be very high on our list of priorities, yet this is happening in our schools. Schools that OUR government manages and OUR tax moneys pay for. Yet it’s “Do as you’re told, because it’s for the good of everyone”. It’s a sickening fact that we live in one of the most free nations in the world, yet at the first sign of trouble we hand over that freedom to the very power structure that’s supposed to be protecting the document that gave us that freedom in the first place. After all, it’s for the children and for the good of the people. I guess it’s more trendy these days to worry about someone having more money that someone else than to actually worry about our liberties and freedom granted to us by the US Constitution. Disgusting.

Ryan commented on Nov 25 09 at 2:01 pm

So these kids were using school time and school moeny and resourses to write what effectively amounted to a gossip rag and the school withdrew their funding after the kids started getting into arguments with the principal?
I am so shocked.

eric commented on Feb 19 10 at 9:16 am

This is exactly what led to the murders at Kent State years ago. This paper is protected under the first amendment and we set another very bad example of republican government if we fail to protect the authors rights to present the story as they perceived. Just because you or I do not like the content means either we are not looking or we choose not to care and either case is the precursor to disaster. My generation ended a war and the presidency of a criminal but we failed to solve the murders of two Kennedys and MLK and look at what that got us with Bush Chaney and a complete disregard for the rule of law. If other “news” outlets covered the stories their readership needed to know about perhaps they would not have been replaced by the likes of talk radio propaganda and Fox “News”. Someone with a law degree and some clout needs to step up and defend these “kids” and their civil rights and the rest of us better anti up and pay the freight for it or we lose a lot more than our integrity. Time has come to walk the walk because the talking has been censored. Just where is Stevenson High School and what was the outcome of this? Are these Journalists now in college and if so where? We need them inside the beltway desperately and right now! If there is nothing to be done I still must congratulate each and every member of that paper for being the “real” Americans on the front line in the battle for democracy.

Katman commented on May 09 10 at 5:06 pm

As a teacher of high school students and the teacher/sponsor of a high school newspaper, I agree with eric. High school kids do not have the maturity to select appropriate “stories” for print. (OK, well, most do not.) I have experienced their tendency to focus on negative, shocking, and rude ideas for their articles. As a responsible citizen and adult role model, I try to instill a sense of integrity into these kids and direct them to keep the school newspaper out of the gutter. I don’t want to sponsor a “tabloid” like what is sold as “news” at the grocery store check out counter. I want to help these kids try to see a little more of the positive side of their world. As a society, we don’t get much in the way of positive in our news. Maybe the next generation can change that if some standards are set early enough.

teach commented on Jul 07 10 at 7:14 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Joslyn Gray
  • Amber Doty
  • Julianna Miner
  • Monica Bielanko
  • Sierra Black
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Carolyn Castiglia
  • Sunny Chanel
  • Madeline Holler
  • Wendy Michaels
  • Rebecca Odes
  • Danielle Smith
  • Danielle Sullivan
  • Katherine Stone
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

    More in Strollerderby (50 of 10438 articles)