She Killed the Class Pet
Two hundred fifty dollars - that’s the going rate for euthanizing a hamster in Caroline Howard’s neighborhood.
Would you pay it? She didn’t.
Here’s what happened: Howard agreed to let her son bring home Cupcake, a hamster who also served as the first grade class pet. Some time later — hamsters only live to be about two or so — Cupcake suffered a stroke.
As an animal lover, Howard couldn’t bear to see him suffer. But $250? Please.
Howard writes:
I value life. If there’s a spider in my home, I gingerly cup it in my palms and take it outside rather than shmooshing it. But while the vet was laying out the options–extensive treatment, wishful thinking or euthanasia–I thought back to a woman I once met whose pet rat was going through a third round of chemo after yet another one of its teats developed breast cancer; female rats typically have six pairs of nipples.
“How much will it cost to euthanize?” I asked. It didn’t take much thought to reject his answer of $250 to put Cupcake to sleep and take care of his tiny body. I have a conscience but I also have a checkbook.
Friends offered suggestions: Break his neck? Throw him down the garbage chute? Howard chose rat poison, and three days later Cupcake succumbed.
Class pets create dicey situations for parents. You didn’t really want a small rodent in your home, but yet here’s your seven-year-old looking you with wide-eyed hope that you’ll say yes, okay, we’ll take Snuggles home. For a weekend, maybe. But adopting it straight out should exempt you from PTA volunteer duties for the better part of a year.
My daughter’s first grade teacher had two pets at the beginning of the year, a fish in a bowl and a hamster. The fish only made it to day three, but I’m keeping my eye on Sleepy the hamster. Because if her teacher approaches me with that look in her eye, I want to be ready with a planned escape route.
Would you bring home the class pet? (All kidding aside, I’d probably give in.) Even if it meant dealing with a problem like Cupcake?
Related Posts:- The 100 Games Cupcake Game
- Is The Zhu Zhu Pets Craze For Real?
- Hamsters Are Hot This Holiday
- Mother Forces Son to Kill Hamster for Bad Grades
- Fifth Graders Get Sex Tape Instead of Slideshow
Tags: bethany sanders, class pet, hampster, loss of pet, parenting, pets, rodent
18 Comments
[...] She Killed the Class Pet [...]
Retirement Community Tries to Evict Six-Year-Old Girl | Strollerderby commented on Oct 22 09 at 10:00 amEric commented on Oct 21 09 at 4:14 pmI am continually amazed at all the wierd, cruel methods people come up with for dispatching sick and injured animals. My wife’s a vet and has a whole stable full of stories of what people do out of sheer stupidity. Throwing it down the garbage chute? Rat posion? You use rat poison to kill rats you can’t catch. Anyone whose seen the suffering animals who get into rat poison go through before they die wouldn’t use it so lightly. Either find a vet who will do it for a reasonable fee (my wife quoted $25) or stomp it quickly.
KellyK commented on Oct 21 09 at 5:06 pmRat posion!? Are you kidding me!? That seems like the WORST thing you could do! I lived for three more days after having a stroke and THEN being posioned?! I would think a pillow or the freezer would have been nicer. And yes calling more than one vet, certainly a sane one, would have been a good idea as well.
eversoloud commented on Oct 21 09 at 5:50 pmI’ll give Caroline Howard the benefit of the doubt in that she must have thought the rat poison was the best way to go, but I don’t think I could have done it. It seems pretty harsh to me. But I wouldn’t have paid the $250 either. I probably would have called around to every vet in my area until I found one with a little compassion, like Eric’s wife. It’s too bad the Howard’s vet wasn’t more understanding.
bethanysanders commented on Oct 21 09 at 6:05 pmI agree eversoloud. $250 is an amazing amount of money. We just had our elderly cat put to sleep AT HOME, and it didn’t even cost $100. Hopefully other vets would be more sympathetic. And I agree, I think that Caroline thought she was doing the best she could for their pet.
Epic Camera commented on Oct 21 09 at 6:06 pmWow! $250. It cost 95 for my chow/shepard mix, and that included cremation.
buzan mind map commented on Oct 21 09 at 6:44 pmComments
we should always be kind to animals… they also have life.
Vet Tech commented on Oct 21 09 at 7:08 pmAs a Veterinary Technician, it is just HORRIBLE to think she watched that hamster suffer for THREE DAYS after she purposely poisoned it. Doesn’t she understand what rat poison does? It’s an excruciatingly painful bleeding out! What’s the lesson to her child there?? At our office, euthanasia for a hamster would be about $40. When I was younger, I had a hamster that had been “mouthed” by a dog that I had put to sleep for $12 after calling several vets in the area and getting the lowest price. If you can’t afford a humane euthanasia performed by a veterinarian, please make the poor little being’s death QUICK. For goodness sake, you could drive over it, shoot it, etc. Sickening to think of, but I’d much rather it be that when compared to a painful, slow death by poison. I don’t care what that woman’s excuse is…That’s just disgusting that she would torture that poor hamster like that.
SE commented on Oct 21 09 at 9:33 pmTHREE DAYS? That is just insane. I am sure her intentions were good, but if she truly decided that she had to put the animal down herself, she should have bucked up and done it in some way that would be over quickly. For my own part, I would have gone straight to the local Humane Society for advice and help.
ann05 commented on Oct 21 09 at 11:55 pmI am continuously amazed at the generosity of vets. We found a kitten once with a broken femur and the vet ended up donating what I imagine was something like $8000 in care in return for a promise we would find the cat a good, safe home.
I cannot imagine treating a living being with so little kindness and not seeking other options. I imagine if you told that vet what you were planning the cost would have come way down.
Ali commented on Oct 22 09 at 12:23 amI have taken in cats and dogs over the years tha twere injured. Paid for their vet bills and shots, cared for them and then usually found them good homes. I once picked up a cat run over by a car tha twas lying on teh yellow line with cars driving slowly around it. I paid over 1000 dollars for his surgery. I helped him use the catbox with his giant cast and then I found his owners. I once gave 800 dollars to a friend to have his 4 puppies treated for Parvo. They all made it. It was all money well spent.
PlumbLucky commented on Oct 22 09 at 7:20 am$250 seems really steep, and I am likewise giving her the benefit of the doubt that she thought that rat poison would be the best option. ::shiver::
Kay commented on Oct 22 09 at 11:43 amThis is why I truly believe any class pets the teacher introduces into the class should be the responsibility of the teacher. I’m sure she thought that rat poison was the way to go, but call around to different vets, ask friends for recommendations to vets, somewhere there is a vet with a conscience and a heart who would have done it for much less.
I personally know two vets myself who would have paid for it themselves rather than see an animal suffer with rat poison.
MJ commented on Oct 22 09 at 2:06 pmOur vet does not charge to put down animals of regular customers, and I can’t imagine them charging for a school pet, either. I agree with many of the others- find a less whacky vet!
Ali commented on Oct 22 09 at 3:06 pmAll she had to do was pick up the phone and call around. She would have found a cheaper vet. Sounds like she was lazy and cruel.
Lizzie commented on Oct 22 09 at 6:06 pmThis makes me glad that my daughter’s kindergarten class pet is a hedgehog puppet. (He was a perfect guest when it was our turn.) And although our dog ended up dying at home, our vet would have come to OUR house and ended her life for $50.
Marj commented on Oct 24 09 at 7:48 pmShe definately could have called around and gotten a lower price. Rat poison is not a gentle death. It would have been kinder to give it alchohol or something else that would have numbed and killed.
tammy commented on Nov 19 09 at 6:26 pmAs a teacher, I don’t send class pets home with kids. Well, not since my first year when our escape artist hamster came back with 16 luggage locks on different joints of his cage..
It’s just too much for the parents. So many things can happen. And, it wouldn’t necessarily be anyone’s fault if it died, but the parents and child would still feel horrible. In fact, Peppy, our guinea pig from last year, resides at my house in a rabbit hutch. He got used to his big cage and didn’t want to go back to a small classroom one, so I let him live out there like a rabbit
![]()
As far as this woman, I can’t believe she took the thing to a vet in the first place. I also can’t believe the price. Were they encasing him in a golden sarcophagus? However, I think I can come up with about 50 better ways to euthanize an animal. I am a major animal lover, but sometimes it has to be done. I would think carbon monoxide would be very effective and gentle. He’d probably just go to sleep; but any method I chose, I’d read up on it first to make sure it wouldn’t cause more harm than good.








