What Pregnancy Plus Swine Flu Looks Like
I’m having a hard time figuring out why perfectly pro-vaccines people are shunning the swine flu shot. Even if you’re very confident you won’t get it, even if you’re confident that if you do get it you won’t die from it, who would even want to suffer through the dang thing in the first place?
Oh, and to then have your kids and whoever else lives with you come down with it? That sounds like a couple of months of absolute misery to me. Am I waiting for the email that our HMO has a nice juicy shot waiting for me and the brood. Yes, yes, yes I am.
But really, how bad could it be? Pretty bad.
The NY Times features Aubrey Opdyke, who was in a coma and nearly died from the swine flu, the saddest part being that her 27-week-old fetus, who was delivered via emergency c-section during yet another lung collapse of the mother’s, did die.
Now, we’re going to ignore the part about the woman smoking during pregnancy. The article doesn’t make any connection between her smoking and the degree to which she and the fetus suffered from the flu’s symptoms. But I’m not going to ignore the part, deep into the story, where the woman’s physical therapist — you see, this once competitive swimmer is now having to do PT so she can WALK! — says she won’t get the flu vaccine.
Here’s an excerpt:
“We have friends who get flu symptoms and say, ‘Oh, I’m not going to a doctor,’ ” Mr. Opdyke added. “And we say, ‘Do you not understand what we went through?’ I can’t imagine why there’s so much nonchalance.”
That nonchalance strikes close to home.
As they said this, Ms. Opdyke was doing her daily physical therapy, struggling to lift one-pound weights. Her therapist interrupted to announce that she opposed flu shots.
“Have you ever read the labels?” she asked. “They’re so full of toxins.”
Asked if she realized that a shot, had it existed in June, might have saved her client and her baby, she frowned and went back to her clipboard.
While I’m not in favor of requiring medical workers to get the shot, as one hospital recently tried to do, I am stunned that there are so many who won’t. What’s the argument?
Any pregnant women out there not getting the vaccine? Anybody already get it? Thoughts? Experiences? Encouragement?
More Posts
The Difference Between Boys and Girls: None!
Photo: NY Times
Related Posts:- Swine Flu Trials - Would You Let Your Kid be a Guinea Pig?
- They Say: Tamiflu’s Just as Bad as Flu
- Schools May Get First Swine Flu Vaccine
- FDA Approves Swine Flu Vaccine
- They Say: Most Parents Skipping Second Swine Flu Shot
Tags: Aubrey Opdyke, flu vaccine, h1n1 vaccine, h1n1 virus, ny times, swine flu, swine flu vaccine
22 Comments
[...] (Oct 20th) Babble, Strollerderby: What Pregnancy Plus Swine Flu Looks Like [...]
The Dear Dr.MOZ Baby Blog » Dr.MOZ’s H1N1 Link Roundup: Swine Flu Risks for Pregnant Women, Pregnancy and Vaccines… commented on Oct 24 09 at 4:58 pmwondering what to do commented on Oct 20 09 at 4:31 pmI’m a vaccine skeptic. Not that I don’t have them or I don’t vaccinate my children, but I do not follow the public health recommended schedule. I am pregnant and the swine flu does scare me (no vaccine available in my state as of yet.) It seems as if pregnant women are getting severe secondary complications, and it seems as if pg women from previous swine flu epidemics had children with higher rates of heart disease. But what bothers me: lack of research on the effects of the vaccine, even the regular flue vaccine, on the fetus. NO RESEARCH. NO FOLLOW UP. We don’t know if the flu vaccine is somehow hurting the unborn child, although we know asthma and many other chronic diseases are higher? Connection? I don’t know, but the lack of follow up really bothers me.
Amanda commented on Oct 20 09 at 8:15 pmTwo days ago my uncle died of H1N1, he is being buried tomorrow on my birthday. I have typically gotten the standard flu shot every year but I’m not taking the chance with my kids or myself this year, we are getting the vaccine.
Mistress_Scorpio commented on Oct 20 09 at 9:13 pmAmanda, I am so sorry for your loss. As for myself and my family, we are getting the vaccine once they receive it in my area. Not taking the chance.
Robyn commented on Oct 20 09 at 10:26 pm“Now, we’re going to ignore the part about the woman smoking during pregnancy. ”
I think that’s a pretty relevant part. If someone’s a smoker, then her respiratory system’s not operating at peak performance, to say the least. My mom was a smoker, and a common cold was hell for her. The woman started out unhealthy, as did the fetus. Who knows what effect the swine flu would have had if she hadn’t been a smoker?
bettywu commented on Oct 20 09 at 11:16 pmAmanda - I’m so sorry for your loss. That’s awful.
Robyn - I also hear she ate meat occasionally! She deserves no sympathy and her points are obviously now without any merit!
Marj commented on Oct 21 09 at 12:16 amI’ll be getting the H1N1 shot as soon as I can, and I got the regular flu shot. I was one of those too cool to get the flu shot people, until I got pregnant. Now I get them. Also, I don’t want a medical care professional who doesn’t believe in vaccines…because they have a poor grasp of medicine and science.
PlumbLucky commented on Oct 21 09 at 7:31 amI am not supposed to get the (regular) flu shot due to an allergy to a component - however, I have issues with medical professionals who refuse vaccines. They deal with a population that has a higher chance of having a compromised immune system (you know, sick people). They wouldn’t think of not scrubbing up before a procedure…
Bekka commented on Oct 21 09 at 9:07 amI had a nasty reaction to the last flu shot I got, and since reactions tend to escalate, it’s not recommended for me. Of course, as of yesterday, I’m 99% sure that I actually HAVE the flu right now anyway - FUN! Go get the damn shot people, this SUCKS.
zoohome commented on Oct 21 09 at 9:16 ambettywu - what’s wrong with eating meat while pregnant???
anyway! I am 30 weeks pregnant, I have never taken the regular flu shots, I rarely get cold or flu symptoms; however I am not risking this time. I am due in the middle of the winter. Although I live in FL, which is pretty warm, December is high season - synonym for collection of virus and other health issues. I am nervous that my county has no scheduled date for the H1N1 shot availability whatsoever!
Gib commented on Oct 21 09 at 10:46 amMy wife’s up the duff, and I’ve got her lined up to get both vaccines. Unfortunately the swine flu isn’t available yet, but I want to get it for her (me too if possible) before we hop on a flight half way across the world….
Lisa commented on Oct 21 09 at 2:00 pmWhen I read this article this morning, my first thought was this woman was 27 and a swimmer? She looks really really old, like 20 years older. I wonder if that was the cigarettes or the H1N1.
Christine commented on Oct 21 09 at 3:20 pmI was lucky enough to get the shot this week from my OB. They had two hundred available and I just happened to call at the exact right moment. No exactly sure why people are so afraid of the vaccine. More afraid then they are of all the terrible stories of people getting the flu and they ending up on respirators or dead. Now I just wish I could find the shot for my two year old. I do feel guilty that I have gotten the vaccine, but the rest of my family is still at risk, all because I happen to be knocked up.
Tiffanie commented on Oct 21 09 at 3:53 pmMy son is just now getting over H1N1 and it was a NASTY bug. I would have had us all vaccinated if it would have been available. I’m just waiting now for the rest of us to come down with it.. including our 7 month old!
cocobean commented on Oct 21 09 at 4:27 pmI have H1N1 right now. Even if I wanted my son to get the vacine it’s not available. It’s already to late anyways. He’s been exsposed to it. Now I just have to hope for the best
ChiLaura commented on Oct 21 09 at 4:52 pmRobyn, the article also points out that of 100 women known hospitalized of H1N1 in the US, 25 have died. That’s a pretty high fatality rate. It’s possible that they were all smokers, but the fact that Opdyke was pregnant in the first place is disadvantageous for her health in the first place.
I want the shot NOW, but our hospital doesn’t have it. I live in Chicago and I fail to understand how a major metro area like Chicago doesn’t have this available to pregnant women. I’m borderline angry about this. One of my sons also has respiratory issues, and I will die of worry and fear if he gets sick.
Skeptic commented on Oct 21 09 at 7:55 pm25 deaths out of 100 hospitalizations is not a high fatality rate unless those 100 women are the only ones to have contracted H1N1 (and of course, they are not). I will not be getting vaccinated, nor will my children. Flu vaccinations typically fail to protect us against the influenza strain that ends up hitting the country in part because the virus is unstable. This is the case with H1N1 as well. We have no assurance that it will end up affording any protection at all and there is a risk in getting the vaccination itself, especially because it is being rushed through instead of tested with the normal care much like the Swine Flu vaccine of the 70s that resulted in far more deaths that that flu did. The fact is the flu kills hundreds of thousands of people per year. This year, the media has everyone in a panic and is encouraging people to think the vaccine is a magic bullet. It’s not and it could end up doing more harm than good, if history is any indicator.
Alicia commented on Oct 22 09 at 3:54 pmI agree with Robyn that the fact she smoked plays a big part in what happened. It’s being said time and again that those at the highest risk of complications of H1N1 are those with lung issues. Smoking = lung issues. I feel bad for her that her baby died, but she compromised herself and her child by smoking during pregnancy. Plenty of women stop smoking cold turkey when they find out they’re pregnant to help their child grow. Why didn’t she?
I have had several friends get H1N1, and have been fine. One is 38 weeks pregnant right now, and so far is fine. Of course, she doesn’t smoke or have a pre-existing lung condition. A friend’s little boy has asthma, but when he had H1N1 a couple of weeks ago he was okay with lots of rest and Tamiflu, and neither his mother or sister got it because they took precautions. My husband had H1N1 last month, and neither I or our son got it because my husband avoided physical contact and my son and I washed our hands constantly.
Yes, my son and I could still get H1N1 from another source, but we still won’t get the shot. Why? Because we’re healthy with no pre-existing lung conditions. The second any symptoms pop up in my son, off to the doctor we’ll go. We’ll practice strict hygiene rules of washing our hands often and not touching our faces. Additionally, there are those that truly need the shot more than we do, so two more will be available for those in the highest risk categories.
My husband and I have been doing our own research into the vaccine and the H1N1 flu since it popped up earlier this year. We read the good and the bad about H1N1 and the shot. We very pro-vaccine for the established vaccinations, but don’t feel that enough work has been done with the H1N1 vaccine yet.
I do feel for this woman and her husband and the hell she went through. However, I can’t have complete sympathy if her smoking habit put her at greater risk because she wouldn’t quit.
Ryan commented on Oct 29 09 at 10:03 pmactually as for the smoking during pregnancy, i have been told by MDs that they will tell preg women not to quit cold turkey when they get preg because the withdrawel can be more harmfull then the smoking. Obviously you want to cut back as much as you can but quitting cold turkey will stress out the fetus. My girlfreind is 36 weeks preg and is on the fence about the shot for fear it will hurt the baby. but like i told her if she does’nt get the shot and gets H1N1 then they both could die. its all about risk vs reward. I would def rather if she did’nt have to get the shot but it beats the hell out watching my baby and Girlfreind die from the Flu.
TheBigB commented on Nov 19 09 at 11:28 pmI generally don’t engage in these discussions. Those who do vaccinate get painted as clueless or careless of the dangers and the ani-vaxxers as smug and condescending. If you do the research and weigh all the possible outcomes, you have the right to make those decisions for yourself and your children. I would not support any effort by the government to make vaccinations mandatory. But I vaccinate my kids, although not usually for the flu until this year. We just got the H1N1 flumist last week and I am quite relieved. Not ALL the people that have died from this or any version of influenza had contributing factors. But anyone who has suffered loss of a child, whether they smoked or not, whether they vaccinated or not, deserves our compassion and mercy.
Dana commented on Nov 23 09 at 10:55 pmI’m not pregnant, but I debated about getting the vaccine because my daughter just turned five on the 2nd and her dad lives with us and is asthmatic. It was more about him than us, really. Then my little girl got a nasty cold with a 100-degree temp the first day or two, and croup on the third or fourth day after never having gotten croup in her life. A few days after she got sick, I got sick, again like a nasty cold, but the symptoms felt different. I don’t have health insurance, and when she scared me gasping for breath and coughing and whooping at 3am, we took her to the ER and they said “oh it’s croup” and did. not. test. her. They aren’t testing anyone! They just assume you have or have not had it.
So I have a dilemma. I could go get the shot. She could go get the shot. But if we’ve already had it, we don’t need the shot. And that’s two less pregnant women, two less small children, or a combination thereof who could get the shot. It was late getting to my area and they are constantly running out of doses. This is nothing to play around with.
So what do you do? It’s so important everyone’s spreading stories about the special cases who die from it (I sympathize, but lots more people die from car accidents every year, including pregnant women and unborn kids, yet we all still drive), yet they won’t test us to see if we’ve had it “to avoid causing a panic,” so we don’t know if we’ve had it if we have had cold symptoms… and then we’re called stupid or bad if we say, “You know, maybe I shouldn’t get the shot.”
…What???
I don’t know what to think. The risk from this flu isn’t any worse than the seasonal, it just affects a different age range. (I don’t usually get *seasonal* flu shots.) But the government needs to start acting more like it is a real problem, if it is. Right now it’s looking more and more like a stimulus payment to Big Pharma. As if they need it.
Sue commented on Jan 26 10 at 2:26 pmI understand that any flu or any illness has a chance of complications…but I refuse flu shots. I have only gotten one flu shot in my life and I’m fine. I do follow the regular vaccine schedules, though some I think are petty (like the chicken pox one, when I was a kid, we had chicken pox parties…one kid got it, they gave it to all the other kids on the block so they would get it young…perfect sense). My biggest concern is I have an autoimmune condition and I know my kids have a higher risk of getting autoimmune condition because it runs in the family, I also know that these conditions are set off by stupid small events. I worry that “what if this vaccine is what sets it off”…I know it sounds stupid, but I’m more scared of the vaccine. Especially considering that years ago this same outbreak of swine flu occurred and MORE people died from the vaccine than the virus. What if it is messed up again? Anyways, I base my decision on a year to year basis…maybe next year I’ll feel different but as of yet we have been exposed to swine flu repeatedly and so far so good! So, anyways, we said no to swine flu vaccines and my husband totally stood behind me. I actually thought it was nuts to give a prego person the vaccine after the incidents 30 years ago…but I’m no doctor, they know what they are doing… I’m not against vaccines and I don’t judge other people for their decisions, I just have reservations from time to time. As a child I never got flu shots and my immune system is obviously working…too well…but it is working! You know, autoimmune disorders are more prevalent these days and it is assumed that we fight too many small things by vaccines and antibiotics and our immune systems have not enough to fight so they turn and fight us thinking something is wrong…well…makes sense to me








