Naked In Front of the Someone Else’s Kid?
Hilary Swank has gotten a lot of flack since she told Marie Claire how much she loves her birthday suit. Especially wearing it in front of her boyfriend’s six-year-old son.
The actress says the kid doesn’t think about it, but it set off my ick radar.
Not because she’s naked in front of a kid per se, or even that she’s the opposite gender of the child in question, but the fact that it’s someone else’s kid.
Our daughter is four, and nudity is still a non-issue in our house. She runs around naked, and she pops into the bathroom while one parent or the other (yes, my husband included) is in the shower. When she’s sick, I even pop into the bath WITH her (and no, I’m not wearing a bathing suit - although I know a mom who does).
But I do draw the line on being naked in front of someone else’s kid - even one as young as her. During playdates, we have a closed-door policy on the bathroom. If my daughter came home with the story of seeing someone else’s daddy in the buff, I’d want a pretty good explanation.
With your own kids, its part of life to be naked. Living all under one roof - it’s going to happen at one point or another. It’s why we want our kid to be comfy with her body - and comfy being in the buff in the privacy of her own home.
Hit a certain age, and it’s no longer acceptable to be naked outside the confines of one’s own house - and in front of other (read non-related) people. Which means there’s no cause for it - no real reason to be naked in front of someone else’s child.
It bears mentioning that Swank is dropping trow in her own home, and the kid in question is actually living there and in a closer approximation of a child-parent relationship than a simple playdate. But I’m still going to say no on this one.
What do you think? Is it kosher or creepy?
More By This Author:
-
Whoa, the Pedophile’s a Lady
-
Trend Alert: Kids Getting Brazilian Waxes?
-
The Boyfriend Jean is for Toddlers?
- Dad Harassed for Daughters in Men’s Room
- Boy Lives Because Mom Let Him Sleep
- Naked Children … at School?
- Miley Cyrus’ Elle Shoot: Over the Top Or Get Over It?
- Bad Parent Alert: Mom Strips to Avoid Arrest
Tags: development, Hilary Swank, Jeanne Sager, naked, nudity, Playdate
13 Comments
PlumbLucky commented on Oct 13 09 at 12:38 pmI’m on the fence…how long has this “nearly parent child relationship” been around…if its more that he’s so used to her that he doesn’t care, that’s one thing. If its still whoa - Dad’s girlfriend, that’s entirely another.
Lizzie commented on Oct 13 09 at 1:10 pmI try to avoid other people’s kids seeing me naked, but the occasional bad encounter happens. (Old house, no locks on bedroom doors, lots of people over for swimming.) It’s just a “hey! privacy! outta here!” moment. I’m fine if another mom is changing clothes or such with my daughter. (I don’t think we have any friends who just hang out in their birthday suits.) But I’d do serious follow up on a naked dad sighting.
TolaniLucia commented on Oct 13 09 at 1:58 pmCreepy. And creepy that she needed to tell a magazine about it.
Ada commented on Oct 13 09 at 2:16 pmMy boyfriend is a single dad of a 2.9 year old daughter, and she has definitely come into the bedroom in the wee small hours of the morning, waking us both up with a happy “hi, daddy! hi ada!” while i have been (admittedly under the blanket) sans clothing. While my relationship toward her has grown increasingly parental, and she is quite young, and I certainly don’t want to inflict upon her any body-shame issues, the idea of a child not my own seeing me naked horrifies me and is something I try to avoid at all costs (I keep a nightgown in the bed at all times, even if I’m not wearing it, to evade an early-morning naked encounter) but occasionally and briefly it happens. The child is also in the midst of a licking epidemic, but that is another story. I think it’s borderline inappropriate at best to be naked ’round other people’s children, but this varies depending on context, relationship between non-parent and child, culture, etc. And as with anything, my anxiety about being nude around my boyfriend’s daughter probably reflects more about my own neurosis than anything else.
Mistress_Scorpio commented on Oct 13 09 at 2:26 pmI’m not so freaked out by it (so over our puritanical society) and it would be weird that she told a mag, but hey, guess what! We’re all talking about Hilary Swank now! Could somebody have a movie coming out?
Bec commented on Oct 13 09 at 3:06 pmOh fun, I love the anti-step-parent bias I read so much of on parenting sites these days!
I read that article, btw, and she was asked what she wears to sleep. She sleeps nude, even though she’s learned that the boy comes romping in every morning. She says he doesn’t seem to notice it.
Ali commented on Oct 13 09 at 4:35 pmSo if she were a man not married to the boys mother would that be okay Scorpio? I guess you think the article about the buy wanting to have sex with his own 14 year old daughter was non-prudish too.
Mistress_Scorpio commented on Oct 13 09 at 8:46 pmAli, I don’t get the point you’re trying so desperately to make. I don’t think children are negatively impacted by simple nudity when they are little kids. I don’t know the other article you are referring to. However, if you think a child seeing a nude body is even in the same realm as incest then I politely suggest you seek the appropriate professionals for your issues.
jeannesager commented on Oct 13 09 at 9:49 pmBec - pardon, who said anything about step-parents? Hilary is not this kid’s stepmother. She is his dad’s girlfriend. Which doesn’t mean she’ll be around for the long haul - and makes the rules very different.
Mistress_Scorpio commented on Oct 13 09 at 11:53 pmBut Jeanne, the bf and his daughter are living in HER home. And as the parent, he’s okay with it, so why are we squicked by her?
jeannesager commented on Oct 14 09 at 9:29 amHonestly, Mistress - because it’s not a daughter. It’s a son. And while I’m largely with you on teaching acceptance of nudity (hence how we do things in our house), I’m squicked by the fact that she’s NOT necessarily going to be a stabilizing influence in this little boy’s life - but she’s certainly influencing him on his first thoughts of a woman naked. If he was younger, I wouldn’t be so bothered, but 6 is an age when nudity is beginning to actually be noticed by kids.
Bec commented on Oct 14 09 at 10:04 amThey live together. That really implies that it’s not a fly-by-night relationship to me; co-habitating is as stable as marriage, honestly. It’s not even just weekends at Daddy’s girlfriend’s house from what I could tell. It’s pretty full-time. If this was brand new, then I’d maybe agree with you that it’s totally inappropriate, but that’s really not the case here. Then again, my mom was a total nudie, so maybe I wouldn’t - I don’t find nudity inherently upsetting.
Mistress_Scorpio commented on Oct 14 09 at 3:23 pmJeanne, she’s gotta be a fairly stabilizing presence if the man and his son are *living in her house.* If she’s prancing about the house in the nude, that’s one thing, and I can deem it questionable. If the child comes into her bedroom at night and she sleeps nude, that’s another. It’s up to her and the child’s father to set the boundaries. Either way, she should have kept this info to herself.







