Teen Boy Told To Dress Like a Man or Go Home

Posted by bethanysanders on October 8th, 2009 at 12:00 pm

cobb dress 268287c Teen Boy Told To Dress Like a Man or Go HomeJonathan Escobar is the kind of kids who stands out from the crowd, especially when he wears his pink wig.  Escobar prefers to wear wigs, makeup, and feminine-style clothing, a style choice that’s gotten him in trouble at school.

For his first day of school at North Cobb High School in Georgia, Escobar chose a pink wig, skinny jeans, and flats.  Everything went smoothly until lunchtime when a fight broke out.  Someone said something mean about Escobar and another student came to his defense.

That’s when the assistant principal told Escobar that he needed to either dress more “manly” or be schooled at home.  “You can’t wear clothing that causes a disruption,” Cobb Country school spokesman told the Atlanta-Journal Constitution.

Escobar left his formal high school not because the school had a problem with his fashion choices, but because his parents did.  He now lives with his older sister and was careful to ask school administrators before he started if he could wear heels and wigs to school.  They said yes.

“I don’t consider myself a cross-dresser,” says Escobar. “This is just who I am….They should’ve told the students to back off.  They should have never given me the option of homeschooling or changing who I am.”

Escobar left North Cobb after just three days, but since then over 900 students have rallied to his defense, even creating a Facebook group called Support Jonathan.  And despite the school’s warning, Escobar won’t be taking off his wig anytime soon.

“If I can’t express myself, I won’t go to school,” he said. “I want to get the message out there that because this is who I am, I can’t get an education.”

Seems like this situation would have been better handled by administrators with a heavy dose of eye-rolling and a little patience.  Sure, teens get distracted by the kid who stands-out, but given time the excitement usually wears off.

What do you think: Should Escobar be able to wear what he wants, or do you defend the administration’s right to tell him to dress like a man?

More:

World’s Worst Baby Names

Gabby Baby Has Something to Say (VIDEO)

Baby Name Remorse - Would You Change Your Baby’s Name?

Salvation Army Shopper Spank’s Strangers Toddler

Photo:  ajc.com, AP

pixelstats trackingpixel

Related Posts:
Ԫ

36 Comments

[...] FROM BABBLE (CLICK HERE FOR ORIGINAL SOURCE) [...]

The Culture Boy | a blog by Corey Michaels commented on Oct 09 09 at 12:15 am

[...] Teen Boy Told To Dress Like a Man or Go Home (is it just me, or does he/she look a lot like a young Molly Ringwald?) [...]

Best of Strollerderby October 9, 2009 | Strollerderby commented on Oct 11 09 at 12:00 pm

[...] Teen Boy Told To Dress Like a Man or Go Home (is it just me, or does he/she look a lot like a young Molly Ringwald?) [...]

Best of Strollerderby October 9, 2009 | Famecrawler commented on Oct 11 09 at 12:00 pm

[...] Jonathan Escobar, the teen boy who was asked to dress more manly or be homeschooled?  A few commenters wondered what would happen if roles were reversed:  If Jonathan was a girl [...]

Gay Teen Girl Can’t Wear Tux in School Yearbook Photo | Strollerderby commented on Oct 15 09 at 9:58 pm

Lets throw it in reverse and play devil’s advocate: would it be okay for the school administration to demand that all jeans-wearing girls dress like women and wear demure skirts and pantyhose….no? Okay. Question answered. No, it isn’t OK for the school to say this. About the only thing I can think they might do is say “okay, no unnaturally colored hair or wigs for non-medical reasons on either gender”.

PlumbLucky commented on Oct 08 09 at 12:03 pm

Unless they make the rule for boys AND girls, there is no way this is unacceptable.

This poor kid. He left his parents to be himself; you know that wasn’t easy. He asked ahead at the school before classes started… how many teens are this self-aware and confident? He rocks.

Bec commented on Oct 08 09 at 12:21 pm

i bet this kid is having a great time attention whoring for his mommy while he’s being home schooled.

totally commented on Oct 08 09 at 2:28 pm

Expressing yourself is not a right. What if he liked to express himself by not wearing anything at all? Or wearing t-shirts with anti-gay slogans? His outfits are meant to provoke and shock. If he really wanted to dress like a girl he would wear dresses and things the other girls are allowed to wear to school. Many of the public schools here have dress codes or require uniforms. Rules are there for a reason. His outfits are distracting. Girls dont wear pink wigs and big hats to school. This jerk thinks he will get famous or rich from this.

Ali commented on Oct 08 09 at 2:42 pm

This is another Chris Rock wannabe.

Fred commented on Oct 08 09 at 2:56 pm

I think he should be allowed to wear tight jeans, or dresses. But I don’t think he should be able to wear the hats and pink wigs. In my public school, we were not allowed to wear hats. I think that is reasonable. Is a wig a hat? I certainly wouldn’t have been able to wear a clown wig all day at school, is a pink wig too much different? I only think you should be allowed to wear a wig if you need to medically. He should just grow his hair long if that’s “who he is.” But as for dresses and high heels, whatever. As long as it’s reasonable and in-line with what other girls are allowed to wear, that’s fine. It’s just clothing. To comment on “All’s” post anti-gay t shirts spread hate and that’s different than a dress.

andrew commented on Oct 08 09 at 3:01 pm

If other kids are allowed to wear wigs and hats and whatnot, then there’s no reason why he shouldn’t be allowed to (and there’s nothing in this article that says that the school dress code doesn’t permit these items for girls). Furthermore, the school officials didn’t say “You can’t wear wigs, students can’t wear wigs” - they said he should “dress like a man.” That’s plain ol’ discrimination. Girls can “cross-dress” every day, so there’s no reason why Jonathan shouldn’t. Go Jonathan!

Bunny commented on Oct 08 09 at 3:13 pm

Talk about having a pair of balls, that Jonathon sure has them. Those school administration idiots never learned a thing from “Columbine”. Oppression in society is everywhere. With brave guys like Jonathon walking the earth, maybe one day we can all be free to be and show our true selves.

Randy commented on Oct 08 09 at 4:43 pm

If I’m reading this right, the school told him before he started he could wear them, so he did. Now it’s a problem? I can understand skipping the hats and wigs, but wearing jeans and shoes, no matter the style, shouldn’t be banned.

coolteamblt commented on Oct 08 09 at 6:21 pm

Please do some basic proof-reading of your work before you publish it. First, you spell the kid’s name as “Johnathon” at the beginning of the article, then “Johnathan” later in the article. Secondly, the sentence “if he could wear heals and wigs to school”, “heals” is the verb “to heal (medically)”. The word you are looking for is “heels,” as in the type of shoes. Sheesh! Your grammar teachers in school must be doing a face-palm right now. Moron.

Grammar Nazi commented on Oct 08 09 at 6:44 pm

Jonathon may simply be transgendered like thousands of others in this country. He should be allowed to wear whatever he likes, unless it’s something that ALL students are banned from wearing. And the school should not make special rules now that they have Jonathon — they should use the existing dress code as a guide. There are transgender men, women, teenagers, and children in this world, and the rest of us need to realize that.

DebbieSLP commented on Oct 08 09 at 7:37 pm

Heels, not heals. Dumbass.

required commented on Oct 08 09 at 8:02 pm

Unless there is a dress code, he should wear what he wants. The thing is, they are TEENAGERS: some will always try it over-the-top and some will not like it. If for some reason teachers want to prevent that from happening, just install a damn dress code and everyone wears the same, end of story.

daisy commented on Oct 08 09 at 8:03 pm

Please do some basic proof-reading of your work before you publish it. First, you spell the kid’s name as “Johnathon” at the beginning of the article, then “Johnathan” later in the article. Secondly, the sentence “if he could wear heals and wigs to school”, “heals” is the verb “to heal (medically)”. The word you are looking for is “heels,” as in the type of shoes. Sheesh! Your grammar teachers in school must be doing a face-palm right now. Moron.

Joe Nathan commented on Oct 08 09 at 8:40 pm

Ali you’re a moron, expressing yourself IS infact a right. Screw that. I don’t think this kid had intentions of becoming famous, or he’d probably cause a bigger stir. The fact that this is happening in the county I live in doesn’t surprise me that much, but the fact it’s happening at all does. I mean the people that live her are all morons, and can’t accept anything that is “different” than the white picket fence lifestyle. What the school did was wrong. He wasn’t violating dresscode rules, so what’s the big deal?

Heather commented on Oct 09 09 at 12:10 am

Kids…

Anthony commented on Oct 09 09 at 12:22 am

Comments
All I can say is only in Georgia! I don’t knock a person for who they are or wish to be. All I say is, God is the only one they have to answer to, that is a fact. Homosexuality is a sin but if he wants to be a sinner that’s his choice, he has to live with the consequences of those acts. A child at that age I feel is just confused, but if he’s gay he’s gay for whatever the reason. If he wants to wear a dress let him wear it, if he wants to wear a wig (not pink, blue, purple, etc. or any unnatural color in school) let him wear it. But I will say, the school is not denying him his education, he is denying his own education. They went too far by saying he should dress like a man, but school is a place for learning not a fashion show, drag queen show, or club you should dress appropriately. That goes for the saggy jeans, yuch! It’s obviously more important to him to dress like a girl, which he is not, than to get an education. Standing up for his rights by not going to school is hurting noone but himself. Stand up for yourself another way. What was worn was a bit too much for school, it’s school not a drag show. There is a time and place for everything and people should be respectful of that. When the school said yes I am sure they were not aware he would be wearing pink wigs, but the question remains if a “real” girl had on a pink wig would there have been something said? Don’t know. Any way gays, homosexuals, and transgenders get away with alot of crap down here, but society caters to that. Gay parades, honestly that is nothing to celebrate but they can knock themselves out. I feel sorry for the people who are that way due to them being molested or grow up feeling confused abut their sexuality but when you choose it I have a problem. People now don’t care about the laws of God and just do all kinds of sinful acts then want special treatment. I give none. Don’t get me wrong I have friends that are gay but it’s their soul that will burn for it.

mature commented on Oct 09 09 at 12:42 am

Comments
My daughter likes to wear different color wigs and hats but she knows I would snatch her bald if she ran out of here going to school looking like a train wreck! Hanging out with friends and wearing that stuff is one thing, but it does not belong in school by ANYBODY! If he want to dress like a girl let it be proper female/school attire.

mature commented on Oct 09 09 at 12:46 am

Comments
He can quit school, but at the end of the day he will just be a teenage boy who dropped out of school because he couldn’t dress like a girl. No education, and we know how important an education is, more important than choosing not to get one cause you can’t dress how you want. School is an institution and there are rules. Yeah you have freedom of choice, but just as your boss tell you to wear business attire and optional jeans on the week end. Guess what, you abide by that or not get a paycheck and loose your home and car. You can’t walk in an establishment and say I don’t care if you say no shoes no shirt no service but i’m gonna walk in barefoot and shirtless nd you better serve me. No, no shoes, no shirt, no service. Period.

mature commented on Oct 09 09 at 12:51 am

Just drop school and come broadcast on BlogTV.com and YouTube: The places were education serves no purpose as long as you have the looks. ANd you can make a lot of money.

MeowTV2 commented on Oct 09 09 at 6:13 am

Settle down, ‘mature’.
He may or may not be gay; it’s actually irrelevant. Kids who don’t go to school are sometimes dropouts, but sometimes they are home-schooled or educated through a long-distance program. And to your final point: The school told him he would be permitted. he did the responsible thing and asked in advance, and now the school is not only going back on their own word, but doing so in a gender-normative and wholly offensive way. Define MANLY for me.

The school went so far as to have a police office pull him out of class to talk to him about his safety. Interestingly, the police didn’t talk to the kids they considered a threat to that safety.

Bec commented on Oct 09 09 at 2:18 pm

Let’s see the fanny-packed cultural elites who are telling this kid he doesn’t look great.

turingcub commented on Oct 09 09 at 3:24 pm

Okay - I am sick of all the lies this kid is spreading about our wonderful school. I am a member of the executive PTSA board at North Cobb High School and am very familiar with the “Jonathon” situation. Our leftist liberal media needs to “get it right” and quit spreading untruths! Jonathon was given every opportunity that any child at North Cobb is given. Administrastion was very accepting of him and cared absolutely nothing about the way he chose to dress - that is until he showed up at school in a pink Hello Kitty wig and a big white bow. There is nothing natural about that - when I think of a pink wig, honestly, I invision a clown in a circus - not someone who is right, left, black, white, pink, gay, straight, transexual or anything like that. All I see is someone who is desperate for attention!No child in a public school would be allowed to go through the day in a pink wig because, duh, it is a total distraction to the educatory process! Teenagers are not to the point where they can filter out such absurdities as pink hair and focus on the more important classroom education that their teachers are working toward. Therefore, any reasonable person ought to be able to see that this was not a “cross-dressing” issue - instead, it is a school dress code issue. NO child could have gotten away with this! Also, our principal, assistant principal and all of our administrators are extremely caring people. They NEVER told Jonathon to “dress more manly” or to resort to home-schooling. They merely objected to his pink wig! These comments that are being published all over the news are all “Jonathon fabrications.” He is weaving a web of lies through our sensationalist media. And they are stupid enough to let him get by with it!

Laura O'Rourke commented on Oct 09 09 at 10:45 pm

Expressing ones self is a right . It sounds like here we have a case of a bratty kid, trans or not. School should be used as a platform for students to learn how to do so. If Jonathan is disrupting people perhaps he is in the wrong school environment. I went to a school where I could and did sport a number of what people are complaining about. I had my green hair, piercing, tattoos and crazy shoes etc. you name it I was wearing it. It did not effect my or my fellow students ability to learn. And in many ways helped me to define and form a strong sense of self. But if my education were pitted against my fashion choices I would side with my education knowing that having that meal ticket of a diploma would do so much more for me in the future.Growing up is very much about having to sometimes do things you do not want to do. And sometimes having to temporarily conform to make a living or obtain an education.This then allows for you to do more later with more conviction.
“If I can’t express myself, I won’t go to school,” he said. “I want to get the message out there that because this is who I am, I can’t get an education.”
What is that? If he wants to be schooled in the classroom then it seems like he will have to tone it down. No pink wig. Oh well. I think he looks wonderful but this is a life lesson. What is he going to do when his place of work says no to the fanciful outfits? Go home to mom? Complain? If you want to dress it up young man be prepared to face harsher judgment than anything school has to offer. From one eccentric to another get a spine and an education. Start with what’s in the head not on it. Then you can paint the world with your message of beautiful self adornment.

TolaniLucia commented on Oct 10 09 at 12:21 pm

Meh. Expressing oneself inside a classroom has limits. A student’s right to self-expression ends when it infringes on other students’ rights to learn. This kid seems like a bit of attention whore, imo, who likes to push boundaries. From looking at the clip posted on feministing it seems like everything he was wearing between his neck and his ankles would’ve been fine with the school. The shoes, though, are a safety hazard, plain and simple, and probably noisy as heck when he walks. Hats (excluding headscarves and skullcaps worn for religious reasons) are usually prohibited inside school buildings, for the primary reason that they are distracting and/or considered disrespectful. Honestly, if he tried to wear that hat in the classroom, he’d have to be in the back row, because no one behind him could see the chalkboard! Yes, he should dress in accordance with his gender identity. No, he should not be allowed to wear hats and wigs for nonmedical or nonreligious reasons, because that is a generally well-agreed on rule, and no one, male or female, should wear those shoes to school.

jenny tries too hard commented on Oct 10 09 at 1:32 pm

“Educatory” - haha! that says it all, I guess. That and, “liberal media.”

Where are these people coming from, and why are they posting here?

Bunny commented on Oct 12 09 at 1:39 pm

I always wonder why people care so much what kids wear to school. If we didn’t care so much, maybe there would be more diversity in appearance, and the teenagers wouldn’t have as much to freak out over? I don’t care what the kids wear, I care if they’re safe and learning.

leahsmom commented on Oct 14 09 at 2:17 pm

Comments I love what he or she wants to be . AM 100% behind his clothing please give him a chance. He not hurting you . love gina

gina commented on Oct 22 09 at 3:51 pm

Funny, if Ms. O’Rourke hadn’t started off her comment with a tirade against the great left wing media conspiracy, the rest of what she said would have had a lot more impact. A bit of advice, if you’ve got a complaint about someone else– in this case the media– try not to make yourself seem like a wingnut in the first couple of sentences.

Anyway, after that bit of advice, if what she says is true, then in my opinion, the school did nothing wrong. The problem is that the whole leftist media comment makes me thing she is one of those hard right folks who proclaim freedom and liberty and then spend their time encouraging the government to poke its nose into all sorts of personal details… what books you can read, what religion you can have, and yes, whether you have to dress “like a man.” Credibility is so important!

Snoop commented on Oct 23 09 at 11:35 am

Our collective addiction to conformity is the factor that will eventually be our downfall.

bloggulator commented on Nov 01 09 at 6:29 pm

What sort of upper class area is this? 900 students in his defense? I grew up in 5 different cities in three different states and never found a single school where I could even be goth without taking nothing but shit from the schools (This was even during the “Marlyin Manson is partially responsible for teen depression and school shootings” era) and other students. What universe is cobb county in?

Dylan commented on Nov 11 09 at 1:30 am

Add a Comment



Quick Search



About This Blog
Updated more than twelve times daily by the wittiest parents in the blogosphere, Strollerderby provides a scroll of breaking news, spot-on reviews of entertainment and products, and irreverent discussions of hot topics.

Send tips to strollerderby@babble.com

Click here to read about our bloggers.


Babble BlogS