Strollerderby

The Floundering Promise of Organic Milk

Posted by shannon lc cate on June 8th, 2009 at 12:30 pm

milk flavors 300x300 The Floundering Promise of Organic MilkThey say that if your budget can’t handle All Organic All the Time, the one most important thing to buy organic for your kids is milk.  And yet, at $6 per gallon, it’s a tough one, even if the rest of the cart is full of bargains.  I know I’m grateful for the not-organic-but-not-quite-conventional option of No Hormones/No Antibiotics milk myself, and that–at roughly half the price of organic–is what my family drinks.

And yet, I can’t help but feel for the family dairies that are suddenly seeing red after making the difficult and expensive switch to organic milk production.

For example, the New York Times tells the story of several family farmers who, promised stable, high milk prices forever, made the laborious and costly switch to organic.  When the economy was still booming, it looked like the demand for organic dairy products would never stop rising.  And now, faced with that high price tag, families tightening their budget belts are making food shopping compromises that cut out organic milk.

The farms that made the shift to organic are not only seeing their profits drop, some are even losing contracts with organic cooperatives that are glutted with product and need to cut back themselves.

One farmer has dipped into retirement savings to cover his expenses as organic feed for dairy cows has shot up by 100%.  Others are looking to sell their milk on the conventional market and/or directly to consumers at local stores or farmers’ markets.

Here’s hoping that a restructuring of distribution methods will save these farmers.  It’s a terrible shame that a shift to production methods that are better for everybody–the farmers and their families, the cows, the consumers, the planet–are ironically putting farmers out of business.  Maybe I’ll pick up a gallon of organic next week when I replenish our ‘fridge.  One gallon out of three might not be such a bad bite out of my budget, if it helps save an industry I so appreciate.

See Also:  Good Food Shouldn’t be a Mommy War

image: germes-online.com

 The Floundering Promise of Organic Milk

Go Back To Strollerderby

8 Comments

[...] Also: The Floundering Promise of Organic Milk SHARETHIS.addEntry({ title: “Good Food Shouldn’t Be a Mommy War–It Should be a Focus of [...]

Good Food Shouldn’t Be a Mommy War–It Should be a Focus of Mommy Activism | Strollerderby commented on Jun 22 09 at 1:31 pm

An ex of mine purchased regular once after years of my cats and me drinking organic. To say the least I knew something was wrong when both of them refused it, and one of them would drink out of the toilet!

On the family dairy farm (my husband’s) in Aland, Finland, because of EU rules, they get great subsidies for letting the cows wander around as they please and avoiding hormonees and antibiotics. They are some pretty happy cows (at least during the summer when I see them).

Shana commented on Jun 08 09 at 5:38 pm

Organic milk is one thing I do splurge on but lucky for me I guess we only pay $4 a gallon. Try Walmart!

Heather commented on Jun 09 09 at 3:24 pm

Seems like your article says that prices are unnaturally inflated. If there is a glut of the product combined with a genuine demand prices should drop and problems solved. But because the word organic is stamped on it it has to be twice the cost of hormone laced milk. Seems like unnatural market forces at work.

Jyn commented on Jun 09 09 at 3:42 pm

I’m not sure if I can put into words how much this angers me. We as American citizens only pay 10% of our disposable income on food. 10%, even if organic milk is twice it would only be 20% of our income, a huge reduction compared to 50% in the 1950′s or the price of food in other countries. What isn’t on the price tag at the supermarket is the price we pay as taxpayers to subsidize the growth of corn to feed the cows to make non-organic milk. Or the price we will pay in the future because of the hormones not only getting into our milk but our lakes, rivers, streams and ground water that are causing deformities in frogs. Also this is bias against the organic industry, dairy produces across the country are suffering as the economy declines.

Brooke commented on Jun 09 09 at 10:26 pm

One thing to remember when insisting on buying all-organic food: In general, not only is organic more expensive, it’s often more consuming of some scarce resources. It often takes more land and/or more water and/or other resources (not to mention labor) per unit produced, and there is limited arable farmland, etc. So your organic milk may mean that others pay more for their non-organic food, due to competition for those resources.

It’s similar to some of the issues with “Buy Local”. Sometimes buying local means buying expensive, inefficiently-produced food, because the food in question is harder to raise near where you live, and again it may use more resources (hothouses, more land per unit food, etc).

Randell commented on Jun 09 09 at 11:16 pm

In response to Randell – I agree that buying organic is not a cure-all, especially because most organic food this country produces is “industrial-organic”, rife with many of the same environmental, human rights, and economic problems as the standard industrial food system. In response to your comment about the “buy local” movement, though, you seem to be missing the point. The local food movement does not promote simply buying the same products grown/produced locally, but rather encourages us to look at WHAT we eat and change our concept of what we “need” to have. I live in the northeast, which means that I can buy local berries in season for about a month each year. I take advantage of that season, but I also recognize that I will not be eating berries in November unless I freeze some of what I get now. I don’t expect my local farmer to build hothouses so I can have tomatoes in January, but I do buy plenty of storage apples in September so that I can have fruit during the winter. Local production does not have to use more resources if we adjust our expectations to include an understanding of our “local” growing season, etc.

Inflated prices of sustainably produced food are in part a reflection of our industrialized food system and the subsidies given by the government to gigantic monoculture farms that grow only corn and soybeans using pesticides and growing practices that deplete the soil. As a previous poster pointed out – WE, as taxpayers, are the ones who pay for those subsidies. Change is needed on a systemic level to make real, safe food available to all of us.

sophia commented on Jun 20 09 at 1:37 pm

I cannot wait to learn more of this superior topic. So much from it Ive never even looked into. You sure did put a new twist on something that Ive heard a huge amount of about. I dont believe Ive actually read most things does this subject as good justice as you just simply did.

flood damage pasadena commented on Jan 05 11 at 2:08 am

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Joslyn Gray
  • Amber Doty
  • Julianna Miner
  • Monica Bielanko
  • Sierra Black
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Carolyn Castiglia
  • Sunny Chanel
  • Madeline Holler
  • Wendy Michaels
  • Rebecca Odes
  • Danielle Smith
  • Danielle Sullivan
  • Katherine Stone
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

    More in Strollerderby (50 of 10535 articles)