Kid Scoop

12 Ways to Separate Birthdays and Holidays (And Keep Any Birthday Special, Period)

Posted by caseymullins on December 15th, 2011 at 11:02 am

7th Birthday 8879 300x200 12 Ways to Separate Birthdays and Holidays (And Keep Any Birthday Special, Period)Birthdays are a big huge deal to me and I believe that there should be a firm separation between Birth and Holiday. Obviously with Addie’s birthday being December 14th, our competing holiday is Christmas — but no matter what holiday your kid’s birthday falls close to, I believe every effort should be made to distinguish between the two. Maybe it’s because my dad’s birthday is in December or because mine is sometimes making out with Easter or Mother’s Day.

Since Addie was born, I’ve developed some practices that keep birthday memories exclusive and super special without spending too much. Cody thinks I’m silly, but I’ve been told by those who have December birthdays all my efforts will one day be appreciated.

 

7th birthday 8908 12 Ways to Separate Birthdays and Holidays (And Keep Any Birthday Special, Period)

We don't do big parties
It's 11 days before Christmas. The whole world seems to be in this uptight fury about money and gifts and all the wrong things. December birthday parties are not well-attended in my experience, so we save the party for her half-birthday when it is warm, sunny and school is out. (We do, however, let her pick a friend or two to go out to dinner with us and have cake and a special activity. Last year she chose a carriage ride.)

Looking for a unique cake for your child’s birthday? Try these fun alternatives!

 12 Ways to Separate Birthdays and Holidays (And Keep Any Birthday Special, Period)

Go Back To Kid Scoop

19 Comments

my boy’s bday is the 20th and my hubby’s is the 23rd. i’m a pro at seperating the two. we do a party, and our tree is up…..but there are no presents under it. we like to call it “birthday season” at our house. thanks for the fun ideas!

kt commented on Dec 15 11 at 11:38 am

I also have a December child and she gets so frustrated that people just lump her gifts together. They also do this for my January child as well. “Since we probably won’t see you for a while….”

We started a tradition where they get x amount of gifts on their birthday and x is how many years old they are. It’s mostly little things that I pick up here or there, but they enjoy it!

domestic extraordinaire commented on Dec 15 11 at 12:58 pm

My husband’s birthday is the 23rd and he is bitter about his childhood birthdays being horrible because of Christmas. I try very hard to keep his birthday separated from Christmas stuff. I also NEVER wrap his birthday presents with Christmas wrapping paper. That is just wrong!

Mariss commented on Dec 16 11 at 8:40 am

My oldest daughter’s birthday is Christmas Eve and I am a pro and seperating the two. We have a family party and all her presents are to wrapped in “birthday” wrapping paper. After almost 16 yrs (she will be 16 this yr) she has never been shafted on her birthday :)

jeannine m commented on Dec 16 11 at 8:59 am

Thanks for the tips! I’m due after Christmas and this is extremely helpful!

cici commented on Dec 16 11 at 9:09 am

My birthday is on the 20th and I hate having birthday & christmas presents combined into one when I was a kid, ditto with the christmas cards that had ‘PS happy birthday’ scribbled into it. My husband’s birthday is on the 31st, so we get to do the festive season + 2 birthdays all under 2 weeks. Lucky our daughter’s birthday’s in July!

Lou commented on Dec 16 11 at 9:56 am

Casey, my favorite part of this entire article is that Addie looks absolutely beside herself with glee in every single picture! We’ve got a little one who turns one next week, so we’ll be taking all the advice we can get!! Thanks. =)

Kelsey commented on Dec 16 11 at 10:31 am

Thanks for the tips! My dad’s birthday is December 26, and now my son’s is Dec. 30. The one thing my dad has always said is important is separate acknowledgement of the birthday, and we will try very hard to make R’s birthday a separate, celebratory event…and not just something that gets lumped into Christmas & New Year.

The flip side of this, however, is my birthday…October 29. I know Halloween isn’t a holiday in the sense that Christmas & New Years are, but I always loved having my birthday near Halloween. It was an excuse to have fun costume parties for my birthday, and even as an adult, when I see pumpkins and halloween decorations go up, it gets me excited for my birthday. In fact, I always sort of saw Halloween as the continuing celebration of my birthday…I had my big day, and then two days later got to do more fun stuff. So I am trying to capture this feeling for my son.

R's Mom commented on Dec 16 11 at 12:18 pm

Loved your practical advice that is helpful to parents. My dad’s birthday was on Christmas day and a German Chocolate Cake was his favorite. Thanks!

Jessica commented on Dec 16 11 at 1:02 pm

My birthday Xmas eve it was always hard on my parents once my Sis n Bro was born but some how my mom always found a way to make it special …Im spanish so every Xmas eve my family will have huge get togethers music ,food n kids running wild but nobody was aloud to open gifts just me n they always sang n had cake for me ….now i have two kids of my own and birthdays kinda non existant but a guy id me once n told me celebrate two wks before or after so u dont get ript off n honestly i highly suggest it lol cuz i always got the one gift for both from family members lol

saida commented on Dec 16 11 at 10:00 pm

My “baby ” brother (almost 52) has a Dec. 19th birthday. I have to be honest I don’t remember a lot of his birthdays. I do know we had them separate from Christmas.
His daughter was born on Christmas night. We promised her to always keep her birthday separate from Christmas. And we did.
Two years ago (nearly) she had a daughter on Dec. 23. They are keeping her birthday separate also.
Everyone has their own day.
For everyone that has a December birthday——-HAPPY BIRTHDAY.

Linda commented on Dec 16 11 at 10:12 pm

My daughter’s birthday is December 23rd. We also skip the big party in favor of a “half way there” party in the summer time. Also, we refuse to wrap Birthday gifts in Christmas Paper, same goes for Christmas cakes, they are a NO-NO… When it’s birthday, it’s birthday, when it’s Christmas it’s Christmas… We also celebrate early, and then just have cake on her actual birthday. She loves it. I also give her one gift for each year old she is. We did her small celebration today, and she informed me it was her best birthday ever! That’s a good sign, IMO.

Bella_Rose commented on Dec 17 11 at 2:42 am

As a twin born on December 13, I can relate. My mom was great about making our birthday special by allowing us to have a party with no Christmas involved and as many friends as we wanted, and even two separate cakes/candles. Christmas decorations and music were not even a thought until after our birthday. We did get the combined birthday/Christmas present…..to share (!) from the occasional friend or relative, but oh well. Wait until high school and college when exams are on your birthday and friends are too stressed out to even remember your birthday!

Emmie Lake commented on Dec 17 11 at 6:21 am

These are all good ideas. Two of my cousins have December birthdays, including a Christmas birthday. Now my daughter will turn 1 on the 27th. My son’s birthday is the end of July and that has its own issues, because schools no longer give out class lists with everyone’s contacts in them, so his friend parties have been taking he and a friend to LegoLand Discovery Center and Rainforest Cafe. This is a big treat since it’s a 90 minute drive from us. The one caveat I would give is on the combining presents. My 19 year-old cousin has ASKED my mom to combine her Christmas and birthday gifts so she can get a more expensive gift(Toms shoes) that she really wants. As Addie gets older, she may occasionally request that and people shouldn’t hesitate to do it if the birthday kid asks. The Christmas birthday in my family always has her birthday party the weekend before Christmas, so we are going to do my daughter’s party the weekend after New Year’s.

Megan commented on Dec 19 11 at 6:43 pm

Dude, you are the coolest birthday mom EVAH. I wish you could have been around to give my parents some pointers… (mine is the 9th). And totally true, no one ever shows up for December parties – although I remember 2… one where we made gingerbread houses, which was kind of a cool birthday activity 20 years ago when it wasn’t so popular, and one when we had a ridiculously fun sledding party.
And the whole 2 gifts in one thing? yeah, my relatives all did that and then my brother got 2 gifts since his birthday in August. Sucky.
Balloons rule though, my boys birthdays are in March and we have always done balloons!
Sadly I’m probably going to be the lame mom that has one family birthday party for the kids since these twins are probably coming in March too… 4 birthday parties in the same month? I don’t think so! I may have to resort to doing milestone parties for each kid in varying years…

Krista commented on Dec 22 11 at 11:42 pm

With a son born on the 16th and my husbands bday on the 27th, we’ve become a bit of pros. We don’t get our tree until the weekend after his birthday, which actually kills him as he LOVES Christmas. But it makes getting the tree even more special for him, as it’s part of his birthday celebration. We do his friend party in January, and the family gets together near his birthday. I don’t think he’ll ever feel slighted. I swear I’m going to do the half birthday thing one year, because I have some amazing ideas for a summer birthday and my kids are all fall and winter babies.

mamalang commented on Dec 26 11 at 12:13 am

My sister was born on the 24th. Something I always made sure to do was wrap her gift in birthday paper, not Christmas and she always appreciates it. Your tips are great, I am having my first baby any day now so I will be using them in the future!!

Patty commented on Dec 26 11 at 7:08 pm

great ideas to use for my feb 13th baby! thanks

adrienne commented on Feb 05 12 at 4:38 pm

Thanks for all the ideas! I needed this! My hubs birthday on 19th and my son is X’mas Day baby(how about that?) My daughter’s Nov baby, so from Halloween on its invites, party, thank you notes, endless shoppings/errands again and again until after NY’s Day…..

P commented on Feb 09 12 at 1:07 am

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Mandy Cheney
  • Stacie Haight Connerty
  • Devan McGuinness
  • Nichole Beaudry
  • Lori Garcia
  • Katie Allison Granju
  • Meghan Gesswein
  • Amber Doty
  • Casey Mullins
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

    More in Kid Scoop (50 of 686 articles)