Kid Scoop

The Truth About (Owning) Cats and Dogs

Posted by caseymullins on October 11th, 2011 at 11:32 am

dorothy 200x300 The Truth About (Owning) Cats and DogsI am a cat person. Cody is a dog person. Addie is a give me a pet now person. Cody likes cats more than I like dogs and I am not easily convinced as to the benefits of a dog (they smell! they bark!) I grew up without any pets. Cody grew up with cats and dogs. In Cody’s world animals stay outside all the time whereas in mine, dogs are allowed inside and are a part of your daily life, you know, if we were to have a dog. (Allow me to mention that as soon as my sister and I moved out my mom got a dog. And air conditioning.) My sister has worked with animals for over 15 years and her one bedroom house is home to three dogs and three cats. She has strong opinions on the type of dog a person owns and how that dog is cared for.

Some families have way too many opinions about how kids should be raised.

Our family?

Has too many conflicting opinions on how pets should be owned.

Addie has already proven herself to be quite possibly the best big sister that ever lived. The kid has oozed compassion and love for living creatures from the time she could chase a cat or dog around the house. She was incredibly close to my dad’s blind and diabetic Dalmatian, Katie. When Katie finally passed away Addie reacted in a way I could have never expected.

She was only four but she was heartbroken. She collapsed into sobs crying out Katie’s name. Katie is still her favorite dog and Dalmatians are still her favorite breed. I on the other hand have never lost a pet that I was close to. It looks really hard. And call me a wuss but I have enough troubles in my life without adding in the inevitable death of a pet.

Sure there’s all this stuff about responsibility and unconditional love.

But we have this baby…and it’s pretty obvious that Addie has learned more about responsibility and unconditional love from having this baby around that I don’t really see the need to go adding any furry creatures to our lives.

But I do love cats. Cody said we could consider getting a cat and I’m suddenly overtaken with anxiety. I am guilty of having an entire board on Pinterest dedicated to Cats. I love my friends cats. I love looking at pictures of cats. I love videos of cats on YouTube, I even have a favorite YouTube Cat (Maru!) But that doesn’t mean I have to own one…the hair! The litter! But they purr…oh I love it when they curl up on you and purr.

NO!

Thankfully the argument for a dog is a little easier. While we have a house and a yard we do not have a fence. And if we’re going to have a dog? We’re going to have to have a fence. Period. We have neighbors who keep a St. Bernard cooped up in their house all day long. I think I’ve only seen the dog outside twice but I’ve seen it staring longingly out the window at least a hundred. I may not be a dog person but I know that’s no life for a dog.

Addie of course would love either. And if we were to get a cat we would rescue an older cat who just wants to live out his or her cat life lying in the sunny patches of our house. It sounds so wonderful doesn’t it?

I know I’m pretty much convinced to pack up and head to the humane society.

But there’s this baby…

What’s the story of cats and dogs in your life? Give them all to me, the good, the bad…the honest truth.

Pets and new babies: 3 common mistakes to avoid

 The Truth About (Owning) Cats and Dogs

Go Back To Kid Scoop

19 Comments

I have an 8 year old boy and a 9 month girl and we have had 3 cats in our house since I was pregnant the first time. Our first cat was a female siamese that my husband got from a shelter as an adult cat when he was in college, the second was a female kitten that had wandered into a coworker’s house as a stray(We still have her), the third was an elderly male manx that had been my husband’s grandfather’s. The manx died when my son was about 2, and we got a female kitten from a shelter. Unfortunately that kitten died from colon cancer just shy of three years old. We weren’t going to get another cat, but some friends started having allergic reactions to their cat so we got an adult female. Our siamese died shortly before I got pregnant with my daughter, and we got a male kitten from a friend who had taken in a pregnant stray.

All five of our cats have always been wonderful with the kids. Our oldest current female will let any child do anything to her, just about. She tolerates tail-pulling, fur-pulling, ear-grabbing, tail-eating, ear-eating, being picked up every which way, and she will stay where she is a allow a toddler running at her screaming KITTY at full volume to “catch” her. The other cats are also very good with the kids, they just don’t tolerate as much. Most cats will just run and hide when they’ve had enough. The male kitten really banded with my daughter after she was born. He sleeps on the floor in her room, and before she was mobile he would curl up next to her anytime she was on the floor. Now that he’s mobile he keeps more of a distance, but he is always nearby.

My best suggestion is to talk to the people at the shelter. Try to find either a very young kitten who can grow up with your kids, or an older cat that is used to kids. An older cat who has never been around kids before, would likely not be a good fit. I have never seen a cat hurt a baby. Even my grandmother’s cat who hated almost everybody, would just ignore the babies or go hide. The litter boxes aren’t bad and Addie is old enough to take on some of the cat chores, although she will probably need reminding. My son started feeding the cats when he was 4, giving them water when he was 6 and he started scooping the litter boxes this year.

Megan commented on Oct 11 11 at 1:55 pm

I have to say St Bernards are extremely low energy and absolutely perfect small space/indoor dogs. Mine actually fights to stay inside, and she has constant access to the yard. We also have a German Shepherd mix, who loves to have access to all aspects of our lives, hates sleeping in the garage when she rolls in something nasty or is muddy and wet. I will say- I’ll never get another giant breed, they are SO hard to find someone to watch, vet bills are a bit bigger, traveling is super tough (car/truck only!)..and now we have the baby to fill most of the car seat the dogs took up- which makes us limited to our truck for travel. But we are firmly of the dogs should be family members group- why bother having them if they are outside all the time? Our opinion. But being raised with animals and the responsibility? Awesome. I learned SO much. (And still dread doggy poo patrol..landmines.)

Stacia commented on Oct 11 11 at 3:45 pm

I just had to have my pug of 12 years to put sleep. Never again will I own a pet. I have had that pug longer that I have had the 7 year old that lives in my house!.
The said 7 year old would really like a cat. My son (grown and does not live at home) is highly allergic to cats and can not even sit in a chair that a cat has graced without Benadryl.
My Dear Mother has 3 Chichuahua’s and called me (privately) to see if I would let the 7 year old have a fully grown 3 pound male Taco Bell dog. NO! absolutely NO WAY! We will not have another animal. I have a hard enough time getting a babysitter for a child that can go to the restroom,walk and talk by herself why, would I want to BEG someone to watch my dog that needs constant care – not to mention bathed, watered, fed, walked and groomed while I go on vacation?

And what do you think my DM did behind my back? Why she went and told the 7 year old that I would not let her get the dog! I still have the crying,sobbing upset 7 year olds voice mail on my phone begging for the dog. Really? yeah, so now I am the bad person. But I still stand firm.

NO ANIMALS!!!!!!

Shari commented on Oct 12 11 at 2:59 pm

I grew up with dogs. Outside dogs. I longed to bring the dog inside for more than a half hour a xmas time but my dad was firm on this. When I was at college, my then fiance got me a dog. He was a rescued sheltie, his family had paid no attention to him for the first two years of his life. I loved him fiercely but being in college he spent a lot of time in my apartment. When I moved to a house, it turns out he didn’t really like to walk. He wanted to be outside, if I was with him, otherwise he was an inside dog. The rescue dog I have now gets walks several times a day and has access to my deck if I’m home; and he loves being outside. But I always feel bad for the dogs that we pass on our walks who live in someone’s yard and don’t get good walks. I firmly believe that dogs should be walked every day; even if they have a yard. It helps them bond to you and also means no landmines in the back yard. (My dog never poops at my parents’ house unless you walk him out of the yard.)

Amy in StL commented on Oct 12 11 at 3:01 pm

I agree with talking to the shelter. Shelter animals usually go through fostering, or are animals that have been given up by owners who know they can no longer care for their animals.

Also, I’m more of a cat person, than a dog, though I will melt into a puddle for a dog, depending on it’s temperament. My daughter grew up with a cat. We got him about 10 months before we found out we were pregnant. He adored our daughter, and we were heartbroken when he disappeared (we prefer to believe that he found another home, and that’s the ONLY thought we will consider ;)). She is still asking for another cat, though both kids know we don’t have space right now (nor can we truly afford the extra $35 a month, per animal, PLUS an extra non-refundable $200 deposit if we did get one [because we would get TWO cats/dogs so they have a friend when we leave the home]).

Sarah @ TM2TS commented on Oct 12 11 at 3:11 pm

Cats are far easier to take care of. Thankfully, you have a good vaacuum. I’d suggest having a litter box in a couple of places of the house, and it be the self-cleaning kind. That keeps the smell at bay. Also, get a kitten, or a shelter cat with a track record of being good with children. Cats + toddlers (which Vivi will eventually become)= scratches.

Emily commented on Oct 12 11 at 5:36 pm

I’d say cats, much less maintenance. We lost our family dog a couple of winters ago and while I miss HIM terribly I do not miss having a dog – or animal at all for that matter. At some point though we will get another because I think it’s part of life to have one, gives you the circle of life emotions.

Jamie (@chosenchaos) commented on Oct 12 11 at 9:44 pm

We love having a cat in our home! Any noise I hear at night I just think it’s the cat so I’m never too afraid of who’s breaking in our house;) We do have to keep the cat’s food up high so my one-year-old daughter won’t eat it. Our previous cat would shed a lot but because I also vacuumed a lot (thanks to a 3 and a 1 year-old) it wasn’t a big deal. My oldest daughter’s first word was kitty. My 1 year-old gives the sign for fish whenever she sees the cat, but I know they both love having this other member of the family. And I love how the cat is always right there, sometimes snuggling, always part of the family.

I think that adopting a cat that’s at least a year is the way to go with kids. The cat is still spunky but not as much as a kitten. The cat knows a little better how to control its claws. And my kids (even my one year old) know that if they’re playing with the cat, they may end up scratched… yet they’re still there playing with him every day.

Stephanie commented on Oct 13 11 at 1:35 am

Kids and pets can be the best combination or the worst. It depends on the pet. And the kids.

We’re dog people, but unfortunately just had to let go of our two mutts. It’s a sad story, one that’s hard to understand as an adult and even harder as a kid, I imagine.

If there’s enough room in your hearts (and home) I say go for it, dog or cat!

mommaruthsays commented on Oct 13 11 at 12:07 pm

I know this is going to sound horrible, so please don’t hate on me. Here I go.

We were cat and dog people….before we had kids. For 4 years before we had our first child we had 2 cats and a dog. Unfortunately, once we had kids, the animals got relegated to the back burner. Sure, we would show them attention. But, not as much as they deserved or wanted. We felt awful about it.

4 years ago, the cats started using the entire house as their litter box – probably in protest to the lack of attention. We eventually had to make them 100% outdoor cats since we couldn’t take the stench anymore. They have a shelter and food in our shed and are still around.

The dog died last year from cancer – it was heartbreaking. Once all animals were gone from inside our house we decided not to get anymore. We knew it wasn’t fair to the animals to get them but not pay them as much attention as they needed.

In a few years, when the kids are older and easier, we may revisit the issue. But for now, having kids and animals are not something that these 2 working parents can handle. At least we can admit that and realize what’s best for the animals.

Mrs. Commoner commented on Oct 13 11 at 1:06 pm

I am a dog person, I treat my dogs like kids. Having kids and dogs might be a little hard. For someone with young kids, a cat seems like the better choice. I am a volunteer for a few animal rescue groups, and I think fostering a cat for one of those groups would be a good way to test the waters. That way you can see how it fits without making the commitment right away (and you would be helping a rescue group at the same time). If you end up loving the cat, and wanting to keep it, you can adopt it! Go to http://www.caws.org, and read up about becoming a foster parent, and you can also see a list of cats in need of foster homes.

Jenny commented on Oct 14 11 at 11:39 am

I would probably suggest a younger cat because of the fact that older cats are going to die sooner and they might not be to keen on babies grabbing on them or uber friendly. You have a pretty nice sized house and lots of places for a cat not used to the family life to hide and not really be part of the family life at all. Cats are much easier to leave by themselves for periods of time and as far as I can tell don’t eat the important parts out of underwear. I mean you are a short trip and I could drop off Barney to play with you all while I take a trip to the Goodwill outlet with Erin and then I would be back for her. I am pretty sure she will convince you either way on the dog front. (Note not liable for any undergarment distruction while the dog is with you)

DExtraordinaire commented on Oct 14 11 at 12:02 pm

If you decide to get a cat in the near future (um, next couple of weeks), I know a great older cat who will be looking for a home. My sister moved to Boston at the beginning of September and moved into an apartment that does not allow pets. She had someone all lined up to take the cat, Isabel, and that person backed out the day of her move. The DAY OF. No notice. Can you believe that? My fiance has put the kibosh on any more pets in our house (he had a cat when I met him; a year and a half later he has two cats and two dogs), so Isabel is living with my mom for the moment, but my mom’s lease is up at the end of this month, and poor Isabel is going to be homeless (the reason for that is a whole different story). We’ve had Isabel for about seven years, and she’s always been a great cat. She’s quiet and keeps mostly to herself, but she does curl up next to you and purr, and she loves lounging in the sun. I hate the thought of taking her to a shelter, but our hands are tied at the moment.

Katie commented on Oct 14 11 at 1:37 pm

We have two rescue dogs – a bigger one and a smaller one. They were our original babies as we didn’t intend on having children so early on in our marriage.
Now Asher is here (and freaking awesome mind you!) and it has made life with two dogs difficult. They are walked in the morning and the evening, and keeping this up with a newborn baby and with the two of us working full time is nigh impossible… but we do it. It just involves planning ahead and really scheduling time. Sometimes I think life would be easier without the dogs, but I love them, and I can see that Asher already loves them. She giggles at them and watches their every move. Our little angry schnauzer/terrier who can be quite miserable is so completely smitten with the baby that I can’t help but melt when I see them together.
I dread having to say goodbye to either of my pups, but I know I have given them a good life outside off the streets and away from the shelter, and that I have taught my little girl to love pets and animals with two of the most awesome mixed bread mutts around :)
ps weekend family cuddles on the bed with baby and “fur children” are the best :)

Andrea commented on Oct 16 11 at 5:44 am

We have a puppy. And a baby. We have been called crazy on more than one occaision. I was so afraid of how the puppy would react when we brought the baby home from the hospital that we stayed an extra day. I CHOSE to stay in the hospital an extra day. Craaaazy. But my fear? Even crazier. The puppy curls up next to me when I’m nursing the baby. He lays under her swing and runs to the nursery door when she starts crying. The baby pulls the puppies ears and sticks her fingers in his eyes. In return, he licks her hands. She laughs hysterically. So now, the puppy is our fur baby, the baby is our real baby, and to each other – they are destined to be best friends. Love it.

Kate commented on Oct 16 11 at 9:04 pm

We got a blue heeler from the shelter last year. He is very energetic neets lots of attention and exercise. He is a total pain and creates a LOT of extra work for me. BUT the bond he has with my just turned 2 year old is absolutely amazing so we we wouldn’t trade him for the world. She put her hand right in his mouth to take his bone, take his food bowl away or sit on him. He also keeps her safe by “telling” on her. He barks to alert me when she tries to go outside alone or once when she tried to run into the road. They play and snuggle and are the best of friends. The dog doesn’t have quite the bond with my oldest (he’s 4) but the dog is very good with him too!

Jamie commented on Oct 17 11 at 10:56 am

When our son was born we had three dogs and a cat. We didn’t plan for three dogs, but my husband and I each had one when we met. Then we took in the neighborhood stray (we’re suckers for a sad story). Then we had a baby. I feel so guilty about the lack of attention we gave to our dogs after our son came. Those first few months, they were fed and let in and out of the house, and that was it. We’re down to two dogs now, and our son is three and a half. Things are much easier because he interacts with the dogs and they LOVED watching the food rain down when he was learning to eat.

The cat? She was just fine. Nothning changed. I am not sure she knows we have a baby.

Sylvia commented on Oct 17 11 at 11:59 am

Sorry no pet/baby references. But grew up with cats. After moving out of parents, got two dogs, then two kittens several years later – all rescue. Dogs mothered the cats growing up and still do. (Think they would so same with baby – being protective etc.) If it was the other way around, cats would torment the younger dogs, but my opinion. So if you get both, try to get the dog first, should be more nurturing between the two – depending on breed of course. Lab mix are always a good choice for kids. Dogs are pack animals, love the family group arangement, cats are more singular person, solitary.
Whatever you get, highly recommend any of the premium pet foods. Worth every penny. Stay away from corn based as first primary ingredient.
My oldest dog is 16 with arthritis, waiting for the next step in her life.
Blogger Doghouse Riley http://doghouseriley.blogspot.com recently lost a cat. Several comments are right on the mark:
“Animals make us better; end of story.”
“Pets are the best thing in the world”
I would add that you cant go wrong with the right pet. It is work to find the right pet though.
Live in Indy also. Please consider Animal Control for adoption/rescue before Human Society. Not as pretty of facility, but need the help and awareness much much more. Also FACE is a great organization too.
I wouldn’t worry too much about it. Something tells me you will do fine with a pet.

Crossed Wires commented on Oct 18 11 at 9:55 am

We always had cats and dogs, and they were always indoor/outdoor. The only time I had a strictly indoor cat was when I lived in New York City and that cat adjusted very nicely to the indoor/outdoor existence in the suburbs. All of the dogs we had (usually 2 or 3 at a time growing up) got along great with all kids. They were never an issue. Since we lived on a farm and the dogs pretty much roamed 700 acres at will, they didn’t get walked but they sure covered a lot of ground as companions. Whenever one of us kids (4 of us) went off on foot, by bike or even by horseback we always had company. In retrospect I think my mom kind of thought of them as our protectors. The cats varied in tolerance of kids. If they didn’t tolerate us they skedaddled and if they did they were really great. I don’t think I was ever scratched outside of the playing getting a little rough (mostly kittens who can’t control there claws) and the wild barn cats (most definitely not let in the house).
My husband and I currently have 3 cats and I am pregnant with our first child. We have no worries in how the cats will treat the baby. They wither won’t anything to do with it or they will love it. Either reaction is possible but them attacking the baby is so highly unlikely that we haven’t even considered it as a possibility. 2 of the cats disappear when kids come to the house and the other one tolerates attention for a short while then leaves when he has had enough.
As for losing a pet, it can be a hard thing to deal with and I have lost many over the years. I think that it has helped me deal better with the loss of family members and friends because I know it gets better and that I can look back on the memories in time and feel happy about them. It made losing people I was close to a little easier. Having the companionship of a pet is something I would never change.

TBerry commented on Oct 26 11 at 1:41 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Mandy Cheney
  • Stacie Haight Connerty
  • Devan McGuinness
  • Nichole Beaudry
  • Lori Garcia
  • Katie Allison Granju
  • Meghan Gesswein
  • Amber Doty
  • Casey Mullins
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service

    More in Kid Scoop (50 of 686 articles)