babble » food » Family Kitchen
Family Kitchen
How to Make Your Own Yogurt
As a kid, our family (thanks to my pseudo-hippie health-conscious parents) was one of relatively few who bought and consumed yogurt on a regular basis. It was something you found mostly at the health food store (along with granola and dried apricots), and mainstream yogurt was limited to those little inverted-cone shaped pots of Yoplait in strawberry, blueberry and peach. We had a yogurt maker in the basement – a Jetsonesque sort of incubator with cords and dials and little glass jars – which never, to my memory, ever got used. (Except to play Smurf Spaceport, that is.) Years ago, I learned to make my own yogurt using nothing but a pot, glass jar and a towel. It truly is easy.
We tend toward the yogurt brands with promises of probiotic benefits splashed across their packages. Probiotics are defined by the World Health Organization as “live microorganisms which when administered in adequate amounts confer a health benefit on the host”. So really, all yogurt with active bacterial cultures can be considered probiotic, whether you see it on package or not.
Unfortunately, consumers tend to have blind faith in advertising, and so the best sellers in the yogurt aisle are not the thick, lustrous varieties with short ingredient lists prepared by our farming neighbours, but mass produced, overly sweet, gelatinous soups that bear little resemblance to the real thing. Far beyond a simple blend of milk and bacterial cultures, they most often contain modified milk ingredients, modified corn starch, pectin, gelatin, sulphites, carrageenan, artificial flavours and colours, and of course sugar, fructose and other sweeteners. Typical sweetened, flavoured yogurts contain between 35 and 42 grams of sugar per cup – far more than a chocolate bar, and on the higher end, as much as a can of Coke.
If you’ve never done it, you’ll be amazed to learn how simple it is to make fresh yogurt all by yourself. The process is much like making your own sourdough; you begin with a live starter (just a spoonful of plain yogurt-the best you can find), your second batch can come from a bit of the last, and so on. If for some reason it doesn’t set up the way you’d like it to, call it a lassi (Indian yogurt drink), or use it to make smoothies.
Homemade Yogurt
I haven’t experimented with soy milk, but regular milk -whole, 2% or 1%) and goat’s milk work very well.
1 heaping tablespoon of the best plain yogurt you can find, making sure it contains active cultures (no additives, stabilizers etc).
2 1/2 cups good quality milk (I like to use organic)Bring the milk to a full boil in a saucepan, then turn down the heat and simmer for 2 minutes. Pour the scalded milk into a bowl, through a strainer or cheesecloth if you have acquired any brown bits around the edge, and cool until you can hold your finger in the milk and count to 10.
Place the yogurt in a small dish and add some of the milk to it to warm it up, then whisk it back into the milk. Pour into a glass jar (glass holds heat well), wrap in a towel or sweater and put in a warm place for about 6 hours or overnight. In the morning put the jar in the fridge to chill and you should end up with a lovely jar of fresh yogurt.
Go Back To Family Kitchen
18 Comments
Sarah commented on Feb 01 11 at 2:04 pmI’ve always wanted to learn how to do this! Have you ever tried this with Greek yogurt? Do you think it would work? Thanks so much!
JulieVR commented on Feb 01 11 at 2:19 pmAbsolutely – so long as it contains active bacterial cultures, you should be good to go!
Elizabeth commented on Feb 01 11 at 2:24 pmAmazing!!! I will be trying this immediately.
Angela commented on Feb 01 11 at 2:43 pmYou can use greek yogurt for your starter but to make to give it the really thick and creamy consistency greek yogurt is known for you will need to strain it after it’s done with a strainer lined with several layers of cheese cloth.
Jenn commented on Feb 01 11 at 5:21 pmHomemade yogurt is so great, and a good way to use up extra milk (especially if you’re on a weekly delivery schedule like we are).
If your house tends to be rather cool, as ours does, plunk that towel-wrapped jar into a cooler.
I left my last batch of yogurt out for well over 12 hours because I forgot it. Wouldn’t you know that it was the best batch yet??
Meghan commented on Feb 01 11 at 7:56 pmInstead of leaving it out and covered, I warm the oven to 100 degrees, then turn it off, pop in the pot I used on the stove (don’t transfer the milk/yogurt mixture), then let it sit in there overnight with the lid on. 12 hours is perfect every time.
I do find that using homemade yogurt as a starter for a new batch of yogurt, though, a bit iffy. It is still a milk product after all. Won’t it turn bad at some point? I only did it once and the next batch just wasn’t quite right.
Amy commented on Feb 01 11 at 8:39 pmI would love to try this with nut milks. Do you think it would work? Has anyone tried it with non-animal milks.
Laura commented on Feb 02 11 at 8:50 amWould this work with skim milk and fat-free yogurt?
Shelagh commented on Feb 02 11 at 11:01 amI, too, had a “yogurt maker” in my basement. A wedding gift that never, ever was used and ended up being donated in the box that it came in to a flea market. My preferred method was always a pot on the stove. Simple and it works.
Kelly commented on Feb 04 11 at 12:00 amWow! I never knew it was that easy. Going to have to try it this weekend! Just need to find a good sized jar…..
Naomi commented on Feb 04 11 at 9:19 pmI make yogurt weekly (with skim milk), and heat the milk in a big glass bowl in the microwave. When it gets to 180 F I take it out, let it cool to between 110-115 F then add my ‘starter’. And just like Meghan, I let it sit in the oven overnight. Works every time. If you like thicker yogurt, strain it before refrigerating it.
Jackie commented on Feb 05 11 at 10:17 amI made some yogurt for the first time based on your recipe. OMG it turned out so good and was so easy to do I’m wondering why I didn’t try it sooner.
Elizabeth commented on Feb 07 11 at 10:59 pmI made yogurt this weekend, following your recipe, but it turned out a lot more runny and less tangy than the supermarket yogurt I started with. Any thoughts as to how to get the yogurt to be thicker or tangier?
thanks!
Michelle BB {Munch} commented on Feb 13 11 at 12:54 pmTo Elizebeth: I have now made yogurt following this recipe a couple of times. I have found that to get it nice and thick, simmer it 10 minutes rather than 2. It works for my anyhow and it’s nice and tangy (but not too sharp) as well.
DD commented on Feb 19 11 at 10:41 amI watched a video online where a woman used a bowl, a strainer and a coffee filter to thicken yogurt. You start with a bowl, place the strainer over the bowl (the bowl would naturally have to be larger than the strainer), place the coffee filter inside the strainer. Then you pour the yogurt in the coffee filter/strainer until it is almost to the top of the filter. Cover the bowl and strainer with plastic wrap. Place in refrigerator overnight and the next morning you will have thick, greek-style yogurt. The riboflaven (sp) left over can be used for something else or thrown out.
Linda Gamboa commented on Feb 22 11 at 9:24 amMy parents are from Finland and often ate home-made “(f)velia” for breakfast. My mother made it by filling individual-size bowls with milk, adding a spoonful of “starter,” and leaving it in a warm cupboard overnight, and when it was “set” it was refrigerated. The starter was made by tearing off a piece of sourdough bread, placing it in a bowl, covering it with milk, and leaving it in a warm cupboard overnight. When the velia was “set,” a spoonful of one serving was placed in each fresh bowl as the starter for the next batch, with milk. It made a probiotic yogurt. I think each serving was about 3/4 cup.
Melissa Simpson commented on Jun 05 11 at 8:23 amOK so I made my yogurt it turned out great till I added some honey then it instantly turned to liquid. I put it in my magic bullet blender to add the honey, can someone tell me was it the honey or the mixing that made it liquify??? I will be making more today or tomorrow and would like to ovoid wrecking it again, it was still great for smoothies…:)
JulieVR commented on Jun 06 11 at 11:09 amI would say it was the magic bullet! I add yogurt (the liquidy kind) all the time and it’s fine! You’re right, it will still be great for smoothies!
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Kelsey Banfield
Aggie Goodman
Brooke McLay
Angie McGowan
Paula Jones
Laura Levy
Shaina Olmanson
Kathy Patalsky
Elizabeth Stark & Brian Campbell
Julie Van Rosendaal
Macki West
Sara O'Donnell
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

18