Is this even a question. Jacob is effing creepy. He’s been effing creepy since the beginning. Always grabbing Bella and acting as if he owns her when he’s not even her boyfriend. Effing creep.

Not Creepy. He didnt have sex with her.

Yeah, I guess that’s why she tries to rip his head off, who wouldn’t. Get off my daughter? But it ends up not being like that, obviously. But Bella’s initial reaction is the right one and I loved it. Of course, it all works out in the end and we all get more relaxed with the situation haha

But loved the attack on Jacob, long time coming where she finally belongs to Edward completely. That was great.

Its TOTALLY creepy.
But understandable.
In real life thats just wrong.
but, ya no, he didnt really have a choice.

Creepy. Yes. One of the most serious flaws in the book, but just another part of the train wreck end of the series that was so brutally disapppointing. My big question is how Taylor Lautner’s career will fare after portraying what is essentially a pedophile. The makers all have to be very cautious with this one because it is creepy, and the franchise is so huge that it will have a lasting effect on the careers of all involved. How they portray it all will be the most interesting part of the upcoming movie as far as I am concerned.

Oh, and he doesn’t grab her because she’s becoming a vampire; he grabs her because she’s going to have sex with Edward.

TOALLY CREEPY!!!!! I must admit. I understand its FICTIONAL, its FANTASY however, it is marketed to a group of individual that haven’t quit figured out all the does and don’t of their hurmones on blast. . .throwing in the CREEPY get what you want from the daugther if the mother won’t is a total let down! This is a pedophile move plain and simple!!! This train has already left the station, and unforunately I purchased the ticket. . .I’m getting off here and won’t be involved any longer, in this case someone should have been left with a broken heart, not a ready made child for your past heartbreak. . .The stories were so good, there could have been many avenues to venture down without making a child a reward. . . Now Everyone is satisfied and at who’s expense? Pedophiles has enough tools at their disposal

Okay so, when I read this book I was sooo pissed. I read all four books in four days and when I got through with this book I was mad. I had read for seven hours straight slept for five and started reading again till I finished. Seeing that I have been on Jacob’s side since New Moon I was heartbroken when Bella dies and Jacob is trying ONCE AGAIN to save her dumb ass. It made me cry and I’m not a crier. The imprinting thing is odd. However once it is explained as not a romantic love, just an overwhelming love.

The book explains that Jacob only believed that he loved Bella, he was only so drawn to her because she always had a part of Renesmee with her. That was why he was so drawn to Bella, the possibility that if Renesmee had never been born then he would have still always loved Bella, but the part of Bella that he loved was in fact Renesmee.

If I had my way with the story I’d rather Bella had been killed by Laurent in New Moon instead of her ending up with Edward in Breaking Dawn. I think Jacob’s character, while young and immature, is full of love and life and fun. Mean while Edward is a doormat and the wallpaper that makes up the background of the story. He is either mopey or jealous, just totally a drag either way. Jacob is exciting, hot blooded, handsome and young. I understand people love Robert Pattinson, but the Edward in the book totally fades after Twilight.

@Jenna I understand it haha…it would still be weird in away, because Imprintings weird. I don’t think Jacob is too good for Bella. He’s immature, cocky, and tries to own Bella when he’s just her friend. I use to like Jacob in Twilight, but after that he just got too annoying. But there’s always the girls who prefer the good guys and the bad guys. I totally understand that, and the girls who like the wild, rebel boys with like Jacob, but regardless it always been Edward.

And I don’t think he faded after Twilight, he may have to you, but before the movies came out, it was all about Edward. Taylor Lautner and his delicious body made more fans Team Jacob.

definitely creepy. I agree with Team Black above. Jacob brings Bella to life, and I wish they would get together.

me again… well, I know the movie script can be a little different than the book, so I would love it if they could continue the tension between Bella and Jake. And it would be wonderful if the imprinting implied being a father/brother-figure for Bella’s daughter rather than a romantic soul mate in the end. This would avoid all of the weirdness.

PS – for the record, I never blog but this has been a great distraction from my PhD. Totally ridiculous!

I don’t see why PPL think it’s creepy for Jacob to fall for Bella’s child when Edward is almost 100 and Bella’s is 18. Is it because he dose not look that old? Jacob will only be 17 yrs older then her VS 60 +
Either way it’s a book not real life and There Vampires and werewolve’s I think Jacob’s part is sweet and I hope he end’s up with someone Bella’s strings him along to much.