Famecrawler
The Great Debate: Is it Shiloh or is it Knox? (POLL)
Is it Shiloh or is it Knox? That, my friends, is the question. Yesterday we did a post, as many other sites did, about Brad and Angelina taking what we thought was Knox for a boat ride in Venice, Italy. But is it Knox? Or is it actually Shiloh? Let’s look at some of clues:
- Zahara was with them. Shiloh and Zahara are always together.
- There is a gap or missing tooth. Shiloh has a gap.
- The hair seems darker than Shiloh super blond locks, but we haven’t seen Shiloh without a hat in a while so it may have gotten darker.
- Since Shiloh always dresses like a boy, the attire doesn’t help us.
We’re not the only people confused. Here are what other sites are saying:
MSNBC – Team Knox
NPR – Team Shiloh
X17 – Team Knox
Just Jared – Team Shiloh
Socialite Life – Team Knox
Huffington Post – Team Shiloh (their initial ID that is..)
A pretty even split…
What do you think? (photo INFPhoto)
Go Back To Famecrawler
5 Comments
[...] photo caused quite a stir on the internet. People couldn’t figure out if Brad Pitt was carrying his daughter Shiloh or son Knox. But just by looking at the size of the child, you could tell it’s big sister Shiloh! One [...]
Star Kid: Shiloh Sports Stella McCartney Kicks | Droolicious commented on Feb 25 10 at 5:31 pm[...] quite a stir on the internet. People couldn’t figure out if Brad Pitt was carrying his daughter Shiloh or son Knox But just by looking at the size of the child, you could tell it’s big sister Shiloh! [...]
Star Kid: Shiloh Sports Stella McCartney Kicks « shoez 4 u… commented on Feb 27 10 at 4:05 pmMergath commented on Feb 19 10 at 3:56 pmIt’s gotta be Knox. Shiloh has massive Angelina lips.
Kweli commented on Feb 22 10 at 9:13 amThis is kinda silly. Shiloh is almost 4, this is clearly a toddler. I’d say this is Viv OR Knox.
jas commented on Apr 25 10 at 4:03 pmIt’s clearly shiloh, as in the bigger picture you’ll see she’s wearing the same trainers as in other pictures
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes
Christopher Rogers 
Shana Aborn 
Joanna Mazewski 
Sunny Chanel 
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.
5