Dadding

Tide’s The Dad Mom — Is He Justifying His Masculinity?

Posted by Ron on January 5th, 2012 at 1:35 pm
dad mom 2 300x196 Tides The Dad Mom    Is He Justifying His Masculinity?

The Dad-Mom aka Captain Awesome

Last week in a post asking if society was finally accepting men as stay-at-home dads, I referenced the “dad-mom.” The term comes from a Tide commercial featuring a stay-at-home dad who is folding laundry while telling us why he’s “being awesome.” Yes. You are totally awesome, bro.

At the very beginning of the ad, Captain Awesome introduces himself as a “dad-mom.” The moniker is then flashed on the screen as if to say, “Yeah, that’s right, I said ‘dad-mom’ and doncha fo’get it, bee-atches.”  Right, because nothing says bad-ass better than pink lettering. With this now visually emblazoned in our subconscious, we hear him go on about how his wife works while he’s home dripping puddles of awesomeness all over the floor (which his dad-mom awesomeness demands he mop it up).

Take a moment to watch.

0 Tides The Dad Mom    Is He Justifying His Masculinity?

 

I just eye-rolled so hard it strained a muscle in my ocular cavity.

As you can probably tell, I wasn’t too impressed our self-proclaimed “hero,” vanquisher of juice pop stains (per the spot’s short version). My initial reaction was that the ad still implied a delineation between masculine and feminine domestic duties by inserting a man into what’s clearly a woman’s responsibility—doing laundry. My opinion here still stands.

Apparently there was a bit of a flap over this commercial when it first ran back in the late fall, and I came across more than a few commentaries on it to include an interesting assessment on the blog, Sociological Images. In the post assistant professor of sociology at Temple University, Dr. Amanda Czerniaswski addresses the same basic issue I have with the commercial.

In the post she points out three problems with underlying messages being depicted: 1) the display of normative heterosexuality as Captain Awesome talks of the mom-moms swooning over his unique blend of masculinity and nurturing, 2) the competitive nature of men demonstrated when our hero brags about his kid-dressing properly, and 3) the clarification of laundry being women’s work as qualified by the Captain’s application of masculine “brute strength” to the task.

Generally, I agree with Dr. Czeriawski’s position. What concerns me, though, is that in our society’s struggles with gender roles and equality, there’s a tendency to disparage our innate differences as men and women. Sure, a man is just as capable of changing a diaper as a women is managing a company merger, but because we approach these challenges differently as men and women that doesn’t translate into gender inequality.

As I’ve said before, I don’t want to be a mommy, mommies offer things I can’t and visa versa. I just want to be a parent, yet at the same time I’m still going to embrace my masculinity in the process.  But there’s a caveat to that, and it ties back to our laundry-folding, French-braiding super stud of a dad-mom.

Masculinity isn’t something you tell people you are; it’s something you live just like parenting. And when you’re living it, others will know without having to be told.  That’s what I hate about the dad-mom. He’s too afraid to embrace the fact he’s a man. He straddles the fence by hyphenating his title, but then qualifies it with references to his sex-appeal with mom-moms, his kid dressing prowess, and his swift application of  brute strength to household duties. (In the short version he adds problem-solving and working out to clarify he’s still a dude.)

The dad-mom reminds me of those wimpy movie characters from suburbia who find themselves in the ‘hood, and then they try to fit in by talking all tough which in turn, tends to piss everyone off and “yuppie-gangsta” proceeds to get his ass kicked.

So to Captain Awesome I say this, drop the “mom” identifier and commit to being a dad, then don’t tell me about it—live it. Otherwise, you roll on up in ‘dis ‘hood—fatherhood—and you gonna get a proverbial smack-down courtesy of my “brute strength.”

P.S. I’m not done with the Dad-Mom—next up: The Religious Perspective

 

* * *

Ron Mattocks is a father of five (3 sons, 2 stepdaughters) and author of the book, Sugar Milk: What One Dad Drinks When He Can’t Afford Vodka. He blogs at Clark Kent’s Lunchbox, and lives in Houston with his wife, Ashley, who eternally mocks his fervor for Coldplay.

 

Photo Credit:  A video still from advertisement on YouTube.  Video Credit: YouTube/MyTideTV

 Tides The Dad Mom    Is He Justifying His Masculinity?

Go Back To Dadding

3 Comments

Good article. I posted something similar a while back when the two versions of this ad came out. They are VERY different, and I reacted very negatively to the “dad-mom” version. I did like the short version with the hair braiding, but there was still room for improvement.

Marketing to Dads: Tide Gets It Right

The Real Matt Daddy commented on Jan 05 12 at 1:52 pm

Thing is, for better or worse, this is how a large percentage of people still feel about the roles of men and women. And Tide is in the business of selling laundry detergent. Those people will either find it refreshing, because they’re bending the stereotypes in an area where they’re catching hell for it, OR they will find it cutesy, because “certainly there aren’t really stay-at-home dads out there.” Bottom line, Tide sells the product. I used to analyze TV ads all the time, in fact I wrote a final paper about the topic in college. But, it’s sort of useless. They really are just in the business of Shock and Awe to Sell Goods.

bwsf commented on Jan 06 12 at 11:26 am

I’m there with you Ron. Man up and call yourself a man. There’s nothing more masculine than doing what needs to be done, and if that means being a domestic god (as opposed to “godess”) so be it. Own it. Do it right. THAT’S what makes it manly.

On another level, frankly I found it funny. I think society just doesn’t yet know what to make of the SAHD as a developing demographic. It’ll come. It’ll just take time, and a whole lot of positive role-models for society to use as examples.

-DorkDad
http://www.dorkdaddy.com

DorkDad commented on Jan 06 12 at 7:01 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Cody
  • Whit Honea
  • Serge Bielanko
  • Mike Adamick
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Dadding (50 of 442 articles)