Dadding
Type A Parenting Doesn’t Mean Being an A-Hole
Not too long ago I had an interesting experience when a Wall Street Journal columnist asked if she could interview me for a piece she was doing on Type A parents raising Type B children. Intrigued by the topic, I agreed to her request. I hadn’t really thought about how my Type A traits impacted this aspect of my life, which as a stay-at-home dad, dominates a considerable chuck of my day.
The interview, I thought, went well. The columnist, Sue Shellenbarger, was sincere, and her questions caused me to reflect on both my failures and successes as influenced by my Type A-ness. There were moments when I was too harsh and not as understanding as I should’ve been, but there were also times when I adapted to the situation rather than forcing the kids to adjust to my timeline or my goals.
At the end of our talk, I gained a new awareness of this aspect of my parenting style, and since then, it jumps to the forefront of my mind whenever I’m dealing with the latest and greatest situation involving my kids. Knowing this hasn’t kept me from more mistakes, but, even so, I find myself looking back at such instances through a lens that asks, “did my Type A traits affect my behavior here?”
One important factor in all of this involves whether I’m dealing with my Type A kids or the ones who are Type B. Each are motivated by different things. For the A’s (and I’m generalizing a bit), they are motivated by reaching the end-state—earning a reward or completing a task. The B’s, however, are concerned less about finishing something than they are about the experience along the way.
Take for example homework. Whereas one bunch is driven to knock it all out as quick as possible so they can go play with friends, their counterparts doddle based on their degree of interest in the topic. So, when it comes to getting the A’s to do long division, all I have to say is, “get it done and you can play video games,” For the B’s, though, I have to turn the work into fun, by telling them to pretend division is really cracking a secret spy code (or something like that). The point here is that, in order to effectively motivate my B children, I’m the one who needs to adapt to them, not the other way around.
I use homework to illustrate this because, hands down, it’s the situation that grates on my Type A traits the most, and as such, it’s where I often screw up. The reason for my aggravation is that homework time overlaps with my work which means diverting time and energy towards checking spelling worksheets rather than items on my checklist. When you’re goal oriented, having to divert energy elsewhere is literally like throwing a monkey wrench into the spinning cogs of my plan for the day. (We would change the schedule, but there are other constraints denying that option.)
Going back to Shellenbarger’s article, “Ambitious Parents, Mellow Children,” I thought she accurately conveyed the topic as she put it into context by using stories from other Type A parents such as daddy blog superstar, Jim Lin of the Busy Dad Blog. Furthermore, as I read through the piece, nothing struck me as being contrary to our conversation during the interview. It all seemed straightforward. No harm, no foul. And then I reached the comments.
Let me say upfront, if you’re going to be a parent blogger who writes about your kids, being attacked, judged, questioned—whatever—goes with the territory. When you put yourself out there, somebody’s going to take pot shots (mostly it’s for no other reason than, because they can). I know this, and I’ve been on the receiving end more than a few times here. Yet for some reason, unlike times past, several of the article’s comments annoyed the snot out of me.
It took me a while before I could put a finger on it, but I eventually realized that the source of my anger stemmed from the insinuations that being a Type A parent meant being an asshole at my children’s emotional expense. Such suggestions didn’t sit well with me.
Am I Type A? Yes, but not in the sense that I walk into a room and dominate it with an inherent force of will. Nor do I stand over my children at dinner and shout motivational slogans into their ears as they scarf down a plate of tacos. I’m actually very reserved in fact.
I do, however, establish goals and aim for success. I am motivated by reaching the end-state, and thus far, I’ve accomplished much of what I set out to do in the military, in the corporate world, and even now as a writer. What’s more, I’ve never had to bully people around in the process, and despite inevitable mistakes, I don’t want that to be any different when it comes to my parenting either.
In one respect, I suppose this post could be seen as self-serving in that I’m writing to rebut those judgmental comments hoping to convince these people I’m not a Type A monster. That would be pointless. What I’m actually wanting is to get your perspectives on the topic. Are you a Type A or B person, and how does it affect your parenting style?
Go Back To Dadding
14 Comments
Chris commented on Nov 29 11 at 11:03 amI am not a Type A. I’m probably more of a Type B personality and tend to go with the flow. As the stay at home, it dictates how we do things. We’re meandering explorers. Every situation reveals an opportunity to insert a lesson. We take them as they come. What I fear is that my toddler will grow up to be a Type A and I will not know how to properly feed his innate sense of drive and forward momentum.
But being a Type B doesn’t mean being boring or passive, just like being a Type A doesn’t mean being an A-hole.
TheCreativeHomestead.com commented on Nov 29 11 at 3:03 pmThis was great. Sounds like you’re self-aware and reflective, which I think is way more important than whether or not you’re Type A or B. Sounds like you learn a lot from your kids. And I agree with Chris, Type B doesn’t mean being boring or passive.
I’m also Type B and prefer to take things as they come. But I’ve also noticed my mind works fast. I’m not saying that to mean ‘smart’ but I get too far ahead when I need to focus on the now. Plus I have an unusual memory and can find myself exasperated when I need to repeat things or remind people of what they did or said just last month.
Jennifer M. commented on Nov 29 11 at 4:50 pmI’m a Type A, but I find when it comes to parenting, I tend to somehow morph into a Type B. In normal life, I can’t handle curve balls, but when it comes to my kids, I’m very easy-going for whatever reason. I have goals for myself and for my daughter, but I’m much more flexible in meeting them. Maybe because my Unstoppable Force met an Immovable Object in the form of family stubbornness in my daughter. She gets it from me, so I can’t really complain. lol. It did, however, help me mellow out a bit when it came to expecting Rosie to be one-the-dot developmentally. As for her own personality, she’s also a type A. It should be interesting as she grows up, seeing how our two very different (so far) type-A personalities clash.
stacey@Havoc&Mayhem commented on Nov 29 11 at 5:38 pmI’m Type B, unless I actually have specific goal to accomplish, then I am Type A+. Most of the time I am content to take things as they come. There are generally vague points I would like to hit during the day – go to the gym, cook dinner, sweep the floor but they happen as & when they happen & if something doesn’t happen oh well there is always tomorrow. But if I am under the gun with a goal like grocery shopping before a doctor’s appointment then get out of my way & don’t you dare slow me down. I recognize it and so does my family so we all work with it. I give warnings ahead of time about how there is no time for browsing in the store today or how homework has got to be done before dinner because of some other goal and it seems to work.
Pam commented on Nov 30 11 at 7:58 amI am type A and my husband is type B. I start the day with a plan and goals for things i want to accomplish and it stresses me out if I don’t get to them all. A good example is a typical trip to the mall. I go, knowing I want to go in store A,B, and C and get items 1, 2, and 3. So as soon as we get in the mall, I want to get those items and stores knocked out. I cannot relax and enjoy just looking around.d until that is done. I get angst and frustrated, but my husband is the type who wants to stop in at some random store along the way. I try to rush him out and he’s tries to tell me to relax, we’ll get there, blah blah blah… I can’t help it. I try to turn it off and I wish I wasn’t like that because I get so stressed out. I can feel my blood pressure rising, but that’s just how I work. And i tend to get more done, although, i’ll give it to the hubby. He gets the important things done and always in a timely manner. I get so stressed out when things don’t go smoothly, that I love being able to count on his more relaxed personality to take care of things like trips to the DMV.
Pam commented on Nov 30 11 at 8:06 amDyac…. Angst =nervous
Tiffany W commented on Nov 30 11 at 8:08 amI am a type B person and so is my son. Sometimes i feel that my lack of the type A personality “hurts” him… He doesnt seem to care if anything gets done… Bribes do not work on him if he doesnt want to do something, nothing is going to make him. it turns into a meltdown….i know that your personality is who you are and its hard to change that but are there any tips to being more of a type A person? … i feel like if we dont work on this he may have issues in school like i did.
Stephanie commented on Nov 30 11 at 8:29 amAs a child I was definitely a type A personality- as I’ve grown into adulthood I think I’ve become more of a type B- however, I don’t think it has to be one of the other. I feel like parenting has helped me develop a good mix between the two. I set goals and make charts for the kids, but I also give leeway to our schedule, because little kids (although they need routine and stability) are spontaneous. I like your perspective on the topic, and the fact that you use it for an opportunity for self-evaluation.
Check out my blog:
http://practicingparenting.blogspot.com/
julieminer commented on Nov 30 11 at 9:27 amI just have to say – Welcome to Babble. You’re awesome. Love your posts! Also? This may be the single best title of a post in the history of ever.
Yvette commented on Nov 30 11 at 11:29 amAs a single mom, I was type A all the way. If I didn’t stick to the schedule, things would fall behind and I’d never catch up. I was super focused. But now that I’m engaged and baby no.2 on the way, I am BOTH. I am type A when I need to be and type B when I need to be. Funny thing is when I’m not type A, he is. My daughter is deff type B. She’s very go with the flow.. but now that I think of it she always ask me what we are doing for the day.. lol so I don’t know what she is! I am very loving with my family but when we have to get A-Z done, I’m ready to do it and get to the fun part (or the relaxing part). It’s odd, I’d have to look more into the types to see which I really am.
Clark Kent's Lunchbox commented on Dec 01 11 at 12:17 pm@Chris – very glad you made the point about Type B’s not being boring and passive just as A’s are not A-holes. The stereotype goes both ways and neither are right.
@CreativeHomestead – ooo, yeah, reminding people to do stuff bugs me too. Thanks about being self-aware, although, admittedly it’s a kind of self-awareness in the same vein as I’m aware there’s blood coming from my foot because I keep shooting myself there. :-)
@JenniferM – You just made me think about the clashes I have coming when my A kids turn into teens in the very near future.
@Stacey – Funny how priority situations push us into that role. On work stuff I’m more Type A but on stuff at home I’m more Type B unless I’m pushed into a deadline like that.
@Pam – Great comment. You reminded me of how I have to act more Type B with my wife (who’s a B). It helps mellow her out when it comes to shopping or rushing somewhere. I have to do this consciously though, otherwise, if I act Type A on her, it works her into a frenzy and sometimes results in a panic attack.
@Tiffany – Thanks for sharing your situation. You’ll have to forgive me as I don’t have any specific tips. Much of the successes I’ve had have been a matter of trial and error. I did however come across this article and it offered some great perspective on the topic: http://life.familyeducation.com/child-psychology/personality-development/40418.html
@Stephanie That’s a really great illustration of finding that balance between who you are and who your kids are and what works best for everyone, Thanks
@JulieMiner – Oh gosh, thank you. I’m blushing.
@Yvette – My hats off to single moms. My wife was forced to be one almost from day one, and so I have the utmost respect for moms (and dads) in that situation. She’s a Type B, and after I read your comment it made me think about all the stories she’s told me where she had to be a Type A person just to make things work for her and her kids.
rebecca commented on Dec 02 11 at 9:49 amI’m a Type A who has always wanted to be a Type B. Sigh. My daughter, in fact, has brought out more of the type B in me, and I think it’s made me a better, or at least, more well rounded person. To watch a Type B, and actually encourage her to be a Type B – because as all Type A’s know, it’s exhausting being a Type A – it’s fascinating. I can live vicariously through my Type B daughter and think how great it is and how lucky she is. As you said, she enjoys “experiences,” rather than the means to the end. Really enjoyed this!
Chammarra commented on Dec 03 11 at 11:06 amIm a Type A personality with Type B tendancies. I’m currently 9 months pregnant with our first so I don’t know how that will play out but it definitely affects the classroom I teach in. Over the years I have had to learn to be more go-with-the-flow and to make experiences fun and interesting to reach my class of Specual Needs high schoolers. While I was always motivated for school work just because it needed to get done, a majority of my high schoolers could care less. To get them to do or learn anything I’ve had to adapt, make games or activities do they try and I realized that if they learn, then it’s ok that things take longer or don’t always go as I planned. I hope the skills I’ve learned as a teacher help me raise my little one.
Brandi commented on Dec 06 11 at 10:39 amI’m totally type A, but my children and my husband are type B – which leaves me hell-fire-mad all the time that things aren’t going my way :) I’m pretty good about controlling it, but when I think back on my parents, my dad was a huge influence on my life and was Type A while my mother who was often out working was Type B….
http://www.pimpangel.com
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes







How To Be A Dad
Monica Bielanko
Serge Bielanko
Mike Adamick
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

14