Being Pregnant

The Sexualization of Breastfeeding

Posted by holly whitney on August 17th, 2011 at 1:06 pm
md horiz The Sexualization of Breastfeeding

Photo Credit: Malia Schlaefer

Before you became pregnant, did you have a strict “no touching” policy when it came to your breasts?

Did you say “hands off” because you wouldn’t want to sexualize a part of your body that may some day provide nourishment for your child?

For most women I would guess that answer is no. When we first start exploring our sexuality, how many of us are really thinking about how that might relate to the public’s perception of breast feeding—positive or negative? I certainly wasn’t.

Currently, Madison Young is dealing with that issue. Sure, her situation is somewhat different than mine. Along with being a mother, a writer and a sex educator, Young is also an adult film star. Something I am definitely not.

Her breasts have become inherently sexualized as a result of her occupation. As a result, she has come under fire for breastfeeding in public.

What I find interesting is that Madison Young isn’t being criticized by conservatives that are against the adult film industry. Instead, she is being criticized by another porn star and sex activist who goes by the name of Furry Girl.

Furry Girl criticized Young on Twitter stating that “only ‘creeps & pedophiles’ are interested in seeing a porn star breast-feed”.

Pedophiles? I have to ask, how is breastfeeding—regardless of the mother’s occupation—an act that would get a rise out of pedophiles? How is feeding your child sexualizing them? Should that keep women from breastfeeding in public?

One of the things that Furry Girl finds so offensive is a photograph of Young looking like a breastfeeding Marilyn Monroe—which I personally think is stunning and reminiscent of Cindy Sherman’s work (who happens to be one of my favorite photographers). Furry Girl is also offended by a vlog Young breastfeeding “while talking about an upcoming event where she would be speaking about breast health”.

Neither of these activities scream sexualization to me.

Madison Young seems to feel the same way. She replied to Furry Girl on Twitter by saying, “the only one sexualizing this image of me breastfeeding is you. Which makes me feel truly disgusted and violated”.

What do you think? Should Young shy away from breastfeeding in public because of her occupation?

Moms share real stories of breastfeeding

 The Sexualization of Breastfeeding

Go Back To Being Pregnant

9 Comments

[...] The Sexualization of Breastfeeding When not Babbling about babies, she's doing recipe development and contributions for publications such as SELF and O magazines, or posting healthy recipes and occasional gratuitous photos of her dogs at DailyGarnish.com. Ceridwen Morris is a writer, … Read more on Babble (blog) [...]

Celebrity Homemade Beauty Secrets commented on Aug 19 11 at 6:26 am

[...] of boobs, I wrote a letter to mine this week. I also discussed whether or not a porn star should be able to breastfeed in [...]

Babbles, Boobs, and Baby | artistmotherteacher.com commented on Aug 29 11 at 10:58 am

No, she should not shy away from it. I’m not sure I understand why it’s a problem in the first place. I will say, though, if you chose a profession that tends to get more flack, you’re going to get more flack in the rest of your life, too.

Wendy Thomas commented on Aug 17 11 at 1:52 pm

Hell no. More power to her. All breasts are sexualized, not just the ones on porn stars or strippers. But that shouldn’t stop women from breastfeeding in public. Also, by Furry Girl’s logic, Young shouldn’t be allowed to give birth vaginally either…

Ashley commented on Aug 17 11 at 4:34 pm

I think the photo is beautiful, and it’s an excellent political statement about how women’s bodies are regarded. Go Madison!

Bunnytwenty commented on Aug 18 11 at 9:45 am

I actually kind of know Furry Girl. #twodegreesofseparation Really love some of the early commentary on the Jezebel article-more thoughtful self-probing I’ve seen so far than irrational outbursts.

I’m surprised by how on the fence I am about this, personally. Not that she needs to not breastfeed in public-that’s not something that should ever come into play. I am a breastfeeding supporter, I nursed all my babies, even the one I had at 16. But I understand some people aren’t comfortable with it, and I think their comfort level with their children is critical, too. After working in child protection, I saw firsthand the long-term effects of poor bonding on a family and I think that can be a bigger problem than lacking the health benefits breastfeeding gives. I think its bizarre that breastfeeding is even an issue, honestly. It’s better for the babies, but formula is fine, to me. Do what you want, feed your baby where you want. It’s not my business. My business is to educate and prepare my children about and for what they will see in the world, including breastfeeding.

All that being said, my discomfort with this is more based on where these images are displayed. If alongside what is broadly considered porn, well, yeah, I don’t think that is appropriate. Not because of the breastfeeding itself, but because I don’t feel that children should be a part of that material. Aside from the obvious kids don’t belong in porn argument, there are legal issues as well. Firstly, there are laws commonly called 2257 that strongly regulate age and ID records for adult performers. A simple clerical error, even if all performers are over 18, can lead to large fines and even prison time for the record keeper. I wonder how that is being handled. And what about consent? The child can’t give his/her consent, and for the rest of his/her life these images will be out there. To hit the exploitation angle from another perspective, how ethical is it to use your child as a prop to further your agenda? It happens all the time, political figures staging family photo ops, for example, but doesn’t it kind of cheapen the message you are sending about personal freedom when you choose FOR your child?

To address what the performer here says is her message, I do think the idea of how motherhood and sexuality coexist is worth exploring. Yes, we are still mothers while we are expressing ourselves sexually, and there are some interesting dynamics in how we manage both in our lives, and how each affects the other. But respecting my children and their autonomy is more important than using them to further that agenda.

Angel Smith commented on Aug 18 11 at 11:58 am

I’m offended enough by issues surrounding “adult film stars” having children around their professions without worrying about breastfeeding becoming sexualized as a result.

Mama Wrench commented on Aug 18 11 at 3:47 pm

The REASON breasts are overly sexualized is BECAUSE of professions like hers. The pornography profession is high on the list of people to blame for this problem for ALL women. If the public is used to and has only previously been exposed to this woman’s breasts being used in a sexual manner, what else are they supposed to think!? I highly doubt that 150 years ago (before “pornography”) women were worried about breastfeeding or breastfeeding in public because of the possibility of their breasts being seen as sexual.
Note, that above I said overly sexualized. I would imagine that 150 years ago that husbands loved the sexyness of their wives breasts, just as they do today…however, I doubt that there were whispers and sneers when a woman breastfed her baby in public and I doubt that she was ever told that she needed to keep that “kind of activity” in private.

If pornography, play boy, etc, etc… ceased to exist, then this issue would become all but obsolete.

Roslynn commented on Aug 18 11 at 4:30 pm

I think it may be helpful for you all to actually reference the art work and the artist statement to provide context to both this work and myself as an artist.

http://feminapotens.org/wordpress/artist-statement-for-becoming-milf/

Madison Young commented on Aug 25 11 at 3:37 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

  • MailChimp

    Sign up for Babble

  • iPhone App Ad

  • Best of Babble.com


    Most Popular on Facebook

  • Aela Mass
  • Casi Densmore-Koon
  • Rebekah Kuschmider
  • CaitlinHTP (Caitlin Boyle)
  • Michelle Horton
  • Ceridwen Morris
  • Katie
  • Devan McGuinness
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Being Pregnant (50 of 5074 articles)