Babys First Year Blog

How Do I Get My 8-Month-Old To Drink Formula?

Posted by melissaejordan on January 24th, 2012 at 3:54 pm

formula1 How Do I Get My 8 Month Old To Drink Formula?Just one bottle a day. .. that’s all I need Arlo to take. One bottle of formula to supplement the endless pumping and nursing that is part of our daily routine. I’ve tried everything — supplements, pumping late at night, pumping early in the morning — and I’m still producing JUST enough to get us through every day. I have zero supply stored up and it’s been impossible to try to build on to it since he is nursing all the time. We attempted to give Arlo a soy formula supplemental bottle a few months back and he had a really bad reaction (projectile vomiting EVERYWHERE) and since then, I’ve literally been pumping like a mad woman and praying that we can stay on top of his needs.

Recently we tried to reintroduce a different formula: a milk-based one recommended by our pediatrician with no luck. He refuses to drink it. We’ve actually tried three different brands in the hopes of finding one he would take. There are some days that my husband has to come meet me at work halfway through the day to get more milk if he is extra hungry.  Arlo is eating 3 meals a day but is only drinking about 10 ounces of breast milk from 9am – 5pm. From 5pm – 9am he is nursing regularly — every 2 hours or so all night long. I feel like his eating schedule got flipped backwards (He should be eating a lot during the day and then going a longer time without over night feedings).

So a formula bottle would be a huge support in ensuring he is getting enough fluids during the day and to take some of the pressure off to pump enough … but I just have no idea how to get him to take it. My biggest concern is that I have a work trip on the horizon in March. 4 whole days away from home and I know I won’t have enough milk stored up to get him through the entire time.  We have to get him to take formula one way or another.

Any tips from other moms who have been through this? I just want him to take one, maybe two bottles a day of formula — I hope to breastfeed for a year (or really as long as he wants to) but I need a little help. Something has to give here!

Any tips would be greatly appreciated!

~M

Breastfeeding confidential: 10 things I wish someone had told me about lactation

 How Do I Get My 8 Month Old To Drink Formula?

35 Comments

i was having a hard time keeping up with our little guy’s demands too. and it was totally stressing me out… which i think we all probably know is a vicious cycle to lowering one’s supply. i finally saw the light when i decided to try mixing my breast milk and formula. i know some may disagree with this, but it’s working for us. i nurse in the mornings and evenings, but while he’s away at school, he gets bottles. those bottles all contain 4 oz breast milk and 2 oz of formula. little dude takes them like a champ. so my advice? maybe try disguising the formula with your breast milk. best of luck mama!

becca @ just one more trip commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:11 pm

Try mixing with a higher BM to formula ratio to start. He probably likes the sweet taste so slowly get him used to an all formula bottle. That’s what we had to do when we introduced out son to goat’s milk at 13 months.

CouRtenay commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:12 pm

When Teagan hit around 8 mths we had to start supplementing a little bit. I couldn’t keep up pumping. I was literally pumping for the next day and at one point it wasn’t enough. So, we started supplementing. Instead of doing whole bottles of formula I would mix in the formula with the bottles she took at daycare. This seemed to work better then a whole bottle. Good luck!

Rici commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:12 pm

Have you tried mixing the formula with breast milk? When my babe was in the hospital we had to supplement some formula and he wasn’t interested but we mixed it with breast milk. You could then try slowly shifting the ratios from more formula and less breast milk until it is just formula.

maggie commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:14 pm

I have a friend whose preemie baby needed to gain weight, and the doctors told her breast milk wasn’t going to give him everything he needed to put on weight as rapidly as they wanted. Their solution was to mix breast milk and formula half and half until he was a few months old, and then gradually they are taking the formula out of his bottles. I know your situation is different, but maybe mixing the formula with breast milk will help Arlo too. Maybe split one bottle of breast milk between two formula bottles at first, and then gradually increase the amount of formula into one of the bottles over a few weeks/month or so.

Ashley commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:15 pm

No tips for formula but have you thought about donated breastmilk? I know I have an oversupply and would have no problems donating if a friend ever needed it.

Betty commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:16 pm

Have you tried giving it to him from a straw? I’m pretty sure my girls were able to drink from A straw at 8 months. or try different bottles, or even a soppy cup.

Teresa commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:22 pm

I was going to suggest mixing it with bm too. Also make sure it is warm. What about putting it in a sippy cup?
Or what if you stored your milk in 4 oz bags and always added 2 oz of formula? (or whatever ratio for how many oz he drinks). At least that would stretch the bm throughout the day. I know some people say not to mix the two, but it helped get my son a full bottle when I only was pumping 4 oz. just make mix te formula with water, warm it and then add it to the warmed bm.

Shannon commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:22 pm

try to give it to him out of something other than a bottle. try sippy cups or i have had the best luck with the tommee tippee cups with straws. try it warm, cold, and room temperature. try mixing it with breastmilk so its mostly breastmilk. you could also try to make your own baby food and thin it out by using formula instead of breastmilk. that worked really well for my daughter. and dont give up, he has to get used to the taste of it so just keep trying it, and hopefully he will eventually start to develop a taste for it.

Jessica commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:22 pm

I

Cindy commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:24 pm

I know you say you’ve tried supplements, but I belong to a support group for women with low supply, and many swear by the recs in these books: Motherfood and Making More Milk, both available on Amazon. Also, you could look into donor milk instead of formula, on sites such as Eats on Feets for Human Milk for Human Babies. Good luck!

DeservingPorcupine commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:25 pm

When I needed to start supplementing, I mixed 1 oz of formula with 3 oz of breastmilk. After a few days I upped it to half and half. Now he’ll drink full formula bottles.

Katie commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:41 pm

Mixing breast milk and formula to start should help. Go very slow and he might not notice. Use a sweet formula like Similac, or try a drop or two of agave if you are using organic.

Jenn commented on Jan 24 12 at 4:44 pm

your child should be sleeping through the night by now. hell, my 3 week old daughter only wakes up twice at night. let him cry it out! not to mention, he should be eating solids, as in table food.

kari commented on Jan 24 12 at 7:22 pm

I gave my daughter 3different types of formula and she loved Similac.it doesn’t have that iron/metal taste/smell like the other formulas do.

Maria commented on Jan 25 12 at 12:05 am

If you STILL don’t have much luck by mixing breast milk with formula, you could try feeding it using a supplemental nursing system (SNS) which he may do better with at first. Then you could hopefully transition to using a bottle. I also wanted to suggest trying domperidone. I have low milk supply and we were having to supplement with a TON of formula. With domperidone I’m back to exclusively breastfeeding. Check out Dr. Jack Newman’s info. on domperidone. And I bought mine from inhousepharmacy.biz if you’re interested (recommended to me by a LLL leader).

Elle commented on Jan 25 12 at 8:28 am

10 oz between 9 and 5 is not bad..my 8 month old was drinking four 6 oz bottles a day- one in morning, one at lunch, one at about 4pm and one before bed. So if he’s on a 6 oz bottle, he’s just 2 oz shy…could you add 1 oz of formula to the 5 oz to make 6? It sounds like he’s just comfort nursing throughout the night, as a 2 oz deficit isn’t that much during the day to warrant nursing all night?

lauren commented on Jan 25 12 at 10:15 am

It took me forever to get my son to take a bottle (regardless of what was in it) when I went back to work. It was the most frustrating experience and made my heart heavy at work to know he was home starving himself for me. Ugh. It still brings up anxious feelings! I’m sure it seems like you have tried everything, I felt the same way. Honestly, I don’t think in the end it had anything to do with the bottle or the nipple or the way we held him, it just took plain time. Patience. He’ll figure it out, but until he does, I know it seems like the days are long and the battle ongoing. Hang in there. Another thing that I think did make a difference was the temperature. Make sure the formula is the same temp as the bottle of breast milk he’s getting. And you can try mixing part breast milk with part formula, adjusting the ratio to more formula than breast milk as he gets used to it. Hope this helps.
ashley @ http://www.thestorkandthebeanstalk.com

ashley commented on Jan 25 12 at 1:12 pm

My soon-to-be 1 year old daughter never took to formula from a bottle; she would gag every time. (To be fair, I did try the formula and it tastes of metal. At first I thought there was something wrong until I tried two other brands and it was the same.) I tried Enfamil and Good Start and both with no luck (I hate having huge containers of it opened and no where to go!). I did have better results with the liquid Similac organic; she would maybe drink 4 ounces at one sitting. All the books said she needed x ounces of milk/formula and as I was nursing, it was really impossible for me to know how much she was getting. And I know when I pumped, I didn’t get more than 3-5 ounces at a time.

If your son is having cereal and you’re worried about total ounces, I would add the formula to his rice/oatmeal/barley. That’s a good way to sneak in more ounces.

My doctor never seemed concerned with her needing more milk. And she was continually on the smaller side of the growth charts. I really wasn’t a fan of formula because it tasted nothing like breast milk (yes, I’ve tried) and had that awful metal taste. I didn’t want to use it, even in her cereal, and my doctor said she was fine. He never made it seem like I really had to supplement or else.

The above ideas of mixing is something I wish I tried though, again, I did have some real problems with the formula itself. So maybe I never really gave it too much of a real chance.

Lastly, if you want to try to increase your milk output, have you tried the organic tea Mother’s Milk? I used that as well as kelp pills (something about the iodine that is supposed to be good for nursing output). Both seemed to help my milk supply.

@AliceinOmaha commented on Jan 25 12 at 3:55 pm

Reverse cycling is hard!
My 7 month old only drinks 10 oz when I’m at work (9-430) — we nurse twice before and twice after, and (usually) once in the middle of the night. He was nursing more often in the MOTN, but then we followed Weissbluth’s sleep training and now I know when he wakes up hungry–which is never more than once a night. He can get all he needs with the 4 daytime nursing sessions (6am, 8:45am, 4:30pm, 6:45pm) and the 2 five ounce bottles when I’m gone.
This means I can pump at night, which obviously you can’t if he’s waking every two hours. Oh, and my LO doesn’t eat any solids (we’ve tried…he has no interest)

So, yeah, I’d guess try mixing as suggested by everyone who commented when you first posted, plus sleep training (assuming he’s gaining enough weight an the doctor gives you the go ahead).

good luck!

Heidi commented on Jan 25 12 at 4:26 pm

my baby is 8 month old too and i was always worrying if she got enough breastmilk, i pumped for quite some time at night to store milk for the next day but it was always just 80ml or so, she drank the whole day so there was no point in pumping during the day, since she started to eat solids i just stopped worrying, she has always been healthy, never under weight (right at the average mark) so why worry?
you have to consider that your milk always changes, once your baby starts to eat solids the content of your milk adapts so you may produce less but still have enough nutrients in it for your baby, if you are worrying about hydration give him some water or unsweetened tee with his solids, that should be enough to keep him hydrated and his stool soft
i have to say i wouldn’t go cold turkey and leave my still breastfeeding baby for 4 days, he obviously still needs you very much and makes up for lost time during the night (drinking a lot during the night doesn’t only have to mean that he needs your milk but also just you), even if he starts taking bottles leaving him for that long will be a HUGE and very sudden adjustment
i would also contact your local la leche league leader and talk to her for guidance, good luck

zoesmumlizs commented on Jan 25 12 at 4:58 pm

I am confused if he was still hungry with your husband why didn’t your husband just feed him more food? Give him some water to drink, it will be one of the best habits that he can get in, plus he can hold onto a bottle or a sippy cup on his own and maybe he will start drinking formula – in another month he will be old enough to drink milk. There is no way a 8 month old needs to be nursing every 2 hours at night – that is something you need to work on like getting your husband to soothe him back to sleep instead of nursing. That’s a habit not hunger.

Lissa commented on Jan 25 12 at 5:40 pm

Try mixing the formula with breast milk, a little more each time. My daughter would only drink Similar organic (with the green lid) and I did a taste test – it tasted better, sweeter – more like mommy’s milk! It was the ONLY kind she would drink. It has organic cane sugar in it.

Mary Beth commented on Jan 26 12 at 8:59 am

mixing BM & formula worked for us!

jen commented on Jan 26 12 at 9:15 am

I work outside the home and my 10-month-old daughter won’t take any brand of formula either. At 9 months, our pediatrician recommended adding whole milk yogurt and cheese to her diet. It satisfies her and has helped take some of the pressure off me to pump. We just make sure she hydrates with water in her sippy cup during the day.

Jennifer commented on Jan 26 12 at 12:41 pm

The discussion of frequent night feeding came up recently at my La Leche League meeting. Often, babies get so distracted with all the fun stuff that they do during the day, they essentially “forget to eat”. Happens sometimes with our little one too.
Lots of suggestions for it already, but try mixing breast milk with the formula. Try using a sippy cup/straw cup that is very different from breast/bottle. Also, try offering the formula cold, right out of the fridge. As an adult, I can’t stand milk unless it’s super cold (warm milk? ew). Your little one bit be the same!

TK commented on Jan 26 12 at 1:38 pm

Someone suggested goats milk to me when I was weaning my daughter instead of formula. Have you read into this? It is more identical to breast milk then cows milk or formula.

Christi commented on Jan 27 12 at 4:53 am

I second the goat milk suggestion. At nine months, I wasn’t pumping enough for my oldest to take to daycare, so we supplemented with goats milk until she was a year. It smells like feta, but for whatever reason, she preferred it to formula (and her ped recommended it). My baby is going to be 9 months next week and I’m going on my first overnight business trip. I’m going to get some goats milk this weekend to try it out. The baby also won’t take formula.

I will say though – bad sleepers are bad sleepers regardless – it’s probably not that he’s hungry. Both my girls have nursed all.night.long. regardless of how much they eat. They just like to comfort nurse.

http://www.kimonobaby.blogspot.com

jess commented on Jan 27 12 at 11:32 am

Start mixing some formula in with breast milk. I started with half an ounce to an ounce of formula with 3-4 oz of breast milk. They can barely taste it and then I just started to increase it gradually. The pediatrician said that was fine to mix them together. :)

Sarah commented on Jan 27 12 at 2:09 pm

Mine just never ever would. I hope this isn’t the case for you!

Ashleigh commented on Jan 27 12 at 2:49 pm

We tried the half breast milk and half formula and it worked very well. Now my 9 month old has 2 full formula bottles a day while at work and I nurse the rest of the time- no more pumping- yay! We also really like the formula we are using, its organic and the only one on the market that is not corn syrup based but brown rice sweetened- Babys Only. We use the soy kind but I know they have dairy. Its on the pricey side but my baby just chugs it down and is helping me tremendously. Hope this helps!

Annie commented on Jan 27 12 at 4:37 pm

OMG, I’ll never understand how bloggers like you Melissa, have the strength to ignore the haters. It’s amazing to me that some mothers think that just because their child was a certain way, obviously every child can be the exact same way! Um, NO. And what worked for you won’t necessarily work for me or her. Duh. Because if life were that simple, we’d all be RICH and SKINNY and BEAUTIFUL. Oh, and HAPPY. And not interested in telling other people what they’re doing wrong! :)

Anywho, I was curious which supplements you’ve tried? I know you’ve probably tried it all but one I found that really worked for me and was super gentle on the digestive track (something fenugreek isn’t) was the Dr. Tori Hudson Lactation Blend. If you haven’t tried it, it might be worth it. You can buy it at Whole Foods on the West Coast but probably any health food store carries it.

Good luck!

Robyn commented on Jan 27 12 at 10:58 pm

Seeing your baby refuse to eat is so stressful and all mom’s go through it eventually. It’s unfortunate that some women have chosen to judge you when you’re clearly asking for ideas. Who has the right to decide when another mom’s child should be sleep training or eating table food? These time lines and techniques aren’t for everyone. Didn’t we all learn that if we don’t have something nice to say, we shouldn’t say anything at all? Anyway, that being said I would suggest the same thing some of the other moms have said. Half breast milk and half formula worked great for our son when my supply started to slow down around the 8 month mark. I also noticed he preferred the organic similac brand over any of the others. Good luck, I hope you’re able to find something that works.

Cecilia commented on Jan 28 12 at 11:55 am

I agree with mixing breastmilk with formula, however make sure you make an amount that he will be sure to finish. If he doesn’t drink the entire bottle, you have to toss the formula as it will spoil. Then you are left losing your “gold” breastmilk. I always kept my bottles seperate just because of that. I am in the same boat… Pumping and barely staying afloat. My four month old eats 8 ounces 5 times a day… I can’t possibly pump that much, so she gets 50/50 most days. I just have to feel good about that, we do what we can do!

Natalie Batesole commented on Jan 28 12 at 2:57 pm

Hey love..

I didn’t read all the comments, but Scarlett had the same reaction to soy formula.. It was so tramatic, I thought she was dying.. She got so exhausted.. pale, limp and unresponsive. :-/

We waited a few months before trying another option. When we’re apart, date night or such, the grandparents have had success giving her any of the Similac formulas.

I’m not sure how to correct the opposite eating behavior. Scarlett is pretty bad at sleeping at night and wants to eat every few hours.. I am pretty sure it started when she started to teeth.. So ya.. She hasn’t slept through the night in 5 months.

My only guess for accepting formula is ratio mix it with the breast milk.. Mostly breast milk in the beginning and then mostly formula in that one bottle.

Good luck <3<3

<3xojo

Jordan Marie Schilleci commented on Feb 06 12 at 1:15 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Lauren Hartmann
  • Arianne Segerman
  • Emily Elling
  • Crissy Page
  • Ali Smith
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Emily Malone
  • Danielle Elwood
  • Molly Thornberg
  • Selena Burgess
  • Melissa Jordan
  • Casey Mullins
  • Roni Noone
  • Madeline Petersen
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Babys First Year Blog (50 of 2684 articles)