Babys First Year Blog
Adventures in Babywearing: Moby vs. Ergo
My boy is a tummy snuggler!
A few weeks ago I didn’t even know that “babywearing” was a phrase. But now that I’ve been hanging out with a newborn for almost three weeks, I know that its not only a phrase, it is also a lifesaver.
Cullen, like many babies, does not like to be put down. He is happiest when snuggled up against my chest like a little bug – much like he used to be when he was still hanging out in utero.
We have a nice little swing for him that he can be tricked into napping in, but usually his swing sessions end in tears.
If I never needed to eat, use the bathroom, feed the dogs, or do anything else in my day, I’d be happy to sit and snuggle him 24 hours a day. But realistically, there are times when I need at least one free hand, ideally two.
Enter babywearing.
Whether I am in the house, working at my counter bar, taking a stroll through the neighborhood, or eating breakfast out in town – Cullen is happy and content when he is strapped to my chest in one of my babywearing devices. My goal is to get him out of the house at least once every single day. I want to expose him to fresh air, new sounds, warm sunshine, and different surroundings. Having a few different carrier options makes this so enjoyable for both of us – our walks are the best part of my days!
So what am I wearing him in? Right now I have two of the well-known babywearing items – the Moby Wrap and the Ergo. There are pros and cons to both, and I use them for different purposes. Here are my thoughts on each…
The Moby Wrap
When I put this on the first time, I thought there was no way I would end up actually using it. It comes as about 15 feet of fabric that you have to twist and tie all around your body. It’s confusing, it’s cumbersome, and it seems totally impractical. I tossed it in a basket and ignored it for a week.
Eventually, after being encouraged by a few other new moms not to give up on it, I watched a few YouTube videos of how to put it on properly and tried it again. MUCH easier than reading the instruction booklet.
Let’s look at the both the good and the bad…
Pros:
- Great fit for newborns – so snuggly and the lack of structure allows fabric to hug the baby’s body tightly.
- Lightweight – lack of bulk means you can put an outer layer (like a cardigan or puffy vest) on over the wrap for going outside.
- Inexpensive – at $40, this wrap is much cheaper than the Ergo.
Cons:
- Awkward to put on – even though I know how to do it easily now, the long hanging fabric would make this difficult to put on outside of the house.
- Limited life – while this is perfect for my little nine pound baby, I can’t see me using beyond a few months from now.
Overall:
I tend to wear the Moby Wrap when I’m in the house working, because it’s more comfortable and less bulky than the Ergo. I’ll also wear it out to breakfast or a coffee shop, but only if I can put it on in the house before we leave. I like that it is lightweight, and Cullen sleeps really well in it because it fits his body so snuggly. Honestly, who wouldn’t love looking down at this all afternoon?
The ERGObaby Carrier
I put Cullen in the Ergo for the first time when he was just three days old. My sister, Rebecca, swears by the Ergo and takes my nephew everywhere in it, so I was hopeful that it would work well for us too. I did not end up getting the infant insert that is sold as an additional piece. Instead Rebecca taught me her trick – I take a baby blanket and roll it up like little log and stuff it into the bottom of the carrier. Then I (carefully) drop Cullen in on top of it, and it forms a little seat for him to sit on with his legs dangling down the sides. Works like a charm, and makes the bulky $40 infant insert totally unnecessary.
Pros:
- Very easy and quick to put on – a HUGE pro in my book. Can easily be taken out for a shopping trip and put on quickly in a parking lot (unlike the Moby).
- Zip pocket for storage – I usually pack this with my phone, keys, a pacifier, a credit card, and chapstick. It’s so nice to not have to take anything additional with me.
- Long lifespan – the Ergo can be used with newborns as well as babies that are several years old. This thing lasts a long time!
- Very versatile – we’ve only used the front position so far since Cullen still can’t support his own head, but eventually it can be worn on the side and the back as well.
Cons:
- Expensive – in fact, I think it’s the most expensive baby carrier I’ve seen. With that said, I still think it is worth every penny.
- Bulky – this isn’t as comfortable to sit and work in because the fabric is so much thicker and more padded.
- Heavier – this could also be a pro in the dead of winter, but in the meantime the heavier fabric makes both of us much hotter when we’re out for a walk.
Overall:
I love the Ergo, and plan to carry Cullen around in it for a long time to come. It is my first choice when going for a walk outdoors, mostly because it’s a bit sturdier and I really like the extra zip pouch. Today I was extra brave and took Cullen AND both dogs for a long walk. Everyone loved it.
My goal is to put my baby down as little as possible, and having wraps and carriers makes that so much easier. I know that there will come a time when he no longer needs to be snuggled up on my chest. Until that day comes, I’m going to keep walking, keep snuggling, and keep babywearing.
As my babywearing adventures continue, I’m considering getting an additional sling. Can anyone recommend a good one, or another favorite carrier/wrap?
Go Back To Babys First Year Blog
27 Comments
em commented on Nov 11 11 at 1:26 pmConsider a Kinderpack:
http://www.kindercarry.com/It’s sooooo much better than an Ergo and it costs the same. They’re all handmade by a mom named Melissa. If you go on http://www.thebabywearer.com you’ll see lots of discussion about Kinderpacks and many people sell them used.
Also, if you like wraps, try a woven wrap instead of the Moby. The Moby is so tricky because it’s stretchy. If you use a woven wrap like a Girasol (def look for one used) it’s super comfortable and can support bigger babies.
Sara commented on Nov 11 11 at 2:04 pmI have a Moby, an Ergo, a Maya wrap (ring sling), and a mei tai. I love them all for different situations/weather. My 20 lb 5-month-old still does fine in all of them. The mei tai is definitely the best for the money (about $20 at Target) – comfortable, versatile, and easy to put on. The Ergo is the only one that is good past 25-30 lbs, though.
kristin k. commented on Nov 11 11 at 2:12 pmI loved the moby when my son was 0 – 6 months. Around 6 months he didn’t seem to want to be in the moby anymore. I did think it was a little tricky but once you get used to it a cinch! Starting around 6 months it was ergo all the way. I love the Ergo and still use it comfortably now with my son and he is 14 months. I didn’t think it was the most expensive carrier. I have the ERGO sport which is a lighter fabric.
Jennie commented on Nov 11 11 at 3:47 pmI LOVE LOVE LOVE my Ergo! Soooooooo comfortable. Couldn’t have made it the first year without it. We went through SIX carriers until I came upon the Ergo. I got the Petunia Picklebottom design too, it’s GORGEOUS!
Reina Chadwick commented on Nov 11 11 at 4:28 pmHi Emily,
I would suggest you try a Baby K’tan next. Why? Well, it is like a wrap without all the wrapping! I’d love to tell you more!
pontificatrix commented on Nov 11 11 at 4:58 pmI swap between Sleepy Wrap (same idea as the Moby – mostly around the house) and Maya Wrap (ring sling – easy in and out for car trips, etc) for young infant; Angelpack (like a mei tai only with buckles instead of ties) after 6 mo. Ergo is too bulky for me. I love the Angelpack bc it is sleek and no-fuss for the back carry; downside is you can’t do front-facing-out carries.
Jacque commented on Nov 11 11 at 5:44 pmMy ergo mostly stayed in the car for trips out of the house because your right about it being much faster and when they get a little older you’ll love the side and back carry. The moby is wonderful for around the house and when they get a little older they love facing out, watching while you cook, vacuume or whatever. My 23lbs 14 month old still hangs out in the ergo quite a bit cuz I hate strollers but we mostly do the side or back carry these days. Love baby wearing!
Erin commented on Nov 11 11 at 6:03 pmI use the Balboa Baby sling. It’s VERY easy to put on and to put the baby in. My little one loves it and usually gets rocked to sleep. It’s a great compromise we worked out – Connor is happy because I don’t have to set him down and I can easily get things done!
Emily commented on Nov 11 11 at 7:08 pmMy 5 month old also loves being cuddled and we have both the moby and the ergo too! At 5 months, he still fits great in the moby and it’s still very comfortable to wear. If I want to use it outside of the house, I will “pre-wrap” it on myself so it doesn’t drag on the ground. I do love my ergo for when we’re out and about, but I think the moby is more comfortable for us still. Yay for baby wearing!
Hollie commented on Nov 11 11 at 7:19 pmI looooove my Ergo, and only used the Moby for about 5 weeks (just too clunky, but perfect for the new-newborn). I have a Hotsling I got at a consignment shop and think it is a GREAT sling. I still use it with a hip-carry for my 10 month old when I don’t want to pack the bulky Ergo.
Meredith commented on Nov 11 11 at 10:36 pmI love my mei-tai! I also used a ring sling when my daughter was littler… Now she is a little squirmy for it to be comfortable.
Angela commented on Nov 12 11 at 3:37 amSakura Bloom sling. Gorgeous fabrics and very comfy so far (have 8 week old).
Maude commented on Nov 12 11 at 6:20 pmI have a wrap and an Ergo. I like both but I love my Sakura Bloom ring sling : easy to put on, many positions for the baby… And it’s so pretty!
O commented on Nov 12 11 at 10:16 pmCan you post a pic of the towel roll? We have an ergo and I find the insert a pain in the a** but love the ergo otherwise.
lornadoone commented on Nov 13 11 at 1:34 amI use a “Sprout Pouch,” which is a single-piece sling (no rings). It is incredibly easy and convenient, folds up really small, and works for kiddos from teeny-tiny to toddler. I cannot recommend it highly enough for ease of use and comfort for the babies. I was never really interested in Attachment Parenting, but it turns out that my first baby was. I used that sling almost constantly for 2 1/2 years and am now on baby #2 with the same one!
Jamethiel commented on Nov 13 11 at 10:48 amI loved my Moby for the first few months of my son’s life. We lived in Vermont & he was born in February, and it was nice to be able to snuggle him in the Moby & pull my down coat over both of us for a walk, anything to relieve the cabin fever! But as we began to get out and travel more the Moby just took too long and was too awkward to put on while in a parking lot, and then my son got heavier. Enter the uncertain period. We went through the Kelty Kangaroo (a beefy kind of Bjorn) and the Jeep carrier (just like a Bjorn) and a Sherpani Rumbi Superlight (a backpack carrier we still use for hiking, but that is way too cumberson and large for daily use in our tiny city car). My friend who had a son a little older swore her Ergo was the best thing in the world, so I skimped & was able to pick up a basic tan Ergo after trying on a Boba and an Ergo.
There are so many great things to say about the Ergo, but for me it boils down to this: My son loves his Ergo, I love my Ergo. ‘Nuff said!
Lisa commented on Nov 13 11 at 1:43 pmFor my first baby I wore her in the ergo, Moby and the Bjorn. LOVED all of them. My 3 week old LOVES to be worn as well. She falls right to sleep when she hears my heart beating.
Chelsea Bailey commented on Nov 13 11 at 4:51 pmI used a Snugli with my second son. I would put my first son in the stroller, the baby in the Snugli and we were all set, every was contained and content and I had both my hands free. I had big babies so it didn’t take too long before he outgrew it, there are days I really miss that. Anyone considering it should practice around the house a bit to get familiar with putting it on, getting it adjusted, getting the baby in safely. Those are lessons you don’t want to have to learn standing in a parking lot.
Katy E commented on Nov 13 11 at 7:18 pmI have a baby carrier/diaper bag combo from go-babyz and I LOVE it. I’ve used a moby before and loved it for littles but now that I have a toddler and a 6 month old, the carrier/diaperbag combo has changed my life. It can be used up to 30 lbs too. I’d look into it for when you have two close in age and worry that you can’t keep the uncooperative toddler safe AND hold the infant while in a parking lot.
Amy commented on Nov 13 11 at 7:46 pmI got the Moby before my friend turned me onto the Kangaroo Korner adjustable fleece pouch – the thing RULES! It is so snuggly and easy to put on – also comes in a mesh weight for hot weather. We lived in that up until about 9 months i think. THere were alternate carrying positions, but didn’t seem that secure. After that we were all Ergo all the way. She is now 2.5 and I still love the Ergo!
Amanda commented on Nov 13 11 at 8:25 pmI love the Moby and the Ergo for my 3-month-old, but I have given up on using the Moby out of the house. I also love my Maya ring sling. It is SO easy to get the baby in quickly, and she loves to sleep in it. It isn’t truly hands free unless you get it really tight, but it is so cozy and versatile. The tail end that hangs down can work as a nursing cover, too.
Adriana commented on Nov 13 11 at 10:19 pmBaby k’tan! Saw a happy baby in one @ theplaydate supermarket and couldnt resist. Got mine 2 weeks ago and it is the best! Lightweight, easy to put on, my son loooves it and it is supposed to work for an up to 25lb baby!
Tammy M. commented on Nov 13 11 at 10:46 pmRight before Halloween this year, I took my 18lb, 9mo daughter for a visit to the pumpkin patch. I wore my MOBY WRAP and carried her front facing so she could see everything! She LOVED it! BTW…I was 18 weeks pregnant at the time. ( I have a very big, very high, pregnant belly….and it was still very very comfortable) I tried the Ergo and it was so uncomfortable. I know other moms around town that carry their 1 & 2 year olds in the MOBY wrap. We’re a MOBY wrap town!!
tracy commented on Nov 14 11 at 12:55 amThanks for helping me decide. I”m going with the Ergo.
Maggie commented on Nov 14 11 at 9:45 amWe preferred the Baby K’tan over the Moby for the newborn stage. The K’tan is just so much easier to use than a wrap, but you can wear baby in the exact same positions. absolutely love how simple and cozy it is.
Sara commented on Nov 14 11 at 7:42 pmI love my moby wrap so much. You get pretty quick at putting it on, and it is so comfortable. I also keep a ring sling in the car for quick trips in and out of stores, but I’m a moby girl all the way.
Max commented on Nov 15 11 at 11:09 amdefinitely worth it to try the K’tan, b/c it would immediately eliminate one of your two CONS you listed for the Moby:
Cons:
Awkward to put on – even though I know how to do it easily now, the long hanging fabric would make this difficult to put on outside of the house.No long hanging fabric and no need to wear it all day, in your car, or before you leave yoru house. I throw mine in my diaper bag b/c all it really is, is an already wrapped wrap (moby or other).. and the final end result in all of them is wonderful – as that is the ultimate goal.
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Lauren Jimeson
Lauren Hartmann
Emily Elling
Meredith Carroll
Emily Malone
Molly Thornberg
Selena Burgess
Casey Mullins
Madeline Petersen
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

27