Babys First Year Blog

So, Now I’m Going to Hell for Letting My Kid Sleep in a Car Seat? Oy

Posted by meredith carroll on November 10th, 2011 at 10:00 am
IMG 0306 214x300 So, Now I’m Going to Hell for Letting My Kid Sleep in a Car Seat? Oy

Can we just let sleeping babies lie, no matter where they're sleeping?

I keep waiting for the Angry Parenting Gods to rain down on me because I just don’t chit chat much with my 10-week-old baby, Peony.

And now I’m doing double waiting duty. Who knew letting your baby sleep in the car seat was a cardinal sin?

I mean, when I told the pediatrician at one of our early visits that Peony wouldn’t sleep in the bassinet, she just shrugged and said to let her sleep in the car seat if that worked better (which it did). She’s since moved to the bassinet, but that doesn’t mean the car seat isn’t our constant back-up plan. Is that so terrible? Apparently it is.

We went away for the weekend last month and even though I brought the sleep positioners with us, Peony wouldn’t sleep in the Pack ‘N Play. But she would sleep in the car seat. Problem solved, right? Apparently not.

I’ve been reading lately about the perils of babies spending too much time in their car seats. From flat heads (which is not just about flat heads, apparently, which is news to me) to difficulty breathing — sleeping in car seats is a new no-no. It’s a wonder my daughter survived the 3-hour car trip, not to mention a few nights in her car seat.

Like the perils of crib bumpers, however, I’m also debating ignoring the new warnings on too much time spent in the car seat. My older daughter survived lots of time with both of them — crib bumpers and car seats — without incident. I feel like my younger daughter will survive them both, too.

Or do I really need to rethink letting my sleeping baby lie if she’s doing it in a car seat (and she’s happy!)? Please say no. Please say no.

Do you let your baby sleep in a car seat, even when you’re not in a car? If so, do you feel like you’re doing more harm then good?

Image: Meredith Carroll

 So, Now I’m Going to Hell for Letting My Kid Sleep in a Car Seat? Oy

20 Comments

As someone who has had refluxy kids I can tell you the car seat was a saving grace for sleep. Also if they had colds. You can’t prop their head up with a pillow so the slight incline of the car seat works great. Now I had a son who had a flat head too. Let me tell you a flat head in itself will do no actual mental damage to your child. The only difficulty I was told I’d have with my son is fitting a helmet or hats to his head. He was in a helmet for around 7 months to reshape his head. It looks much better by the way, but sleeping in the car seat was not the cause of his mishapen head. It was because we couldn’t get him to stay on his tummy. We didn’t find out until it was already too late that his extreme hate of tummy time (and I mean the second he was on his tummy he screamed in excruciating pain) that it was because of reflux. So make sure you get your tummy time in everyday and sleeping in the carseat is not going to be the cause of a flat head.

Monica commented on Nov 10 11 at 10:07 am

Sometimes it’s the only way I can get Elliott to nap!!

http://apaprikao.blogspot.com/

Anjie commented on Nov 10 11 at 10:13 am

I think you can stick with what’s working. I used the Fisher Price Rock n Play sleeper thing for almost six months, even though tons of parents said it flattened their kids’ heads. She slept awesomely in that, then transitioned into the crib perfectly… when she was ready for it. Sometimes they just need that incline! PS, adorable nubbly little pumpkin outfit!
http://www.themombat.blogspot.com

Hollie commented on Nov 10 11 at 10:30 am

My kids with reflux got the ok from the pedi to sleep in their carseats and they did just fine, no flat heads.

Teri commented on Nov 10 11 at 10:39 am

I never did but I see NOTHING wrong with me! I’m shocked that people find something wrong with it?

Darlene L commented on Nov 10 11 at 11:23 am

If mine was in the car seat and fell asleep, he stayed asleep in the car seat! I was told it wasn’t good for them to be in it a lot because they were scrunched up, but as long as he was happy, momma was happy.

Megan commented on Nov 10 11 at 11:24 am

That seems silly. Most of my friends have let their kids sleep in car seats for naps, overnight, or to battle reflux. I will concede that -maybe- it depends on the car seat, but even then, I’m not really so sure.

I’d rather have a well rested baby who is not suffering from a cold or reflux because I refuse to let her nap in her seat. Silly.

TheCreativeHomestead.com commented on Nov 10 11 at 11:36 am

When it is sometimes the only way to get my kid to nap? Sleep deprivation is an issue too.

SarahB commented on Nov 10 11 at 11:43 am

I am thankful for all of the necessary and life saving advancements that have been made in baby care, but all of this PC garbage is ridiculous. common sense. if your pediatrician gave it the ok and your baby catches some z’s in her seat- then mommy hell is where I’d like to be. because at least in mommy hell I’d have a well rested baby. and the real hell is a baby who’s not.

Megan commented on Nov 10 11 at 12:49 pm

i think whatever works- and this is even doctor approved! if i listened to every ‘expert mom’ or parenting blog that says co-sleeping is the only way- no wait- co-sleeping is dangerous- blah blah blah i would be changing my parenting tactics by the hour! at the moment the tactic is take the easiest path as long as my dr is cool with it and it feels right for me!

Taz commented on Nov 10 11 at 1:12 pm

The carseat was one of the first parenting tips I got while I was pregnant. I never had to use it, but it was always in the back of my mind if I needed to!

Teresa commented on Nov 10 11 at 1:23 pm

My baby slept in her carseat from about 5 weeks until about 3 months. And the keep word is “SLEPT.” It was the only way that she would sleep. Our pediatrician wasn’t crazy about it and told us to be careful. Eventually she hit a sleep regression and wouldn’t really sleep anywhere, so I transitioned her to her crib. She now sleeps just fine (and with a round head) in her crib most of the time, but we still use her swing as backup. And if she falls asleep in the carseat, she stays there.

I say whatever works. It’s all about survival. Your baby will grow out of it or you will transition eventually.

http://www.acraftybalance.com

Libby commented on Nov 10 11 at 1:25 pm

If sleeping in a carseat is dangerous to their breathing, then how in the world are they considered safe for driving?! Every infant sleeping in their carseat while driving… and I can’t see that it would make any difference if the carseat is inside your house while she dozes. But, this is coming from the mom of a tummy-sleeper… ;-)
http://www.thehappinessofrainydays.blogspot.com

Laura commented on Nov 10 11 at 10:48 pm

I wondered the same thing Laura.

My baby slept exclusively in his bouncy seat from 2 months to 4 months. I admitted this sheepishly to the doc and she said it would probably help reverse the flattening of his head, noted at his 2 month visit. I don’t know if it was the bouncy chair or just time, but his head seems pretty round now.

Meagan commented on Nov 10 11 at 11:37 pm

I will try anything that allows any of us to get some sleep including putting him on his changing pad on the floor or the changing pad in our bed between me and my husband, the car seat, the pack and play. If we ever get around to putting the swing/rocker thing together then I would be willing to try that too. Whatever works at the moment. My son always sounds congested at night and sitting upright just makes more sense. i would think the car seat would prevent flat head since the head doesn’t have as much pressure in that position. I say do what works.

Rachel commented on Nov 11 11 at 2:17 am

my babe slept in his bouncy seat (even at night) until he was 4 months. then he got to big for the bouncy seat so he upgraded to the car seat until 6 months. he had bad reflux so it was best for him to sleep in this position. doc said it was fine and his head has always been nice and round. ;)

sallie commented on Nov 14 11 at 1:02 pm

my first child was always sick…he cried alot..and he had stomach aches and gassy….it was awful…and never slept in his car seat….my second and third child…….they slept in their car seats because they would cry and would not lay flat on their backs , side or anything..I never..had a problem with flat heads…my children are grown and are fine and normal…I say do what works and use common sense…all 3 of my kids had crib bumpers…I always had a fan on in the room..I personally can not sleep with out the white noise or the circulation of air in the room…I think sometimes…these so called experts…get alittle carried away…speaking as a grandmother of a baby who passed away last year of SIDS…some times…awful bad things just happen…and there is no answers, no reasons, just a night mare that came true…I am expecting twins in April…my boys will have bumpers…and sleep in their car seat if that is what works…I do not fear losing one of them for those reasons..

lagatalopez commented on Dec 09 11 at 7:07 pm

My oldest son has a flat spot on his head we traveled a lot and he would keep his head one spot I didnt know anything about flat spots a postioning until someone noticed his flat spot better, but as long as there getting plenty of tummy time to I dont see anything wrong I have two other children and have since learned from my mistakes and they beautiful round heads.

angela commented on Dec 16 11 at 1:20 pm

my daughter wouldn’t sleep laying flat because she had an ear infection if you lay her down she’d instantly wake screaming when i told the doctor this he suggested that because of the air pressure it might hurt her to lay flat and to try propping her with a blanket or pillow when i being paranoid new mom said “but isn’t that dangerous, all the books and everyone says blankets in the crib can cause SIDS because of rebreathing or whatever” he then suggested i use the car seat or one of those vibrating infant seat things worked great and to this day she prefers to sleep sitting up and bent forward like a doll that flopped over after being sat up on the floor then sometimes she sleeps sprawled out on her stomach arms through the crib bars and feet stretched behind her through the bars on the other side (she wont sleep end to end she sleeps side to side)

Samira commented on Dec 24 11 at 11:27 am

I feel that on occasion, or get you thru an illness or with reflux you should be fine. I do see babies that virtually never leave the darn things. At home, in the car, at night, everywhere. I would imagine when the Dr.’s start asking about how much time the poor baby with the flat head spends in it, parents clam up and don’t admit it is more like 18 to 20 hours a day. They probably say, well he/she just sleeps there for naps. I only used the carrier style for about a month with my second child, and for about three months with my third. Not fond of them and they were too hard on my back. I see why some people like them. I see and understand why some babies need them, like with reflux. But people would you like to spend hours on end strapped into a seated position? Even when you take a road trip ow long is it before you need to stop and stretch? I also had a bassinet style stroller for my babies, I found it was no problem to get the sleeping baby out of the car, and into the stroller where they fell right back asleep. Since it is how I treated them since birth they could care less. But once they were awake they could roll, and wiggle, and stretch. I would just swaddle the littlest so they didn’t flop around. JMO

Heidi commented on Jan 31 12 at 10:52 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Lauren Jimeson
  • Lauren Hartmann
  • Emily Elling
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Emily Malone
  • Molly Thornberg
  • Selena Burgess
  • Casey Mullins
  • Madeline Petersen
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Babys First Year Blog (50 of 3276 articles)