Babys First Year Blog

In Which We Band Together and Discuss Nipple Flow.

Posted by caseymullins on August 10th, 2011 at 12:13 pm

Preview1 207x300 In Which We Band Together and Discuss Nipple Flow.Look down at your boobs. Now look at the nipple aisle at any baby store. Look down. Look at the massive wall of nipples. Look down one more time for good measure. Wall of nipples. It seems to me (correct me if I’m wrong) that boobs really only have one flow setting. So knowing that there are several different choices when it comes to bottle feeding nipples? I am overwhelmed.

You see, I am trying to keep the bottle feeding relationship I have with Vivi as close to the breastfeeding relationship we were never really able to have. If getting quicker flow nipples is simply a way to get bigger feedings out of the way faster then no thank you! I want to spend all the time possible curled up with my little baby feeding her. Not firehosing it down her throat in an effort to get on with life faster, I have the next 80 years for that crap. Let the time with my tiny baby be the time that goes slowly.

Honestly I haven’t really looked into it (aka asked google) because I figured I’d ask you. Those of you with boobs that have worked and those of you with boobs that have not worked and those of you somewhere in between. Do they really flow faster as your baby requires bigger feedings (side note: Vivi’s going through a growth spurt or she’s getting the serious munchies from California contact highs. CHOW. HOUND.) or do feedings just take longer at this phase before you move onto solid foods and milk intake drops down a bit?

You’d think I hadn’t done this before. But oh with Addie. OH WITH THAT FIRST ONE. Let’s just say I’m lucky I survived. So this time I’m taking a slightly different more proactive approach.

Nipples, to fast flow or to stay slow flow? That is my question.

 In Which We Band Together and Discuss Nipple Flow.

17 Comments

[...] In which we band together and discuss nipple flow. (Verdict, level 1 it is!) [...]

moosh in indy. » *hiccup*…elsewhere…*hiccup* commented on Aug 12 11 at 12:33 am

It’s not so much that the milk flows faster, but that babies become more efficient in their sucking which allows them to eat more at a quicker pace.

I had two very different nursing experiences (my first was breastfed until 9+ months and my second was only breastfed for 3 months). In both instances both took bottles starting around 3 or 4 weeks. I followed their cues and didn’t change to a faster flowing nipple until they showed signs of frustration during bottle time.

I say as long as Vivi seems content with the flow, no need to change anything.

tehamy commented on Aug 10 11 at 12:22 pm

I don’t know a thing about bottles, but I think maybe babies become more efficient nursers as they get older. Honestly, each of my kids nursed so differently right from the start, I’m not sure there is a “normal.” And my mom swears my brother weaned himself when she started supplementing him before bed because once he figured out he could get the milk faster, he didn’t want to go back to that slowpoke boob.

My guess is that part of it is increased efficiency, and part of it is supplementing with purees and table foods.

Not that any of that helps to answer your nipple question :)

Becky commented on Aug 10 11 at 12:33 pm

My daughter used newborn flow nipples until she was 14 months old and done with the bottle.

(Background: Tried to breastfeed, she hated my boobs and wouldn’t latch, pumped exclusively for 10 months before my boobs gave me the finger and said “DONE” and could only pump about an ounce – both sides – per session, then gave her formula from 10mos – 12mos).

I tried to switch her to different flows several times just because I felt I SHOULD, but she was never happy with it. So maybe just wait until you get a cue from Vivi?

I would start with newborn and just see what works for her.

bessie.viola commented on Aug 10 11 at 12:33 pm

For bottles – faster nipple = bigger hole (or sometimes 3 holes)

We had to go to faster flow nipples because we had to add cereal to the formula to thicken it and help with reflux (with all 4 of my kids). And logic would tell you that the 3 hole fast flow nipples won’t work for that because the cereal can’t flow through easily. But yeah…I am not always logical, so it took me a few very frustrated feedings to figure that one out.

Bridget commented on Aug 10 11 at 12:53 pm

If she seems okay with the flow, then I wouldn’t change anything. We went up to Level 2 when my daughter seemed frustrated and ended up playing with the nipple when she was still hungry. The difference with the faster flow nipple was marked. Her intake increased enormously before leveling out- making us wonder if she’d been going hungry before. And it was way more efficient. A 20-min. feeding down to 5-10 min. She had stuff to do, things to mouth, and lots of kicking to get back to!

Sarah commented on Aug 10 11 at 1:12 pm

I am a breastfeeding mama but I work full time so my son takes bottles of pumped milk during the day. We started with the slow flow and were that way for a few months… in fact, I believed he had either started or was just about to start on solids when we switched to a medium flow nipple (I just use the medela ones that came with the bottles). We also switched when he started getting frustrated that he wasn’t getting the milk fast enough. Medela only makes slow and medium flow nipples so we never progressed beyond that and it has been fine.

May commented on Aug 10 11 at 1:17 pm

We use evenflow bottles and nipples for day feedings when I am at work. My tip?
Try a firmer nipple. I had a whole set of Medela ones, but he had difficulty latching onto those and actually swallowing the milk. nipples that make him work a little harder seem to suit him.

Lou commented on Aug 10 11 at 1:41 pm

I stuck with slow flow when I went back to work with my first. I didn’t want him to get his milk from a bottle so fast that he wouldn’t want to nurse when I got home…I never changed it and he never seemed to mind…about to set out on the same road with number two and keeping my fingers crossed!

sara commented on Aug 10 11 at 2:00 pm

So…I breastfeed and work full time, so I pump while I’m at work and nurse at home. We’ve just always used the medela bottles/nipples, and, to be honest, I don’t even know if they make different flow nipples because these worked for us. The girls are now 9.5 months and we’ve started weaning to sippy cups. I’m not sure if that helps or not, but it’s what we do. :)

the smeiska family commented on Aug 10 11 at 4:46 pm

I breastfeed and work full-time, too. I use medium flow nipples with the Playtex drop ins. I’ve read that you want to keep the nipples slow to mimic nursing. It works for us.

Emma commented on Aug 10 11 at 8:19 pm

My babies always let me know when they needed MORE.NOW. (and hence a faster flow) because they would act all fussy and frustrated during feeding. If she’s happy where she’s at then don’t change it for now.

Ami commented on Aug 10 11 at 8:53 pm

I too had a lot of confusion about the nipples, and also was unable to nurse and consciously made an effort to keep bottle feeding as close to breastfeeding as humanly possible. From bottle feeding day 1 the bottle was only ever offered with it lying parallel across my breast with the baby in a nursing position, just so we could keep the contact. When she started getting older and turning into a chow hound, I tried switching to a faster nipple to accommodate her and she hated it. Gave me a face like ‘Woah, woah, woah…You had me thinking I was still nursing, now I’m on to you! This is nothing like boob!” and totally rejected it. I immediately switched back. Now she’s 18 months old, and I’ve been slowly diluting the bottles with water from her first birthday up until last month. She now has a bottle of water before her naps and bedtime (never had a paci or a lovie, so this is her only major comfort item) and still only takes her bottle of water while being held to my chest in a nursing position. I still love it, and she still adamantly refuses anything more than a slow flow. Me and my slow nipples ended up with a 26 pound chow hound. So no, it’s not necessary. It might take a little longer, but why rush a good cuddle? Man, with an 18 month old running around I’ll take any chance for a cuddle I can get, even if it’s just long enough to suck down a bottle of water twice a day. As long as baby isn’t getting frustrated trying to get their necessary nutrition, why mess with what works?

skelly commented on Aug 10 11 at 8:58 pm

I have a theory…

Sometimes babies who have faster flow from bottles don’t like to continue nursing because it’s harder work. My babies would need a bottle of expressed milk when I was at work. Their primary source was still from me. As a result, I kept their nipples on the default newborn setting so they wouldn’t prefer the faster flow and less work of a bottle.

So, if your question is about keeping it more like nursing was, keep the newborn nips! We used them until the babes changed to sippy cups.

Carina commented on Aug 10 11 at 9:32 pm

I love the adiri bottles… you can get them on amazon. They were.recommended by the teacher of my childbirth class as a good airing with breast feeding, and I havent had any trouble with them. They have different rates of flow for different ages. They are also a very nice simple design which pleases my designer sense, not to mention fewer parts to clean. Whatever you do, stay away from the “breastflo” bottles… they leak horribly.

Meagan commented on Aug 11 11 at 12:56 am

I agree with the comments above about the baby letting you know when he/she needs a faster nipple flow. We kept our daughter on the newborn nipple until around 4 months when I noticed she was playing more than she was eating. After a few days of frustration on my part (and I’m sure WAY more on her part), I decided to try a faster flow, and VOILA! She sucked the bottle down without one bit of playing with it and could go on with her day. Like at the breast, I think they just get more efficient at sucking somewhere around 3 months (which is why all the level 1 nipples say 0-3 months I’m guessing) and would either get more milk from the boob in a faster time, or they need a faster nipple flow on the bottle in order to be satisfied. Wait until Vivi shows you she needs it to change.

Michelle commented on Aug 12 11 at 9:07 am

Mine were very fast flowing because if one of the girls popped off in a feeding it was like a fire house or something, it was crazy. But I think like bottles each boob is different. And was that when I was feeding your cute little one because SQUEE! Miss you both!!

DExtraordinaire commented on Aug 13 11 at 2:38 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Lauren Jimeson
  • Lauren Hartmann
  • Emily Elling
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Emily Malone
  • Molly Thornberg
  • Selena Burgess
  • Casey Mullins
  • Madeline Petersen
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Babys First Year Blog (50 of 3276 articles)