Babys First Year Blog
Not Everyone Can Breastfeed – My Story
I’ve always thought that I wanted to breastfeed. There was something so intimate and special about that moment between mom and baby and I wanted to experience that. Plus, I knew that there were hundreds of health benefits from breastfeeding. But I worried that I’d be one of the few ladies who were unable to breastfeed exclusively. And on Wolf’s 4th day after he was born, I discovered that I’d have to fight if I wanted it to happen for me.
I wrote about having low milk supply a few months back and my struggles to accept my “burden” of supplementing at the breast. To recap, for all of Wolf’s life, I’ve been using the Medela Supplemental Nursing System to supplement him with formula at the breast. At 10 and a half weeks old, I’ve just begun to notice an increase in my supply to where I’m able to satisfy him by exclusively breastfeeding when he first wakes up in the morning. But from what I’ve noticed during nursing, my supply is no where near enough to support my baby.
To be quite honest, I’m kind of tired of hearing about breastfeeding and what I’m doing right or wrong or that I’m doing the wrong thing by supplementing or that I’m not doing enough. I realize that it’s a tender subject around here, so before we get all factual about boob vs formula, let me tell you more about my struggle.
I’ve cried many many times over breastfeeding. The SNS is a burden, I’m embarrassed to use it in public, I’ve been hiding in the house while nursing and revolving my schedule around when Wolf is hungry. I take 21 fenugreek pills, 3 saw palmetto pills and 2 tsp of more milk plus tincture a day. I used to pump between feedings but my pump pretty much sucks so I let Wolf nurse on demand until my breasts feel less full. I’ve tried simply nursing Wolf without the SNS and he gets frustrated which upsets me and leads me to think he’s hungry and not getting enough. He grunts and cries then I put on the SNS. I feed Wolf with a bottle on rare occasions but mostly I’m nursing him and using the SNS.
Low supply is real and it happens to lots of women. Unfortunately for me, I have insufficient glandular tissue which makes it more difficult to establish a supply. The fact that my body just might not be made to breastfeed really upsets me. I go through moments where I want to do anything to continue breastfeeding Wolf. Then I go through moments where I want to rip off the SNS, fill up a bottle and just give up. There was a time when I envy women who have no trouble breastfeeding. I envy women with oversupply. I envy women who are able to whip out the boob anywhere they go and feed their baby with convenience. I envy those women who don’t have to spend $30 every two weeks on formula.
Right now I content breastfeeding Wolf with the SNS to continue hopes of boosting my milk. Most people quit after a few weeks of low supply and I’m determined to at least give it 3 months. If you’ve got a similar experience and would like more info, check out this site: Not Everyone Can Breastfeed.
Ok, mini rant over. :)
Go Back To Babys First Year Blog
28 Comments
[...] made it to my hotel, my breasts were so engorged they hurt. Since I’ve been struggling with low milk supply, I was not used to this nor did I expect it to hurt so badly. I rushed into my hotel room and [...]
Can I Tell You A Secret? I Hate Pumping. | Babys First Year Blog commented on Aug 09 11 at 8:06 pm[...] I’m still supplementing at the breast with low milk supply, I need all the stimulation from Wolf that I can get. I’ve seen a gradual increase in milk [...]
Getting On a Schedule While Working Full Time | Babys First Year Blog commented on Aug 25 11 at 12:58 pm[...] you so so much for reading. Your thoughtful comments on my struggles with breastfeeding and the complex learning process of raising a new baby have meant the world to me. So long, [...]
So Long, Farewell, Auf Wiedersehen, Good Bye! Plus, A Little Game! | Babys First Year Blog commented on Sep 30 11 at 1:26 pmjamie commented on Aug 08 11 at 6:52 pmi am so, so sorry you are going through this alyson. my heart goes out to you. you are an amazing woman and mother. wolf is such a lucky baby and his papa, a lucky husband! sending lots of love and support. and feeling bad that it can’t be easier for you. <3 <3 <3
Denise commented on Aug 08 11 at 7:09 pmBreastfeeding is difficult even in the BEST of circumstances. I don’t know why women can’t seem to cut each other some slack, especially on this subject! I’m fortunate that my daughter latched on right away and haven’t had any supply issues, but I have to use a nipple shield because of flat nipples and am now battling mastitis. There are so many things that can make breastfeeding difficult, other women shouldn’t be one of them!
Daisy commented on Aug 08 11 at 7:28 pmI used a similar system in hospital for a few days with my first baby. It was quite difficult, so I admire your persistance! You obviously love your baby very much and are working hard at something you feel strongly about. You are doing a great job!
Liane commented on Aug 08 11 at 7:51 pmI have a similar experience as yours I also felt insecure & depressed that I am not able to feed my baby I only breastfed for 2 weeks. But in the lone run a happy mom equals a happy baby. But you are really doing a good, great job keep it up we will never know. Btw have you tried drinking pure tablea cocoa it helped me lot.
Dana commented on Aug 08 11 at 8:02 pmOh, this post breaks my heart. Breastfeeding is not easy! Good for you for being so committed. At the end of the day though, I second a happy mama equals a happy baby. Whatever you choose is the right choice for you and Wolf.
Melanie commented on Aug 08 11 at 8:05 pmWhile I am a big supporter of breastfeeding, I hate that women give eachother such a hard time about it! Any amount of breastmilk is great, but if the momma isn’t happy then that isn’t great. Keep going for as long as you feel like it, and then know that you did a great thing for your son! Also, have you checked your insurance to see if they cover pump rentals? You might be able to get a prescription and it could be covered under “durable medical equipment”. It wouldn’t hurt to give them a call and there are websites that tell you how to word it when you call so it is more likely to get approved.
Katie commented on Aug 08 11 at 8:23 pmWow, you are an amazing mother to be doing all you are doing for your son. Whatever you decide to do, you have done the very best for him. I have had my own breastfeeding struggles with oversupply and it has been very hard – vomiting, extreme gassiness, choking while nursing. It can be very frustrating when we don’t get that ideal breastfeeding experience with our children. But, we all do the best we can and that is all we can do.
m.j. commented on Aug 08 11 at 8:45 pmbreastfeeding IS hard! my first struggled with latch issues and i supplemented for four months until we switched to formula altogether. it was so frustrating, and i was honestly ready to be done with breastfeeding. he ended up weaning himself and refusing breastfeeding. i just had my second and i was so worried that it wouldn’t work out again, but she latched right on and we struggled with oversupply issues the first two weeks. she choked every time she ate, like to the point that she wouldn’t breathe, and i was ready to give up again. we’ve kept going and it’s getting a lot better, but no matter how your baby reacts to breastfeeding, it is HARD. good job for doing what you can, but at the end of the day all that matters is your baby is getting fed and that you love him. thank goodness for formula in instances where breastfeeding doesn’t work!
Janssen commented on Aug 08 11 at 8:46 pmA friend of mine was a nurse before her baby was born and she told me she was CONVINCED that everyone could breastfeed. Everything she’d been taught, everything SHE’D taught, said anyone could breastfeed.
And then, of course, she had supply issues too and ended up supplementing with formula.
It just makes me sad that there is this “ANYONE CAN BREASTFEED” line being fed to women that makes them feel like a need to supplement (or do straight formula) means they are a failure or that, if they tried harder, they could make it happen.
Annie commented on Aug 08 11 at 9:02 pmAlyson!
Did you reach inside my head and write exactly what’s happening with Maebel and I? Sns, 10.5 weeks, embarrassment, crying, guilt. And myother in law is a lc. If these jugs could produce more, they would.
Great post. I feel ya sister. Exactly.
Lauren commented on Aug 08 11 at 9:20 pmHappy mama= happy baby…you are AMAZING for coming this far. Just try a bottle for a day, if you feel less stressed and happier and wolf appears happy i say fuck breastfeeding. If you feel disappointed and not as bonded after that day then keep trying till month 3…….just stop killingyourself over this, I promise when you come to true acceptance with whatever way you choose you will feel so much better TRUST ME!
Taz commented on Aug 08 11 at 9:21 pmcelebrate all of the things your body can do and has done- like giving birth to a beautiful baby!!
Kim commented on Aug 08 11 at 9:26 pmI just wanted to say that I think you are brave. Good for you for posting this because it sure is an issue for a lot of women.
Amy S commented on Aug 08 11 at 10:14 pmKudos for doing all of this for Wolf! I too had low supply, I never tried the SNS, but would pump for 20 minutes every two hours, plus nurse and then bottlefeed what I had pumped previously, then supplement formula in a bottle. After about 3 months it did get better and I only had to supplement formula about 1/3rd of the time. But I never was able to stop pumping. It finally got to be too much at 9 months. I wasn’t enjoying it anymore so I pretty much stopped. My daughter is doing well on the formula and i do still nurse at night when she wakes up, but I’m sure if I pumped I would not get much.
Just remember, formula is not poison. You do what YOU have to do for YOUR baby and don’t listen to anyone else. If you haven’t already seen a lactation consultant give that a try. Seeing mine really helped me to understand and to let go. I also tried out domperidone (helped a LOT, but was expensive) and Goats Rue (also helped alot) and Malangay.
Melanie commented on Aug 08 11 at 11:12 pmI was doing some research on insurance covering breast pumps. A few websites I came across talked about Edgepark (https://www.edgepark.com/shopcatalog/buy/health-and-personal-wellness/breast-pumps-and-supplies/electric-breast-pumps/). They will get in touch with your insurance to see if they cover any of the pump or if you need paperworkfrom your doctor. It’s worth a try!
Tam commented on Aug 08 11 at 11:17 pmI totally understand how you feel, although I didn’t have glandular problems my son didn’t latch for the first 11 weeks and it took me a LONG time to get my supply up. We used a shield for 8 weeks and I was mortified to nurse in public. I felt all the same envious things that you do and thank g-d everyday that things worked out for us. The one thing I did was stopped setting goals. I took each day feeding by feeding. I soaked in my son and told myself how happy I was for THAT feeding. In the end the most important thing is a healthy baby and a healthy Mama and struggling to breastfeed can be all-consuming. Do not feel like a failure if you choose to stop. You ARE a breastfeeding Mama and always will be. You’ve done a wonderful thing, and your efforts are commendable. Hang in there Mama!
Amanda commented on Aug 09 11 at 1:44 amI’m so sorry you are having a hard time with this. You are working so hard to do the best thing for Wolf, and it must be so frustrating. I admire you for sticking it out for so long, and hope that you can be at peace with it if/when you decide to stop. Ultimately, the most important thing is that he has your love… and plenty of food, wherever it comes from!
logan commented on Aug 09 11 at 9:10 amI feel you! We had the same troubles with our son. No milk, and he wasn’t a good nurser. So much guilt on top of your post -pregnancy emotional rollar coaster. Do the best you can, and then you know you did everything you could. Happy mom = happy baby. Bottom line. We gave in to formula (which surprised me at how much relieft it brought to me and my husband) and now we have a happy, smart, healthy 16 month old. You can’t tell him apart from any breastfed baby! Good luck and just do your best!!
Been There in SF commented on Aug 09 11 at 12:43 pmI could have written this myself! My son is also 10 weeks old, and I have also been supplementing with an SNS and taking tons of herbs, etc. starting when he was born. And I have the same underlying issue – insufficient glandular tissue. The one difference is that my son is my second child, so I have traveled this road before…
It can be so discouraging and frustrating to put so much work into what comes so naturally for most mothers. Every day I seem to have at least one feeding that is frustrating for both of us and makes me want to quit. Then I also have at least one a day that is cozy, cuddly and wonderful and makes me want to stick it
At least this time I have accepted things and am no longer filled with the anxiety and sometimes despair I felt when learning about my problems feeding my first child, my daughter. When I look at her today and see how healthy and happy she is I am both proud that I stuck it out seven months under very difficult circumstances and regretful about how much time I spent stressing about feeding her instead of enjoying her.
My guideline for this time is the same as my first: do everything I can to make it to three months, then after I experience five days in a row of truly feeling “done,” I will stop knowing I did my best
Roni commented on Aug 09 11 at 9:51 pmI had similar problems. I felt like such a failure— U are an amazing mom!!! Good Luck with everything…
lori commented on Aug 15 11 at 11:57 pmI have the same issue honey and did the lact-aid sns for three months but bottles too. Honestly there comes a time when you have to choose sanity. I miss it and wish it were different but my daughter is doing amazingly and I am still very affectionate when I feel her and make sure to get her lots of kisses and snuggles. There is life after the sns. Hugs to you.
Little Gray Pixel commented on Aug 28 11 at 8:17 pmI feel for you 100 percent because I could’ve written this post a few months ago. My husband could tell you how many times I cried about having to supplement. I thought I was a failure as a woman that I couldn’t seem to “get it right” no matter how hard I tried. But do you want to know a secret? After I decided to let go of breastfeeding a few months ago, everything changed. Within a week’s time I was back to my normal self. I was no longer crying with guilt. My baby girl was happier to be fed via bottle in her mommy’s arms, in the same position as breastfeeding. Our bond did not shake. She is a confident, strong and healthy seven-month-old now. There are more of us breastfeeding-challenged mamas out there than you know, and I promise you if you do not make it to six months or a year or whatever your goal — you will be OK. Wolf will be OK. You’ll gain perspective and the guilt and frustration will melt away. Hang in there, mama.
Nan commented on Aug 31 11 at 1:19 pmI really appreciate your posting this extremely personal blog. I too have low milk supply and due to my ignorance, I’m a first time mom to a 3 week old baby boy, and stubbornness my son ended up back in the hospital one week after he was born because of high bilirubin, constipation and dehydration. During that hospital stay, upon the Dr’s order, I had to stop breast feeding and only feed my son formula, Similac. He was given phototherapy for two days. I cried so much at the sight of him in the incubator, with an iv drip and at the multiple stick tests they performed on him. On the last night there my breast was incredibly engorged to the point where the nurses called the hospital’s lactation counselor, who then convinced the Dr to allow me to nurse my son. Since that visit I began to supplement with formula twice a day. I was and am terribly concerned with nipple confusion but my son still latches on to me for most of the day and night. I am still working on getting over the
disappointment in my low milk supply and inability to exclusively satisfy my son’s needs. I am happy that my son is receiving most of his nutrients from my breastmilk and still hopeful that more milk will come once I receive the breastpump I ordered earlier this week.
My little man is no longer jaundice or constipated or dehydrated. That’s all that
matters. Thank you for sharing your story.
SirUlrichsMom commented on Oct 20 11 at 6:31 pmi completely understand!! i had so much difficulty trying to get my supply up. i was taking 6 fenugreek and 5 brewers yeast 4 times a day as well as drinking non alcoholic beer with hops and several other herbal remedies i had ben suggested by my LC. i was pumping every two hours for 20 to 30 min and feedas well. i never was able to exclusively BF and due to the difficulties, some health issues that i have and his own want my son was weaned at 6 months.
jennifer commented on Oct 28 11 at 9:58 pmThank you for your honesty. While I breastfed my daughter for 6 months, I struggled with my supply coming in bc she was a c-section and then had my supply drop when I went back to work. I was popping tons of supplements just to keep my supply up at work as my daughter demanded more and more in her bottles. I came to the realization that stressing myself to supply her food wasn’t worth it. I’ve supplemented with formula for 2 months and now she is exclusively on formula and she’s fine – the best I can do for her is to make sure she’s fed whether by breast or bottle
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes






Lauren Hartmann
Arianne Segerman
Emily Elling
Crissy Page
Ali Smith
Meredith Carroll
Emily Malone
Danielle Elwood
Molly Thornberg
Selena Burgess
Melissa Jordan
Casey Mullins
Roni Noone
Madeline Petersen
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

28