Babys First Year Blog

Can You Teach A Baby To Walk? Would You?

Posted by naomi on August 5th, 2011 at 1:16 am

5503138833 1eecc4a0d7 300x205 Can You Teach A Baby To Walk? Would You?I happened upon a slideshow on our fair site entitled “10 Ways To Teach Your Baby To Walk.”

I have to say, I kind of laughed when I saw the title.

Why would you want to make your baby walk faster than they are ready?? Life becomes much more difficult once you have a walker on your hands. With walking comes lots of falling, and getting into even more places that are unsafe. After walking comes running, and that is a whole new can o’ worms.

And guess what? Your baby will figure out how to walk with absolutely no help from you. If you do nothing, he will still walk.*

 

*I’m referring to babies who are already developing at a normal pace, of course. Many babies that have been adopted from other countries have not had the freedom of movement necessary to build muscle strength to sit up, crawl, and walk. Other babies may have identified  developmental delays. In these cases, yes,  of course muscles should be exercised as prescribed by a doctor or physical therapist. What I’ve been told is that walking any time up until two years of age is completely normal, but every pediatrician has their benchmark for when to be concerned about developmental delays.

Even before I started taking Fuzz to RIE classes, I was never a fan of making Fuzz (or Shnook for that matter) ‘practice’ any of the skills that are highlighted in this slideshow. I did put him in tummy time, but mostly because he would get tired and then take a nap on his belly. Even my pediatrician said it was ok to let him nap this way, though it made me a little nervous.

With Shnook, I always thought it was funny how friends and family would always work with him on ‘skills.’ Things like baby sit-ups: essentially pulling them up by their arms, or walking with him by holding his arms. While I don’t necessarily buy into the idea that practicing these moves makes your baby not trust themselves, I do think it’s kind of silly to ‘exercise them’ when they will eventually figure this stuff out on their own.

RIE goes so far as to say you aren’t supposed to prop a baby up into sitting. I did do that, not because it helped to teach him to sit, but because often, it was more convenient for me. Sometimes life isn’t all about the baby.

My instincts tell me that children don’t need our help when it comes to these gross motor skills. Put them down and watch them move, and you’ll see for yourself.

Would you teach your baby to walk? Is this even possible?

Photo Credit: Flickr/Dermot Ohalloran

 Can You Teach A Baby To Walk? Would You?

7 Comments

Disclaimer: Please try to accept the following critique in the not-bitchy way I mean for it to come across.
Did you do any research before you jotted down your opinion in the form of this post? Many children need additional support and help to build the muscles that promote walking. In my group of friends there have been several children adopted from foreign countries. Due to poor nutrition and spending most time in their crib, these babies and toddlers do not have the skills to teach themselves to walk before three years of age. With parental support they learn much faster. Additionally I also have a few other friends who have had babies with small medical issues that, while not requiring physical therapy, did require additional work from the parents to help their children walk and overcome bad habits.
Further, even with ‘normal’ children, having parents and other caretakers work and play with them to promote walking might not necessarily speed that process up, but will most probably help the babies’ communication and relationship skills.

Ami commented on Aug 05 11 at 7:38 am

@Ami- You are absolutely right and I will amend my post to include these types of babies as well. Thanks for bringing it to my attention.

Naomi commented on Aug 05 11 at 8:24 am

That slideshow didn’t seem to show how to teach your baby to walk faster…seemed just to help them keep on the normal track. One thing I didn’t see them “suggest” was playing with baby’s feet- doing little kicks and stuff.

Stacia commented on Aug 05 11 at 8:58 am

I agree with you, and Ami, absolutely. My now 18 month old daughter didn’t walk until 14 months and I was trying every trick in the book to get her to take interest (of course she’s my first baby so I didn’t know what I was getting into). Nothing worked at all, and just when I finally realized that she was a very efficient crawler, lived in a small apartment that facilitated easy cruising, and was focusing a lot of energy into talking and probably didn’t feel the need to learn to do something as silly and time consuming as walking, she finally got up and started walking on her own accord. Within two weeks she was a pro, running around with me barely able to keep up with her. It really is one of those things they have to be ready for. On the other hand, I was born with congenital hip displasia. I had to have three surgeries starting at 13 months old and was unable to walk well on my own until the age of three, almost four. Because it was so frustrating for me to rotate back and forth between a body cast and limp legs as a toddler, my parents had to employ boat-loads of tricks to help me gain confidence and finally walk. Apparently I grew so attached to the freedom my walker afforded me that they had to collapse it and put it in my hospital bed so that I’d stay calm while being wheeled off to surgery. It became that strong a comfort item. So that being said, with a healthy child with no developmental setbacks, just let them crawl their hearts out. All these tips and tricks will just drive you nuts and not get you that much farther. For kids that need the extra confidence boosters and practice, why not? It’s not like helping them take those first toddles is really going to hurt.

skelly commented on Aug 05 11 at 12:27 pm

Well, children with medical or developmental issues aside, I see where you’re going with this. It feeds into this neurosis and, in some cases, the crazy mommy competitiveness.

Neither of my children walked until they were 16 months but I never really cared or did anything specific about it. I had read somewhere that children usually begin to walk somewhere between when their mother and father each started walking, so my mind was at complete ease: their father began walking at 22 months. (Don’t worry, he has lots of strengths!)

People do tend to get quite neurotic about milestones, but it’s a dangerous precedent to set. It’s so important to realize that just about EVERY aspect of development has a huge range of normal.

I think you are right when you say that they will get there on their own… and it’s so much better for them to be allowed to do so at their own pace. It’s sad to think that so many children are being made to feel that they aren’t walking/talking/eating/learning fast enough; it can’t be good for their developing self esteem.

Voice of Reason commented on Aug 05 11 at 12:55 pm

Why??? Is it so important *when* a baby learns to walk? Even “developmentally delayed” babies? If babies are given the opportunity for free, unrestricted movement, they will develop and strengthen their muscles, and meet developmental milestones when they are ready….why push them, and pull them, and prod them? I think there is something to be said for trusting the child, and trusting the natural unfolding of motor skills. Janet Lansbury writes beautifully about this : 9 Reasons Not To Walk Babies. http://www.janetlansbury.com/2011/03/9-reasons-not-to-walk-babies/

Lisa Sunbury commented on Aug 05 11 at 3:58 pm

I get that people like to coach and know people feel proud helping children get to the next stage of “enlightenment” but when I greet children I want to know who they are right now and if they are non verbal, I am going to need to watch to see who they are.

I call it stealing a child’s einstein moment~showing and coaching even with the most engaging of techniques is stealing that child’s moment of discovery and how many of these moments do adult steal in the name of their ego?

Now I have 3 special needs kids and have protected their einstein moments even if it meant delays in milestones. It is hard road with PT, OT and Early Start coaching a different philosophy “it takes a million steps to learn to walk” they would tell me and I would come back with “a child learns to walk in their sleep” from Maria Montessori.

Goals for myself~not to take away a struggle from a child to ease my tense, make time for einstein moments, limit hand over hand or direct teaching to short predictable times for a child (therapy) and help the therapist to “get out of their face” in every session to allow the child to just be self initiating again.

surfcitymom commented on Aug 06 11 at 11:19 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Lauren Jimeson
  • Lauren Hartmann
  • Emily Elling
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Emily Malone
  • Molly Thornberg
  • Selena Burgess
  • Casey Mullins
  • Madeline Petersen
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Babys First Year Blog (50 of 3275 articles)