Babys First Year Blog

How Did Our Obscure Baby Name Suddenly Become Trendy?

Posted by melissaejordan on July 30th, 2011 at 10:09 am
fave 300x200 How Did Our Obscure Baby Name Suddenly Become Trendy?

I guess Arlo's name isn't as uncommon as we had hoped

My husband, Brent and I like unique baby names. We tried hard to choose names for our children that would be unique, but not made-up sounding or hard to spell. When we learned we were having a daughter, we knew immediately we would name her Everly. We had chosen her name years earlier after playing many rounds of “What will we name our kids” after we got married. Several months after she was born, the name Everly suddenly skyrocketed to the top of 2010’s “Names growing fastest in popularity”.  WHAT THE HECK? Somehow the obscure name we had loved for years was suddenly deemed one of the hottest out there.

So when it came to naming our son, we felt confident the name we had picked out all those years ago wouldn’t land at the top of the most popular list. After all, it hadn’t even hit the radar of the Social Security top 1000 baby names since the 1930s. I knew of one Arlo (The one and only Arlo Guthrie) and had never come across a baby boy with the moniker from a celebrity or on any of the blogs I read.

But just weeks before my due date, actress Toni Colette named her newborn Arlo and then this week Arlo was determined to be one of the hottest baby boy names of 2011. What gives? There are a gazillion names out there – how have both of our kids uncommon names (neither of which were chosen from a popular tv show character or after a celebrity’s child) suddenly bumped to the top of the popularity list in the years that they were born?

 How Did Our Obscure Baby Name Suddenly Become Trendy?

28 Comments

[...] here’s the one that I found most intriguing:  Melissa of Dear Baby shared her reaction at Babble.  The list, you see, included Arlo – the name of Melissa’s newborn son.  Her family [...]

Sunday Summary: 7/31/11 | Appellation Mountain commented on Jul 31 11 at 5:45 pm

Frustrating, isn’t it? We picked out ‘Aden’ ten years before we had her, and there were no Adens (of any spelling) anywhere. Now the playground is chock full of Adens. I don’t get it either.

Korinthia commented on Jul 30 11 at 12:16 pm

It just means that you have good style! It’s incredible how quickly the naming landscape changes and what influences those changes. I am sorry you are frustrated that your unique names have become less so, but it’s pretty crazy how few children will actually share your children’s names. The year I was born, my name was ranked around 300, but I have never met anyone within 3 years of my age that shares my name. And of course that was just the beginning of Madeline shooting up the charts, which my mother never anticipated. She was just naming me after her mother. Anyway, I love your kids names!

MadelinePetersen commented on Jul 30 11 at 12:35 pm

Both of the names that we have picked for a girl (and have had for a while now) are shooting up the list. I love the names, but I find myself wanting to change to something else just to get a more unique name (which probably won’t work anyways).
My parents gave me a fairly unique name (January) and I’ve known several others over the years, including one in college that lived in my building just a few doors down and had the same middle initial and last name. Talk about strange.

J commented on Jul 30 11 at 1:11 pm

Be flattered that you are apparently a trend setter. I can understand your disappointment though. I cried when I found out a friend of mine that I hadn’t seen in a while named his daughter Hadley. Literal tears, over a name. Granted I was like 80 weeks pregnant with her and we hadn’t shared the name with anyone…and I might have been slightly hormonal at the time. I am sure the kids will love their names.

Jennifer commented on Jul 30 11 at 1:59 pm

We also named our son Arlo (for most of the reasons you listed- uncommon, old fashioned, not made up sounding, etc.), and like you we only knew of one “real life” Arlo; Arlo Guthrie. When I started reading this blog I learned of your Arlo, but that’s it! Imagine our surprise when my husband came across that “Trendy Baby Names” list yesterday! Boo! What a bummer- I guess we weren’t as unique as we thought!

Emily commented on Jul 30 11 at 4:08 pm

Our 2 year old son is named Arlo and everyone we meet LOVES his name so I guess it was bound to happen but I never thought it would become so popular all of a sudden. I had the same thing happen with my name I knew no other Olivia growing up now you are tripping over them at the playground.

olivia commented on Jul 30 11 at 4:19 pm

Lots of folks try to pick uncommon names, so it’s not really surprising when the names are suddenly common again. Everly and Arlo are right on the trend curve towards old fashioned sounding names. They are also beautiful! I’d try not let it worry you and keep in mind that you always would have noticed the names more after using them for your children.

We didn’t know anyone called Archer before our son was born. We’ve met 4 or 5 in the 9 months since then.

Elissa commented on Jul 30 11 at 5:51 pm

next time, pick a name that doesn’t even pop up on the chart at all. that’s what we did. and no, we didn’t make up the name. it’s a real name. but i’m not telling you what it is.

julianna commented on Jul 30 11 at 6:43 pm

This happened to us too. We chose Luna last year, and it’s hit the same list Arlo is on. So much for my mom and MIL saying it’s too strange. I’ve always had good taste. ^_^

Lucky commented on Jul 30 11 at 7:10 pm

I too have an Arlo, 10 months. I was really bummed when I saw this list too. When I delivered my Arlo the nurses told me there was an Arlo born a couple weeks before – aughh!! Oh well, we adore the name, it suites him perfectly, and it’s a cool name.
I have a girl on the way in 7 weeks and the name we have picked out is off the radar too, but I am starting to think I’ll see it on some sort of list next year.

Tori commented on Jul 30 11 at 7:35 pm

Three weeks ago we named our baby Mila. I had an impulse to go back and change her birth certificate. I’m not, but I’m totally bummed.

Liesel commented on Jul 30 11 at 11:47 pm

Arlo and Everly are GORGEOUS names. We have Milo picked out, and as soon as we settled on it and got over our parents and grandparents wrinkling their noses, Milo’s started popping up all over the place :) Still, no other Arlo’s or Everly’s are YOUR Arlo and Everly.

Ashlie commented on Jul 31 11 at 10:28 am

I have met a few Everlys. I don’t think that name is as uncommon or unique as you think it was (but still a cute name). Then again I think there are geographical factors as well. I live in a big city and meet a whole lot of babies maybe in a smaller town it will feel more unique? My sister is also a pediatric nurse in a very large hospital – and she has seen her share of them too.

I think it’s a bit silly when people assume that they chose a name first- or that they had it before it became trendy. No matter when you named your baby that, 1,000 other people gave their baby that name somewhere else in the world right before you did.

Emily commented on Jul 31 11 at 10:58 am

I feel your frustration! I grew up in a large (25 first cousins large) family, and each time my aunts would announce a pregnancy I’d think of my favorite names for the baby. Without a doubt, they always became super popular within months of my cousins being born! And for years I’ve loved the names Henry and Olivia (both family names) and now…well, you know :) I think I’m cursed to always love names on the cusp of popularity!

L commented on Jul 31 11 at 5:46 pm

I love the names Arlo and Everly. And don’t worry. They are still obscure. I go through birth announcements for my blog (http://names4real.wordpress.com/) and I rarely see either. They are being talked about, searched, but not used so much. I just checked the Social Security Stats. 181 babies named Arlo and 159 girls named Everly were born in 2009.

http://names4real.wordpress.com/ commented on Jul 31 11 at 6:25 pm

None of lives in a vacuum, we are all part of the zeitgeist — and that’s ok. Laura Wattenberg is really good on this topic when it comes to names. All the babies are still quite unique and amazing. Cheers.

liz commented on Jul 31 11 at 7:44 pm

You have great names! I hear what you are saying though. I wanted Dashiell forever for a boy and then my husband came home one day sad and worried to tell me his cousin chose it for her son (I had it in my bag for a few years). Then I was set on Arlo for a boy. I did get a little negative feedback and had finally decided on Charles, nn Arlo for a boy. My mom told me (when I was pregnant but didn’t know the sex yet) that my sister would name her son (if she ever had one) Charles… I said, what about me naming baby Charles, nn Arlo though? And she went on to explain it would be different because of the nicknames. I can’t understand people sometimes. Anyway, I had a daughter and named her a name around the 250-300 mark in popularity and have seen numerous comments about how trendy her name is too. I don’t think it is but us name nerds do find anything under 500 popular I suppose. By the way, Ever was considered for our daughter. I love your children’s names!!

Erin commented on Jul 31 11 at 10:59 pm

The same thing happened to us last year with the same list. We named our son Finn. We had never seen “Glee” and had no clue that there was a character named Finn on the show. We just wanted a literary name that was not popular. I keep meeting people with sons born last year who are named Finn. Our dayghter’s name, Juliet, is also rising in popularity faster than we had hoped. It is disappointing. I have a very unique name and I grew to love that as a teenager. I wanted unique names for my kids that people also knew (I have to repeat my name so many times and then spell it often when first meeting people.).

Perrin commented on Aug 01 11 at 6:51 am

I understand what you mean! When I was 15 I decided that I wanted to name a daughter Hazel Jane after two of my great grandmothers. Ten years later, those names are getting pretty popular! I have a boy, but if we ever have a girl I will have to weigh the options between something rising in popularity or a name that I love that honors our family.

Adrianna commented on Aug 01 11 at 11:32 am

Several of my top choices for my now (nearly) one-year old are on the list, but not the name we settled on. He is not Arlo, Henry, Atticus, or Finn, though he very nearly could have been any of them. I’m actually a bit surprised his name hasn’t made more popularity gains, but I can’t say I’m not pleased about it!

Alison commented on Aug 02 11 at 3:39 pm

I love the names you chose for your kiddos! I also feel your pain of thinking that you’re being super unique – and then being disappointed to see the name on trendy baby lists. We picked the name Henry two years ago, when we first started thinking baby names, and our Henry is six months old now. Little did we know that we’d meet nine bazillion other little Henrys all around his age. Blast.

Megan commented on Aug 03 11 at 1:58 am

I adore your kids names. Arlo *was* on our list for our second, but she turned out to be a girl. hmm…though her name is not at all that different from Arlo. I wouldn’t worry too much about it; you’ll likely only be joined by other name nerds with discriminating tastes. I profile names of this sort on my blog, and often wonder how “marginal” they’ll be in one to two years. I’d love you all to join the discussion on them over at marginamia

Best,
Kristen

Marginamia commented on Aug 04 11 at 3:50 pm

Trust me I feel your frustration! We chose three names for each of our children: their first names “unique” and the second two after family or a more common name we loved. Both Zion and Phoenix were totally unusual names when we chose them, but now I’ve heard of several kids with those names! And Phoenix is being used a lot for girls, which is interesting.

Lydia Collins commented on Aug 05 11 at 1:30 am

My 3 month-old is Mila. We don’t know any other Milas and were surprised that most people weren’t even familiar with the pronunciation. We chose the name years ago and then half way through my pregnancy Black Swan came out. Now Mila Kunis (the only Mila I’d heard of) is everywhere. I just read that Mila is one of the hip name of 2011. Hot damn! Ah well…

http://www.kimonobaby.blogspot.com

Jess commented on Aug 10 11 at 10:59 pm

Oh my gosh — I’m having a fit! We named our sweet little 9-week-old Adelaide after my beloved grandmother, and just adore the name for its sentimental value AND its originality… but lo and behold, there it is on the nameberry.com top names list! I’m definitely surprised; everyone keeps telling us they haven’t heard of a baby named Adelaide in forever. Oh well — our babe will certainly wear it well, and any other Adelaides out there will have one cool girl to share their names with. :)

Peyton commented on Aug 19 11 at 12:17 pm

I always wanted to name my daughter Isabella after my cousin and lo and behold someone writes a teen vampire drama and every kid under the sun is named Isabella. I have to constantly tell people, no, I have no love of Twilight.

Marta commented on Aug 19 11 at 5:41 pm

I am the Momma of Everly Claire born November ’09. I had never ever heard of a female Everly. The only Everly that came up when we played the google game was Anthony Kiedis’ son Everly Bear (obscure enough that only one other person in my ‘name council’ even referenced this). I adore her name though I have seen lists alleging it’s trendy rising status which disgruntle me somewhat. My Momma sent me some such link a few months after her birth which led me to googling again and THIS time I found your blog, your Everly Veda, and have truly enjoyed learning about your families growth, philosophies, and adventures ever since. So, a happy connection out there in the world of the Intranets!

Megan commented on Sep 06 11 at 5:24 pm

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Lauren Hartmann
  • Arianne Segerman
  • Emily Elling
  • Crissy Page
  • Ali Smith
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Emily Malone
  • Danielle Elwood
  • Molly Thornberg
  • Selena Burgess
  • Melissa Jordan
  • Casey Mullins
  • Roni Noone
  • Madeline Petersen
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Babys First Year Blog (50 of 2684 articles)