Babys First Year Blog

Breastfeeding An Adopted Child–Did You Know That Was An Option?

Posted by natthefatrat on July 19th, 2011 at 4:44 pm
 Breastfeeding An Adopted Child  Did You Know That Was An Option?

Fenugreek!

When I was pregnant with Huck, I looked at breastfeeding with some trepidation. I mean, it’s not like you don’t hear stories about breastfeeding. It’s hard, it’s complicated, it comes with cracked nipples and engorged breasts and leaking all over places and heavy-duty bras of questionable fashion, and you never get to leave the house, not ever, and other women will think you are an idiot and/or a floozy if you do it in public. Breastfeeding! Soo fun! I figured I’d give it nine months and then pat myself on the back for a job well done and then switch to formula or whatever it is you do after you wean.

But once our first harrowing three months of nursing were behind me (those first three months, holy yikes), I fell unexpectedly in love with nursing. Where once my goal was nine months, now I’m hoping for 18. And I have to be honest with you, sometimes, in very, very silly moments, I allow myself to consider the possibility of . . . extended nursing? I mean, I wouldn’t really, but also, I sort of want to? Why isn’t “Wet Nurse” a respectable occupation anymore, anyway? What are the odds I could make a fortune off pumping for the black market, do you think? I’m kidding, I’m kidding. I’m mostly, 90% kidding.

So, you can imagine my excitement a few weeks back when I read a post in the Being Pregnant blog about a woman who was able to establish her own milk supply and breastfeed her adopted daughter thanks to some pills, some fenugreek, and a hospital-grade breast pump.  Did you know that kind of thing was possible? I didn’t know that kind of thing was possible.

And then it opened up ALL SORTS OF QUESTIONS in my poor sleep-deprived brain!

More after the jump.

In the article, the author’s sister was able to establish her own milk supply by taking Domperidone, which induces lactation, plus fenugreek and blessed thistle (commonly used herbs to boost milk supply in lactating mothers), and then pumping like crazy. In time, she had enough supply to breastfeed her adopted infant (with supplementation).

Isn’t that amazing?

So, here are some questions I have:

1. What impact could this information have on breastfeeding mothers who had a tough time establishing supply and decided to use formula and then regretted it? Could they potentially reestablish their milk supply and give it another go, even after the initial lactation window has closed?

2. What could this mean for the profession of nannying? Would you ever hire a “wet nurse” nanny who could take over nighttime feedings? How much extra pay could a lactating nanny demand, do you think? And does that cross the line? How many lines does that cross? Like, a million? None? There are no lines?

3. While we’re on the subject, what are your thoughts on another woman breastfeeding your baby for you when you aren’t able to? Say, when you aren’t around, or if you were too sick? Does it make a difference if the breast milk is delivered via bottle rather than via another woman’s breast?

4. What about the breast milk industry? Do you suppose it could ever become common for a woman to have the option to supplement her own breastfeeding child with another woman’s breast milk bought at, say, a grocery store? How crazy would the FDA requirements for that be? (I know some people do this already (I believe I read that Neil Patrick Harris’s twins are breastfeed using breast milk from a “surrogate”–is that even the right word for it?) so humor me if that is a stupid question.)

5. Do you think some day breast milk will be available as easily and at equal cost to formula for those of us who aren’t able to breastfeed for whatever reason?

I am sure these questions aren’t nearly as interesting to you as they are to me, and possibly the answers already exist and I am just woefully uneducated, but, you know. What do you think?

Read the article: An Adoptive Mother’s Decision To Breastfeed (It’s a good one.)

 Breastfeeding An Adopted Child  Did You Know That Was An Option?

16 Comments

I think all of your answers are in the book “Ina May’s Guide to Breastfeeding.” I just read it to prepare for my second baby and it blew my mind! You’ll love it. I nursed my son until he was 2- we only stopped because of medication that I had to take. I assure you that as long as you and Huck are still willing, it will not be weird at all for you to continue to nurse him for as long as you want to. They are your baby- whether they are 18 months or 36 months or 24 months. You always see a “baby”. Besides, at that point they only nurse like a couple of times a day, if that. So no biggie :)

I wonder if they could re-establish feeding after switching to formula. I would think so. In Ina May’s book she points out that it is common in other cultures for the grandmothers to nurse babies- yes, grandmothers who have not nursed in DECADES. Crazy! (Crazy awesome, that is!)

Wet nurses are also very common in other cultures. Americans are prudes, to be sure, so it is looked at as disgusting or repulsive here, but women nurse other women’s babies in for convenience or because the mother is ill/dead/whatever all of the time in other countries. I think it’s a great idea- and milk banks do basically the same thing here in the states. I would gladly nurse someone else’s baby, and I’ve been asked to on occasion (though I didn’t at the time- I was much less educated about it then. Sigh.)

If I was dead or ill or otherwise unable to nurse my baby, I’d much rather have another healthy mother nurse him instead of giving him formula. I’d choose that every time over formula, in fact.

I don’t think they could buy breast milk at a store- it’s illegal to sell bodily fluids like that, I think. Not sure though. I still think wet nurses are a great alternative to that, though.

What would be really be nice is if the US govt would stop subsidizing formula and start enacting more laws that make breastfeeding more acceptable. We, as a society, also need to do the work to promote breastfeeding relationships which not only includes less societal pressure to “hide” breastfeeding, but also demanding that hospitals and workplaces become more breastfeeding friendly. Formula is often pushed onto new mothers in hospitals, babies are whisked away to nurseries rather than staying with their mothers to promote healthy attachment and a good bf-ing relationship, c-sections are the norm which unnecessarily interfere with the ability of a mother to establish breastfeeding…. the list goes on and on.

Thanks for writing this, Natalie. It’s great to hear more voices speak up on behalf of the normalcy of breastfeeding. It’s so important!

Jacquelyn commented on Jul 19 11 at 5:27 pm

Isn’t this crazy?!? I (despite whining) was glad to be able to breastfeed, but woah, would this ever turn breastfeeding on its head!!! What would women hate each other over after this? ;) You know what I mean? Tee hee. A few thoughts: 1) EVERY SINGLE WOMAN who has staggered to her baby’s room at 3:00 in the morning (often for the third time in a night) would gladly sign over her worldly goods to a wet nurse if else if she could give mindnight feeding a go every so often. But usually we eyeball the sleeping daddy in the next room first with an exhaustion-induced “I wonder…”. Seriously. Men have nipples. They ought to figure out how to use them. 2) Since breastmilk tastes differently from mom to mom, it might no go so well with discerning babies. Long ago, my awesome MIL was watching a baby who was inconsolable and didn’t want the bottle his mom had left him. Linda was nursing her third baby at the time and thought, “Hmmm–what if I…?” so she decided to give the baby a sip or two. The baby latched on, gave a few sucks, then reared back with this look of wounded indignation and SCREAMED. I’m sure he was thinking, “IMPOSTER!!!” She said it was funny but she didn’t dare try it again!

Megan commented on Jul 19 11 at 5:32 pm

Weird–the words “if else” just magically appeared in the middle of one of my sentences. Huh. Anyway, one more thought! I don’t really love to see other women’s boobs (like it or not, that’s nudity in our culture, even though it should be acceptable and often is wayyyy better looking than, say, dudes’ hairy backs). I don’t mind an artfully draped t-shirt, but the Portland nursing scene can get a bit in-your-face. Like, literally. But when I was at BYU and I’d go into a restroom and see someone in a stall trying to nurse their baby, I felt OUTRAGE. I wanted to (kindly) march her into the hallway, direct her to a comfortable chair (where ARE those at BYU???), and then shout to the hallway at large, “None of YOU guys eat your lunch on the toilet–and neither should that baby!!” Good grief. If marriage and family are so important at BYU, then so should caring for those families. Weird BYU prudishness infuriates me.

Megan commented on Jul 19 11 at 5:42 pm

*sigh* So I did all of that stuff. And I had a baby to boot. But none of it worked. I was never able to establish a full milk supply. Or even a snackish milk supply. I had such hope that if an adoptive mom could breastfeed an adopted child then surely I could! Nope. Guess I have something to write about now.

caseymullins commented on Jul 19 11 at 10:38 pm

@Caseymullins: I too, have take Domperidone, use fenugreek, and pump to establish a scarce milk supply for the children I birth. I use a supplemental nursing system to provide the rest of their nutrition with formula. It’s called insufficient glandular tissue, it’s real, and I have it. Look at noteveryonecanbreastfeed.com for some more info. You can join the online support group, which I have found to be very cathartic.

And in case any naysayers want to tell me that I just didn’t work hard enough and everyone *can* breastfeed, I have had this confirmed with multiple lactaction consultants and had the same experience with all three of my kids. Most women can, some of us can’t, though we desperately want to. The good news is that my sister-in-law wants to try adoptive nursing should they get a baby–now I can show her the ropes of inducing lactation and using nursing systems!

M commented on Jul 20 11 at 1:03 am

My friend was breastfed by her mother and godmother. The mothers swapped childcare and whoever had the babies did the breastfeeding. I think that’s awesome although as a mother I think I might find it a bit hard to imagine my baby being nursed by someone else.

BUT! It’s such a thing of trust! My mum walked in on a babysitting friend breastfeeding my brother without prior agreement and she flipped. They’re not friends anymore! But seriously, who does that?

annabelvita commented on Jul 20 11 at 3:45 am

@caseymullins and @M
Totally- I know women who just cannot breastfeed despite trying EVERYTHING. It certainly isn’t a 100% guarantee, and my heart breaks for the women who try so very hard and it just doesn’t work as it’s supposed to.

Jacquelyn commented on Jul 20 11 at 2:28 pm

So stephanie nielsen write on her blog after her last was born that while at the temple for her sister’s sealing, her new baby was inconsolable. She said that some kind woman had ben hearing him cry and finally nursed him herself (obviously asking and getting the ok from whomever was watching him)…. I thought it was so touching. But most people think it’s weird. I was at the lake a few weeks ago and a friens there had to go into work all day, leaving her baby (same age as mine) with dad and us. The baby cried and cried and refused the bottle and I so wanted to just nurse her and ease the hours-long sobbing… its an interesting idea, this sharing boob juice

Tara commented on Jul 20 11 at 2:57 pm

My husband and I are expecting to adopt a baby boy that is due in August. My husband has always insisted that adoptive mothers can somehow just start lactating because he knew an adoptive mother who breastfed her children in his neighborhood. I was not convinced! We have since found out that she was breastfeeding using a supplemental system…he just didn’t know all of the details because he was a little kid at the time. Anyway, long story short…I have decided to try to establish a milk supply…mostly for the bonding experience. I’m not sure how long it will last, but I started pumping this week. I know that there will be a lot of people that think I am a big weirdo, but I want to do whatever is most healthy for my child just like any other mother. I think it’s unfortunate that people are so skiddish about the whole breastfeeding issue. It’s a natural and healthy part of life that should be honorable not “gross”.

Laura commented on Jul 20 11 at 10:33 pm

I donated my spare frozen pumped milk to a stranger (through Milkshare) and to a friend who had low supply. It was really, really nice to see it get used since my daughter wasn’t interested in drinking it and I would have hated to just throw it out (the cost of the bag alone!). And, though I’m not really interested in actually nursing anyone else’s kid, there have definitely been a few times where I’ve heard someone’s baby crying the “feed me” cry and felt a rush of “someone just nurse them already!” hormones.

Sid commented on Jul 22 11 at 11:58 am

I sadly lost my milk supply way sooner than I wanted to be done nursing (and I also tried all of the things the adoptive mother tried). Thankfully, I have a wonderful sister who was willing to nurse my little guy for me! If not, my community has a local milk bank that pasteurizes breast milk that I would have turned to. I would imagine that many big cities have similar milk banks available.

Becca commented on Jul 23 11 at 2:01 am

When I was a baby our neighbor, a good friend of my mom’s, asked if she could nurse me just once as her baby (same age as me) was not drinking nearly as much as she was making and she was so engorged (no breast pumps then). Apparently I gave her an odd look the whole time, but nursed anyway. I don’t see any problems with women nursing babies not their own, but if I’m going to be honest, I wouldn’t turn that job over to anyone else. There are many times I’ve wished it didn’t have to be me getting up every night, but the bonding I get with my child is more than enough compensation. Even for my first, who was bottle fed, I bonded with him during feeding and wouldn’t give that up to another for anything (other than my hubby, of course).

My third is now 13 months and I just weaned him. I could have gone longer, but he didn’t want to anymore and it seemed like I was forcing him more often than not. Once when I was nursing my 2nd baby in a mother’s room there was another woman in there with her 2.5-3 year old. He wasn’t nursing, but he kept staring at me, pointing, and saying “baby ahm!” and the mom saying, “yes, baby ahm, just like you do.” It was really weird. There comes a point, to me, where I can find other ways to bond with my child (who is no longer really a baby) than nursing that is more comfortable for the both of us. Especially since at that point it is not really about nutrition.

Rachel commented on Jul 23 11 at 2:25 am

Did you hear about the breast milk gelato????!!! I am not even kidding:

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-london-12569011

(if the link fails, google it!!!)

Rianz commented on Jul 24 11 at 7:24 am

I know I’m going to be in the minority here, and maybe it’s just those social worker universal precautions drilled into my consciousness, but I’d be weary having someone else nurse my baby. Not because of an ick factor, or jealousy, or anything along those lines but for the health of my baby. We all have to be really careful when it comes to sharing body fluids and unfortunately breast milk is still a body fluid, an awesome body fluid but a body fluid nonetheless. Most pregnant women are HIV tested during their last trimester, so we go into nursing knowing pretty well whether or not it’ll be safe for our babies (and I hope that like me, most nursing women, not to mention everyone else, takes the time to get tested regularly afterwards) but how often would we really take the time to ask a friend, family member or even wet nurse to show us medical papers? I’d like to see something similar to a blood bank, where women can donate as often as they’d like and have the milk tested for safety before giving it to the babies. Something regulated, free, and widespread. It’s unfortunate that would eliminate the ability to directly nurse a child, but I think it’s a necessary evil. Besides, in cases of screening fluids without or before testing them discrimination tends to come into play (like the blood banks in my area not allowing gay men to donate. Sickening) which wouldn’t be fair to the donors. Testing breast milk really is the only way to keep it safe. Which makes me very sad. I’d love for wet nursing to be common and acceptable in our society again, but for the same reason we need to educate our kids on matters like handling wounds and proper condom use, we need to be conscious of where breast milk is coming from. But on another note, adoptive breastfeeding moms rock! I don’t know if I’d have that level of strength and commitment, and I know how hard it was trying to manage my own diminished supply after giving birth, so props to those adoptive mammas!

skelly commented on Aug 05 11 at 12:47 pm

The one thing I would worry about is disease if another woman was breastfeeding my infant. I don’t have a problem with the concept, but if wet nurses came back into fashion there are now diseases like AIDs and herpes that can be passed through breastmilk. And what about drugs?

Sure you can demand a blood test before you hire your “wet nanny” but you don’t know about her lifestyle, and some of these diseases can take months to show up on a screen.

The only way you can be sure is to use your own milk. Something to think about.

Amaryllis commented on Aug 07 11 at 10:18 am

YES – It is entirely possible to breastfeed an adopted child! and YES – it is possible for a mom who switched to formula to re-establish her supply and go back to breastfeeding.
As the non-birthing mom in a 2 mom (lesbian) family, I have done extensive research into the topic. Also, I am fortunate to live in an area that has a breastfeeding clinic staffed by 2 (female) doctors who are experts in lactation.
It is NOT an easy task and takes serious dedication. Most often, Domperidone, fenugreek and blessed thistle are used to induce supply, while pumping with a hospital grade pump frequently AND feeding baby (at the breast) with a supplemental nursing system. The SNS is a pain to use, but it allows for baby to suck and stimulate the breast for milk production (in a way NO pump could ever do), as well as the bonding with the parent.
It is also possible to establish a supply WITHOUT all the extra’s, but is much more difficult.

As for wet nursing – I’m all for it. The difficulty lies within the stigma of our society. Given proper medical testing, I would gladly allow my child to be breastfed by someone else, and likewise I would be ok with breastfeeding someone else’s child.

TS commented on Oct 12 11 at 11:53 am

Add your take:

Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.


Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes

Most Popular on Facebook

Best of Babble.com


  • Lauren Jimeson
  • Lauren Hartmann
  • Emily Elling
  • Meredith Carroll
  • Emily Malone
  • Molly Thornberg
  • Selena Burgess
  • Casey Mullins
  • Madeline Petersen
  • Disney Online Moms & Family Portfolio

    The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice. Click here for additional information. Privacy Policy | Terms of Service | Interest-Based Ads

    More in Babys First Year Blog (50 of 3275 articles)