Babys First Year Blog
When did you 1st leave your baby overnight?
Last night, at about 9:00 pm, as my husband and I lay feverishly tossing and turning in our bed – both miserably ill with some kind of stomach virus – we got a call from his mom. She was caring for both 3 year old C and 4 month old G over at her house because Jon and I were simply too sick to care for them ourselves.
She had had the girls all day, and the plan was that at bedtime, she would bring them back over to our house. I was SO grateful for her help (as I always am) because I was so miserably sick, and I was worried that the more the baby was around her father and me during the acute phase of this virus, the more likely she would be to catch what we had. Since she is not getting any breastmilk, the idea of her catching a bad stomach virus at her age is pretty scary.
But anyway, my mother in law called at about 9 to offer to have both of the girls spend the night at her house so that Jon and I could get a full night’s sleep, and so G would be less likely to catch the illness.
Of course, her incredibly generous offer made perfect sense in terms of logic, and since G is bottle-fed, feeding her overnight at her grandmother’s house wouldn’t be an issue, but I still hesitated. I had already been away from G for more than 12 hours that day, while I suffered through the nausea, fever and aches that came with the virus. I didn’t know if I could stand not seeing her until the next day. Plus, it felt just…well… weird to think of a 4 month old baby spending the night anywhere but with one of her parents. But Jon gently convinced me that this was the most prudent course of action, so we allowed his mother Janice to keep both girls overnight (thanks Janice!).
I went to sleep feeling physically terrible, but relieved that G was in good hands with her grandmother. I also felt a bit like I had forgotten something really important, and all night long I dreamed that I’d misplaced my baby, and that I needed to find her right away. It was just a really strange feeling to be in our house, in our bed, with my 4 month old baby in another house a few miles away.
Apparently, G did fine overnight, while 3 year old C was a bit fussier (she’s spent the night at her grandparents’ house numerous times by now, so this should have been old hat to her). And I got a full night’s sleep, even if my dreams were bizarre. I am sure the uninterrupted sleep will help me get well faster, but I feel more than a little guilty at having let someone other than Jon or me care for my tiny infant overnight just because I was sick.
How about you? When is the first time you left your baby with a grandparent or other non-parent caregiver overnight? Before 12 months? After? Was it because you were ill or had to travel for work? Or because you just needed a break? Tell me about it in the comments below.
FOLLOW KATIE ON FACEBOOK AND/OR TWITTER
READ MORE OF KATIE’S BABBLE BLOGGING AT HOME/WORK
VISIT KATIE’S PERSONAL BLOG
Go Back To Babys First Year Blog
35 Comments
ClumberKim commented on Nov 23 10 at 11:30 amMy son was 2 the first (and only) time we left him with someone else (my sister) overnight. We still had my daughter, who was about 4 months old, so it wasn’t an entirely kid-free night. My daughter still hasn’t spent a night without at least one parent with her. She’s three and a half now.
It’s not because we don’t want to leave them. We just don’t have anyone nearby to help. We are already making plans to fly someone in to stay with the kids when we have our 10th anniversary. That’s in 2013.
Jessie commented on Nov 23 10 at 11:43 amI didn’t really done it, and boy do I regret it! It makes it so much harder when they get older to try. My oldest did spend a few nights when she was a young toddler and was fine, but then we didn’t try again until she was 3 and it was a disaster (kept getting my Dad up all night)! I also have twins and have never tried with them…though I have spent nights away for work, but my husband has been home.
Let’s just say…earlier I believe is good because you get them used to it and it is not such a trama.
Hope you feel better soon!
Jennifer commented on Nov 23 10 at 11:47 amhow wonderful of your MIL. The very first time was I left our daughter she was 17 months when I was in the hospital having her brother. The second time they were 3 and 18 months while we were moving. That week turned into 3 due to some complications. Those kids are 20 and 19 now and they watched their younger siblings 11, 8 and 5 this summer for a week while their dad and I took care of some things out of state. We have never had family nearby, so the times are few and far between.
Chrissy commented on Nov 23 10 at 11:53 amMine never has – not that we’re against it or anything we just live far (up until a few months ago we lived almost 5,000 miles away) from family and up until now he’s been (we feel) too young to stay over with friends. He’s five now and we’re planning for him to stay with an out of town cousin for a couple of nights while my husband and I take our first ever kid-free vacation since our honeymoon. Le sigh.
Pinkie Bling commented on Nov 23 10 at 12:01 pmNo kids here, but my stepbrother and his girlfriend first left their daughter with my parents when she was about 5 months old, so they could go camping with friends. Everyone did great!
KathrynT commented on Nov 23 10 at 12:08 pmMy husband and I were also once both so sick that we couldn’t take care of our little one (who I think was about five or six months old.) Thank heavens for my parents who had done quite a bit of babysitting for us and volunteered to keep the baby overnight. I remember wondering how we would have managed if we lived far away from friends or family. I am glad to hear you are starting to feel better!
lisa commented on Nov 23 10 at 12:32 pmWell, first full night they were 1 and 3. Previously, we dropped older daughter at Gma’s at 2am when I went into labor with the baby. And many evenings we’ve picked them up after they’re asleep. But a full night has been only once, at 1 and 3.
Leslie commented on Nov 23 10 at 12:35 pm#1 – at 3 when I went to hospital for #2. #2 – at 1 when I went to hospital for #3. #3 – at 2, when my husband and I went away alone together for the first time in six years. #4 – at 3, again so we could go away together before #5 arrived. #5 – at 2 so that I could go to a church training event out of town; my husband was out of town for another reason. Kids were left with either my mother or my sister for each of these first trips away.
SNSinNC commented on Nov 23 10 at 12:45 pmHow do you do it if you’re breastfeeding? My mom offered to stay with our son (just turned 1) in March so my husband and I could have a night away to go see a play (they’re 2,000 miles away, so we have to plan) but we’re still breastfeeding and while he sleeps through the night on occasion, it is not an every night thing and when he does wake up he has no interest in seeing anyone but me(bottles don’t cut it at night). Do we just need to wait until he weans to try this?
K.C. commented on Nov 23 10 at 12:48 pmI left #1 at 20 months when I was in the hospital having #2. Other than that, they have never spent a night away from us. Someday… :)
BeccaV commented on Nov 23 10 at 1:06 pmD was just over 2 years when both of us left him overnight with Grandma for 3 nights. He did great, but did ask about us a lot. I’m in the same boat as a lot of other people. We don’t have family that live close, so it certainly would have happened sooner if our family was close.
Hope you and Jon feel better soon!
PlumbLucky commented on Nov 23 10 at 1:17 pmSNSINNC – we didn’t leave our oldest when he was still breastfeeding for the same reason. Never did figure out something that would make it work.
Oldest – when he was 16 months old, he spent the night at his grandparents so that we could celebrate our anniversary. Then again a second time when he was 20 months when we were delivering babe the younger.
Claire R commented on Nov 23 10 at 1:28 pmI was single when I adopted my kids, and when the first one was 6 months old I got horribly sick with the flu. My very close friends who lived nearby, and who were very involved in her life, came and got her for 2 nights. I don’t know what I would have done otherwise. It really saved my life. My second child was 3 when I adopted her, and I didn’t let her sleep overnight with anyone else for over 2 years-it was too frightening to her not to have me there-by that time my older daughter could have helped me through if I had fallen ill.
Clisby commented on Nov 23 10 at 1:32 pmMy first, at 6 months, while we were in the process of moving from Ohio to Georgia. The second, at 3, so I could be at the hospital during/after my husband’s surgery. No need to feel guilty – just about anybody can competently take care of an infant. I’ll take two infants over a toddler any day.
Danielle commented on Nov 23 10 at 1:49 pmMy first did not spend a night away from me until she was 2.5 years old, and not again until she was 4 and I was delivering #2. Thanks to post-partum depression and severe sleep deprivation…#2 spent her first night away with grandma at 6 weeks old. I was nursing, and we started her on bottles at 4 weeks just for her to get the hang of it. She did great! Now, at 13 weeks, my mom has had her almost every weekend so we can spend some quality time with our older daughter and catch up on sleep. I am so thankful to have this kind of help, and my baby is fine. Smiles when I go to pick her up. I will admit that she is getting more and more bottles and doing less and less nursing as a result of this separation. I wish I had taken more of a break with my older daughter to get her used to it, though she is fine spending the night at grandma’s now. It felt weird to be away from the baby the first few weekends, but now it doesn’t. When I go back to work (I’m on maternity leave), she will stay at home on weekends as that will be the bulk of the time that I spend with her.
Cindy commented on Nov 23 10 at 1:53 pmjust wanted to comment on your love and appreciation for your mother-in-law. I, too, was so blessed to have the best MIL and the most wonderful grandma to my girls. Hug her tight and let her spoil your kids rotten. Grandmas can do that.
MrsK commented on Nov 23 10 at 2:00 pmJ was 8 months old when I left her with my Mom from 8 PM to 8 AM. I pumped twice while she was gone. But I pumped at work all the time and my Mom was watching her so having a bottle was no big issue. She is 6 now and twice since May she has had two occassions where she slept over 2 nights in a row! Once with his parents while I stayed in the hospital with hubby after surgery and then 2 weekends ago with my Mom because we needed a break. I am so thankful our parents live so close to us. Get better!
Alexicographer commented on Nov 23 10 at 2:08 pmWe left DS with my mom (who already cared for him regularly a bunch) when he was 13 months, so that I could go to a work-related conference and DH could tag along. DS was fine, and overall we had fun, though having an attention-deprived-feeling hubby at a work conference isn’t the best set up. The only other nuisance was that I was still BFing … not a problem for DS (who was of course well into solids at that stage and also comfortable using a bottle) but a bit of a nuisance for me. He did self-wean very soon thereafter and it likely would have happened anyway, but perhaps the trip contributed; I’d have rather he nursed longer, but oh well.
And I left DS with DH for a work-related conference when DS was 18 months. That was divine, as it wasn’t a terribly busy conference for me and I got to sleep in two mornings in a row … ah!
Hope you feel better soon!
Katie commented on Nov 23 10 at 2:11 pmMy 21 month old has spent the night at my parents’ house (20 minutes away) at least 4-5 times since she was 15 months old. She has a room and a crib there, so very little planning is involved. They follow our nighttime routine to the T, so I think it makes her feel very secure. She does great and STTN for them every time. I am so glad because #2 is on the way and I think this will make it seem normal to stay for a couple nights if I have a repeat c-section (a significant possibility.) #2 will have to wait until I wean, which will likely be later than with #1 who weaned at 7 months because of a milk/egg/soy allergy that we couldn’t get a handle on.
I spent the night at my maternal grandparents’ house a LOT as a child. By the time I was 4, we probably spent a weekend at their house every month. I hope my kids have a similarly close relationship with my parents.
Melanie commented on Nov 23 10 at 3:11 pmMy daughter was 1 month shy of turning 3 when she spent the night at her grandparents for the first time (and the first time I was ever away from her overnight). It probably would have happen sooner (possible) except we live in California and our extended family lives in Ohio. We were there for a visit and my husband and I were going to dinner and spending the night at one of my good friends house. Surprisingly I (and my daughter) did very well!!
KL commented on Nov 23 10 at 4:30 pmSNSINNC, about the breastfeeding. I left my daughter with my mother for two nights when she was 18 months old. She was (and still is, at 23 mo) nursing. I was worried about how she would do without me at night. But she did great. She seems to react differently when she knows I am not there. If I am there, nothing but boobie will do, but when she is with my mom she will go back to sleep with just some cuddles and such. I am not sure how it would have worked when she was younger, and really needed the nighttime milk though. But as she has gotten older she has really gotten good about not nursing when I am not there, and just picking back up when I get home. My mother said she asked to nurse once, but after that just kinda moved on. Now, a few months later she will even let her daddy pat her back to sleep at home, which is a fun new developement.
My point is that I was very worried that she would freak out without mom and the boobie, but she surprised me and was just fine, not even clingly when we got back, and my husband and I got a wonderful couple of nights to ourselves. So don’t rule it out.
DCmom commented on Nov 23 10 at 4:43 pm4 months. She was a happy and healthy baby and my husband and I needed a break. She spent the weekend with her grandparents and loved it.
Amy commented on Nov 23 10 at 6:24 pmWe left our son with my parents overnight when he was 4 months old, and we were breastfeeding. He could take a bottle of breastmilk, and has done it numerous times, so I left my parents with a stockpile of pumped milk, and everyone was fine. I took the pump with me so I didn’t explode! He is almost 2 now and he spends friday and saturday nights at my parents every week while my husband and I work. My parents rule.
Steph commented on Nov 23 10 at 7:43 pmWe started leaving our son with grandparents when he was just a few months old. I knew they were more than capable and I would just pump breast milk and freeze it for these occasions. While it was difficult and I had similar feelings, my husband and I felt it was important to get away just ourselves every now and then. Additionally the grandparents, who live a couple hours away, loved spending the time with him.
carrie commented on Nov 23 10 at 7:45 pmBoth my boys were 18+ months old the first time they spent the night at their grandparents’ house (they’re now 2 and 5). This was not so much for their benefit as for mine. When they’re away their dad and I take turns calling to check on them/irritate their grandparents. A stomach bug is no joke, Katie. It is nearly impossible to take care of even yourself when you’re in the grips of that devil. I’m glad you have a mother-in-law who is so capable/thoughtful and that you were wise enough to take her up on her offer! Hope all Hickjus are well soon!
jepea commented on Nov 23 10 at 11:16 pmhey, you know, give yourself a break! you were sick. the kids stayed with their grandma. this is what extended family is all about (at least in my neck of the woods)
Heather commented on Nov 23 10 at 11:59 pm#1 was 4.5 and it was when I was having #2 and #2 was 1 day shy of 2 years when I had #3 and #3 is now 22 months and has never spent the night away from me. We are planning our very first kid free weekend in June to celebrate hubby’s 30th birthday so we are thinking of doing a trial run beforehand when we are close by incase of meltdown. I strongly dislike spending nights away from my kids when they are under 5, but hubby and I both feel this weekend trip we plan on taking is much needed. My oldest was 1 when we started dating and we have never in our entire relationship spent one full night kid free, including when we got married. So I think maybe it is time?
Kata commented on Nov 24 10 at 3:55 amM son was 15 mths old when we had a 2 week holidays at my parents’. While staying there, me and my partner went for a 4 day little holiday, we really needed it, as we don’t have any babysitters during the year, except when we go visit my parents. (They live on the other side of Europe.) T did fine, kind of didn’t even notice we left. Was rather upset and hurt when we got back and he realized we left him. :) Next sleepover 4 mths later, again the next at 2 years old. Always with my parents, and he just loves them so he is fine. He would ask where we are, they tell him we went to see/do this and that and will be back tomorrow, and that’s it. :) I still think he is too young to be left alone with friends though, at 2.5 yrs.
Lillian commented on Nov 24 10 at 1:55 pmMy daughter was almost 2 and a half the first (and still only) time she stayed overnight with my sister so DH and I could celebrate our 5th wedding anniversary. Mind you, my sister watches her twice a week while I work and anticipates her every need. So Em said “YAY!” when I asked her if she wanted to go sleep at Aunt Jean’s house.
I missed the heck out of her though.
suze commented on Nov 24 10 at 8:11 pmWell, my son spent weeks in NICU as a baby so I was away from him all that time. Consequently I didn’t spend a night away from him until he was 10! (and didn’t mind a bit)
vicki commented on Nov 25 10 at 1:56 amMy youngest was a preemie and in the NICU, and I had to leave her there when she was a few days old. It was dreadful, for me. I am so glad we were only away from her for 4 nights–after that we went back and slept two nights at the hospital with her so she could prove she could eat by mouth, and I’ve been with her every night since then.
My oldest had his first night away from me when #2 was born, he was 4. #2 had his first night away from me when my water broke and I went into premature labor with #3. He was 4 also, and I spent a lot of nights that year in the hospital.
Last year my husband and I went on a cruise for a week and took the baby (she was 1) and left the boys with Grandma and their aunt. They were 9 and 5.
Sandra commented on Nov 25 10 at 7:18 amMy son was 10 weeks old when it was my birthday and our anniversary. We had just dealt with a lot of visits and were not in the mood to have any more guests over for a celebration, as is common in The Netherlands. Instead, we had a lovely dinner for two and stayed over in a hotel, while our son was taken care of by my mom. She raised me and my 3 siblings lovingly, so he was in real good hands. I have to add that the hotel was just a block away. But that gave me a feeling of safety, that she could ring me and I could come over if something was not right. But I have to say. I loved being out of my cocoon for a while, and have a good night’s sleep. Never regret it!
Rebecca commented on Nov 27 10 at 8:01 pmMy older son (now 2.5) was about 7 months old when we left him w/Gramma to go on a 4 day vacation. We’ll be leaving him and his now 4 month old brother with Gramma and Grampa this weekend to take a few nights alone. I feel bad for people who don’t have family nearby. :(
Joni commented on Dec 18 10 at 9:08 amMy daughter stayed overnights with my mom or grandma every few weeks by the time she was 11 months old. It just never seemed like a big deal, though I was so ready to have her back by the 24th hour. She also has 2 bff’s and I’m good friends with both of their families. We have had an unofficial overnight babysitting deal since our girls (who are now nearly 6) were 18 months or two years old. In fact, I will have an extra 5 1/2 year old girl tonight! My daughter can’t wait to share her new crayons she got as a gift from her teacher!!
B commented on Feb 01 11 at 12:16 pmMy son was 5 months old. My husband and I flew to NYC for the weekend and baby stayed with his grandmother. I left a stockpile of breastmilk and pumped through out the trip (including in the airplane bathroom!) A good time was had by all – especially Grandma. We plan to leave him again when he is 10 months old because we have a wedding to attend in Boston.
Add your take:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.
Comments are delayed up to 15 minutes







Lauren Jimeson
Lauren Hartmann
Emily Elling
Meredith Carroll
Emily Malone
Molly Thornberg
Selena Burgess
Casey Mullins
Madeline Petersen
The Walt Disney Company supports Babble as a platform dedicated to honest, engaged, informed, intelligent and open conversation about parenting. However, the opinions expressed on this site are those of individual parents/writers and do not reflect the views of Disney. In addition, content provided on this site is for entertainment or informational purposes only and should not be construed as medical advice, diagnosis, treatment, or safety advice.

35