It is NOT the Same as Having Twins
Posted October 14th, 2011 at 12:30 pm
As a parent of twins I am still constantly shocked at how many people tell me that they have kids that are 18 months so it is the same thing.
It isn’t.
It isn’t even close and I will tell you why.
1) When your kids are 18 months apart people don’t think it is okay to ask you about your reproductive history. People probably don’t say “Are they natural?” to you at least once a month.
2) Your uterus had nine months of rest between babies.
3) Shall we compare stretch marks? Or NICU stays? Or how long you were on bed rest before the kids were born?
I know that some people with one baby at a time have difficult pregnancies. I know that they get stretch marks. I know that singletons can end up in the NICU. I also know that I threw up at least four times a day for 22 weeks then spent six weeks living in the hospital on bed rest before my children were born. I also needed a blood transfusion after delivery. And people like to tell me that I did it the easy way.
4) Let’s talk about May 12, 2020 – the day BOTH of my children can get their drivers licenses. Or August 2022 when they will both go away to college.
5) People ask which one is the good twin. In front of them.
6) So when neither of your babies could hold their heads up on their own and were both eating every two hours, not on the same schedule how did you handle that? Hey remember when you hated all of your friends that only had had one baby? Remember when you were pregnant and people kept telling you about their sister-in-law’s friend who was pregnant with twins and how one embryo absorbed the other one? Remember when you fed one and put her down and then you laid down but before you even turned off the light the other baby started crying because he needed to eat too and you just cried because your nipples hurt so bad that you thought you might die?
Oh right. That never happened to you.
* * *
Listen, I’m not saying it is easier to have your kids born 18, 14, 11 or even 21 months apart – I only had to give birth one time – but I AM saying it is different. I have no idea what it would be like to be pregnant with a toddler. I would imagine it is pretty hard. But I don’t know, because it never happened to me.
And you KNOW I am not about to say that I know what it would be like to have triplets or quads because I don’t even like thinking about how hard that must have been as newborns. I don’t even know how people handle having more that two kids period. As one of my clients once said after his third was born, you have to switch from man-to-man to zone defense. I am not prepared for that level of parenting. I barely know what to do with the two I have.
The truth is that no two babies are the same. No two families are the same. No two people are the same and I can guarantee that your “Irish twins” are not the same as my fraternal twins. I mean that for better or for worse.
So please, stop saying it.
Tags: Irish twins, multiple births, multiples, parenting, twins
Back to: Goon Squad Sarah
43 Comments
[...] Like here: Ranting about how having kids that are close in age is not at all the same as having twins. [...]
Sarah and the Goon Squad » So… commented on Oct 19 11 at 11:21 amHeadless Mom commented on Oct 14 11 at 1:04 pmI can’t believe some of the stupid things people say sometimes. Gah!
red pen mama commented on Oct 14 11 at 1:13 pmI was terrified that my third and fourth pregnancies were twins. Terrified. Yes, i had difficult pregnancies, and i have used that same ‘zone defense’ language when talking about parenting three. But i would never compare anything to having twins. No way. Kudos to you!
Suzie P. commented on Oct 14 11 at 1:17 pmAmen, sister! I get those comments all the time once folks learn about my twins and it drives me nuts. (Mine no longer look the same so people don’t jump to that conclusion as much as they used to.)
Issa commented on Oct 14 11 at 2:20 pmI have a great answer for number one….no they are pod people. ;)
LauraC commented on Oct 14 11 at 5:07 pmThank you thank you thank you.
NO THEY ARE NOT THE SAME.My not nice answer – Was your husband traveling when you had two 3 month olds and you decided NOT to wake them at the same time since one could definitely sleep longer and then they managed to wake up in such a way that you only got two 45 minute blocks of sleep and you still had to go to work the next day? Oh that’s right, you got to go back to sleep when your one baby went back to sleep.
My nice answer – “I pretty much never want12lbs 4oz of baby in my belly ever again.”
daniel commented on Oct 14 11 at 6:48 pmI have an answer for #5. It might take some practice, especially on the kids part, but you all just hang your head and say “We don’t talk about him any more.”
erin commented on Oct 14 11 at 8:24 pmone person asked me if they were “nocternal”…instead of “fraternal”. my answer? why yes they are…..lol.
daralee commented on Oct 15 11 at 12:43 amAMEN! I had one and 16 months later had my twins. I had people telling me all the time they knew EXACTLY what I was going through because they had babies less than two years apart. I also had people telling me that it would be just like having triplets. Knowing people who have triplets I would never make that comparison. I could at least hold both my babies and not run out of hands. And unless you’ve fallen asleep while feeding one baby and burping the other one or given birth to 15lbs of babies in 15 minutes without any medication, you have no idea what having twins is like. I’m not saying it’s harder, I’m saying it’s different.
smart aleck commented on Oct 15 11 at 11:40 amPeople are idiots–that’s just a given. I think they are in awe of the mad skillz it takes to take care of twins and try to put themselves on the same level.
Answer to #1–”yes, they are 100% natural/organic–I picked them up in the Whole Foods parking lot…some lady left them unattended in her car while she returned her shopping cart”
On another note–you had to have photoshopped those kids into that picture, because you look extremely well rested for someone with babies that age. Or did you have a staff of three rotating nannies?
Jenn commented on Oct 15 11 at 12:41 pmSo, So true. And I even had an easy pregnancy. Horrible delivery, but easy pregnancy. Even so I couldn’t walk by the end. And the sleep deprivation. Dear God.
Tammy commented on Oct 15 11 at 9:46 pmI’m sorry. I miss you!
Barbara commented on Oct 16 11 at 1:10 pmHi
I agree with you on all accounts. I was lucky and needed no bedrest, but got pretty much all the other ‘advantages’ of having two babies in one pregnancy ;-)
I am sick of being asked about them being natural. I often say something like: do they look artificial to you?
when they were newborns with colics, one with additional reflux, we had a rythm of feeding one for 45 minutes, lay her down screeming (cause it was nearly impossible to burp them) pick up the other one, feed for 45 minutes….start afresh.
they didn’t nap at the same time until they were 1.5 years old!
until they were 3 years old i got up every night between 7 and 10 times to get them back to sleep, i don’t know any mum of a singleton who wakes up that many times.
so, nobody with one child at the time, no matter how close, needs to tell me it’s the same!!!!
but, to finish this rant on a positive note:-)
my girls are now 4 and the best of friends, spend hours playing together and just love each other to death. they really care about and look out for each other.
so, to all the mums of newborn twins out there: it does get easier over time. my advice is: try and meet other mums of twins. it’s great to talk to someone who truly understands.
lots of love to all twin mums
Barbara
John Cave Osborne commented on Oct 17 11 at 10:18 amtotally with you. i’m constantly amazed at how people tell me they can relate to our experiences w/ the triplets b/c they, too, have 3 kids.
it’s like, really? you can?
not that it’s some kinda contest. b/c it’s not. still, as parents of multiples, so few people can relate to what we go through, so it’s kinda frustrating when people pretend like they can.
TheCreativeHomestead.com commented on Oct 17 11 at 1:39 pmMy aunts are twins. And we have twins in numerous places across every generation in my family. As they get older, your twins might get asked “So can you read each other’s minds?” or ask out the other twin when the one says no. Or get treated the same for something the other twin did. Or ask which one is smarter.
I was sort of hoping for twins with my first only because I wouldn’t know the difference on how difficult it is with two babies at a time and they could grow up together. I didn’t think about all the difficulty in just getting from conception to birth.
I can say I know a family with 3 kids, 2 twins and the other 10 1/2 months older. Yikes.
Roberta commented on Oct 17 11 at 1:46 pmI bow down to anyone who has twins (or other multiples, yeow) because I am not worthy. One at a time was quite hard, and I CANNOT imagine two. I have no doubt that your experience was WAY different than mine! But those questions? Which one is the good twin? The hell?
Celeste commented on Oct 17 11 at 2:24 pmWOW. So only people with twins are allowed to talk to you? It must be nice to be so cool, to be in such an exclusive club. Grow up.
Birthing, parenting & plain old DEALING WITH PEOPLE is hard.
It doesn’t sound like you got any more or less unwanted comments or questions than I did. They are just different questions. It doesn’t get any easier as kids get older. The advice, questions and ‘competition’ grows and multiplies as your children do.
I am so tired of all the ‘I had it harder, my life is more difficult, I am sooo special’ whining crap from Babble.
Kirsten commented on Oct 17 11 at 2:52 pmI love this! As the mother of twins (almost 6 months!), I totally relate! People love to compare, which is fine, but you DID NOT have two babies at the same time, so it isn’t the same. And I don’t understand why people have to make it like their lives are harder, we are all doing the best we can with what we are given. I love when people look at me and say, “I don’t know how you do it!” I don’t know the appropriate response, but one day I looked at the girl and said, “I don’t have a choice.”
Heather commented on Oct 18 11 at 3:42 pmThe “good twin, evil twin” thing never goes away. EVER. Still getting asked it at age 32.
Rachel commented on Oct 19 11 at 12:31 pmWow Celeste. You are a delight.
Franny commented on Oct 19 11 at 12:38 pmMy favorite question is with boy/girl sets of twins — are they identical?
I believe the correct answer is “yes. yes they are”
Kelly commented on Oct 19 11 at 3:20 pmAs someone who is about to have kids two years apart, I cannot even fathom how a sane person could compare that to twins. I have always tipped my hat to those with multiples and humbly admitted that I don’t know how you did it. (And while that may be lame to say, I mean it.) One newborn, and now one mobile year and a half year old monkey taxes my capacity on any given day. I truly do not know what I would have done with two at once. Being pregnant with a toddler? Harder than being pregnant without one, but the fetus is still a lot easier to care for than the one I have to chase around the house. I can’t believe that people even make this comparison (but I can because so many are stupid.)
ohjennymae commented on Oct 19 11 at 6:32 pmwowee zowee, celeste! sarah is using humor to write a satirical post about the ridiculous questions parents of multiples often get asked. i don’t read that she thinks she’s better than anyone. i have 4 kids and my first 2 were twins and they were very easy babies, but i did get some hilarious comments and questions from some people. i could write a book about the silly things that people thought were okay to ask me. and she’s right, no one asks me if my 3rd and 4th were natural or if i used ivf. only do they think it’s appropriate with twins. do i think that i had it harder, my life is more difficult, or that i’m sooo special because of anything? nah. do i think i’m in a “cool club” with all the other multiple parents out there? nope, but i do think my kids are pretty cool. and that’s all i care about.
Linda commented on Oct 20 11 at 6:25 amI think the first 3 years are a misery. They are cute and all but they are terrible bosses with the whining and the micromanaging.
I often say really stupid things in a misguided attempt to commiserate with someone else. I don’t truly believe that our circumstances are the same, just that I’m having a tough time and I know they are too. If that makes any sense…
Canuckmom commented on Oct 22 11 at 7:54 pmAnd twins are nothing like triplets…
ErinShea commented on Oct 24 11 at 9:50 amMy favorite even now, when my twins are 11 years old, are the women with single deliveries who say “I always wanted twins.”, or the newly married who say “I’m hoping I have twins.” Because it would be “cool”, or convenient. All I can think is “How ignorant.” LOL. And maybe even if they had an in depth understanding about what they were wishing for, they’d wish for the same thing, and that’s fine. But I had a single before my twins and I didn’t have a clue, so I doubt it. Right now twindom is fantastic, but if you’d asked me up to the their age of about 5yo if I wished I could go back and have them individually, as singles, I would have said YES. To be able to give them both the attention they deserved as babies would have been so wonderful. I feel like both myself and the babies were robbed. I remember very little up until their 2nd birthday. It’s a blur. Now they are the best little people and I wouldn’t wish for having them any other way if it would make them different than they are. But if it would make no difference their personalities? Yeeeaah.
Devon commented on Oct 25 11 at 12:29 pmWho does this???!! My 2 are 20 months apart and there is NO way I would compare that (you know, the older one LIKED to help mommy by getting stuff and throwing away diapers and finding pacifiers….) to my friends/family with twins. One friend who just had twins has a deployed husband and moved across the country while pregnant with her older two boys, wound up on bedrest, and is now taking care of 4 kids, including the two newborns, BY HERSELF. She doesn’t just deserve an award…she deserves a crown, a small country to rule, and a cash prize. Oh, and a nap. Daily.
Juliette commented on Oct 28 11 at 10:52 amTHANK YOUUUU!!!!!
I am pregnant (6 months), they are twins, I have 2 older boys (5 and 2), and wound up on bedrest since the third month.
I get both:
-”I know what it is to be laid, I had it for my first Baby”. And were you disappointed to say no to your 2 toddlers asking you a glass of water / play/ book reading, … Was your husband constantly taking care of you or house and kids??
-”Oh and you were on a treatment to have babies?” I already have 2, I am NOT that crazy! And by the way, thank you, our reproduction and genital systems are OK!!
April commented on Oct 28 11 at 2:27 pmHow is it I’m just now reading this?! I love this article! I was ridiculously lucky to have an uncomplicated twin pregnancy that required no bed rest and went full term (I was actually induced a few days before my due date) and no NICU time. I did have a toddler though. When I was pregnant I considered getting a shirt made to say:
Yes, they’re natural (thanks for asking about our sex life!)
One’s a boy and one’s a girl.
No, they’re not identical!
Yes, I am huge, thanks!
Yes, I’m quite aware that I’m going to have my hands full.
Juliette commented on Oct 29 11 at 3:21 amWow, I’m so sorry I clicked on this! What a bunch of cry babies!!!
I have a question: Are your babies healthy??? Oh, well then, I’m so sorry that you have had to put up with SO much giving birth and raising beautiful, healthy twins, it must be rough. Some of us have not been so lucky, so quit complaining and enjoy this precious babyhood because it doesn’t last long.
Anna commented on Nov 07 11 at 3:53 pmJuliette, how dare you complain about this blog post when so many people aren’t even lucky enough to have a computer to read blogs on in the first place! Ever think about how lucky you are to be able to read? Or to be able to see in the first place! Did it ever occur to you that some people are born BLIND?? You should stop going around complaining about the things people write on the internet, when you have so much to be grateful for in the first place.
Sarah commented on Nov 08 11 at 4:50 pmAnna is my favorite.
Brittney commented on Nov 11 11 at 3:59 pmI had one lady tell me having two dogs was like having twins. I said really? Why don’t you trade me for the day and get back to me on that one.
Chelsea commented on Dec 06 11 at 6:37 pmI know! I don’t know what it is like to have a toddler and a newborn, but having 10 week old twins has to be like the hardest thing ever! I have a friend whose children are 21 months apart and when the twins first came home with me, (and I was so exhausted!) she said that she knew what it was like because her kids were so close in age. And I’m thinking, wait your little boy was almost 2, he slept through the night, played or watched tv during the day and you made your husband help even though he worked (which I don’t do), so really you only had one baby to have to get up with every 2-3 hours, how is that the same as me having to get up every 2-3 hours get one fed, changed, and rocked to sleep and then having to do it all over again with the second one only to realize that by the time that is done I have about 30 minutes before I have to get up and do it all over again? Sigh.
And then she kept them for 3 hours before bringing them back to me calling me a saint, lol.
So it is NOT the same, obviously.
And that is just after they were born, the pregnancy was another story. I have another friend who just had a baby at 40 weeks. The drs said her baby was going on 9 lbs. S he kept on complaining and I’m thinking, I had almost 10 lbs of baby in me (4 12 and 4 13) plus two sacs and two placentas, your nine pounder is nothing compared to that! Not to mention the sciatica, the vomiting, the 6 weeks of bed rest, the 8 days of labor ( they stopped my labor but not the contractions for 7 days), the nasty hospital food, the magnesium drip that caused me to be sicker than I have ever been in my life, and then there’s the c-section that for some reason was not as easy as everyone else claims they are because my body went into shock from the pain 3 different times and I had to be completely sedated 2 of those times and passed out the other time.
Anyways, lol. Rant over. It is MOST DEFINITELY NOT the same.
Meg commented on Dec 12 11 at 6:36 amI wouldn’t wish twins on my worst enemy! It was hard enough with one newborn. My son’s 3 now and I’m 6 months pregnant which is flipping hard work (especially with a puppy thrown into the mix) but I would never begin to compare it with the physical effect of twins, especially in the first year. ‘People’ do have a habit of saying stupid and insensitive things to you about kids and pregnancy whatever your situation.
Rebecca commented on Dec 20 11 at 11:33 amI have found that everyone has their own personal hell when it comes to kids. It’s better to just find the shining light in every situation and hope that most people have your best interest at heart. There is about the 3% of people who are truly jerks but you can’t even relate with people like that. I have two singletons who were born far enough apart (and full term, yippie) so I don’t know your struggles but my own struggles include so many surgeries on my youngest that I’ve lost count. So many doctors visits that I feel like I would exchange an entire year in the NICU for the past almost five years in and out of the hospital. God what I wouldn’t give to have just one year in the NICU.
Stephanie Elliot commented on Dec 20 11 at 11:37 amYeah, but people do ask you if your second was an accident. And why did you want another one so quickly? And are you crazy? And you still don’t get sleep with Irish twins, maybe not even as much as regular twins because they’re often not on the same schedule. And regardless, you still have two babies to care for. You still have double the amount of diapers to change. You still have to get up in the middle of the night to care for your babies. Why can’t women and mothers understand that it’s not a battle between us and can’t everyone just support one another? Why does it have to be who has it harder, who’s work is more demanding. Why can’t we just be blessed to have babies?
Gretchen Agans commented on Dec 20 11 at 4:48 pmA FREAKIN MEN!!!
I had my twins when I already had three others. I still love my husband of 20 years…but there are days I want to run down street screaming.
nicole commented on Jan 01 12 at 12:36 amI have irish twins…exactly one year apart…never have I ever thought of them being the same…however my 2.5 year old has special needs..when the baby was born she didn’t walk,talk, or really do anything that a one year old did..in fact she was like a 3mo. Old baby…I agree why does it need to be a I had it easier or harder…btw incase we are counting hash marks I had an NG tube, zofran pump and eventually a PICC line due to sever hyperemesis with ALL 4 of my pregnancies that ended up in a child, be happy and content with your life, your childs health…all of us are not that lucky!
Shelby D commented on Feb 16 12 at 9:44 pmI have 2boys 11 months apart a lnd I’m always asked if they are twins it never fails its a bit ridiculous some times
Linda commented on Feb 17 12 at 3:34 amI normally enjoy your blogs, this one I found seriously offensive. Really, do you not know what Irish twins are? They aren’t 18 months, 15 months or anything more than a year apart. Which means there is much less than nine months between each child. I had a two day long labor in the hospital with my first child, and when she was about five WEEKS old we became pregnant with out second child. Yes I know, we didn’t wait as we were supposed to; however no regrets. Yes Irish twins are not quite the same as twins, but you try to give birth after 36 hours in labor only to find out whoops ya did it again, while still on maternity leave. Yes it was my own fault, however please do not try act like you know what it’s like to carry and deliver two children in separate pregnancies less than a year apart. I can guarantee it makes your twin pregnancy and labor look like a walk in the park. I was on bed rest for the last six weeks of both pregnancies (for two totally different issues) and wasn’t supposed to even lift my daughter when I was five months pregnant with my son. My children are now 4 and 5 and are roughly the same size, many people assume they are fraternal twins. They behave like twins, they are absolutely inseparable and have their own unique way of communicating with each other that’s uncanny. Yes twins are special, but you don’t have to be so obnoxious with your blog.
Cecilia Barreto commented on Feb 18 12 at 6:03 amI have an 8 year old and boy girl twins 2 years old. Believe me I know the difference between one and two. Having twins was is and will be a wild ride on everyone’s life is overwhelming exhausting stressing . Some days you just feel miserable even knowing you are the luckiest mamma on earth for having them.
The first year I thought I was gong to collapsed I created a facebook group twins moms out of hopeless and despair to vent and talk to people that speaks the same language as me twin parents language. I hate getting those silly questions are they twins? Are you sure he is not older? Was it natural? Don’t you get crazy with 3 kids? Blah blah now I became so much tolerant and I keep jn mind that before having the twins I’ve never imagine things could be this way at all and I nicely answer to them.
Is m extreme parenting experience and the most annoying thing is to get the they are 18 months apart just like having twins miss no way when the second was born the first was walking almost eating by himself talking laughing and so many things but then I say before living this I thougjttgd same .
Now my babies are 2 and I enjoy them every second but their first year was tough and stressfully exhausting
Erin commented on Feb 24 12 at 11:26 amI had three babies in three and a half years. I can’t imagine having two newborns at once, I know having two very close in age is not the same thing as having twins. At all. But, I bet people ask me if they’re twins nearly as much as they ask you. One is skinny and one is stocky, and they look a little bit alike, but not THAT much… Every time I go out in public with all three of my little kids, someone ALWAYS has to bust out the “Wow, you’ve got your hands full.” I just smile at them and say “yes, but you should see my heart.” Unless they’re tantruming and tearing up a store, then I just ask them to hold one while I get a bottle of wine.
Add a comment:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.











43