My kid’s nut allergy is bringing you down
Posted By Cassandra Barry On October 18th, 2011 at 4:18 pm
My husband, Joel, cursed our son, Laszlo. While I was pregnant, he wrote a column in which he said that the rise of nut allergies in children was a figment of everyone’s imagination. Or something like that. I don’t really read his columns too often. When he told me what he was writing about, I said, “You’re going to doom our unborn son to have nut allergies.”
I was kidding. I come from hearty stock. I’m about half German and the rest of my heritage is comprised of other bad-ass peoples like the Irish and English who are tall and ruddy cheeked and can survive in sub-zero temperatures on cheap cuts of beef, potatoes, beer and whiskey. While people of my heritage may be plagued with a predisposition to alcoholism and depression (note the booze and cold weather stuff), they are not prone to allergies. Joel, meanwhile is one hundred percent Jewish: People who are kind of known for their allergies. And the fact is that if one parent has allergies of some sort, their kid has a fifty percent chance of having an allergy as well. And not necessarily the same allergy. So Joel’s allergy to cats and his hay fever has translated to Laszlo’s allergy to nuts.
When we found out about Laszlo’s nut allergy, I got mildly depressed for a little while. Not because Laszlo may never get to eat nuts again. I panicked because Laszlo has an obvious and immediate Achilles heel. Someone could bring him down. I pictured him becoming a powerful man, perhaps a ruler of some Germanic country where tall and ruddy cheeked peoples enjoy cheap cuts of beef, potatoes, beer and whiskey. And like all powerful men, he becomes undone by a spy from enemy territories who slips a nut into his drink. Laszlo, reaching for his Epi-pen, remembers he left it in his other castle and keels over. Maybe I’ve seen “The Princess Bride” and that scene with the Iocaine powder too many times.
Once I got past the distorted imaginations of enemies bringing him down, I found that the hardest part about having a son with an allergy is the feeling like you’re being a real party pooper. When we signed Laszlo up for a temporary daycare program, they had to send letters home to the families of the other kids stating that nuts of any kind were no longer welcome. We felt like the bummer family. While sunflower seed spread really does taste a lot like peanut butter and is actually better for you, there’s the feeling that when it’s suggested as a substitute, people act as if you’re taking away their right to vote.
At an orientation for our son’s preschool recently, a director at the school asked if anyone has a child with food allergies. My hand shot up and as soon as it did, I got that party pooper feeling. Thankfully, another parent raised her hand as well. Her kid’s allergy was peanuts. Phew, I was not alone! The director said, “Okay… No peanut butter.” I said, “No! No nut butter! All nuts!”. My husband, whose fear of being socially ostracized might override his fatherly protective instincts, said, “Um, other kids can have nuts. Our son can be around them…. He just can’t eat them.” Joel defended the class rights to nuts because he doesn’t want to be a party pooper.
Then a dad at the orientation shouted out, “Um, my kid is allergic to broccoli…. And basically all vegetables.” I heard chuckles all around. He was making fun of this! He was deep in the sea of parents and I didn’t see who he was, but I will find out. And I will let him have it. Or, more likely, I will just give him a lot of searing looks. Broccoli Dad’s attitude reflects the other major reason why it sucks to have a kid with allergies: I get the feeling sometimes that other parents think we’re just being paranoid or sort of making it up. As if “allergic” means he might get a little rash or some mild sneezing. And we’re just bringing people down for no good reason.
Which isn’t true. When Laszlo was one year old, I gave him some mixed nuts and within the next couple of hours, we were at the ER. He started off with a weird and constant sneezing that didn’t stop. Then the shrieking started. Then full-body hives. His face puffed up. Have you ever seen a whole face puff up? It’s scary. His eyelids got so swollen that upper and lower lids met in the middle and his eyes disappeared from view. He gasped for air. By the time we got to the ER, he threw up at the entrance. We were rushed in because his oxygen levels were low. The whole thing was definitely not made up.
We don’t want to ruin the whole party of life with our (delicious) Sun Butter. We’re sorry if you think your nut butters are so important during that half hour of the day. And personally, we’d actually be cool with you bringing your nut butters to school. Laszlo won’t have a reaction to it from it’s mere presence in the room. But most schools just want to avoid any potential fiasco and keep it away altogether. I’m sorry we’re such party poopers, but I swear that the allergy is a real and a dangerous thing for Laszlo. Well, I apologize to everyone except Broccoli Dad. He was such a jerk about it.
Tags: Health, Home, Mom, Preschool, Toddler Food
Back to: Cassandra Barry
132 Comments
[...] own website about nutrious eatting and an article about allergies that can be shared with others: http://blogs.babble.com/babble-voices/joel-stein-cassandra-barry-more-stories-about-some-kid/2011/10... Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:LikeBe the first to like this post. Filed under [...]
A Look Behind and a Walk Forward…. « moniquecolasanti commented on Nov 14 11 at 10:01 pmDebbie commented on Oct 18 11 at 5:22 pmYou are not imagining that other parents are annoyed by your kid’s allergy. I am one of those parents. Planning the school parties has over the years turned into a difficult proposition. The restrictions increase every year. Halloween especially is a nightmare because of the candy. But you know what? We need to get over ourselves. Better a party pooper than a child harmed.
Jen commented on Oct 18 11 at 5:48 pmI am also one of those parents annoyed by childs allergies, as wrong as it sounds, its true, but let me explain. It is NOT YOUR fault NOR your childs fault that there is an allergy. But why should my child not get to have the lunch that she wants at school when she sits half way across the HUGE cafeteria away from those children with peanut allergies………the allergen doesnt spread THAT far across one room. Im not annoyed at your child for having an allergy, im annoyed that my child is denied her choice of lunch (which its hard enough to get her to eat as it is) because the school doesnt want to be liable for an oopsi does it, when they are in charge of making sure that oopsie does it DOESNT do it ;) Its not fair to your child to be allergic to nuts, but its also not fair to ask mine not to eat something with nuts in it, when she knows not to eat it around those who do have the allergy. Its all in how we raise our kids with respect.
Kelly commented on Oct 18 11 at 5:55 pmI also have a son with nut allergies… ALL NUTS. He, however, can NOT be around them. For the first week of first grade he was sent home from school everyday with hives and struggled breathing because he sat next to the kid with the peanut butter sandwich. I felt like the “Bad Guy” because I was upset…
Kimberly commented on Oct 18 11 at 6:07 pmJen, with all respect, it is clear that you aren’t understanding the full magnitude of how severe some nut allergies are… yes, it can spread across a room. There are too many what ifs in your example to even be a plausible argument.
I was a flight attendant for 5 years, there were times when we’d have to have a specially cleaned plane and not allow passengers to eat any nut products they brought with them. Not allowed to even open the packaging. This is on major airlines… this is real. Nut allergies are real. And you know what… hardly anyone complained. In fact in the 5-6 times this happened I only recall only one passenger complaining.
I have a picky eater too, but come on, your kid not getting to have a P B and J is not even in the same ballpark.
Dina commented on Oct 18 11 at 6:28 pmReally sad that people feel put out and rights violated. Its another human being, a child for gods sake. We are lucky here no allergies.
How selfish can we be? your rights, my rights, his rights.. who cares… treat others how you would want to be treated..or better yet how you would want your child treated if in anothers shoes.
Rtuck commented on Oct 18 11 at 6:28 pmThe reason your child should have to sit allll the way at the other end of the cafeteria is to protect my child (along with all the other ones) and his LIFE. My son’s nut allergy bothers me to the point of annoyance because it is an inconvenience, just as your non-allergic child is inconvenienced. But my son’s inconvenience is at the risk of losing him altogether while yours is at the risk of your child being distanced from friends for a few moments or not having EVERY food option for one meal. I know it is annoying to us ALL, but please consider the circumstances here.
By the way Cassandra, our ER visit was very similar, but with much more vomiting. I wouldn’t wish it on anyone. I’m just hoping for better luck with our younger daughter. It is comforting to know that we are not alone in the fears and the party pooper issue, but it is unfortunate that it is our common ground.
Jen commented on Oct 18 11 at 6:29 pmI know nut allergies are real. So are many different allergies. Like the young girl that wears perfume to school causing my daughters asthma to act up. Or how about the child thats allergic to bees, yet the school cant seem to clean up its trash. There are very real allergies that go on in schools, yet the only one that seems to take prominence is the nut allergy. My kid cant eat peanut butter because of other kids allergies, than children shouldn’t wear perfume or cologne (one because they are too young to do so anyways) because of my childs asthma and other childrens asthma and yes that can also spread across the room. I was merely making a point that you just made through sarcasim. Sorry If it wasn’t clear enough for all of you. I worked at my daughters school for 2 years as a nurse’s assistant, I have had many children come in due to allergy flare ups, asthma flare ups, one special kid came in with a reaction to a childs make up……MAKE UP on an elementary school CHILD. Can you believe it? Children have allergies, the schools should make ALL children safe, not just ones with nut allergies, ones with asthma, and allergies to scents from perfumes and make up. If one child shouldn’t eat something due to another child’s allergy, than BAN EVERYTHING that can cause a child to have a flare up. Make up, perfume, nuts, (bees cant be helped) teachers should not wear perfume, or make up, or eat anything with nuts. See what I am saying?
Jen commented on Oct 18 11 at 6:33 pmRe-read the first comment I made……WOW. i am so sorry to everyone I offended, none of that came out how I wanted it too :( I think all children should be made safe in schools, by banning things that could cause an allergy flare up. That includes NUTS, perfume on a child OR teacher OR administrator. There should be no air freshners used in the classroom or scented items, these things CAN cause someones asthma to flare up. Just like NUTS could kill a child with a nut allergy.
Elizabeth commented on Oct 18 11 at 6:48 pmMaybe it was something on Burchard Ave??? Three of my youngest children (all of my boys) have nut allergies. Not to mention that the 3 year old has the same type of reaction to milk and eggs!! He has started preschool and talk about feeling like a party pooper. Milk allergy somehow implies ” the runs”. I find myself describing our first experience with formula as watching my infant begin to sufficate. His teacher (at Skidmore)has implemented a dairy free room as well. She understands the severity and is fantastic, but that didn’t make parent night any easier. I try to emphasize that I DON’T WANT THIS EITHER. It’s not just for fun.
I once heard a parent describe their daughter’s allergy to another parent by saying; “It’s like someone telling you that you have to send your child to a place everyday where there might be loaded guns and they may or may not go off and harm your child.” Maybe a bit drastic, but what other comparison do we have. Let’s keep our fingers crossed that thie will soon be a thing of the past!!!
lynn commented on Oct 18 11 at 7:23 pmI got a 3 page list of things my kid can and cant take to school for snack and its just not PEANUT BUTTER as some may think. Its anything processed in a plant that processes tree nuts. If it were my child with the allergy I would definately want them safe but I would also recommend a classroom for kids with allergies only. That would be the safest way to protect my child.
Very Bloggy Beth commented on Oct 18 11 at 7:27 pmThere are two girls at our school with nut allergies, and aside from being hyper aware that I have to really wash the peanut butter off my son before he heads to school, I seriously couldn’t care any less. As you said, there are a number of seed butters that are delicious and nutritious that won’t cause anyone any troubles. I don’t usually swear in forums like this, but fuck that dad. I mean it. He can (and likely will) go to hell. You’re doing what you need to do to protect your child, the way I’m sure does for his children. And, you have a good attitude about it. I think going out of your way to say you don’t mean to be a party pooper goes a long way with *most* people. They know you’re not doing it to be annoying, just safe.
Kirsten commented on Oct 18 11 at 8:15 pmMy son is allergic to milk and we made the mistake of saying it was ok to have in his preschool for snacktime. One of the mom helpers accidentally gave him a glass of milk (even though he had a bright yellow sticker declaring his allergies on his back)! This year we sent a letter to all the parents explaining the seriousness of his allergy.
Cindy commented on Oct 18 11 at 11:11 pmJen, I think the part you might be confused about is that if your child eats the nut butter for lunch and then accidentally touches a door handle, a pencil, a table, a wall, and an extremely allergic child touches the same thing that child can end up in the hospital. That child could even die if its not caught in time.
Its not about respecting someone enough to not eat the offending product by them. Of course you’re doing an amazing job teaching your child to respect others. In fact, this is just a continuation of that.
I understand your wanting your child to be able to have whatever they want for lunch, but we deny our kids things all the time for one reason or another. If my son wanted to eat donuts for lunch I’d say no and explain that donuts are a sometimes treat, not a lunch food. Obviously nuts are not the same as donuts, but the principle of setting limits with children about what they can have and when remains the same. It really is a simple thing to say no, no nuts at school, but you can have nuts and peanut butter sandwiches at home and on the weekends. Explain to your child that by not eating nuts at school they are doing their part is keeping their classmates safe and showing respect for their friends by not doing something they know could really hurt them. Even if they never know the child who is allergic, knowing they are helping to ensure that a nut allergic child in their school won’t be harmed can really make them proud, and teaches good citizenship, being a good neighbor, respecting your classmates, and most of all empathy. There can never be enough empathy in the world.
Maria Hardy commented on Oct 19 11 at 8:30 amI’m sorry this happened to your child too. I hope you’ve found a lot of support through family and friends and you should also consider local area Mom’s groups who support food allergies. I’m so glad I’ve met families in my own area. I founded what is my area’s Loudoun Allergy Network and just completed Chairing the FAAN Walk of Northern Virginia. It was a great event and FAAN’s LA Walk is coming up Oct 23rd! You should really check it out. They have organized a great event, your little boy will appreciate having some friends to know with allergies too in the future. Best of luck.
Naty commented on Oct 19 11 at 8:45 amMy son has peanut and egg allergies, and his life is more important to me. I resent anyone who gets annoyed with the fact that their kid can’t have peanuts or eggs or whatever it is that some other kid might be allergic to. It’s only at school and it is to keep my child and other children with allergies safe. People need to be more sensitive and realize that if it was their kid they would probably raise hell about not having peanuts or other allergen’s in school. If anything happened to my little boy i would just die, he’s my only son. My son also has asthma, and sometimes the daycares ignored the fact that his cough was due to his asthma, and I have picked my son from day care wheezing and all. I was pissed and i let them know about it. Believe it or not, most schools discriminate children with allergies. If your school isn’t doing it’s job to protect your child’s allergy, then let them know, and if they don’t do something about it.. take it to the school board. It sucks enough as it is that most parents don’t have the luxury of being able to work at their kids school where they can be there in case of an emergency.
Angi commented on Oct 19 11 at 10:30 amI will never understand why a food like peanuts is seen to be worth a person’s life. Hey, I love Reeses just as much as the next person, but I’m not willing to put someone’s life at risk because I think I have a “right” to eat it around people who are allergic to it. My daughter has a peanut allergy. Her school has been awesome about it (thank goodness)! I can not say the same thing about members of our family who insist on sneaking PB into the house. BTW -I love Elizabeth’s analogy about the guns. Drastic but true!
Homa commented on Oct 19 11 at 10:40 amWe deal with multiple FAs, so schools have no interest in us. I just wish food wasn’t everywhere in classrooms! I think kids can learn math just as well with beads instead of m&ms. Sigh.
Kelli commented on Oct 19 11 at 10:54 amPeople complain about their child’s rights to something as stupid as peanut products in schools, and they always, ALWAYS resort to, ..”well what about perfume that makes my child’s asthma act up, or what about this, or that…” You know what, NO ONE has died of smelling perfume, but PEANUT allergies KILL. And NO, all food allergic children do not deserve to be segregated and put into a separate classroom and kept away from everyone else any more than a child with a visible disability does. I mean really people, listen to yourselves…It’s a child’s life you’re talking about. Their LIFE.Just because ten years ago, this was practically unheard of doesn’t mean it is any less REAL now. It is here, if a child has a food allergy it’s not a matter of taking a magic pill to make it all go away…it’s here with vengeance and there is nothing you can do about it but strict avoidance to save the life of that child. It’s not easy to avoid something that is as common as air. The sensitivity to nut allergies is hard to believe sometimes…UNLESS it’s YOUR child you are holding and praying the Epinephrin injection does it’s job to help your child live long enough to get emergency help, unless it’s YOUR child you are watching swell right in front of you, unless it’s YOUR child you watch get covered in hives, sneeze, cough and gasp for air,…then stop judging us parents of Food Allergic children and start listening. Educate yourself and be understanding we are only doing what we need to do to hold our children ONE MORE DAY. What would you do in OUR shoes??? Think about it…
Michelle Young commented on Oct 19 11 at 11:04 amI understand the severity of food anaphylaxis very well I am a registered nurse of 10 years, as well as a former parent of a severely food allergic child. The obsession over nut allergies has gotten totally out of hand. Yes my son has suffered anaphylaxis on multiple occasions requiring dosing of epi. I just do not understand how these children exist in their day to day lives outside of school, do they live in bubbles? Nut free zones create a very dangerous false sense of security, and I am against them beyond grade one. I believe treatment cold likely be delayed since it’s assumed the zone is nut free when it really might not be. That is a far more dangerous scenario. A little common sense can go a long way.
Summer commented on Oct 19 11 at 11:14 amLynn, please don’t take this the wrong way I am not trying to attack you this is just very serious to me. These kids would be in a class all alone or maybe with one or two other children in different grades. Is your child’s pb&j worth my child becoming an isolated outcast that surely will become bullied? Then comes the day of the special assembly where my poor isolated kid gets to be involved, but the pb&j kid forgot to wash his hands, and touched the chair my child is sitting. Anaphylaxis has started, but he could not take his epi-pen to the assembly. So, how to get to the nurses office in time and get that locked cabinet opened. I know this sounds extreme but THIS HAPPENS peanut allergies are that severe.
Katie commented on Oct 19 11 at 11:37 amI personally have a nut allergy, and of course passed down an allergy to not only nuts, but also almonds and peanuts to my daughter. After my daughter’s first reaction and we got back her allergy results (class 5 to peanuts), a friend thoughtlessly brought her kids to a playdate with PB&J asked me if we “tried to give her something with peanuts just to be sure…” I tried to hold back my fury, and explained that the allergy test was sufficient and I didn’t want to kill my kid with some reckless experiment! I try to appreciate that parents who don’t have to deal with allergies just don’t understand, but they need to see that as parents we are not hysterical. I am constantly educating other parents and teachers about this issue and unfortunately find that scaring them about the issue is probably the most effective way to keep my daughter safe.
Anne commented on Oct 19 11 at 11:41 amI have two children with multiple life threatening food allergies (more than just nuts). When they were toddlers, I started informing myself on how other parents dealt with schools to keep children safe. After 2 years of actively being involved with the school/school administration, I decided it would be best for all that my children be homeschooled. Why? Because my children are high risk and asking a teacher to keep them safe while teaching another 22 kids is unrealistic. Because I am not the kind of parent that would say “please don’t bring this, this and this,…” because I know how difficult it can be and how easily a mistake can happen. I am fortunate enough to be able to stay home with my kids and homeschool them. I have a Master’s degree and believe that my children will learn more in a safe environment without constantly having to take Benadryl or fearing the Epi & ER episodes. I have met with teachers, administrators and yes, they do want to help and protect these children. But is is realistic? Also, having allergy kids together is no solution! Most kids have more than one food allergy and put a group of these kids together and it is a nightmare to find anything they can all eat (trust me, I have tried). Outside homeschooling, I find activities that are safe and do not require any extra precautions for my kids (e.g. swimming, biking, ice skating, running,…). This is to avoid them feeling they are different and me feeling like a party pooper. So I can completely relate to this article. Even if your husbands original article was a real hardship for us allergy moms to read!
Michelle commented on Oct 19 11 at 11:49 amI despise broccoli dads and moms! I have come across them in a few unexpected places…one I thought was a dear friend and another, a cousin who I now believe is the most selfish person I have ever come across and I now distance myself completely from her.
Exposing children in schools with severe, life threatening allergies to those foods is just as ridiculous to me as sending a child to school with leprosy so that the other children in the class may or may not contract it. Maybe that seems like an extremely ridiculous idea but like I said, I think bringing any kind of nuts to school is extremely ridiculous…
BTW, my child was cured of his severe peanut allergy. Its rare but it does happen and in my family it happens to be genetic.
There is absolutely no way I am ever going to make any parent or child feel like an outcast. I go out of my way to make everyone SAFE!
Chris commented on Oct 19 11 at 11:57 am1st off, I’m a “sufferer” of nut/poppy seed allergies and have been all my life. They started out somewhat mild (itchy mouth/hives) when I was a kid, and by the time I hit adolescence, went to full-blown anaphylaxis. The main difference between my child hood and that of the author/commenters kids is that you guys actually care about the issue–my parents took the issue very lightly even after I was nearly hospitalized back in highschool.
That being said, I think the primary problem with all severe food allergies is the label placed on them. When John Q. Public thinks of allergies they think of seasonal allergies. Sneezing, watery eyes, etc.; a moderate inconvenience but definitely not life threatening. “Allergy” is almost a misnomer. We should be calling it Food Anaphlyaxis. Not only would this provide a nice contrast to seasonal allergies, but is sounds about as serious as the condition really is.
Now, I personally think that the only level of accomodation needed for any food anaphylaxis sufferer is limiting the contact with said allergen to a point of informed consent. If Little Debbie is allergic to peanuts to the point that she can’t ingest them (inhaling the dust won’t kill her), then the only accomodation she needs is to be forewarned if any food contains any peanut products in it. That’s it. It’s not too much to ask. And parents, please remember your kids are smarter than you give them credit for–if they know the depth and the breadth of their anaphylaxis, they can police their own food even when stymied by teachers, other ignorant adults, and willfully ignorant parents.
And lastly, keep your kids encouraged if they do suffer from food anaphylaxis. Sometimes life has a nice way of balancing things out. If I eat nuts or poppy seeds I get a trip to the ER; but I can also eat food so spicy that it can send most everyone else to the ER. :)
CJ commented on Oct 19 11 at 12:07 pmIf only an allergic “flare up” was the only problem…. Anaphylaxis is not a runny nose or itchy eyes. It is two or more organ systems failing and the result can be death. No one is asking you to never eat nut products, just to noe eat them at school.
Even if you child eats on the other side of the cafeteria, he might have peanut/nut residue on his hands, face or clothing. This can kill. It’s like carring a loaded gun. Is it really such a big deal to leave the nuts at home????
Elizabeth commented on Oct 19 11 at 12:10 pmSince the disease of life-threatening food-allergies can present itself at any age in life, I pose the question to the parents who think their non-allergic child’s rights are being violated by not being able to eat nuts in school: how would you feel if your child was stricken with this disease tomorrow knowing that coming in contact with just one nut could possibly send your child into anaphylatic shock causing possible death in a matter of mere seconds? Is a non-allergic child’s right to eat nuts while at school really as important?
Dana commented on Oct 19 11 at 12:14 pmTHIS MADE MY DAY! Thank you for writing this! My son is allergic to soy, egg, wheat, peas, barley, oats and rice, oh yea and corn. Everyone thinks we are making it up too. We have not tried nuts or fish yet and are forbidden to until 3 years. UGH! It is so nice to know we are not alone. I will totally punch broccli dad, what an ass!
Jennifer commented on Oct 19 11 at 1:05 pmJen, who commented on October 18th, I want to let you in on a little secret. Some kids do have severe enough allergies that you can have a reaction from being in the same room as the allergen. There was a child at a school near our home, he was so allergic to peanuts and any nut for that matter, that if he breathed anywhere near nuts he would go into anaphylactic shock. Some allergies really are that severe. I don’t think your child eating a snickers or having a peanut butter and jelly sandwich is more important than someone’s life. Not every child’s allergy is that severe but you need to remember some are. What if that were your child? Would you want their life endangered because some self centered parent wanted their child to eat whatever they wanted.
Cassandra I really appreciated this article. Thank you. And I want to apologize to you for any parents who don’t know how to be adults and respect others and their differences. You have no need to feel like a party pooper, you are simply protecting your child which is what being a mother is all about.
April commented on Oct 19 11 at 1:59 pmThis comment is for Jen, and anyone else who cares to read it. My daughter is 6 years old, in 1st grade, and has a life-threatening allergy to all nuts. It is an unimaginable worry, and my daughter has nearly died from anaphylactic shock despite all of our obsessive precautions. We have been met with both compassion, and accomodation; and annoyance and intolerance. I don’t give a care if parents are annoyed, they’ll have to get over it. We have been asked “Why don’t we pick a different school?” Why don’t YOU pick a different school if you can’t live buy tolerant guidelines?? My child has as much “right” to be in her school as yours! My job is to protect my daughter, period. I think one of the most important, key pieces of information left out of this comment session is this……If your child has asthma: You know the triggers(smoke, Christmas trees, etc), you avoid them, you know the symptoms of a flare, you know how long you have, you know what to do to fix it, you take an inhaler, symptoms subside, and the flare-ups are usually predictable. If your child is allergic to bees: You know the trigger, you can see the culprit (bees), you avoid them, you know how to treat a sting, and your reaction is usually predictable. A nut/peanut allergic child’s culprit is invisible…you can’t see the peanut dust in the air when 300 other kids in the lunchroom had trail mix on their trays, you can’t see the peanut butter residue on the art desk everyone shares, and you can’t see the almond extract in hand soaps and lotions. So the ONLY option is total exclusion and avoidance from peanut/nut products as much as humanly possible. Also….EVERY TIME a peanut/nut allergic child is exposed to and reacts to their allergen, the reaction time (aka…treatment time) SHORTENS! That is….when my daughter had her first reaction…her body was crashing within 6 minutes. Then you add the time a child sits near a child with PB&J and luckily has only a slight reaction , maybe a few hives and sneezing…it was still an exposure….now reaction time is 4 minutes. The body continues to heighten it’s response now. Then a child accidentialy uses a hand soap with nuts in it (Bath and Body works is notorious for) and start having hives, but the reaction is caught and under control….another exposure…reaction time now 1 minute. Now we are dealing with life and death! It is not possible for a school staffer member to identify a childs reactioin, run for an epi-pen, administer it, and call 911 in 60 seconds! The child, or my daughter, would DIE!! Is it really that damn important for your child to have a right to lunch food now?! How far would you go to save YOUR child?? Would you want accomodations to keep your child YOUR child from a needless, preventatble death?! Feed them a peanut butter sandwich the second they get home, or in the car even on the way…I think they can wait! Atleast they won’t DIE waiting!
tammy commented on Oct 19 11 at 2:11 pmI can’t believe that people make a life threatening situation – about them. If there was a poison near your child and u KNOW its there and could potentially kill them – what would u do?
It is up to each individual how they choose to respond or not when it comes to food allergies. Know more about it – before taking a stand. Is it really that important for a child to have the peanut butter at breakfast or dinner? Instead of at lunch? Where the oils from peanut butter are easily spread? Especially in young elementary school aged kids.
I heard more than one person say – oh, just make sure u have your epipen. Really? That is so wrong! Our family lost a cousin last year. Someone mixed butter into her food. She injected herself with her epipen – ems got lost – a coworker injected her with the second (when she became unconscious) the needle broke. A horror of horror stories! A 20 year old girl lost her life because someone made the mistake and didn’t really understand.
Susan commented on Oct 19 11 at 2:19 pmI feel blessed to say that I too have a food allergic child, my deal sweet, smart, kind and thoughtful son has a life threatening allergy to milk, eggs and peanuts. Hes so allergic that if a food with any of see ingredients or byproducts of these items touch his skin he will swell, gasp for air and could die within moments…this child is just 1 of my 4 boys but he is so precious to me because just like someone said, sending my food allerg son to a school with 499 other children is indeed like sending him to a room with 499 loaded guns that could go off at any time. Please to all of you who do not struggle with feeding your children food that could kill them, think of what we have to think about every moment of the day….and what COULD happen….it terrifies me daily, hourly and I’m sure all of the other food allergy moms out there understand the constant fear. We love our children and are not trying to inconvenience your precious kid or their lunch or snack choice, we just have more things to worry about. Imagine having only a few choices for lunch or snack, not because we are picky but because that is all that is SAFE! Veggie dad should be smacked for
being a total jerk!
Ellie commented on Oct 19 11 at 2:41 pmDaughter is egg, peanut, treenut, seeds, soy, pork (hello, gelatin) allergic, some life threatening, all able to escalate. 1.) Get all the food out of the classroom. No one needs more baked goods, sugar, starch, fat, etc in their lives. Figure out how to enjoy each other and create a celebration without ingesting food. 2.) The younger kids are, I think the more protected their environment needs to be. As they age, can communicate, understand their allergies, the burden shifts off their care-givers and supervisors and onto them selves. When they can carry their own albuterol and epi-pen and use effectively, they have lost the “bubble.” Our job as parents is to help them grow and learn to be aware and self-sufficient. However, you cannot really expect a child under the age of say 13 to fully be responsible for things they cannot control (like access to medication).
Cassandra Barry commented on Oct 19 11 at 3:44 pmDear Jen (from the second comment), if your daughter is really attached to her peanut butter sandwich, have you tried Sunbutter? (Sunflower seed spread). It’s hard to believe until you try it, but it really does taste almost exactly like peanut butter. And I’m pretty sure it’s healthier, too.
Debra commented on Oct 19 11 at 5:12 pmI know how difficult it can be having a child with allergies and I’m sorry it’s been difficult for you as well.
I own a bag tag company and we do a peanut allergy bag tag to attach to children’s lunch boxes or backpacks for school. Many parents find this helpful to have in case there is a substitute teacher in the class. I’d be happy to send you one at no charge for your son. This is the link for the tag; http://www.etsy.com/listing/80788355/peanut-allergy-alert-bag-tag-allergy
On the page there is a “contact” field. If you press that and send me your address I will mail you one for him.
All the best to you!
-Debra
Toddle Tags, llc
Cassandra Barry commented on Oct 19 11 at 11:30 pmThanks, Debra. But oddly enough, Laszlo’s allergy to peanuts is probably very low (according to the blood test). He’s through the roof on a bunch of other nuts though. Are you peanut-exclusive?
Julia commented on Oct 20 11 at 3:12 amTo the parents of kids with allergies:
Please stop treating your children as victims. They have allergies. This sucks. This is the way it will be, in all likelihood, for the rest of their lives. They will not have the luxury of allergen-free zones in the real world. The sooner they (and you) realize that, the better.
I am not trying to be insensitive to your child’s specific needs. I am more than aware of the difficulties associated with having food allergies because I have severe and life threatening food allergies. However, when I was in school, there were no nut-free tables. Allergies were downright mysterious at the time, at least as compared to today’s knowledge. I made it through without ever having to go to the emergency room from school, not because I was coddled by fearful adults, worried about liability, but because my amazing mother taught me to be proactive about my health, my needs, and my own safety.
By the time I was able to go to school, I knew when and how to use my epi-pen. I knew when I should take benadryl and what to do after (the side effects were particularly difficult for me). I knew exactly what I was allergic to. I knew how to ask adults what ingredients were in the food offered to me, and I knew how to refuse that which would harm me. I wore a bracelet to help protect me should I ever not be able to speak for myself (I also have several drug allergies).
These are not unfair expectations to have of your small children! While I completely support asking the adults around your kids to take ALL precautions they can, please remember that you child is his or her own greatest advocate. If he catches a whiff of peanut butter, he needs to know to high-tail it out of the cafeteria immediately and let an adult know what is going on.
Food allergies don’t go away when school ends. School needs to prepare our children for the rest of their lives, not confuse them into a false sense of security. Food surrounds us. We will NEVER be safe from food allergies, regardless of precautions taken.
Please, empower your child to be proactive about his health, not ashamed of how he might affect someone else! It will make a world of difference…especially to the few who are still “annoyed” by food allergies. Believe me, parents and teachers will not roll their eyes or ignore your son when he asks for help. I am alive today because of it.
K. C. commented on Oct 20 11 at 9:42 amJulia, I do teach my son to be proactive; I’m sure those of us with food allergic kids do. But my son is 3: if someone gives him food, he doesn’t understand yet that he can’t eat it unless we know it’s safe. I tell him that all the time, but he’s 3. Along with teaching our kids to stand up for themselves, we need to teach others that this epidemic of food allergies is NO JOKE.
Donica Haraburda commented on Oct 20 11 at 9:47 amI love this! Feels so true to our experience too. Thank you for giving me a laugh. So little to laugh about re: life-threatening food allergy in our children.
Sanriobaby =^.^= commented on Oct 20 11 at 9:57 amI used to care for a child who had numerous food allergies and to say it was stressful was a complete understatement. While he was in my care, I constantly had to moniter him around other kids, just to make sure he wouldn’t accept a snack from a friend, new or old. At school, it was difficult for him to not partake in birthday parties w/o his mother sending along his own “special” snacks. His teachers, God bless them, they had to constantly check his classmates meals and have extra backup food on hand in case one of them showed up with a “forbidden/deadly” food item. Did it annoy some of the parents, yes, but surprisingly, many of them had a big change of heart once the mom sent home a letter to them explaining her son’s severe allergies and how she understands the inconvienence and burden of it all on his classmates. To me, having severe food allergies is like a disability and if more people had that frame of mind, then they would take it more seriously. Food allergies are not just about breaking out in a rash, many times it’s deadly if not treated in time. I sympathize w/any family that has a child w/food allergies. It can be quite expensive just to feed those kids who need a special diet. And for anyone who thinks this is an over reaction, shame on you. Most of these situations deal w/very young kids who need this hyper protection b/c they are too young to take on that responsibilty on their own. Until they are old enough to be trusted to care for and be hyper aware of thier OWN enviornment, they need extra protection at school. Until then, I don’t blame any parent who does whatever they need to in order to protect thier kids.
nutterbutter commented on Oct 20 11 at 10:02 amI have every sympathy with the sufferers of allergies and their families/carers who try to keep them safe. I have no issue with selecting class snacks/lunches that are suitable and healthy for all children at school. At our school all of our allergy children are in one kindergarten class and they have a very strict handwashing , seating and food policies. However no one is upposed to know who the allergy kids are. This is the stupidest policy I have ever heard of. Surely a life threatening condition that hinges on the co-operation and understanding of others trumps “privacy”. Some of our school children have nut allergies (all nuts), some are only peanut, and others are only tree nuts. Seafood, egg, dairy, wheat… the list goes on. Seating becomes a nightmare. I suggested personalised reusable placemats that indicated the food constraints required but the was a no because of privacy.Then there are kids who have had a specific intolerance to one type of nut, is not affected by traces in the air or on food ie they actually have to ingest a significant amount, and despite the parents advice, protests and frustration- that child is lumped with all of the allergies and denied a donut…to a chorus of shrieking harpies “Nooooo he has ALLERGIES!”. As a parent trying to keep all the children safe, to educate myself and my children, to feed my kids healthy food I would appreciate getting much more information from the concerned parents than is given. In Australia you can order brightly designed vinyl labels, T shirts and wrist braclets that clearly indicate a child’s allergy.You can bet my kids would sport a neon sign if they were deathly allergic to peanuts! Mostly I wish allergy parents, who have lived and researched the beejeesus out of their childs condition could provide a list of “safe” foods to be shared with the class parents, and be advocates for openess to improve understanding about allergies. Perhaps there is an opportunity to create an online class specific food safety website that can be tailored by parents of allergy kids.
Maybe brocoli dad isn’t stupid, just a klutz, and maybe he didn’t intend to belittle your fears but perhaps he was trying to lighten the moment when you were feeling uncomfortable and actutely aware of feeling judged?
BTW sun butter tastes awful, simply awful. I tried it, gave it to my kids..but it was a no go so I tried cooking with it… ick. I truly wish it was not so.
tmana commented on Oct 20 11 at 10:09 amWithout intending to downplay the severity of any of these allergies, I must pose the question: if schools are to be absolutely airborne- and contact-allergen free for all students and teachers, what would be left for them to consume at lunch or snack? No milk, eggs, cheese, fish, soy, peanuts, nuts, or meats = no protein. No grains (gluten), corn, soy, or nuts = no cookies, breads, chips, pretzels, or other similar foods = limited, or no, starches. Nothing aromatic = no seasonings for the raw fruits and vegetables (cooking them releases aromatics — and raw? there are all of those coatings and pesticides and such to worry about!)… so what’s left? An unseasoned (peeled) baked potato and water?
Removing food from the classroom is NOT an option if you want to keep ALL children safe. Children with diabetes MUST have ready sources of sugar and other snacks with them at all times; if for any reason their blood glucose levels drop (given too much insulin at breakfast or lunch, played a lot more than usual, or a number of other things), they need food right then and there. If they wait, they can go into seizures and die.
Finally, as several commenters mentioned, what happens when these children leave the school premises — whether to walk home, or to go on a field trip? What happens when they grow up and find the real world is a lot less tolerant of those allergies than their grade school? How and when do you teach your children to be aware of their environment, to avoid exposure when the allergen is pervasive, invisible, and fatal in concentrations too small to taste or smell?
Delia Lloyd commented on Oct 20 11 at 3:26 pmWell I must say I chuckled when I read this post because I had just returned from the hospital for my tenth (!) annual skin test for my son’s multiple food allergies. I, too, have always felt guilty for the notes and explanations and extensive questions at every birthday party/restaurant/dinner at a friends/camp/play date/you name it. I feel like it’s just asking too much of people to have to worry about this (and I of course always offer to send food along which they sometimes allow me to do.)
But over time, I find that I feel less burdensome. Part of it is that I live in London which is super multi-cultural, so there are loads of religious restrictions on diet. I also always feared that he would be teased for his allergies but that has never happened. It’s the opposite! I’ve had kids come to our house and imagine/wish that they had allergies too! It gets better. They grow out of some of them…including, in our case, peanuts (!)
Anyway, hang in there. It’s an ongoing struggle but you’ll get used to it…
Delia Lloyd
http://www.realdelia.com
Gwen Smith commented on Oct 20 11 at 3:53 pmThank you for this column, Cassandra. As the Editor of Allergic Living mag and an adult with allergies to peanut, soy and shellfish (diagnosed by severe reaction to each of those foods on separate occasions), I so get what you’re saying.
My advice: worry less about the party-pooping. More and more fellow parents are starting to see that that it’s a just sandwich, 5 times a week we’re talking about here. Kids can have their pb in the morning (pls. do wash up) or after school or whenever their parents allow. But school should be a safe place for ALL kids. School janitorial budgets aren’t what they once were, pb smears like crazy, and in cafeterias without much supervision, young kids can’t be relied on not to smear on each other.
I’m about the last person who’d ever ask a favor of those I don’t know, but it helps when you stop thinking of food allergies as an imposition. Rather it’s: yes, I hate to bug you but this is a health & safety not food issue. If my child was diabetic, would you not want to help? If my child had asthma, would you insist on pet projects in the class? Of course not. And ask yourself Cassandra: If this was Laszlo’s little friend who had the serious, possibly fatal allergy, would you do no less for him?
p.s. I am glad Joel did a mea culpa on the original column. He’s a great humorist with this notable exception.
Canuckmom commented on Oct 20 11 at 4:09 pmI was a nanny for a little girl with severe nut and peanut allergies (and soy, eggs, as well as having eczema, asthma, etc). At her older brother, W’s, school one day one of the moms was bragging to me how she snuck peanut butter sandwiches into her son’s lunch by mixing it with lots of jam. She thought she was hilarious and oh so smart. I told her about M’s allergy and she told me I must be exaggerating, M was just “picky”. So I told her tomorrow I would give W a rat poison and jam sandwich to give to her son. She didn’t seem to like that, but IT’S THE EXACT SAME THING!! How do people still not realize how deadly these are?!?
Oh, and these were 5 year olds, who share and smear. And if W had a tiny bit on his hand and held his sister’s hand, it WOULD be enough to transfer and harm her.
Melissa commented on Oct 20 11 at 4:59 pmI have a friend who is severely allergic to all uncooked or undercooked vegetables. No joke. He gets allergy shots once a week so that he can have lettuce on his sandwiches. He orders soup instead of salad. I once brought a veggie tray to his house and his wife looked at me like I was trying to kill him. Sometimes I forget, even though I have a freakish allergy to dairy (not lactose intolerance, it gives me severe cold symptoms for 2 weeks). Maybe broccoli dad was being serious?
Lisa commented on Oct 20 11 at 8:05 pmI understand the stress of food allergies. There are lots of fake healthy peanut butter alternatives out there for children who can’t live without their peanut butter – peanut butter is also a cheap protein packed great way of feeding anyone.
My issue with food allergies at school is that it is never truly explained, children aren’t educated on why and how it can actually affect another person. Childen are for the most part more empathetic than parents. If kids really understood why they are turning off the tap with paper towel maybe they would grow to be better understanding adults. I don’t think the no to this and that is helping anyone kids don’t live in bubbles, and yes they should feel safe at school and their peers should know why and support them.
Mari commented on Oct 20 11 at 9:21 pmI was diagnosed with diary, gluten , and egg allergies as an adult – and Ive spent every day afterwards feeling like the party pooper! Or some variation of picky eater, finicky personality, narrow-minded, too-good-for-your-food, etc. Because there are many restaurants that aren’t worth eating at and friendly food-related gatherings where I just can’t eat unless I bring my own. It’s hard, but those of us with allergies know it’s damn worth it.
GirltoMom- Heidi commented on Oct 20 11 at 10:30 pmMy husband went to Princeton with a girl who died from ordering chili at a restaurant- they used peanut butter to thicken it. You can’t be too careful, in my opinion.
Heidi- GirltoMom.com
Lauren Downing commented on Oct 20 11 at 11:14 pmI just want to thank you for posting this. My son broke out in hives after eating a cereal containing a trace amount of peanuts. Months later his lips and eyes swelled after a family member accidentally gave him a bite of a peanut butter cookie. I have already had friends who have mentioned how annoyed they were because they couldn’t serve their kids peanut butter at school, so I know I will be going through this when my baby goes to school.
Voice of Reason commented on Oct 20 11 at 11:42 pmI have a child who has Sensory Proecessing Disorder and is a highly resistant eater. Making lunches for him is difficult and I have a very limited number of choices from which to work. So, if faced with the choice of him going hungry all day and sending him with a PBJ, what would I do? He can damn well go hungry all day. Because your child’s problem is bigger and more important than my child’s problem. Your child’s problem is life-threatening.
Who are these assholes who don’t understand this fact? We talk about raising children to be kind and have empathy and then we spout this shit?! Yes, educate your children and give them tools to help themselves in a god-forbid type of situation, but we are the adults and while they are minors we need to take the lead and take the responsibility for their wellbeing. You know, like that village we’re always talking about. (The inconvenient village.)
Walk the walk, people. And for the record, my children’s school is fragrance-free, as is my yoga studio and a few other places that spring to mind. A lot of changes are being made to accommodate the needs of others and I, for one, am okay with that.
Voice of Reason commented on Oct 20 11 at 11:42 pmOops, that’s meant to say Sensory Processing Disorder. Duh.
yahoudi commented on Oct 22 11 at 10:37 amI think the safest and most sensible solution is to take food out of the school equation altogether. No food. Kids go home for lunch. No treats in classroom, no food at parties AT ALL. Parents responsible for feeding own kids at lunchtime and transporting them to and fro. Like when I grew up.
Remove the responsibility and liability from the schools- and save money by getting rid of the school lunch, breakfast, and in some localities, the dinner, programs.
Feed your children peeps. YOUR responsibility.
_Susan_ commented on Oct 23 11 at 7:59 amCassandra, I remember your husbands article. It seemed like one of many that ridiculed allergies and issues involving allergies. When we found out that your son had allergies, no one was happy. This is not something that we would ever wish on a child.
Children are fabulous! They instinctively protect and care for each other. They don’t want to be the cause of someone elses injury/death. They are the ones who pressure their parents to include their friends. Hatred and one-up-manship is learned behaviour.
I hate to give voice/credibility to those who demand they have a right to party or eat certain foods at school. What ever happened to the 3 R’s? We need to get those thoughts and feelings out into the cold light of day and see themfor what they are – fear of losing control, fear of the unknown. This is an opportunity to educate. For this I thank your husband but it has taken me sometime to get over the threatening feelings I first felt from his words.
I like to think that he was trying to open up dialogue with his article… and truly, that did happen.
Good luck in the future and your son is adorable!
kim commented on Oct 23 11 at 8:30 amMy son has an allergy to both peanuts and tree nuts. I read your article with similar feelings and dealings. It was even a little tougher as we own and operate a family candy store. Several of the items we make are with nuts. I had an overwhelming feeling of failure. I took my knowledge and turned it to my favor. We now have another location, directly across the street that is a dedicated peanut & tree nut free environment where we make several nut free products. We also now can do birthday parties for nut alleric kids in a safe environment.
Kim
Skips candy corner
Skips sugar shack.
Traci commented on Oct 23 11 at 8:42 amI love this. My son had allergies to peanuts, wheat, eggs, milk and bananas. He also has many environmental allergies. We have been fortunate in that his schools have been supportive. His preschool was awesome. When they made things in their classroom, the teachers always let me know so I could provide a safe alternative. Once, they were making bread…the teacher asked me for a safe recipe.
Now, he is in kindergarten. I was very nervous about this. He is only allergic to peanuts and bananas now. His teacher has been great. Before school started, she asked if she needed to wipe the tables down before they went to lunch. I declined since his class is t’d first one and the tables are already cleaned. The cafeteria is not nut free, and, so far, that’s been ok. They do not have an allergy table, however, they do have a “peanut table.” Only the kids who have safe lunches can sit with my son. It’s cute…I’ve heard the little kids tell him, “I didn’t bring peanut butter today! I get to sit with you.” It amazes me how caring and protective this group of five year olds is. They choose
I am totally supportive of nut free schools, but, fortunately, my son’s allergy doesn’t seem to require it.
Colleen commented on Oct 23 11 at 9:31 amMy son is allergic to broccoli and peanuts
He has 5 safe foods
My son’s class doesn’t eat nut or cheese products
Its hard when your kids are allergic
I’m not clear why you are mad at broccoli dad
Dorothy commented on Oct 23 11 at 9:36 amI continue to find issues with this family. She implies that because of HER HERITAGE, her kid is strong and healthy and only falls victim to allergy b/c her husband is JEWISH. What the heck does that have to do with anything? And furthermore, she rags on the man she calls “Broccoli dad” b/c he made a comment that his kid is allergic to brocc and all other vegetables. It is implied, but not stated, that broccoli dad is just being an ass–but there ARE children allergic to broccoli-my son was one of them. There ARE children who can’t eat vegetables–think of the kids with EE who can’t eat everything. I’m still annoyed by the fact that she refers to her husband’s statment that “he didn’t want to be a party pooper.” Well I’m sorry-I’ll be the party pooper EVERY SINGLE TIME. Impliying that those of us who DO speak out and speak out LOUDLY about our children’s FAs is NOT being a party pooper!
Karen commented on Oct 23 11 at 9:55 amCassandra, you are right on the money. We parents of children with life-threatening allergies do often feel like party poopers; I find I constantly have to check in with myself – should I just ease up a bit? Or be a drag and protect my daughter’s life? Oh right! Choice B! As for the woman who very dramatically described the children sitting WAY across the cafeteria, let me ask you this: How about if that kid across with the room finishes up lunch, forgets to wash their hands (kids never do that, right?), comes back to my kids classroom, rummages through some class supplies, and my kid is right behind them, ready to stick her hand in next? I know – it sounds involved, but not all that off-base if you think about it. Sorry your kid can’t have that one lunchbox item they prefer. If it helps, my kid might not have her life endangered, so thanks for managing your inconvenience.
Susan of Little Ladies Who Lunch commented on Oct 23 11 at 10:35 amWe don’t have any nut allergies here, but it would never occur to me to rant and rave about my children’s right to eat nuts or nut products at school should they be asked not to. Lunch options are endless. Just teach your kids to eat a variety of foods and you won’t be worried about their right to eat peanut butter. Give it to them as an after-school snack and you have yourself a solution. It’s funny to me that the majority of school children actually understand and respect allergies, while the parents do not. Does that tell you anything?
Anna commented on Oct 23 11 at 10:39 amI usually equate the inconvenience another way: If we required the handwashing and avoidance list because a child in the class was a cancer patient, would you consider it the same inconvenience? Cancer and food allergies can both kill. My 7yo son is allergic to eggs and peanuts (and until last week, milk as well…we finally passed the food challenge after 4 long years of attempts). Luckily, he can be around the allergens, he just can’t ingest them. He’s been advocating for himself since he was 2 years old, though, and he knows what he can and can’t have and not to accept food from anyone else. Now that he can read, it’s even easier for him. But yes, I send the long list of no-nos to his teachers/school nurse every year, and I send home a list of treats that are usually safe to the other parents. Do they abide by it? No. But he waits until he gets home to open treat bags and the like until an adult he trusts can check everything and tell him if can have it or not.
Sadly, you can’t stop other people from being @$$holes and you can’t make them understand something that they don’t want to understand. Yes, your kid has a right to a PB&J, but my kid has a right to live. Eat your PB&J at home.
Steph commented on Oct 23 11 at 10:42 amI have a 3 yr old with life threatening allergies to multiple foods including tree nuts, peanuts, and shellfish along with a lactose intolerance(don’t confuse w milk allergy) and he has asthma. I have a real problem for any adult who thinks limiting the types of food in schools is such an inconvenience when it could mean life or death for my son. My son can die within minutes from trace amounts or airborne protein of nuts in the air. He doesn’t even have to ingest the allergen to have an anaphalyatic reaction just touching a cashew was enough to trigger his first reaction.. Hives swelling and gasping for breath (asthma makes food allergies even more severe). Airborne Particles can trigger life threatening reactions as well..and for all those ppl saying you have to teach your child about their allergies and what to do..do you think we don’t?! My son is 3 he KNOWS he has allergies, ask adults to check the label, knows how to use his epipen, and wears a medic alert bracelet. Yet I am terrified every day he is at school and I am not there w him. His school is REQUIRED by law to be a nut free zone (for those of you who have trouble w the school complying to keep your child safe without SEGREGATING them get a 504 plan asap) i still worry bc we have had an incident at my sons school. The cafeteria sent cereal for breakfast one day, honey nut Cheerios..now how that didn’t register as a nut product..idk says Nut right on it. Even said Containd Almonds (tree nuts are in a lot of foods!!!) All those non allergic parents who say their kid has rights to eat what they want, our kids have rights too!!!! And making them feel isolated bc it’s an inconvenience to you or your child, is down right wrong! A few hours of the day without nut products will not kill your non allergic child however, any contact with nuts could kill my child. Parents of young children with food allergies are our Childs biggest advocate! Our kids are discriminated against enough in the real world..do you know how food allergies changes your entire life?! It’s not just about not beig able to eat pbj..it’s way more than that. There are place my son cannot go bc of his allergies restaurants, malls (bc they have a roasted nut stand and the airborne particles), bday parties are a nightmare let alone Halloween, soaps, and lotions can trigger a reaction. My son is 3 and I could go on for hours about the things my son cannot do. I watch my son like a hawk, at school is the only place he isn’t with me ALL the time. So yes I expect the school to KEEP him safe..I volunteer when I can and I ALWAYS go on field trips. I do what I can to keep my baby safe but allergic reactions happen..avoiding the allergen all together at school is the only way he will stay safe. It’s not asking much when it’s life or death. Under the 504 plan a young child with severe food allergies is considered to be a hidden disability..and anyone that says allowing nuts in school is not preparing them for the real world. Tell me how cupcakes in the classroom provide any educational experience? Or the fact my child is THREE and doesn’t fully understand, avoidance is the only way to stay safe. Most parents who have kids w food allergies don’t go out often to put their child in the position to have a reaction. Oh and let me be very clear peanuts are a legume when someone says they have a nut allergy DO NOT assume it’s just peanuts..TREE NUTS are in everything!
yahoudi commented on Oct 23 11 at 10:47 amAgain- make schools FOOD-FREE zones. Problems solved, money saved and everyone is SAFE and ALIVE.
Feed your children in your OWN home under your OWN supervision.
Cat commented on Oct 23 11 at 11:37 amI’ve been a classroom parent & have seen children’s attitudes about allergens. Let me say that children aren’t the ones with the attitude that their rights are being taken away. It’s their parents teaching their children this. I have seen allergies explained to elementary school age children & a food-allergic child make a presentation on their allergies & what could happen if they are exposed accidentally. The children in the class have always wanted to keep this child safe & go so far as to tell their parents not to have certain items at birthday parties just so the allergic child could attend. So, when you hear about children’s rights & see the protests and signs, remember it’s the parents who are teaching their children to be intolerable, hateful, condescending, & apathetic. It is so sad to see some children who were very worried about their allergic classmate, come back to school & tell the class that “my parents say food allergies aren’t that bad”. I have seen the change & it’s always the PARENT instilling this change in their child. Children are innocent & want to take care of each other until the parent has their way with their child telling them why this allergic child does not matter because everyone should eat whatever they want to no matter who it hurts.
Nicole commented on Oct 23 11 at 12:00 pmI remember the day your husband, Joel’s, column about food allergies was published like it was yesterday. As the parent of a child with 11 life-threatening food allergies and the chair of a support group, that column was cut, pasted & emailed to me constantly over the course of a year. As it was reprinted in various sources, people would clip it out & use it like a weapon against my family. I found myself explaining over & over that, “Mr. Stein is NOT a doctor.” and , “This is an OPINION column, not a medical journal.” As I sat down to read your blog, I thought today was the day I would forgive Joel Stein. Sadly, that was not to be the case. His choice to remain “liked” rather than advocate for your son is very disappointing. No one wants to be the crazy allergy-parent, but asking his classmates to forgoe a portion of one food group during the course of a short preschool day, is hardly a sacrifice. Man-up, Mr. Stein!
And to those who comment that we’re not preparing our food-allergic kids for the real world: Since when does PRESCHOOL in any way resemble “the real world”? That’s like eliminating school crossing guards because “In the real world no one’s going to stop traffic for you to cross the street.” Some of us just want our kids to live long enough to reach the real world.
Rebeca @ The Average Parent commented on Oct 23 11 at 1:05 pmthe ignorance in some of these comments is infuriating! My son has a life threatening allergy to peanuts and tree nuts. And while I appreciate the fact that there are tons of other serious allergies that children suffer from, the fact is that nut allergies (along with shell fish) are the most life threatening. For my son, he does not have to ingest nuts to have a reaction. So, if your child has a peanut butter sandwich and touches my child–HE COULD DIE! That risk is just to great to mess around with. I’m sorry that you find it to be an inconvenience, but the fact is that your children will not die if they refrain from eating nut products…but having them around just might kill another child could. Do you want that to be on your conscience?
Furthermore, it wouldn’t kill you to show a little compassion. Do you ever think about what my 4yo feels like when he can’t have the same cookies everybody else is enjoying because some parent didn’t think it was necessary to read the label? Are you that selfish that you can’t even stop to consider what the child is feeling? There are plenty of nut-safe foods on the market and the more people start buying them, the more food manufacturers will make them available.
yahoudi commented on Oct 23 11 at 1:22 pmIf we make schools FOOD-FREE zones, the problems are solved, money is saved and everyone is SAFE and children are kept ALIVE.
Everyone feeds their own children at home and makes sure they don’t eat foods to which they are allergic. The schools should not be in the feeding business and do not need the liability associated with allergic reactions.
FOOD-FREE SCHOOLS!
Jan commented on Oct 23 11 at 2:24 pmI really enjoyed reading your article – it was funny and I am the parent of a child with allergies and some hearing loss – if my child had an arm missing or 2 heads it would be easier for people to accept that these challenges were real – it is not about an allergen traveling across the HUGE dining room but that your kid who is smeared in peanut butter may touch a book, desk, toilet door or any anything else with their allergen hands and harm my child – so suck it up – all you parents irritated by our children – would you take the risk with your kid – would you feed them cookies if the ingredients said may contain shards of glass. no I don’t think so either. I would not dream of exposing your child to something that could harm them and if you are willing to do that to my child you are starting a war.
Jodi Zavos commented on Oct 23 11 at 2:36 pmFirst of all, I am very sorry that your son has food allergies. But I remember reading your husband’s insensitive article and how angry it made me and my food allergic son. I am no longer angry but now satisfied that your husband will know first hand what it feels like to encounter people like himself.
Barb commented on Oct 23 11 at 3:11 pmI think you are right on the button with this article. Our daughter has multiple food allergies with anaphylaxis to all nuts. We have friends who kept bringing dips with nuts in them to our house when we were having BBQs. It took many months of telling them not to before it sunk in. Then going to their house was always a nightmare as they thought it would be okay to have the nuts there – duh! They even bought nuts with them when they went camping with us and worse they actually put them out on the table and when I asked for them to be removed she said to her daughter – ok just have a few more before I put them away. I was shocked and when I asked them to go and wash their hands and they didnt. I then had to throw away all the safe food that the child then touched. I totally lost the plot over this and the rest of the holiday did not go very well. This incident had a safe outcome because I was there. But what if I wasnt? We were in a remote camping area with people I thought we could trust. Yes I felt like a party pooper but my daughter’s life is way more important. This is the sort of incident our allergic kids are exposed to everyday. It is a blatant disregard by some people to the seriousness of the allergy. Like others my daughter is allergic to so many different foods, but it is only nuts that she reacts to in a serious life threatening way. I advocate education about the seriousness of allergies and what better place to start than in schools. And I totally believe that all parents should take allergies more seriously. I mean really people, it can kill – do you want that on your conscience, or on your childs because you gave them nuts to take to school?
puzzled commented on Oct 23 11 at 3:33 pmOr blatant disregard by the parents [of the child with allergies] to the seriousness of the allergy. If a whiff or touch is enough to cause anaphylaxis, why would you trust society to safeguard his/her life at such a young age?
Esther commented on Oct 23 11 at 3:44 pmThank you, thank you, thank you, Cassandra and previous commenters!!!
Everyone else pretty much covered anything I might’ve thought to say, but I would like to mention something to Jen and others in similar situations. Your child does not have to continue to suffer with fragrances. Say something! It is well documented that fragrances are a problem for some people. If this continues and you do nothing, don’t complain to those of us with food allergies and/or food allergic children. You have a responsibility to speak up for your daughter, and if anything, you want to make friends with us because we get it. If anyone will understand your situation, we will. You want us on your team!
Tmana and others who may be confused about this issue: An aroma and a fragrance are not the same thing. Fragrances in the sense that we’re talking are generally manmade/man engineered chemicals
Cross contact is my biggest concern for myself and my son. There are a number of foods that I cannot have
Yahoudi, I am of the opinion that everyone should homeschool. It’s a great life and there’s more realistic control of the food situation. Short of that, I don’t think food is going away in the schools.
Esther commented on Oct 23 11 at 4:14 pmDarnit! My dog made me hit the comment button prematurely. Anybody want the most annoying Jack Russell on the face of the earth??
As I was saying in the spot where I had inserted a comment about aromas and fragrances: Just because you can smell it doesn’t mean it’s a fragrance in this context. It has nothing to do with seasonings in food. Season away!
Plenty of people have issues with fragrances, and manufacturers are responding to that by making fragrance free/dye free detergents, etc. Our church has a huge ladies’ event at Christmastime and it is announced that those attending need to refrain from using perfume or other heavily scented products. Scented candles, etc. are not allowed. It’s not a big deal. Sensitivity to fragrances is acknowledged as a very real problem and people are responding by being accommodating so that everyone can have a good time. But if you never say something about your child having this problem, don’t expect anyone to help your child. How can we if we don’t even know?
Re: Preparing for the “real” world – The school environment bears little resemblance to the real world. That’s not a valid point.
Jennifer commented on Oct 23 11 at 6:04 pmAs a parent of two peanut and tree nut allergic children, I understand you completely. Wait until your kid is old enough for field trips and parents like Broccoli Dad complain that you always get picked to chaperone. People can be such jerks.
Nicole commented on Oct 23 11 at 8:35 pmAllow me to clear up the question of our “blatant disregard” for you, Puzzled. Not a single parent of a young child diagnosed with anaphylactic allergies doesn’t think to themselves at one point or another, “There’s no way he/she can go to school. I will have to find a way to keep him home with me.” But the reality is, as they grow up, we realize that they DESERVE to go to school. My daughter can be killed by something as benign as milk or flour…but she desperately wants to be normal. She not only deserves to be taught by qualified professionals (which I am not), but to have recess and a best friend. My child deserves to experience art class, the clang of a locker door and the dread of an impending parent/teacher conference. These are the things that enriched our own childhoods. How could I deny them to my daughter? And how could you, for the want of a sandwich, deny her? It’s so simple to make school a safer place for all of our kids. Why would anyone even think of complaining about such a thing or worse, implying that we “disregard” the safety of our children?
Barb commented on Oct 24 11 at 3:33 amPuzzled – So do you think all allergic kids should be locked up at home so nothing can hurt them? Then what about allergic adults, they couldnt possibly go to work either – Allergies dont stop when you grow up, it is all about learning to take ownership of their own health and school is a really important place for them to do it. I dont know what the stats are, but I’m thinking more serious allergic reactions happen in the teen years than at any other time. By ensuring people are aware at an early age can only be helpful in the long time, and really, how hard is it to be nut free? We do it on a daily basis and my husband and son used to have Pb every day. and we miss it. but we would miss our daughter more.
Beth commented on Oct 24 11 at 7:41 amHaving a child with multiple life threatening food allergies (11, if you do not count each specific kind of nut) is difficult, emotionally, physically and mentally. Kids are in school for a mere 6 or 7 hours. If the parents feel their non allergic kid is being deprived, let those families LOAD the kid up in the morning at home before school, and again when they arrive home. Our town has been fabulous how they have handled my son’s allergy situation and because of the common sense approach, he is a well liked, well adjusted student. He still gets hives during and after basketball, his favorite sport, but we do our best to keep him healthy. Our school made it mandatory for ALL grades to bring only real fruits or veggies to the class for snack. Not just the classroom with the allergic kids. They sited and rightly so, the overwhelming obesity epidemic – kind of a “get back to basics” way to have kids be aware of what they put in there mouths. My child stayed safe, the other kids all got at least one serving of fruit or veggies that was NOT a french fry. He is in eighth grade now and is very savvy about his allergies and is able to give himself the epi pen. The years that the “ultra careful” phase that the surrounding public needs to heed lessens (not disappear) as the child learns life skill appropriate for the life HE will need to live. My son now sits with everyone at lunch and has had milk spilled on him, he knows to wash (had hives were the milk hit immediately) and change his clothes – we were lucky none reached his eyes, nose or mouth, but he handled it and carries and epi all the time. He has been penned 9 times. The epi pen does work. He feels like the risk is so worth the benefit of socializing with friends at lunch. So parents, it is ALWAYS the parents that have issues with keeping a food allergic child safe. My child’s peers care with a depth that NEVER ceases to amaze me. Empathy runs deep in the children in our town and not a day goes by that I am not eternally grateful. <3
puzzled commented on Oct 24 11 at 11:16 amSo what do you do when a class or school has children whose 504s demand that it be a peanut,/tree nut/all nut, wheat/gluten, cheese/dairy and egg-free environment?
La commented on Oct 24 11 at 11:38 ami find it ironic the folks here expect people to respect and tolerate their childs nut and other food allergies, but yet so many of you are quick to blow off broccolli dad as a faker. i feel bad that so many of your children are going to grow up as demanding, impractical, and self centered as you are. and as far as the “you can’t put them in their own class because then they will be social outcasts” arguement goes. they have a deadly food allergy that requires near sterilization of their entire area of certain common food products. THEY ARE GOING TO BE SOCIAL OUTCASTS ANYWAY. treating them like fragile soap bubbles is only going to make that worse for them. i applaud the commentor who advised to teach them proactivity. they’ve got the right idea.
and for the record, i am allergic to artichokes.
Barb commented on Oct 24 11 at 9:33 pmJust for the record, I do not advocate blanket nut/allergy bans because it is too hard to police and, in our case particularly, would involve too many foods. My daughter has known since she was 2 how to keep herself safe, and not to accept food from anyone except us, as she has grown up she can now go to a friends house without having to take special food – most of her friends have food she can eat and their families are respectful and do not put nuts out around her. As for being social outcasts, that is just rubbish. The only people who think that are likely to be people who cant see past themselves anyway.
Stacie @ The Divine Miss Mommy commented on Oct 25 11 at 12:12 amUntil I read this article, the peanut allergy thing always annoyed me as a parent. Now I will never look at it the same way again. Thanks for enlightening me. Truly.
Cam commented on Oct 25 11 at 10:28 amI have a question for the parents of kids with allergies, which I am not. I’m not being inflammatory, sarcastic, or trying to be insensitive. I truly want to be educated, as two of my children in elementary school have been in classrooms where there is a child with an anaphylactic allergy. My oldest daughter is now in junior high, and they don’t restrict anything in classrooms or the lunch room. Sometimes on extended home room days, they even allow the kids to bring in baked goods, etc. Wouldn’t that expose the kids with allergies to potential particles in the air, or residue on objects throughout the school? Also, while the elementary school has classrooms that ban allergens, and the cafeteria has allergen free tables, they don’t have an entire ban on sandwiches brought from home. Wouldn’t that also potentially expose the kids with allergies to residue on objects around the school, or air particles? Not all parents can leave their jobs to take their children home for lunch, so what is the answer to protect these children, and also, where do you draw the line on banned items? My son has a friend who is severely allergic to milk, almonds, and corn ( that includes many food additives that aren’t clearly labeled that they are derived from corn). Unless you prevent all food at school, how can you be sure to protect everyone, and not just one type of allergy? Again, there is no snarkiness intended. I truly want perspective from parents who may have legitimate ideas, who know the issue well.
Lauree commented on Oct 25 11 at 6:31 pmI do think allergies are becoming so prevalent that there should be special schools for those children. We had a child at our daycare that couldn’t be anywhere around peanut butter. If another kid had peanut butter the day before and didn’t get it completely off him than this kid could die. The mother wanted to ban peanut butter in all households but even then, for example, if a kids aunt was visiting and didn’t know about the rule and kissed the child before school just that miniscule amount could kill the child. I certainly feel bad for the child but there are things that can be done such as homeschooling or a charter school and then you’ll know what your child is being exposed too and another child or family won’t have to feel like they’re criminals for accidentally causing a bad or lethal reaction in your child.
yahoudi commented on Oct 25 11 at 6:37 pmI guess a private pre-schools/schools could make peanut-free households a condition of enrollment of their students, but a public school could not.
Erica commented on Oct 25 11 at 11:16 pmTo the person saying perfum/scents can’t harm someone. I’m that someone. I get instantaneous migraines from perfume/strong smells. Luckily, as an adult I know what to do. As a child, I had more asthma attacks than I can count due to this.
Eucalyptus is my silent killer. If I smell it – asthma attack and migraine w/in minutes. If it gets on my skin – instant hives/burning sensation. If I ingest it, instant swelling of tongue and throat. Learned each by accident….let’s just say that having a Hall’s cough drop about killed me. Heck – the smell of one makes me really sick.
To the person who says/thinks smells are a hoax, come live with me. Let me show you what an arrangement with dried eucalyptus in it does to me. Until you experience a life threatening allergy yourself, you will never truly understand. My last allergy test I had such severe reactions to cat and various enviromental allergens that w/in 1 minute of the prick, I could barely stand the itch; w/in 3 minues I had 4 various pills and a steroid shot in me. Don’t tell me that smells won’t affect someone with allergies.
Marlena Salgado commented on Oct 26 11 at 6:06 amMy problem is exactly the opposite, my son has an extremely limited diet and the only protein he gets is from peanut butter. He doesn’t eat meat, cheese, other dairy, or soy products. We’ve been to specialist and are working on expanding his diet, but for the last three years, only peanut butter. We’ve been livivng overseas and are moving back to the U.S soon and I am extremely worried about the blanket peanut butter bans. My son will not get enough protein to grow or have anything for lunch if he doesn’t have a peanut butter sandwich.
I suffer from serious allergies myself, so I don’t take other’s allergies lightly. However, what about my son? He needs to get a healthy lunch that fit within his restrictions as well.
Estarianne commented on Oct 26 11 at 11:55 amThe problem that people don’t understand is that not all allergies are created equal. The human immune system reacts differently to some proteins than others. The reason nut allergies (like bee allergies) are more important than broccoli allergies is that they can be instantly fatal and brought about by seemingly non-existent contact with the protein (which is very large). Is a bee going to spray toxin out of its back-end into the wind? No. But a child eating a peanut butter sandwich is going to cough, sneeze, speak, touch things- it’s DIFFERENT. And a child could DIE! Yes, a child could DIE because you didn’t want to make your kid a turkey (or tofurkey) sandwich instead of a peanut butter sandwich.
I do not understand people, honestly. If you don’t understand, ask, learn, investigate. Just refusing to believe because you don’t understand why a child’s peanut allergy is different than your kid’s strawberry allergy is ridiculous. Not all proteins are likely to cause anaphylactic allergies, and even those that do tend are not all equally likely to be fatal.
Emily commented on Oct 26 11 at 7:00 pmMy son started kindergarten this Fall and two boys in his class have life-threatening allergies to peanuts, cashews and pistachios. Today, I ate some chocolate covered cashews in the car and made a pit-stop to wash my hands before picking up my son. If one of those poor boys touched the same door handle as I did with my cashew-contaminated hands then put those hands in his mouth….hello emergency room! It is dangerous. It is inconvenient. But it’s worth it for the well-being of those little boys.
When my son realized WHY he can’t bring a PB&J to school, he got so excited about listing off things he CAN bring that won’t hurt his friends. Your kids will react to children with allergies the way you do–if you act like they are an inconvenience or an outcast, your kids will behave likewise. And that is a horrible way to raise your children. I thank God every day that I don’t have to deal with that in my home–and I do whatever I can to ensure the safety of the kids we know who do have to deal with it.
yahoudi commented on Oct 26 11 at 8:15 pmHow about if it also included wheat, eggs, dairy/cheese products in addition to peanut/tree nut and soynut allergies?
Seriously people, is it going to take deaths before you realize you NEED to get food OUT of the schools altogether? Feed your own kids their meals and let schools feed their minds. Put ALL kids on an equal playing field at school. NO FOOD at school. Period.
yahoudi commented on Oct 26 11 at 8:16 pmHow about if it also included wheat, eggs, dairy/cheese products in addition to peanut/tree nut and soynut allergies?
Top 8 allergies:
Milk
Eggs
Peanuts
Tree nuts (such as almonds, cashews, walnuts)
Fish (such as bass, cod, flounder)
Shellfish (such as crab, lobster, shrimp)
Soy
WheatSeriously people, is it going to take deaths before you realize you NEED to get food OUT of the schools altogether? Feed your own kids their meals and let schools feed their minds. Put ALL kids on an equal playing field at school. NO FOOD at school. Period.
Jill commented on Oct 26 11 at 10:39 pmyahoudi, you are you really as ignorant as you sound? There are millions of children in US schools who get their only meals from the free breakfast and lunch programs. They would certainly not be on an “equal playing field” if the schools were to only “feed their minds” as you suggest.
yahoudi commented on Oct 27 11 at 12:08 amDon’t have kids you can’t afford to feed. THAT is true ignorance.
Louise Larsen commented on Oct 28 11 at 6:49 pmSorry to sound so stern, but I really hope your readers fully grasp what your husband originally wrote about nut allergies. It’s not funny now and it sure wasn’t funny then. It was just plain disturbing.
JOEL STIEN’: NUT ALLERGIES — A YUPPIE INVENTION
http://www.latimes.com/news/opinion/la-oe-stein9-2009jan09,0,3149168.columnLook: I am really, truly sorry your child has this. I would never wish this on another living soul. I am not so sure about any “Karma theory.” I am sure more and more people are being born with serious food allergies which has always been something I’ve struggled hard to raise awareness about.
In light of this, I just have to ask, do you think he’s done everything he can do to counter his original LA Times piece (now cached forever on the internet as fodder for stupid AM Radio talkshow hosts) that anaphylaxis shouldn’t be taken seriously? Or that peanut allergies are just an annoying fiction? It is not a fiction when it happens to your child. I truly hope to God that never happens to you or anyone else on the planet. But, happen it will to someone. Because of one mistake. One little mistake is all it takes. One person who didn’t do enough to take the allergy seriously enough.
To have contributed to the dumbing down of our collective awareness regarding nut allergies must be hard to live with. Please consider doing more to raise the right kind of awareness, about food allergies. In particular, about peanut allergies. I think that’s a great way to right this kind of wrong. Thanks for reading. Louise Larsen — Creator of Facebook’s “Parents of Kids with a Severe Peanut Allergy.”
Cheryl commented on Oct 29 11 at 1:51 pmMocking “Broccolli Dad” when you don’t know him or his child’s health history is rude.
Please feel free to nickname me Vegetable and Fruit Mom because in addition to tree nuts, my child is anaphylactic to some vegetables and fruits; allergic to many more. First anaphylactic reaction was to a carrot. We have never asked that fruits and vegetables be removed from the classroom but she cannot touch or eat them – and for some she cannot even be around if they are being cut – e.g., onions or melons. While it is not as harsh as the tree nut allergies I can tell you that it is harder to live without fruits and vegetables than the tree nuts. Labelling is mandatory for tree nuts but not for celery, carrots etc. Did you know that lip gloss often has avocado?
A school should never ask publicly about food allergies because that is private health information. If the family chooses to bring it up in a public forum that is their choice. The kids typically figure out who has the allergies but it should be generic “a student in room 102 has…” because there are nasty people who will bully students with food allergies.
Nicole commented on Oct 29 11 at 7:02 pmYour husband did not curse your baby. Even though I didn’t particularly like his article, I don’t blame him either. Now that he lives with it, maybe he will get over his “I want to be Mr. Popular” and become a real dad. My son can be hurt by the peanuts and peanut butter in the room. You’rs may in time too, so, you may as well ask them not to bring it. Plus, a person accidentally cross contaminate and hurt your child. I also want you to know, no one in my family can eat nuts. I had sent my son to school, ate a pbj sandwich at work and didn’t see him until after washing my face, hands, and brushing my teeth, I kissed him on the cheek and he had a hive on his face for two days. I wish it was psychosomatic, but it’s not. It’s very scary and real.
Karen commented on Oct 30 11 at 1:26 amThere is an accupressure protocol that can eliminate a person’s reactions to an allergen. Check out naet.com. There is a special protocol for severe reactions, such as to peanuts. NAET has given my children and me our lives back-we no longer have to watch what we eat. Also, I know how to test myself and my kids before they eat something to see if they will react to it.
BTW, the rise in peanut allergies is due to the fact that virtually all peanuts are now GMO. People are reacting to the GMO, rather than the acutal peanut. Same with soy allergies.
Mira commented on Oct 31 11 at 1:47 pmI know I’m responding late, but I loved this article. My only critique is that you were far, far too kind to Broccoli Dad. The next time this guy makes a remark like that, some other dad (or mom, but I’m picturing a dad) is going to hunt him down in the parking lot and initiate a “conversation” that begins “You wanna know what a peanut allergy feels like?”
I’m also impressed by the majority of comments on this thread, and horrified by the few posters who seem to value their own customer-is-always-right sense of entitlement over the lives of children. I mean, what if they send their child to school with nuts because, you know, they WANT to, so therefore they have the right to, and that action is responsible for the death of another child. What about their own child’s terrible, lifelong feelings of (undeserved) guilt?
Finally, I’m curious, have there been any lobbying or legislative efforts to get companies from manufacturing just about every food product “in a facility that also handles tree nuts”? Rather than making all of this a battle among parents, couldn’t these companies invest some of, say, their CEO’s pay into sending the majority of their products to a no-nut-ever facility?
yahoudi commented on Oct 31 11 at 2:58 pm” I had sent my son to school, ate a pbj sandwich at work and didn’t see him until after washing my face, hands, and brushing my teeth, I kissed him on the cheek and he had a hive on his face for two days.”
And with an allergy that severe, you feel safe sending him to school? You realize that no entity can assure that no one that enters that school has not had peanuts/peanut products in their homes, correct? I would hope no one sues schools over what they, themselves cannot ensure.
Cassandra Barry commented on Nov 02 11 at 2:26 pmTo those of you who said that maybe Broccoli Dad’s kid had allergies to broccoli and vegetables: I’m sorry I wasn’t more clear. He was definitely joking. People laughed. He was making fun of the few people who piped up about their kid’s nut allergies.
Cyndi commented on Nov 02 11 at 6:52 pmholy crap. Just read the first few comments- tried to ignore some of the arguments… anyways, Public School sounds awesome! Can’t wait to put my kid in there. So….can we make a short list of what they CAN do? What is causing all these allergies? I was in public school in the 80′s and 90′s and don’t remember anybody having any problems. That I can remember. Thank GOD I’m just allergic to dust. I hesitate to say I’m “allergic” considering I just sneeze. Allergies are obviously serious…. It’s just weird how prominent they are now! Is homeschooling an option for anyone? Probably not but maybe… Maybe in the future there could be schools for kids with a high allergy problems (?) It’d really be no different than fancier public schools or charter schools or deaf schools. The alternative is everyone focusing on what they can and can’t do, rather than LEARNING.. everyone would be in a bubble. Literally. Even kids without allergies. Just put them all in a bubble. That’s a hell of a way to live. What a dilemma..
Isabelle commented on Nov 02 11 at 9:16 pmThe preschool my child attended cannot be nut free and prospective parents know this. Generally families with children with allergies avoid this preschool. One year there was a child with life threatening nut allergies whose parents some how missed this fact when selecting the school. By making sure all the kids knew to be careful, seating the kids carefully and doing some extra hand washing (and of course having an epi pen just in case) it was possible to avoid any reactions even though other kids ate all sorts of nuts and nut butters. I think that schools can manage situations like this carefully and well if they choose too. I know that many parents would not continue to send their child in to such a situation because of the risk. I just thought it was an interesting situation and was handled in a way that was different than what I usually hear about.
Laura commented on Nov 04 11 at 10:21 amHugs, and keep up the good work.
To the mother who thinks the allergen cannot spread ALL THE WAY ACROSS THE CAFETERIA, it is not just that; it is not airborne. It is the peanut oil that might get on your child’s hands, then on the water fountain and onto the allergic kid’s hands and trigger a severe attack – there was a boy at my preschool whose allergy was THAT BAD.
If you want to pay for that kid’s ER bill, well, risk his health. Just don’t then come looking to me for sympathy if your child develops a resistance to gluten and I insist on sending my child’s favorite snack – pasta – to your child’s school. Get over yourself.
yahoudi commented on Nov 04 11 at 1:20 pmExactly. There is no way to keep all allergens out of schools- especially gluten.
Get schools out of the food catering/controlling/policing and have your kids walk home or drive them home- and feed them at home.
And Laura, any child can eat a peanut butter bagel in the morning and still have trace amounts that escaped careful hand washing and tooth brushing, as evidenced by the mother whose child suffered hives after she ate a PBJ at work.
Still cannot, for the life of me, decipher why anyone would trust a school to protect children that allergic, that young.
Anonymous commented on Nov 08 11 at 6:15 pmHello pot. So you can’t take a joke from Broccoli Dad, a joke that probably wasn’t even meant to be a slight against your child and his allergies, just an innocent attempt to make a funny comment about kids and food, but then you turn around and accuse your readers of not getting the humor when they they criticize you for publicly mocking a family in your child’s class simply because they had the nerve to invite you to a birthday party? You are a real piece of work.
Raina commented on Nov 09 11 at 3:18 pmEveryone should just stop eating.
Illy commented on Nov 09 11 at 11:11 pmHow many of you with kids with allergies had in vitiro?
Josette at Halushki commented on Nov 14 11 at 11:52 pmActually, the kid with cancer is a bad analogy. A child in my daughter’s school had cancer, For him to attend school safely, children in school would have to have additional immunizations and probably wear masks as well to keep the child away from germs/illness. The parents pulled him from school to homeschool until he was well enough to return.
I’m torn on this. On one hand, not having nuts is a small thing to ask. On the other hand, I’ve been in enough situations where there was a “whoops” (school, scouting, sports, etc.) because kids are kids and people make honest mistakes, and that mistake caused someone harm. I don’t think parents of kids with allergies are being party poopers. On the other hand – from my experience – the risk can only be minimized. It’s a scary situation. I don’t think people are so resistant to not sending nuts. I think there is a fear that if the rule is in place and there is an honest whoops, that they will feel guilty. I think the defensiveness against nuts may be at times masking a”but what if I mess up and accidentally hurt this child” fear.
Danielle commented on Nov 30 11 at 9:35 amI understand the seriousness of food anaphylaxis and the precautions that. We’d to be taken. I am wondering where do you draw the line, does a college campus of 1000 students not serve nuts or peanuts because of one person? Are nuts not allowed in a mall food court? Do restaurants have to stop serving anything with nuts to accommodate ONE person. There seems to be a real sense of entitlement and ‘f” anyone else in the allergy community. If a child is allergic to bees, does that mean an entire class cannot go outside? What a about dairy allergies? Is miilk not allowed in schools? How do these children ever grow up and fit into the world when everything is a out them (500 people have to change their eating habits because of one person)? BTW, allergy parents, other people’s children have needs and also require some accommodation.
Lia commented on Dec 01 11 at 2:28 pmUm… Broccoli Dad might not have been ‘being a jerk’. I really am allergic to raw fruits and veggies, which includes broccoli. Yes, I can be around it, but I should not eat it…
Tiffany commented on Dec 05 11 at 6:15 pmI am a school teacher and have severe allergies that put me in the hospital more than once. I have a nut allergy where I send a letter home to the families explaining to them the situation. I had a father that had a similar reaction to brocili dad and jen. Even with my epi-pen, i become unable to work with the students and explained that to the parent. he was the one thatt i had to prove to on how dangerous allergies are and risk my life. he brought peanut butter cookies for his kids bday and as it came my throat shut and ipassed out before i could get my epi pen. he changed his tone after seeing that. no one should feel bad for the cards that were dealt to them.
Kate commented on Dec 13 11 at 3:44 pmI loved Julia’s comment and I am entirely confused by how a school should be food free…So, we expect children to go 7 hours without eating anything? Oh, they should go home for lunch? To an empty house? Nice.
Natural selection is a good thing and some of your parents raised you to be selected and some of you were not.
Danielle commented on Dec 14 11 at 6:24 pmDoes anyone have a theory why we have created a generation of children who are so delicate,they can only fit into a bubble wrapped world? In a Darwinian world these ultra allergic children would not survive.
Joanne commented on Dec 16 11 at 1:08 amIn two generations we have gone for, the greatest to the skimpiest generation? What has been done to the world that has created legends of children who cannot fist into the physical world. God forbid these wimpy kids need to go to battle to defend our country. No wonder America is becoming a second rate nation. BTW, isn’t it mostly rich white kids with debilitating allergies, not children from the hood or from immigrant families.
Jess commented on Dec 19 11 at 11:48 pmHello, I am 14 years old and have known I was severly allergic to peanuts since I was 5 months old. My parents found out when we were on a plane because I was playing with an empty bag of airline peanuts. Remember back then there wasn’t as much knowledge of these kinds of food allergies. I experienced extreme hives and since then have had a few more bad encounters with nuts. Living with this allergy sucks, I know from experience. I was the girl who used to sit alone at the “peanut free” table. I’m the one one who had to (and still does) read every label on every little thing, because you never know what it might say at the bottom of the ingrediants. Some of these comments are horrible, next time think of what the child must be going through. I hope that there are more parents out there like mine sticking up for their childs allergies.
Nikkii commented on Dec 21 11 at 4:47 pmI’m interested in your perception of your European stock being non-allergy prone – I did chuckle. I’m Scottish, my 15yo son is allergic to peanuts, treenuts, just about any legume and coconut. It’s scarily common here as my teacher husband can testify – oodles of them of all ages – and they’ve mostly got red hair. In fact, every nut allergic child I know personally is a red head……
Lisa commented on Dec 22 11 at 10:29 pmI am sorry your son has food allergies. My son has food allergies and when your husband wrote what he wrote I really worried that it would make my child less safe because it cast doubt on well, my sanity and my son’s very real life threatening condition. I didn’t appreciate it at all. I was still very sorry to hear your child ended up having food allergies, though. I wouldn’t wish them on anyone. I want to warn you that nuts and peanuts are super potent and that people can have anaphylaxis from contact ingestion which means that although they don’t eat the nuts or nut butter, small amounts can get on objects like desks and toys and etc and then your child could come along and touch that object and touch his eyes, nose or mouth and have anaphylaxis. Your husband seems to want to prove that he isn’t one of “those parents” but he should not risk your child’s life to prove a point. My son was at a party just two weeks ago and he did not eat anything and he had anaphylaxis because he touched something other kids touched that must have had food residue on it and then he touched his face. It happened 3 times when he was little as well. The reaction included having his throat get tight, breathing trouble, swelling, chest pain and stomach pain and nausea. Again, he didn’t eat anything! Nuts in a room can cause a reaction. Nuts and peanuts and seeds require 1000 times less amount to cause a reaction than other allergens and peanuts and nuts are responsible for most food allergy fatalities. So, if a child truly needs a milk-free environment in his or her classroom at school that should be done but it is a lot more likely a person will react to minute amounts of nuts, peanuts and seeds than other allergens so bans on those are more common. I’m pro-food-free classrooms with snack and lunch in the cafeteria. Have to say that your stereotype about certain stock not being allergy-prone is not true at all. Stereotype all the way. Food allergy rates are skyrocketing around the world right now in developed countries. Asian Americans happen to have the highest rates for food allergies but certain Germans have skyrocketing rates now, too. And Jewish people can be every bit as rugged as Germans! Best wishes to you. I recommend you check out and join kids with food allergies. There are over 20,000 members and it is a great place for support and info about food allergies.
Justrelax7 commented on Dec 30 11 at 11:17 amMy God Daughter/Niece has a peanut allergy and I watch as her parents struggle to make the world understand the severity of it. My three month old daughter’s baptism is coming up and I’d LOVE to make arrangements at a local Italian restaurant for all of us to have a nice lunch afterwards. Everyone will be coming from out of town and it would be great to show off our favorite place to eat. Also, I wouldn’t have to clean my house to host a party in it. But I know this is a nightmare situation for Emma and her parents. I’ve seen them struggle with restaurant managers to make sure food doesn’t cross contaminate. And then have to work up the courage to remind Grandma Nancy that the carrot cake she just ordered for desert has peanuts so she should wash her hands and not kiss Emma afterwards. So instead, we are going to clean the house, grab some lasagnas from Sam’s Club, and make cup cakes.
Would I do it differently if she didn’t have a Peanut allergy? Yes. But, SHE DOES! So we are going to work around it and still have a great time!! When it comes to saving a child’s life, isn’t it better to be proactive than reactive?
Margarett commented on Jan 02 12 at 6:25 pmI am shocked by the severity of some of the allergies I have read about here. I do wonder however, if a child could actually die from touching something that a child who has eaten peanut butter has touched it seems that banning nuts from school would scarcely protect them. Many of the “allergy-parents” suggest feeding kids their PBJs before and after school. If a child’s allergy is really so dangerous as all that then what to do about the child who has peanut butter on toast and then get’s on the same school bus, or touches the same chain of the swing set as an allergic child? In small towns it may be possible to get all parents on board and even to have nut free households, in larger communities there will always be parents who forget or even just don’t care. I am not suggesting that I think that allergic children should be segregated or don’t deserve the same right to a public education as other children, I am just truly inquiring if a child can be made safe when contact with 100s of kids from as many families on a daily basis can kill them? I understand that if it is your own child who’s life is threatened that you don’t make mistakes, but for other families, other things will preoccupy their minds and it is hard to believe that mistakes won’t be made. I have to say I don’t know how the parents of children with this sort of life threatening ailment make it through the day. I found it hard enough sending my 5 year old to Kindergarten and the idea that someone’s lunch could kill him wasn’t even on my list. Ironically (because of all the comments about homeschooling) I bet a lot of you wish you could just keep your precious babies with you 24/7 and never let anything through your front door that could hurt them! Like John Travolta in that bubble!! Ah, if only life worked that way =)
Cassandra Barry commented on Jan 12 12 at 2:13 pmTo those of you who think that allergies aren’t really fatal, here’s a recent story about a fatality: http://www.wtvr.com/news/wtvr-chesterfield-student-death-20120103,0,4150762.story (Via my friend’s blog: http://www.freedomtoeat.blogspot.com)
goddess commented on Jan 15 12 at 6:54 pmThere is NO way my HOUSEHOLD would become nut-free, absent an allergy IN that household. Perhaps the fact that I ate it every day throughout each of my pregnancies has something to do with why none of my children ever had a food allergy.
Sara commented on Feb 01 12 at 1:36 pmYahoudi – Your food-free school suggestion might make some sense in some schools, but certainly not in our rural district. Our average bus route is about an hour long. That’s two hours of transportation PLUS ‘lunch break’ time, so you’ve just lengthened the school day by 2 1/2 hours and doubled our (already significant) transportation budget. Even if you assumed that every child had a parent who was available to drive him/her home for lunch instead of being bussed, a lot of families live 30 minutes away from the school, so you’re looking a 1 1/2 hours for lunch. It’s just not practical for us, and I suspect there are many more districts in the same position.
Donna commented on Feb 07 12 at 4:36 pmI am not sure if this has been touched on already… but because these are airborn allergies… then there is even a danger on the playground. My daughter almost died when she was younger because a parent decided to just go ahead and feed his child “what he damn well pleases”… and they were playing three hours later and they were too close, he breathed on her and thank goodness I was still present- because I dont think it is fair to even expect that the school yard monitors can catch everything… such as a child hidden behind a structure, gasping for air, unable to help herself…. if there ever was a better example of the need to walk a mile in an others shoes, this might be it- holding a dying child in your arms knowing that it was completely preventable… it is horrible. Not everything is preventable- that is why we watch our children closely and carry epipens… but those are intended for real accidental emergencies- not cases of ignorance and selfishness. I know this may sound harsh… but I really have never understood people who complain about this issue- even before I had a child with a life threatening allergy.
Donna commented on Feb 07 12 at 4:41 pmGoddess- I ate plenty of pb in my pregnancy and also when I was bfing… who really knows why these happen- or who is to blame, but if a child has this deadly allergy then it is too late for all of that, I am afraid. I have beaten myself up plenty… she was my first of five children. Maybe it was the eating my bfing, maybe it was the fact she was vaccinated and the others weren’t… maybe it was the formula she had for a while…. and maybe it was terrible bad luck. I have never asked people to remove peanuts from their homes or even diets- but that their children are cleaned up, teeth brushed and fresh clothing on before coming in contact with our child- I would do the same for them without hesitation… even if it were something that seriously inconvienced my family- I had a home daycare for while when my daughter was younger- and we were 100% egg free for another family for the whole ten months they lived in our area and their child came to our daycare pt. It was easier than you would think!
goddess commented on Mar 02 12 at 5:51 pmI would NOT get rid of peanut butter in my home. In fact, I stocked up on it for the peanut drought. Luckily, their schools do not ban peanut butter, or I would take them HOME for lunch.
An commented on Mar 03 12 at 5:13 pmFunny….about dooming your son to nut allergies. With us, I read something about kids being allergic to things because they live in too-clean environments and don’t get a chance to build up immunities. So, I said to myself, not too much a chance of that, we live in an old house that gets dusty! Fast forward a few years. My son always having a runny nose and post nasal drip. Had him allergy tested….he’s severely allergic to dust. Sigh.
Now, where did you read people of European descent are not allergic? The worst allergic people I’ve known are the whitest people I know. My ex, pure Irish, had horrible seasonal allergies. My nephew, half German, half English, pure blond hair, very allergic to cats and dogs. My dad, a mix of German Irish and Dutch, bad hay fever.
Cassandra Barry commented on Mar 10 12 at 9:34 pm@goddess I ate all kinds of nuts during my pregnancy, too. My kid still got a nut allergy.
Jenifer commented on Mar 12 12 at 1:56 pm. As the mtoher of a nut-, egg-, dairy-, and more-allergic child, this issue is near and dear to my heart. As an avid cook, mtoher of 2 non-allergic children, and having no allergies myself, I have strive to maintain balance in my perspective regarding the treatment of food allergies especially in public places. This comment was way out of line. I am constantly overwhelmed by the level of compassion, understanding, and support that our community offers regarding . Still, likefood allergies. But like you I cdo ome across the occasional instigator who is misinformed or under-educated about food allergies and believes that we are catering to the whims of a picky child. This user’s comment came from a purely selfish and intentionally hurtful place. How truly sad things must be for this individual if he/she is really unable to accomodate a simple request to refrain from his/her bag of peanuts for a matter of hours to preserve the life of a child or anyone for that matter. It’s almost too ridiculous a notion to entertain. Thanks for being the voice for so many of us!
Holly Robinson commented on Mar 13 12 at 2:58 pmI work for a travel summer adventure program for teens, called Adventure Treks. It has been a challenge but I am proud to say over the past three years we have successfully integrated many dietary limitations including nut and wheat allergies into our program. Other programs like ours are turning kids away because they don’t want the risk or say it is too complicated. We put in the extra effort because we just don’t feel like kids should miss out.
Terri commented on Mar 20 12 at 9:09 pmSorry, but there are cases where the allergies are taken way to seriously. I will agree that nut allergies are bad. Possibly because of the fact that many everyday products like soap and lotion contain nut oils. Those poor kid’s bodies just can’t get a break from nuts and the severity of the allergy never goes away. However, there are other food allergies that don’t pose a threat unless the allergen is actually consumed. Banning wheat, gluten, eggs, milk and nuts from classrooms just isn’t feasable. There is a child in one of my kids classrooms that actually bullies the other kids if they have a snack with something he can’t eat. If he can’t eat it, no one else can eat in peace. I’m talking major temper tantrums here and it’s not right. I take great pains not to send in any snack with his allergy triggers, but he will throw a fit even if he thinks there’s one of his forbidden foods. For example, I purchased egg and gluten free ranch dressing for my child to dip carrots in for snack time. Other child had a temper tantrum over it because some dressings contain eggs. My child couldn’t enjoy his snack. This child freaks out over everything and it’s driving me and his teacher crazy.
Shannon commented on Apr 04 12 at 12:29 pmDon’t underestimate any food allergies. Yes, no allergies are created equal, but neither are all people so you never know how someone will react. Do not scoff at any food allergy. I saw someone brush off strawberry allergies. Well guess what I’m deathly allergic to strawberries AND HAVE ALMOST DIED BECAUSE OF IT. Peanuts may be common, but so are strawberries and everyone apparently loves them. Being the only person I actually know with the allergy in my group of family and friends is tough, but I have great friends and families and have learned to live with it. Also you would not believe what strawberries are in salads, desserts, drinks, baby food, fruit gummies, and I’ve also been told that some artificial flavored stuff uses strawberries (but, I’ve never come across any). All food allergies should be taken seriously and that being said I also know it’s impossible and irrational to ban all foods that cause allergies from an environment. I never asked anyone to do that with strawberries, but my parents and I were/are hyper vigilant. I have had people ask if I would like them to ban strawberries and I refuse. I carry my epi , Benadryl, nose spray and my inhaler (I have asthma and severe environmental allergies (to the point at times it affects my breathing) too and fragrances are a nightmare). I would ask to be excused from class if I was having problems with fragrances or something (A student so my grades weren’t affected). From the time I could talk I learned to ask questions and make sure food and everything else was safe. In kindergarten kids brought strawberry stuff for snack, so my mother packed special stuff for me and asked I not be allowed around the snacks (no biggy I just sat away from the kids eating or sat with kids who had a different snacks). I also had a weak immune system. I always carried germ-x in my lunch and book bag, etc. (incase no water was available) and frankly I think washing your hands often is a great idea, so many things can be passed around through touch (so to parents that complain about that in allergy free classrooms why is that a problem?). However, you cannot have absolute control over the environment and it’s irrational to think you can. I live near the woods where wild strawberries grow (and I’m also allergic to real pine trees). I walk in the wood I know don’t touch the strawberries and if I get sap or anything on me (I try to wear long sleeves and pants), I have to wash it off quickly. Also, my neighbors down the road run a pick your own strawberries patch, so I know to avoid their place and be careful around them. The trick is vigilance. I hate special treatment and always have been embarrassed by it. In fact friends and family worry more than me (once had a friend who tried to throw me in a car and rush me to the ER because I used strawberry scented shampoo, until I explain the scent is fake and I’m obviously not eating the shampoo).I find a lot of people over react to my allergies. I had/have a lot of health concerns and I learned from a young age to not rely on other people to assure my safety and if I have a need, I have to not be afraid to ask for it to be met (for example asking my family at parties to make sure every dessert has its own server, so strawberries won’t be mixed in to the different dishes. Ok, big deal bring a couple of extra spatulas). However, I don’t want to be treated like and invalid or a leper and frankly if everyone had to accommodate every health concern I have we’d all be bubble boys. I’ve lived with my health concerns for years and have gotten pretty good and making sure I stay safe (when I was in school there were no special precautions for kids with allergies or anything. You had to do it yourself). My kids will probably have the same health issues as me (maybe more), so I’ll do the same thing my parents and I did. Teach self-reliance, teach your kid to keep themselves safe and not rely on the kindness and concern of everyone (frankly if you don’t have the concern you don’t think about it and can absent mindedly do stuff). If they cannot be in the same room as peanuts, well is there a special classroom for kids with allergies? If so sign me up. Special table? Great. I don’t consider it ostracizing I consider it a safety measure that needs to be taken and if you approach it right the children won’t feel like a leper. I repeat DO NOT RELY ON ANYONE ELSE they do not understand and may fail you. For example, I have a cousin who is deathly allergic to everything (meat, cheese, nuts, fish, and a million other things) his mom enrolled him in cyber school to keep him safe because it’s difficult in a big classroom to monitor everything and she understands this and also there were some problems at school with his food allergies. The sad thing is that my cousin has a VERY VERY limited diet due to his allergies (like insanely limited) and to ask other kids to abide by his special diet is cruel (he can’t eat a lot of things kids like i.e. hot dogs), unhealthy (he takes special pills to get nutrients), and absurd. She knows this and that’s why she removed him from that environment. Like the person who said bout the potato for lunch, what are you supposed to feed your kid? If you have one kid for every allergy then the answer nothing (you can be allergic to anything). No cheese, dairy, wheat, gluten, nuts, meat, etc. So no sandwiches, no cookies, no cereal, no potato chips, etc., it’s hard. Also, not going to lie a lot of allergen free foods are expensive and I know where I live a lot of families wouldn’t be able to afford it (peanut butter and jelly or easy mac (gluten) may be all they can afford). And quite honestly school meals are the only meals some people get (we even have a summer meal program at the school for poor families). No one should go hungry (like the person whose son only eats peanut butter, separate him from the other kids yes, but don’t make him go hungry), but reasonable accommodations should be made. Btw I’ve worked with kids with autism and other disorders and there are some of them that will only eat certain foods (even to the point they put it on everything (think Will Ferrell in Elf with the syrup)). What if one of these kids only eats peanut butter (it’s happened). Is their disorder any less important? Also change is hard for them so if they have to eat the same thing for lunch (i.e. peanut butter sandwiches) and you change it will set them off (I’ve had the bite marks, scratch marks, and bruises to prove it). Everyone’s child is special to them and they all want their child to be safe and healthy, so we should not rip on people for wanting that (whether its wanting to ban peanuts or pack your child a healthy lunch that may include peanuts (certain cultures use peanuts in their food a lot, had an Indian and a Chinese friend who had peanuts and soy in their food a lot).For example I can’t eat certain veggies, but I understand veggies are important to a healthy diet so I don’t ask people to not eat veggies at work or school. What we need to do is promote understanding and attempt to come to a mutual agreement that is beneficial to everyone (separate rooms table etc. or something like that). You have to do what you have to do, I understand that. If a parent sent a note requesting peanut free classrooms (classroom not household, I’m opposed to telling people what to do in the privacy in their own home. Just ask that kids wash up etc. if they have peanut butter in the morning etc.) I’d comply (wouldn’t be hard I don’t eat peanuts, so I don’t really understand the big fuss), but I’d want the kids educated about it and I would hope they are taking steps to teach their children how to keep themselves safe (and simply not relying on the kindness of others). Sorry if I offended anyone or anything, not down playing the seriousness of stuff like food allergies I totally understand, just my opinion.
BTW in an off note I have been told by my grandma (who is a diabetic) and various medical professional that one of the best ways to quickly help a diabetic until help arrives and one of the best thing you can give them is those peanut butter crackers (my grandma always carried some). We had a guy at work whose Blood Sugar would drop and we always had peanut butter crackers around so when he started to have problems we would have to rush and get him crackers and fruit juice until help arrived. Just a note (and just to let you know if there are any kids with diabetes they may have those on them).
Shannon commented on Apr 04 12 at 3:37 pmFunny story about people not understanding the seriousness of food allergies btw this is an actually convo I’ve had multiple times:
Other person (usually offical at work/school / medical office or a new friend): Do you have any food allergies?
Me: Yah, Strawberries
Other person: Oh, so what happens you get a rash or hive or something.
Me: Nope, I die
Other person: Blank Stare
(Usually followed by WHAT?, HOW?, stammering, or lots of other questions).Not making fun of food allergies and most the time I do it to be smart, but yah some people don’t understand food allergies. BTW this is how the convo went with me and my boyfriend the first time he took me out to eat.
Natashenka commented on Apr 08 12 at 2:59 amTo Cassandra: was upset as many readers here about your husband’s article as was going through very difficult time of my 1 mnth old baby having at first milk allergy, then I had to eliminate all nuts, eggs, soy, fish, almost all veggies and fruits from my diet as I tried to breast feed him, because the “safe” formula he was prescribed just smelled and tasted horrible. But I think your husband was trying to joke and I a kind of get where he was coming from because my oldest (5) does not have any allergies and I could not even imagine what a life with allergic kid was like. And I’m so happy for all the parents whose kids don’t have allergies, but you just don’t understand what it’s like to live every day with fear of your child dying just because he ATE or touched something. God, wouldn’t my life be so easy if I didn’t have to deal with this on a daily basis. To Goddess, I ate nuts with my 1st, she doesn’t have allergies, ate nuts with my 2nd one – he does. Some other person commenting – no, did not have IVF with either one of them. I’m not Jewish, I’m Russian (another topic of frustration because Russians are also big on Darwinian survival jokes and no-jokes). I’ve heard it all – my cleanliness caused his allergies (if you would’ve seen my house, when is it ever too clean?), stress caused it (well, having an older child, a job (which I quit for the time being) and a life is stressful)), my addiction to chocolate caused it (that coming from a friend!). All the witless comments – I will ignore. But I will continue to fight for my child to not being unnecessarily exposed to what can kill him. And I will send him to preschool that treats allergies as real (my daughter’a does) and be very thankful for public education system where we live being more progressive than in some other places.
Add a comment:
Note: Babble is a supportive, diverse community. We encourage a range of opinions,
but any unduly hostile comments will be removed.











132